More

Arizona High School Bans Cheerleaders' Breast Cancer Shirts For 'Questionable' Slogan

First Posted: 10/14/11 01:39 PM ET Updated: 12/14/11 05:12 AM ET

An Arizona high school cheerleading squad's efforts to raise money for breast cancer research has been a bumpy ride.

When Gilbert High School cheerleaders revealed the pink T-shirts they were planning to wear at the next two football games as they cheer and raise money from spectators, the administration issued a ban on the shirts for their "objectionable slogan," The Arizona Republic reports.

The shirts say "Gilbert Cheer" on the front and "Feel For Lumps, Save Your Bumps" on the back, featuring the recognizable pink ribbon for breast cancer awareness. October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month and the cheerleaders were hoping to support Susan G. Komen for the Cure.

Gilbert High School Principal J. Charles Santa Cruz said in a statement that he personally supports Fight for the Cure, and the administration backs the cheerleading squad's efforts. He adds that the students may wear generic pink shirts or other apparel without slogans, "they may not, however, wear the unauthorized T-shirt with the questionable slogan. The 'Fight for the Cure' is a serious matter and is much bigger than the slogan," KNXV-TV reports.

But varsity cheerleader Natalie Skowronek, a 17-year-old junior, says she doesn't think the slogan is inappropriate and her team should have the right to support their cause their way.

"We're not saying anything a doctor wouldn't say," Skowronek told The Arizona Republic.

The disagreement at Gilbert High is just one of many conflicts between school administrators and students over proper ways to display support for breast cancer awareness and research.

Earlier this year, two Philadelphia girls were suspended for defying a school ban on "I (heart) boobies!" bracelets by advocacy group Keep A Breast. The students took the case to court and a federal judge ruled in their favor, noting that the bracelets were neither lewd nor vulgar and can't be banned by public school officials that deemed them offensive.

The bracelets were also deemed inappropriate in many schools across the country -- so much so that Keep A Breast has a special section on their website that offers students resources to convince their schools otherwise.

While many students just like Gilbert's cheerleaders are fighting to bring awareness to the cause, some breast cancer advocates and survivors are questioning whether having a dedicated month and so many corporate sponsorships have watered down the actual message.

"The pink drives me nuts," 18-year-old breast cancer survivor Cynthia Ryan told the Associated Press. "It's the cheeriness I can't stand."

Part of the frustration and concern over breast cancer awareness campaigns is what has been dubbed "pinkwashing," in which the pink ribbon and color pink are used by companies who have declared a commitment to help search for a cure, even though the company may use chemicals linked to cancer.

Back at Gilbert, the cheerleaders are still upset over their limitations to express themselves, arguing that other clubs have displayed much more sexual slogans -- like the sign language club's "I'm good with my hands" shirts and the choir's "I'd hit that" shirts, according to The Arizona Republic.

The cheerleading team threatened to fight the decision and boycott the games by not cheering, instead wearing their shirts at the gate and collecting donations. But facing administrative threats of possibly being kicked off the team, the cheerleaders are now looking to simply collect donations at the games and may sell their banned shirts and donate those proceeds, according to KNXV-TV.

School dress codes and limitations to what students call self expression through apparel is a regular debate. Last month, a California school banned cheerleaders from wearing their uniforms to class, saying that the students must cover up with sweats because the uniform's skirts are too short. A Pennsylvania school district in August attempted to ban skinny jeans, but backed off the decision after stark protesting from parents.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST EDUCATION

An Arizona high school cheerleading squad's efforts to raise money for breast cancer research has been a bumpy ride. When Gilbert High School cheerleaders revealed the pink T-shirts they were plann...
An Arizona high school cheerleading squad's efforts to raise money for breast cancer research has been a bumpy ride. When Gilbert High School cheerleaders revealed the pink T-shirts they were plann...
Filed by Emmeline Zhao  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 117
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
broui
No d#%& cat. No d#%& cradle.
03:46 PM on 10/18/2011
My wife and kids and I did a breast cancer walk a couple of weekends ago.

Best shirt there was from the Marines: SAVE 2nd BASE.

I teach for a living. If my girls came to school wearing a shirt like the one the girls in Gilbert designed, I'd be proud of them, frankly. I recognize that in my community, like many there is a small but loud evangelical community that might object, but it is for breast cancer and the phrasing is pretty inoccuous.
photo
VirginiaDreaming
Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent
11:12 AM on 10/18/2011
A couple of years ago, some of my students got in trouble for wearing shirts with save the tatas. Totally silly in my opinion, but I may be biased since I teach about TATA boxes in my advanced bio class. (I'm not sure, but I got the feeling my vice principal didn't like that either.)
JStading
Trust me, I'm an attorney...
11:39 AM on 10/18/2011
Your school violated their 1st Amendment rights.  Those shirts are regularly upheld as being acceptable and part of students' free speech rights.  It's also exceedingly likely that the fact that you teach about "TATA" boxes means that a ban on the word based purely on context makes an even worse 1st Amendment violation.  We need a class to teach kids what their rights actually are, the problem is that I'm not sure who you would find to teach it - http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/04/12/i-heart-boobies-bracelets_n_848208.html
photo
VirginiaDreaming
Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent
03:43 PM on 10/18/2011
Thanks - I thought at the time it was silly to ban the shirts, and your information makes that clear. That Vice Principal also banned Obama shirts after the election on the grounds that the kids who supported McCain were angry and wearing the Obama shirts was like taunting them. That one brought a well deserved reaction from the ACLU and NAACP. I would guess you would not be surprised to hear that she is no longer our vice principal.
03:13 PM on 10/17/2011
Once again, student free speech is being tested. Our educators are well-intentioned but need to be educated about the legal rights allowed teenagers to express themselves in a non-violent, sexually appropriate manner. The Supreme Court has addressed this issue several times. It ruled in 1986 that "The undoubted freedom to advocate unpopular, controversial views in schools and classrooms must be balanced against society's countervailing interest in teaching students the boundaries of socially appropriate behavior." (Bethel School Dist. v. Fraser). This particular breast-awareness shirt would pass the constitutional challenge it presents to school administrators today. Regards, -Judge Tom.
www.askthejudge.info
photo
VirginiaDreaming
Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent
11:14 AM on 10/18/2011
Thanks for an informative and logical comment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rogelio Lopez
11:52 AM on 10/17/2011
oh c'mon....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dede Eagleburger
well behaved women rarely make History...
11:02 AM on 10/17/2011
Wow, I've learned so much on this thread...about Gilbert, AZ.
09:56 AM on 10/17/2011
Seriously??? The slogan is cute and appropriate. Every woman should start self breast exams in their teen years so that they can develop it as a habit. I am so tired of our society being so hung up on words that have to do with our bodies. Whatever you call them "lumps", "breasts", "my girls" you need to exam yourself once a month.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dede Eagleburger
well behaved women rarely make History...
10:56 AM on 10/17/2011
Truer words were never spoen, and I'm proud to be fan #1.
12:39 PM on 10/17/2011
Thank you. I found a lump when I was just 24. I was lucky. It was a benign precancerous tumor. I will never take monthly exams for granted. I still perform them and I have a hollow spot on the outside of my left breast to remind me of how important they are.
01:33 AM on 10/17/2011
WOW! That principal's stick up his butt has got a stick up it's butt!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
rwaller
My bio never meets guidelines!
08:07 PM on 10/16/2011
So the cheerleader uniforms are too short to be worn during school while walking and sitting but they are perfectly fine to be worn in front of a crowd while doing flips, cartwheels and high kicks. Is is it just me or is there something askew about the thinking?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
roaddawg31
07:10 PM on 10/16/2011
It's fine as an adult slogan. BUT

Kids are immature, and one (e.g. an administrator) can easily imagine situations where immature students (i.e. boys) take this slogan and do inapproriate things related to said slogan. Then what? Parents (i.e. moms) would be all up in arms, complaining about why they ever let such a suggestive slogan go by. You can't have it both ways idiots.
photo
VirginiaDreaming
Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent
11:24 AM on 10/18/2011
I understand what your saying. However, if we want our students to act more mature, we need to give them opportunities to act mature, or learn from failing to do so. Being a little risque to make a very good and important point more memorable is a good way to do so. I would much prefer this type of campaign than having a student come to school wearing a 5 dollar foot long t-shirt with an arrow pointing to his groin.
JStading
Trust me, I'm an attorney...
11:42 AM on 10/18/2011
So the prospect that someone may, under some outrageously attenuated circumstance, use a slogan for something other than its original, state sanctioned intent is adequate grounds to ban it?  Hope you're ready to ban all DARE shirts, since stoners love smoking marijuana in them.

What do we do when the parents complain about a slogan?  Remind them that there is a First Amendment and it's their job to raise their kids so that they don't fall apart at the mere sight of "offensive" language.

Also, your sexist assumption that only boys are immature is silly and misguided.  I seriously doubt that 14 year old girls are wearing these clothes because they all feel strongly about breast cancer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sam Smith
03:59 PM on 10/16/2011
Kilts for Cancer Awareness... Guys, DO IT......
VA Jill
Retired RN, Army mom. Bring the troops home!
02:41 PM on 10/16/2011
The school administrators need medical attention for broomstick removal!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pjohns
This political year---it, too, shall pass
12:30 PM on 10/16/2011
In a macro-world, they micro-manage as much as possible. A wonder we're not a prozac, nose-candy, drunken, anethisized society in totality. Says something for staying conscious, if only to read something like this and think of freedom of expression as a plus, not a minus to be eliminated. What a lop-sided society.
photo
SkeeBee
Offending InFoxtrination Sufferers With Facts.
12:09 AM on 10/16/2011
It is disturbing that a culture that repressed and uptight is so rife with weapons.
And Stupi Ditty,
cereally
10:40 PM on 10/15/2011
I know people who've worn 'I -heart- boobies' wristbands and shirts to school and haven't got in any trouble. I don't understand how they expect you to talk about breast cancer without mentioning the breast part.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
merrimac10
10:20 PM on 10/15/2011
Where can I buy one? I like the slogan, the shirt and it's for a good cause.