More

Transgender Victory In Australia: Pair Win Legal Recognition As Men Without Surgery

Transgender Victory In Australia

10/ 5/11 11:06 PM ET   AP

CANBERRA, Australia -- Two transgender people won an appeal in Australia's highest court Thursday giving them legal recognition as men despite not having had complete sex change surgeries.

Transgender and intersex organizations praised the High Court's ruling as a precedent that would spare others from having to undergo medically unnecessary surgery to have their chosen gender recognized.

The court ruled that characteristics that identify a person as male or female are "confined to external physical characteristics that are socially recognizable." This recognition does not require knowledge of a person's sexual organs, the court said.

The pair, who have not been named, had their breasts surgically removed and underwent male hormone therapy, but retain some female sex organs.

The Western Australia state Gender Reassignment Board had refused to certify them as male because their sex change surgeries were incomplete.

Aram Hosie, spokesman for the W.A. Gender Project, said transgender people had previously been unable to legally change their gender "without invasive, medically unnecessary surgeries that may be unwanted, impractical or unattainable."

A Gender Agenda spokesman, Peter Hyndal, said the judgment was in line with South Africa, Britain and some other European countries that have relaxed surgical prerequisites for legally changing gender.

Last month, Australia altered its rules to allow transgender people to change the gender on their passports without sex change surgery.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GAY VOICES

CANBERRA, Australia -- Two transgender people won an appeal in Australia's highest court Thursday giving them legal recognition as men despite not having had complete sex change surgeries. Transgende...
CANBERRA, Australia -- Two transgender people won an appeal in Australia's highest court Thursday giving them legal recognition as men despite not having had complete sex change surgeries. Transgende...
Filed by Jade Walker  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:27 PM on 10/23/2011
So this means that MEN who get Breast Implants and are on estrogen ALSO GET FULL RECOGNITION AS WOMEN?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christina-Xena
That little Voice in your Head...is mine.
04:11 AM on 11/06/2011
Can't speak for Australia, but increasingly so in the US (varies by state). And not required for new gender marker on passports. Birth certificate changes can be a tad more restrictive...again...varies by state.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Valerie Keefe
10:15 PM on 11/13/2011
Well, they're NOT men, and breast implants aren't all that necessary when one can grow their own with said hormone replacement therapy, but yes, surgery should not be a requirement of basic human rights for trans people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Clozure
Whovian Likes Papadum
08:53 AM on 10/20/2011
Great news for the trans community in Oz and surely an inspiration for hope around the world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ioan Lightoller
Proud Married Gay Pagan Man
10:06 AM on 10/06/2011
How I WISH they would do that in the US. Neither my spouse nor I can have hormones or the surgery (me age and possible cardiac issues, my spouse hormonal problems that would be exacerbated by hormones and an inherited immune problem that she has been advised rules out surgery). We are classified as lesbians when we are actually gay men. But without surgery/hormones there can be no recognition of that.

Why can Australia see that and not the US?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eleanor Ruby Moon
Writer, Air-race Pilot, Australian
10:44 PM on 10/06/2011
Because Australia is a very intelligently run country. Advanced in so many, many ways.
01:20 PM on 11/15/2011
One of my dearest friends is Australian. They are pretty amazing. I like the new carbon tax too. However the support of gay marriage by the government is dreadful. Yet I would still live there in a heart beat if given the chance =D