More

Pittsburgh Couple Sue Hospital Over Hepatitis C-Infected Kidney Transplant

Hepatitis Kidney Transplant

The Huffington Post   First Posted: 09/21/11 12:53 PM ET Updated: 11/21/11 05:12 AM ET

A Pittsburgh couple has sued the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center over a botched transplant involving a hepatitis C-infected kidney.

Michael Yocabet, who has diabetes and diabetes-related kidney disease, received a kidney from his life partner Christina Mecannic on April 6 this year after finding that the two are a match. But the couple said in the suit that there had been blood tests as early as January indicating that Mecannic was infected with hepatitis C before the transplant even took place; yet, it was allowed to continue on, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported.

Now, Yocabet has hepatitis C , too.

"When i first heard about it, like I said, I was blown away by it," Yocabet said in a video from the Post-Gazette. "I couldn't believe something like that could've really happened to me, you know. When I heard about it … I was angry for awhile."

The lawsuit also claims that after the hospital staff realized that the hepatitis C-infected kidney had been transplanted, they asked Mecannic if she had ever cheated on Yocabet, who she has been partnered with for the last 21 years (they have an 18-year-old son together). They also asked if she had ever done cocaine, and then they asked if she wanted to keep the whole news of the infection a secret from Yocabet, MSNBC reported. However, Mecannic said in the Post-Gazette video that she did not cheat or use drugs to contract the disease; rather, she believes she probably got it from the hospital she works at as a nurse.

Since the incident, UPMC closed its kidney and liver transplant centers for two months, and also took disciplinary action against a surgeon and a nurse, according to MSNBC.

With living organ donations, donors are screened for infections including hepatitis, HIV and syphilis, MSNBC reported. However, screening procedures can vary from transplant center to transplant center.

According to the Post-Gazette, UPMC said in a statement that there was no cover-up of the botched transplant, but rather that "once the error was discovered, UPMC disclosed the information to the patients involved and UNOS. We voluntarily suspended our live-donor program and have fully complied with all investigations. The well-being of our patients remains our highest priority."

The transplant programs resumed again in June, United Press International reported.

Hepatitis C is considered the most serious of all the hepatitis diseases, and is contracted by exposure to contaminated blood (the most common route of transmission is through sharing needles during drug use). The virus that causes hepatitis C attacks the liver and causes inflammation, according to the Mayo Clinic.

Symptoms of the disease are usually mild -- even flu-like -- and can cause nausea, fever, fatigue, muscle pain and tenderness in the liver area. But after many years of having the disease, complications can be serious, leading to cirrhosis, liver cancer and liver failure, the Mayo Clinic reported.

The lawsuit over the hepatitis C-infected kidney comes shortly after the Mississippi Organ Recovery Agency and the University of Mississippi Medical Center were sued after parasite-infected kidneys were donated to two people.

One of the transplant recipients died three months after receiving the kidney in 2009, and the other is partially blind and says he is less healthy now than before the transplant, The Clarion Ledger reported.

And in 2009, a kidney transplant recipient contracted AIDS after it was discovered that his donor was infected with the disease. The kidney donor had unprotected gay sex between the time he tested negative for the disease, and the time of the surgery, the Associated Press reported.

Just today, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, released enhanced draft guidelines for organ transplantation. They call for more screening of donors and testing of donated organs to ensure minimal infection spread, particularly of HIV, hepatitis B and hepatitis C.

“Our first priority must be patient safety. These recommendations will save lives and reduce unintended disease in organ recipients,” Matthew J. Kuehnert, M.D., director of CDC’s Office of Blood, Organ, and Other Tissue Safety, said in a statement. “The guideline will help patients and their doctors have information they need to fully weigh risks and benefits of transplanting a particular organ.”

Between 2007 and 2010, the CDC conducted 200 investigations into potential transmission of HIV and hepatitis B and C due to organ transplants.

For more on the lawsuit involving the hepatitis C-infected kidney, WATCH this video from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST HEALTHY LIVING

A Pittsburgh couple has sued the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center over a botched transplant involving a hepatitis C-infected kidney. Michael Yocabet, who has diabetes and diabetes-related k...
A Pittsburgh couple has sued the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center over a botched transplant involving a hepatitis C-infected kidney. Michael Yocabet, who has diabetes and diabetes-related k...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 245
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
03:00 PM on 09/22/2011
I live around Pittsburgh and this story has been in our local news. It was easier to understand from the local news sites. lol This is the story we heard:

PITTSBURGH -- A local couple filed negligence lawsuits Tuesday against the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center-Presbyterian Hospital and University of Pittsburgh Physicians.
The lawsuits allege that UPMC allowed an April 2011 transplant to proceed, even though tests had shown the kidney was infected with Hepatitis C.
The lawsuits were filed by Michael Yocabet and Christina Mecannic, partners who have been together for 21 years. She donated the kidney to him, and the lawsuit claims UPMC didn't tell either of them Mecannic's kidney was infected until after the transplant.
"I was devastated," said Mechannic. "When they told me, I was actually in shock and totally devastated."
Mechannic said she is a nurse and suspects that she contracted the disease from one of her patients.
After the incident UPMC shut down the transplant program for two months but didn't explain why at the time. UPMC officials said a surgeon and nurse were disciplined.
A UPMC spokeswoman released a statement to Channel 11 News on Tuesday saying, "We sincerely regret the human error that caused this situation however any allegation of a cover-up is completely false. Once the error was discovered, UPMC disclosed the information to the patients involved and UNOS. We voluntarily suspended our live-donor program and have fully complied with all investigations."
06:02 AM on 09/22/2011
Here is what I want to know presumably since they have a child together they are sexually active with each other, and live together, so how do they know he didn't get it from her the old fasiond way?
06:53 AM on 09/22/2011
" Sexual transmission of HCV is considered to be rare. Studies show the risk of sexual transmission in heterosexual, monogamous relationships is extremely rare or even nil" according to the CDC.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hepatitis_C
05:20 PM on 09/22/2011
Learn something new every day I guess, I thought Hep C was an STD.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eric Graff
All LIBERAL ALL THE LIBERAL TIME
05:59 AM on 09/22/2011
I've had C for 20 years now. I've never had a single symptom. No viral load & no issues so far so if you're spewing ignorence, knock it off!
03:41 AM on 09/22/2011
IM sorry but they already knew she was infected before hand and they still did it they have no one to blame but them people are out to get rich any way they can these days it dont make no sense
06:00 AM on 09/22/2011
What??? Are you suggesting they did this for MONEY?? WHAT the hel are you talking about? get over your jealousy of people who made something of themselves. Why don't you throw in a "Fat Cat" or two and may be a "Big-Oil" done it.
photo
1question
Questions now...retribution in the after life...
06:08 AM on 09/22/2011
I am very confused...trying to make sense of your comment (effort).

It's okae to use a 'comma' or a period (where applicable) or...at least try.

http://www.grammarbook.com/punctuation/commas.asp
tccat4
We all have a right to our opinion, like it or not
03:20 AM on 09/22/2011
Many nurses have tested positive for Hep C, not knowing where or why they got it. Back many years ago, in the ER, we didnt mask or wear gloves when a patient came thru the doors, little did we know that years later diseases like AIDS and Hep C were going to become a nightmare. Why do you think that many medical workers quit when the job they loved so much was going to be a Death Sentence???
photo
arakuzi
The worst blind is the one that refuses to see
02:58 AM on 09/22/2011
huh, how could she not know about it? she must got sick due the hepatitis C in some point and time on her life.....I know well, I got it long time ago....would not recommend my blood to no one.

I hope they get nothing, I smell a pre meditated scam.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jaguar8450
02:16 AM on 09/22/2011
She's a nurse and she missed the symptoms of Hep C long before the testing and transplant that were affecting her?
GOODDOC1
"civil war" is an oxymoron
02:47 AM on 09/22/2011
It's rare, but Hep-C can be "silent" until it is somewhat advanced. Or she could have been recently infected, with no symptoms.
09:07 AM on 09/22/2011
Actually it's rare for people to KNOW they have hep-C. The initial infection is rarely recognized, and people typically have it for 20+ years before it is even detected. Most people die WITH it not FROM it.
Rates of detection have improved with more widespread screening, but the testing only became available about 20 years ago. (Hep-B vaccination has been available for > 20 years & screening for even longer).
jpoze
Constitution.
01:59 AM on 09/22/2011
Another medical mistake. When are regular people going to become outraged by medical mistakes that kill innocent people? To date and still, this biz just gets swept under the rug.
Oh well, someone died, next!!!
01:58 AM on 09/22/2011
Oh my God, she screws around on her partner and gives him Hep C and blames the Hospital. Love it!!! Of course you don't hear the hospital's side of this argument because news reports are all getting biased. Esp in AOL huff post
GOODDOC1
"civil war" is an oxymoron
02:48 AM on 09/22/2011
Article says she did not cheat or use drugs.
01:40 AM on 09/22/2011
If this lady was a nurse, and knew she had Hep C why did she consent to the surgery. She had to know that he would get it also. I don't understand why they are surprised or the lawsuit.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barry Clarke
Retired Air Traffic Control Aviation Meteorologist
02:03 AM on 09/22/2011
I wonder if it could have been planned?.................
11:48 PM on 09/28/2011
The transplant team did not let her know she has Hep C untill after transplant..
01:37 AM on 09/22/2011
Sadly that is the risk one takes in any Hospital today!!!
photo
j14kline
Deliver us from evil.
01:22 AM on 09/22/2011
If they were sex partners he would have eventually contracted the disease from her, a large number of people with hep-c received it form snorting cocain through a $ 20.00 bill, which is why they were asking her about any usage, dirty needles are another source.

I do feel sorry for him though and i think there is much more to this story then we are currently aware of, Hep c is not an airborne disease, so unless she was having sex on the job, sharing needles, or accidentally poked herself and failed to report it, then i seriousley doubt her claim that it was job related.
GOODDOC1
"civil war" is an oxymoron
02:51 AM on 09/22/2011
Blood or other bodily fluids on nicks, cuts, or mucous membranes, but she shoud have reported that, too.
12:54 AM on 09/22/2011
What's worse, dying of kidney failure, without someone offering to give you part of their body, (which seems like the ultimate gift!) or receiving that gift, and living longer with a defection? Seems to me, they both knew the odds...My prayers are with them both. Believe! God heals if you ask Him.
12:32 AM on 09/22/2011
No Jesus, no peace.
Know Jesus, know peace.

See John 3:16,17.

"Righteousness exalts a nation; But sin is a reproach to any people" (Proverbs 14:34).
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
11:57 PM on 09/21/2011
She tested positive for hep C in January and they went ahead with the transplant in April. It was their decision. Why are they surprised?