Huffpost Education

John F. Kennedy High School Issues Illegal IDs To Students Based On Standardized Test Scores (POLL)

Posted: Updated:
STUDENTS
PA

An Orange County, Calif., high school has come under fire from state education officials after they issued student ID cards that are color-coded based on their standardized tests scores, the Orange County Register reported.

At John F. Kennedy high school, the cards come in three colors: Black, the highest level, gold, the second best, and white ... the worst.

The cards do more than just announce students' testing levels, however. The gold and black cards also give students access to a variety of discounts and campus privileges, while the white cards give none.

Los Angeles' KABC reported that some parents claim the status cards humiliate their children, after state officials have deemed them a violation of the students' privacy rights, the Anaheim Union High School District is reviewing the program.

District spokeswoman Pat Karlak told the Orange Country Register, however, that any invasion of privacy was unintentional.

"Kennedy's sole motivation was recognizing kids for their achievement," Karlak said. "At this point, we'll look into this to determine if unintentionally, confidential information has been released; clearly, we have no intention of doing that."

Ben Carpenter, principal of Cypress High School, which employs the same program, told TODAY Santa Ana that he sees the cards as a motivator.

"We have seen tremendous results, and the kids love it. It's the least discriminatory thing we do; anyone is eligible to get a gold card. It's not based on race, GPA, whether the student is an English learner," Carpenter told TODAY Santa Ana. "It's not based on anything other than how hard you work to learn the material in the classroom and how well you've performed in this classroom."

Kennedy high school senior Kiana Miyamoto told the Orange County Register that she disagrees.

"You see a lot of condescending attitudes toward everyone without a black card," Miyamoto told the Register. "One IB student said in class, 'Hey, you're in IB. Anyone who has a white card shouldn't even be in IB.' It's really sad to see people who have the black cards acting this way."

Quick Poll

Is this an invasion of privacy?

Yes!

No way.

Around the Web

Students' test scores show mixed results

Student IDs that reveal test scores deemed illegal