iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Eurozone Bailout Fund: German Parliament Passes Expansion Of Powers

Eurozone Bailout Fund

MELISSA EDDY   09/29/11 05:34 PM ET   AP

BERLIN — Germany kept alive hopes that the 17-nation euro currency can survive the sprawling debt crisis when lawmakers in Europe's largest economy voted overwhelmingly on Thursday in favor of expanding the powers of the eurozone's bailout fund.

The vote strengthened Chancellor Angela Merkel's center-right coalition, which had struggled to win support from a bloc of rebellious members, and could bolster her ability to negotiate new European crisis measures.

While many investors and experts believe new steps will be required in Europe, such as letting Greece write off more of its debt pile, Germany's approval of the fund's new powers and scope was necessary to avoid a new bout of massive market turmoil.

"The support of the Bundestag is an important step for stabilizing the eurozone," Michael Kemmer, head of Germany's Bank Federation, told the news agency dapd. "With that, they have set a course that leads out of the debt crisis."

The euro440 billion ($600 billion) fund will be able to buy government bonds and lend money to banks and governments before they are in a full-blown crisis, making Europe's response to market jitters more rapid and pre-emptive.

Germany, which pays the lion's share of European bailouts, became the 13th member of the eurozone to support the expansion of the rescue fund, the so-called European Financial Stability Facility, or EFSF. Cyprus and Estonia also passed the proposed expansion on Thursday.

Austria's parliament is widely expected to pass the measure on Friday, the same day Germany's upper house of parliament is set to finalize Thursday's vote, while the Netherlands is expected to approve it in the first week of October.

The biggest remaining hurdle is the final country to vote – Slovakia – where the government will not have enough support to pass it if the leader of the junior coalition Freedom and Solidarity party follows through with threats to vote against the fund's expansion. Its parliament is to vote later in October.

In Berlin, 523 lawmakers in parliament, the Bundestag, voted in favor of expanding German participation to guarantee loans of up to euro211 billion, compared with euro123 billion so far. Eighty-five voted against it and three abstained.

"It was a strong statement of Angela Merkel's position. She has the backing and the support of the coalition and she is able to negotiate on the European level," Peter Altmeier, the parliamentary whip for Merkel's Christian Democrats, said after the tally was announced.

Markets appeared calmer even before Thursday's votes, following weeks of turbulence triggered by uncertainty over Germany's position on the fund. The euro also traded slightly higher.

"The overwhelming majority in the Bundestag is a good sign and will hopefully mark a step change in German commitment to bringing the spiraling crisis under control," said Sony Kapoor of the Re-Define economic policy think tank.

The lingering problem, however, is that investors are resigned to the fact that Greece will have to default – that is, impose tougher losses on its bondholders.

French President Nicolas Sarkozy will meet with Greek Prime Minister George Papandreou in Paris on Friday to discuss the debt crisis, the president's office said.

Papandreou met Germany's Merkel for similar talks Tuesday. Germany and France combined represent about half of the 17-nation eurozone's economic output.

Greece was saved from default by an initial euro110 billion ($150 billion) bailout in May last year before the EFSF was established to help any other countries in trouble. A planned second rescue package for Greece this year includes a voluntary participation by private bondholders, who agreed to write off about 20 percent on their Greek debt holdings.

Many experts say those writedowns should be closer to 50 percent. The debate among European leaders now is whether to allow such a move under controlled conditions, providing help to banks that may take heavy losses on Greek bonds they hold.

Germany and the Netherlands are open to the option, with Merkel suggesting this week that Greece's second bailout deal might have to be renegotiated. France and the European Central Bank, however, oppose the idea.

Greece's international debt inspectors returned to Athens on Thursday to complete a review. Merkel has said that any new decisions would depend upon the results of the inspectors' report, which is not due for days.

Forging consensus over new measures – particularly something as delicate as imposing more severe losses on Greece's creditors – will likely be very difficult, however.

Indeed, the parliamentary debate on the EFSF in Berlin on Thursday was a feisty three-hour long affair, reflecting how high tensions in Merkel's coalition were running over the idea of providing more backing to the eurozone's weakest members.

Frank Schaeffler, a dissenter from the junior coalition partner, argued that bailout measures have worsened Greece's economic situation.

"Despite all arguments, the first bailout did not make the situation for Greece better, but worse," said Schaeffler, a Free Democrat. "Expanding the fund will make the situation even worse."

Schaeffler and others had long expressed their concerns, and opposition leaders had said going in to the vote that if Merkel's coalition had to rely on their votes, it would be a sign that her strife-prone and increasingly unpopular government is finished.

Yet after a night of intense lobbying, Merkel's camp was able to secure a majority of 315 – enough to have passed the measure even without support from the opposition parties.

"This shows the clear determination of the coalition on this issue," Rainer Bruederle, the Free Democrats' parliamentary leader. "We have made an important decision for Europe."

Any future changes to the current fund will also require parliamentary approval and maintaining that determination will be crucial to making swift, effective decisions to combat the crisis.

In addition, the Bundestag will face another major vote early next year on the fund's permanent replacement, the European Stability Mechanism, which is due to take effect in 2013. Schaeffler has already vowed to rally his party to reject the ESM.

Party leaders insist they are not worried by Schaeffler's plans, but many analysts have noted Merkel will have to hold her majority together, or Thursday may have only been the first in a series of nail-biting parliamentary showdowns over shoring up the euro.

______

Geir Moulson and Tomislav Skaro in Berlin, and Menelaos Hadjicostis in Nicosia, Cyprus, contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST BUSINESS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Money newsletter!
BERLIN — Germany kept alive hopes that the 17-nation euro currency can survive the sprawling debt crisis when lawmakers in Europe's largest economy voted overwhelmingly on Thursday in favor of e...
BERLIN — Germany kept alive hopes that the 17-nation euro currency can survive the sprawling debt crisis when lawmakers in Europe's largest economy voted overwhelmingly on Thursday in favor of e...
Filed by Chris Gentilviso  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 169
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LudeDude714
02:55 AM on 10/01/2011
I have always been amazed and mystified by the German people and their resilience, in a 60 year span they threatened the world in WW 1 was stripped of everything by the cruel Versailles treaty, they built an awesome military and threatened the world again in 20 short years. While Hitler was one of histories greatest politicians he was a corporal trying to tell admirals and field marshals how to win a war, thankfully he did not let his generals run the war. After being beaten down and stripped of everything again by the 1960s they were an economic super power once again. Now they concede to helping the weaker nations of the EU, it is all a test by the CFR to see how a single currency will do. There is talk about the Amero for north and central America and it will come to pass within a decade or two, one step closer to a one world currency that the CFR has been working on for nearly a half a century.
08:29 AM on 09/30/2011
I thought the Germans had more sense.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
obeliskpress
Muddy water, let stand, becomes clear.
06:19 AM on 09/30/2011
In other words another massive bank transfer from the people to the speculators and 'job creators.'
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kringle
Resurrection of the Gifting Spirit
12:26 AM on 09/30/2011
What are all those credit card looking thingies they're all holding up, and why do they all look like they just won the lottery?
10:19 AM on 09/30/2011
The "credit card thingies" are our representatives' personal ballots (see the barcode to speed up counting and registering the vote electronically; the cards are also imprinted with the representative's name and caucus/ party). Blue cards mean "yes", red cards mean "No", white cards mean the representative abstains.

The picture was taken right before the President of the Federal Parliament declared the voting opened. If the picture was larger you could see that the Chancellor (every Chancellor needs to be a member of parliament) is standing right next to one of the ballot boxes, surrounded by other parliamentarians.

Holding their cards into the air (and thus signalling which choice they intend to make) is just a habit. I can only guess but I suppose beyond mere politeness and making a show of confidence - at that point many among Chancellor Merkel's own party, as much as herself, were simply relieved that they could expect to win a majority even without needing the support they got by the opposition parties' MPs.

Hope, that explains it a bit.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kringle
Resurrection of the Gifting Spirit
01:42 PM on 10/03/2011
Actually yes! Quite helpful. Given the goings-on in America these days, you might understand how an American might thus misinterpret this photograph...

Cheers!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
aztrukin
I am the leader of opting out of badges.
09:23 PM on 09/29/2011
Why would anyone want to tie their currency to another country like this. Politics in Greece can pull them all down, what sense does that make.
Michael5555
I built it despite you people
11:16 PM on 09/29/2011
If there is only one currency then it is easier for the central bank to monopolize the creation of it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
floodberg
Attorney (ret.)
09:15 PM on 09/29/2011
German bank exposure and the bailout debate in Germany.

When Greece became insolvent, Greeks were faced with cutbacks, no stimulus, being reviled worldwide for 'taking' bailouts (which they never got), and they rioted.  Bailouts went to big banks outside Greece (mostly German), who made lots of money with the loans but also continued to lend at higher interest rates knowing the borrowing country/company was already in trouble.  On FT.com it was almost inconceivable that lending banks might have to take a loss.

Der Speigel* discusses 'Ego-Europeans' in Germany who are now adopting a Germany-first policy.  The cracks in the €zone and EU are making citizens and now their MPs fearful that Germany could become the 'paymaster of the continent.'  A newspaper poll of Germans;50% said immigration must be cut drastically; 30% call for an Independent Germany without the €.  The Euro-barometer (opinion poll) showed 50% associate German membership with a benefit, while 32% have a generally positive picture of the EU. 

25% of German jobs depend on EU exports; but a piecemeal solution won't keep the orders from EU countries from falling.  Bailouts for Greece benefit predominantly the German banks, but won't stimulate the economies involved, nor make cutbacks in the Greek budget.

Peter Bofinger's analysis of the crisis management hits the mark::

Since the start of the Euro-crisis problems were solved piecemeal.  Easy to say we are against the bailout, because for millions of German it is the worst solution. It would be better to explain to citizens why the billions are inevitable. It is not primarily about the problem countries, but our own banks, which are heavily involved with loans there.  http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/0,1518,762097,00.html  

German MPs see the only way to save Germany is to bailout all the banks holding debt, but they still have to stimulate all EU economies, enforece major budget cuts in all countries and subsequently pay back the debt so German taxpayers are made whole.

*I couldn't find a formal translation, so I touched up a programmed translation. Any good translation would be appreciated!
05:32 PM on 09/29/2011
As a man who who was born in Germany, has very close ties to Germany, who owns home(s) in Germany, and also the US, I find the work ethic very similar. I grew up believing one worked, saved, and invested in my familys future. I was never told I would retire at 50, or 53. Never expected that the state owed me so much as I was a member of a a very long line of men and women who had served the state when we were asked. I also know the reunification of Germany is ongoing, is quite expensive, and we do not need debt thrust upon us, not of our making. I would hope each member state of the EU can find a way to meet its own financial obligations, and soon. I am not at all comfortable working to allow another member state to go into my pocket for money to play with.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:03 PM on 09/29/2011
Well said. At some point Germany is going to say no more as it should. From what I understand the citizens are already getting to that point fast.

The difference between Germany and what I currently see in the US is that Germany has learned from it's mistakes - and they were some of the most atrocious in history - and I feel confident they will not repeat them. Sad to say the current US admin seems to have no such wisdom
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:29 PM on 09/29/2011
It must be somewhat in Germany's best interest to be doing what it is doing. I suspect if they still had the Mark, or returned to the DM, its value would be skyrocketing relative to other currencies. This would create a bad headwind for Germany's export driven economy. A weaker Euro helps German corporations. I the best of all worlds, Germany keeps the Euro without having to bail out other countries but since when do we live in the best of all worlds?
08:07 PM on 09/29/2011
There is also the option of Greece leaving the Eurozone, not Germany.
05:20 PM on 09/29/2011
Germany pays for WW2 again.
05:12 PM on 09/29/2011
That's nice now who is going to bail them out next year. If they like us do not cut spending it sooner or later comes right back at you. The stimlus teacher olice hire will kill states as stimlus gone no new funds to support these hires.
04:28 PM on 09/29/2011
I guess I'm no economist, nor a magician (if there's a difference).

We invest in bonds to keep up with inflation.

We print money on the basis of national worth, vs gold, but then print more, anyway, in hopes of stimulating the economy of a nation that now has more money in circulation than it's worth, which means th emoney isn't really worth much: inflation.

Writing off debt really doesn't make it disappear. It just lets more money circulate that isn't really shouldn't be there, since it should have gone back to the creditor.

Seems we're just manipulating the system around it's own worthlessness, like the politically correct way of saying "broke". If you don't say "broke", you aren't.

It's like musical chairs, with too many chairs. Nobody ever gets left out, no matter what they do, which also mean that nobdoy will win and kind of makes the whole game useless.

I say, let's print "Bernanke Bucks".. They have a $2 face value, but you buy them for a dollar with the caveat that, at some unkown time, they'll vanish. We'll print them on flash paper, or something.

this way, everybody can double their wealth band the economy will roar because nobody wants to be holding "Bernankes" when the clock strikes the hour.

And, it's kind of like what we're doing, now, anyway.

If there's no penalty for doing anything wrong, then, nothing is really right, either.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:26 PM on 09/29/2011
I am an economist (and yes non leftist economists are different than magicians, we deal with reality) and you just completely and utterly hit the nail on the head. Kudos you should replace increasingly coo coo for coco puffs krugman.
04:26 PM on 09/29/2011
Europe and America, bastions of white liberal Gods, who can print $$ to save and take care of all worldly ills in third world, were bluntly humiliated when they asked China to buy the worthless bonds to keep Eurpoean nations like Greece from default. The head of China's sovreign fund answered: " we cannot save someone, we are not saviors, we must save ourselves". The latter part referred to China's inflation challenge. Do these insane Europeans think that orientals in China are totally stupid and will waste their hard earned assets on worthless paper so white liberal swindlers can live off of them? Chinese are smart,fair, and prosperous and had to humiliate these Euro. and American swindlers in order to get rid of them. The white Gods are not so mighty today.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
taina2
Spending my money smarter than government
04:26 PM on 09/29/2011
See the bank robber barons don't just plunder the US Treasury.
Michael5555
I built it despite you people
11:27 PM on 09/29/2011
Already have.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ecitjc
03:35 PM on 09/29/2011
well the BBC say the US goverment hold almost 7 billion euros worht junk notes,, who will bail us out....................
photo
turkeylurky
Just keepin it real........
04:50 PM on 09/29/2011
Ummm, the U.S. GNP is Approx $14 Trillion annually (as in 14,000 Billion)
7 Billion anything is chump change...
photo
jstov48
VastRightWingConspirator
09:17 PM on 09/29/2011
Ok turkeylurky. If it is chump change, you pay for it!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ecitjc
03:32 PM on 09/29/2011
So does anyone know how much Obama is going to buy of these junk bonds to help his lefty freinds out
05:53 PM on 09/29/2011
While I don't share your wording "lefty freinds", it's actually easy to answer your question:

The whole construct - both the temporary EFSF and the permanent ESM - are contributed with 250bn Euro (USD 340bn) from the IMF. According to the IMF regulations, the US provides around 15 to 16 percent of that: around USD 55bn.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:53 PM on 09/29/2011
My understanding is they will fund the fund with money from junk bonds issued by member countries to sell to banks and investment houses. Sounds like another financial meltdown coming.