Huffpost Technology

Google Engineer Trashes Google+ As A 'Pathetic Afterthought,' 'Knee-Jerk Reaction'

Posted: Updated:
GOOGLE ENGINEER GOOGLE PLUS
AP
Print

Google+ hasn't been getting much love from users in recent days--its traffic reportedly plummeted 60 percent from its peak--but the most damning criticism seems to be coming from Google itself.

A post penned by Google engineer Steve Yegge has surfaced and in it, the software engineer trashes Google+ as a "pathetic afterthought" and "knee-jerk reaction."

Yegge describes Google+ as "a study in short-term thinking, predicated on the incorrect notion that Facebook is successful because they built a great product."

"But that's not why they are successful," he continues in the post, which was shared. "Facebook is successful because they built an entire constellation of products by allowing other people to do the work. So Facebook is different for everyone. Some people spend all their time on Mafia Wars. Some spend all their time on Farmville. There are hundreds or maybe thousands of different high-quality time sinks available, so there's something there for everyone."

Yegge also argued that Google's mistake was to attempt to "predict what people want and deliver it for them," an exercise that few if any innovators have been able to do successfully.

"Steve Jobs was one of them. We don't have a Steve Jobs here," Yegge wrote. "I'm sorry, but we don't."

In a follow-up post directed at "external-world folks," Yegge wrote that the 4,500-word entry, titled "Steve's Google Platforms Rant," had been posted publicly by mistake and that he had decided to remove the post because it was "really a private conversation between me and my peers and co-workers at Google."

The sharing mishap is particularly noteworthy given that Google touted Google+'s privacy protections as a key selling point and one of the major advantages its social service offered over Facebook. Google+'s "Circles" feature was lauded by Google as a solution to precisely this type of accidental over-sharing (if indeed it was an accident: one user who reposted Yegge's entry and made it available to the general public thanked Yegge for "allowing us to keep it out there" and said he "was given permission to keep it up"). "You share different things with different people. But sharing the right stuff with the right people shouldn’t be a hassle," Google wrote of Cricles when Google+ launched.

Yegge maintains that Google hasn't cracked down on him following his post.

"I contacted our internal PR folks and asked what to do, and they were also nice and supportive. But they didn't want me to think that they were even hinting at censoring me [emphasis his] -- they went out of their way to help me understand that we're an opinionated company, and not one of the kinds of companies that censors their employees," he noted.

His entry has since been re-posted on Google+ and Hacker News, among other sites.

Google did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the matter.

Google CEO Larry Page has been mum on the matter on his own Google+ account--his most recent post was about a new YouTube initiative, YouTube Space Lab.

Yegge is hardly the first Google employee to demonstrate mixed feelings about Google+. Though Google is said to have "bet the company" on the recently-launched social networking platform, many of the web giant's senior executives have barely used the site, according to research by MIchael DeGusta.

Close
Google+ Problems: Users' Biggest Issues So Far(CLONED)
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Around the Web

An ex-Googler's inside view on Google+ vs. Facebook - Jul. 19, 2011

Facebook engineers bring Google+ Circles to Facebook | ZDNet

Google engineer on Google+: 'A pathetic afterthought'

Googler: "We don't understand platforms"

Google engineer makes public rant about Google Plus

From Our Partners