iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Target Manager Says He Was Fired 'Ironically' For Working Through Lunch

Target

First Posted: 10/17/11 03:53 PM ET Updated: 12/17/11 05:12 AM ET

An 8-year veteran of Target stores has accused the retailer of firing him for working through his lunch break against company policy.

In a lawsuit filed in federal court, Jason Kellner, a former manager at the company's Oxford, Ala., store, claims he was let go after supervisors caught him "performing work activities" without being clocked in.

Kellner claims the firing was retaliation for complaints he'd made in the past about Target's break policy, and his lawsuit sheds some light on the scheduling practices that helped spur a high-profile unionization drive among Target workers.

Kellner, who was paid on an hourly basis, says he was routinely denied an uninterrupted break at Target, often having to leave his lunch to handle any number of problems at the store: Customer complaints, cash register issues, shoplifting incidents, etc. Whenever he asked to be recouped for the time he worked while on break, he was told by supervisors that Target "couldn't pay overtime," and that he should just try to take another break later in his shift, according to the lawsuit.

But Kellner claims that he couldn't find another manager to cover for him, and that he often wound up working more than 40 hours per week without getting overtime pay. He also says he would have to close the store down off the clock at the end of the day.

According to the suit, Target has a policy against employees working while off the clock, yet the time clock at the store prevents workers from clocking back in after a break of less than 30 minutes, a practice common in retail. The result, Kellner claims, is that employees sometimes end up having to work without pay.

Asked about the allegations, a company spokeswoman told HuffPost in an email that "Target is committed to following all state and federal laws. However, as this is pending litigation, we don’t have any further information to share at this time."

A lawyer for Kellner could not be reached.

Kellner says his firing came after he and other hourly managers complained to their superiors that there were no salaried managers to cover for them when they ate. Kellner also had a meeting with an "investigative manager" from another store to discuss the break issue. He says he was fired two weeks later.

Kellner "was told he was being fired for working after he had clocked out for a meal period," according to the suit. Considering Kellner had apparently already complained about having to work through his break, the lawsuit notes that the stated reason for his firing was "ironic."

After several employees made a much-watched bid to unionize earlier this year, workers at a Target store on Long Island voted against joining the United Food and Commercial Workers back in June. It was the first union election the company had dealt with in two decades, and it brought some rare negative attention to a company generally beloved by its customers.

At the time, many workers told HuffPost that their schedules change frequently and they have a hard time hanging onto their hours in the face of newer, lower paid colleagues. They also said their pay has not kept pace with their increasing workload, even though company profits have grown over the previous two years, according to Target's 2010 annual report.

According to his lawsuit, Kellner had a different schedule to adjust to for each week of the month, his shift switching between mornings and evenings and his days off constantly changing. None of the schedules cited in the lawsuit offered two consecutive days off.

Kellner earned $20.37 an hour at the time of his firing, and he's asking to be reinstated and paid for the overtime he claims he's worked.

Read the lawsuit:
Kellner Target Lawsuit

FOLLOW HUFFPOST BUSINESS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Money newsletter!
An 8-year veteran of Target stores has accused the retailer of firing him for working through his lunch break against company policy. In a lawsuit filed in federal court, Jason Kellner, a former ma...
An 8-year veteran of Target stores has accused the retailer of firing him for working through his lunch break against company policy. In a lawsuit filed in federal court, Jason Kellner, a former ma...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,220
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (28 total)
09:41 PM on 11/02/2011
This is BS...Target has every opportunity to fix problems like this. For example, they provide an anonymous company hotline. If he really had a problem with working while on lunch (which my store would NEVER interrupt my lunch break for work) he should have said something. I'm sure there is more to this story...and I know my store is very strict when it comes to working on and off the clock. My point is, he should have done something about it before he got fired...if he really thought he was being treated unfairly.
bipolarbears60
common sense isn't so common
01:28 PM on 11/03/2011
According to the article he did say something and that's why he was fired. "Kellner says his firing came after he and other hourly managers complained to their superiors that there were no salaried managers to cover for them when they ate. Kellner also had a meeting with an "investigative manager" from another store to discuss the break issue. He says he was fired two weeks later."

You seem to be saying the results would have been different had he used the anonymous company hotline.
Oneandoneandone
Professional Spitfire
01:38 PM on 11/03/2011
The story says he did report it, and the lawsuit states that's why he was ultimately fired.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tmduke55221
02:29 PM on 11/02/2011
I worked fro wal-mart for 5 years and I really never had an issue like this. They gave me extra time at lunch to go home take care of my disabled fiancee and I made up that time at the end of the shift. Yes there were some issues that I saw but nothing on this scale. Other Jobs had other issues but so does life. I do not think Unions are the answer to this, they say strike and people strike and what happens they lose their hourly wage and maybe get a small strike allowance while the higher ups still get full pay. so both sides can be unfair.
photo
yukonsam
This space reserved for self-referential irony.
01:23 PM on 10/19/2011
Unless Target is consistantly firing people who work off the clock, this suit should be a slam dunk for the plaintiff. I'll bet they're working up an out-of-court settlement so they can kill the story without changing anything.
photo
gts31bumbee
a Warehouse of Information
11:42 AM on 10/19/2011
This is one of the few instances where management should be salaried employees only.... I would hesitate to add, if this person was a union member he should not be allowed by either side to hold a management position. This would go a long way in preventing abuses from either side !
09:45 PM on 11/02/2011
The managers are salaried, he must have been one level under the on duty managers. Idk why he would have to leave his lunch to handle issues that should have been handled by the salaried manager (which most of time there are one to two there) not the hourly employee. But he should have went beyond his store if he was being forced to work on his lunch.
08:17 AM on 10/19/2011
This situation doesn't surprised me one bit! Walmart, Target, Sears, Home Depot as well as other retailers have this dictatorship mentally on their workers. Many employees or former employees of these retailers have told or made legal complaints against their employers of these unfair labor tactics. Sometimes these employees can't even enjoy a proper lunch break due to the responsibilities they acquire working on a daily basis. Some employees are wearing two or three hats while working for these retailers but only getting the pay of one position. Employees get burned out easily, which cause chaos between the employee & employer. This been a problem since the days when Hecht company, Zayres, Sears, Woodies & Kmart was the retailers back in the day. It shouldn't be no surprise of this workman's abuse at the other retailers today.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mrald
Not to decide....is to decide.
08:17 AM on 10/19/2011
Every manager works off the clock at some point, Target wanted to get rid of him because he spoke up. It happens all the time.
photo
pickles n pops
Restore pre-1981 income and inheritance tax rates
05:18 PM on 10/19/2011
Doesn't a "manager" have to be a salaried employee?
10:57 PM on 11/02/2011
No. Target has what they call "team leads." They often get managerial duties and responsibilities thrown their way. These are not salaried employees.
01:26 AM on 10/19/2011
A year ago I quit shopping at Target when I learned how unfairly they treat their employees. I had been a good customer, buying cameras, photo accessories, clothing, and an expensive radio there. One feels rotten shopping at a store that is not fair to its workers.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Gudrun
My micro-bio is empty
08:08 AM on 10/19/2011
I am sorry to hear this about Target.
08:30 AM on 10/19/2011
Mr. Slate and Gudrun; it appears that neither of you have ever worked in retail or Target. I used to work at Target and have to say, they treat their team members with a LOT of respect. It is a shame that you both take the negative and run with it. There is always something negative said about all places of work; they are usually opinions. About the article....1) Yes, that is correct, when you are in retail, you work weekends, nights, day's and where the business is critical....this is not unfair and is simply a part of having a career in retail. 2) He is obviously well compensated, $20+hr.....that is very, very rare. 3) You can't work off the clock in any industry.....that is why there is a policy, hopefully, everywhere.....this protects the team member and the company. I would be willing to bet there is much more to the story. Last, Mr. Slate, would it be right for me to believe that if someone said you were not nice, that I simply believe that? No. Go with what you know sir.....Target is a solid company; I worked there for over 10 years.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
giftsthatpurr
zestful life
02:31 PM on 10/22/2011
Target backs the GOP. Do they back you?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
justafarmer
micro-bio? don't need no stinkin' micro-bio
11:21 PM on 10/22/2011
"You can't work off the clock in any industry..."
REALLY??? I see this all the time and it's been going on for years.
01:10 AM on 10/19/2011
JK was a Senior Team Leader. This position would be considered one step down from an Assistant Manager. He was probably the only person working in the store who had keys to the building. Therefore, if he was punched out on lunch, and a customer asked for "the manager"... that would be him, or an employee was calling the store to call in to work - he'd have to take that call.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ryan Schmidt
03:04 AM on 10/19/2011
Usually, he's not the only manager in the store working. Usually, when Sr Team Leads are working there is another LOD on duty..
08:34 AM on 10/19/2011
This is not correct. If the Sr. TL is closing, they are in charge of the building. Once more, the Sr. TL know's before the last ETL leaves, that he/she will need to take their lunch so they avoid situations like assisting a guest off the clock. The early/mid ETL always ensures the Sr. TL takes their lunch before leaving for the day.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gerorem
Linus v. Lucy
08:53 PM on 10/18/2011
SOBB: Same Old Big Box. Their idea of profit is to constantly play games with payroll. The quarterly or annual profit equates to how many people they can lay off. I saw this first hand for 13 years in retail. I use local merchants.
photo
SparkyGump
Obey the Beagle!
07:48 PM on 10/18/2011
Yet another reason not to shop there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sadiemae1214
Life is a Cabaret old Chum!
07:15 PM on 10/18/2011
I worked for a MAJOR corporation (which shall remain nameless), in one of their convenience stores. Our scheduled hours could be from 4 to 12 hour days and company policy did NOT include breaks or lunch, either on or off the clock! We got no meal breaks and were told we had to eat and work at the same. time. To get just a short break required sweeping the parking lot if you were a smoker. I was told that in this particular industry, it was legal. Sitting down was not permitted unless it was on the floor while you were stocking a bottom shelf.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ryan Schmidt
03:05 AM on 10/19/2011
That's wrong.. State laws protect you against stuff like this where they have to provide breaks..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sadiemae1214
Life is a Cabaret old Chum!
10:49 AM on 10/19/2011
Find me a Federal Statute number and I'll pursue the matter.
03:59 PM on 11/02/2011
Bull! My son worked for Racetrac and this was their "policy" also. He worked long hours and was never given a break. He'd stuff down a sandwich while working the register. They were not permitted to sit down at any time during their shift. He wasn't a manager, but was left "in charge" on a regular basis, performing managerial duties (but not at a managerial salary).
07:05 PM on 10/18/2011
I hate Target. And he's a fool for working off the clock. They tried to get me to work all the time off the clock at Pizza Hut with no overtime. I laughed and told them eat dog ****.
photo
Conservador-Rebelde
Insert witty comment here:
04:10 PM on 10/18/2011
"Kellner says his firing came after he and other hourly managers complained to their superiors that there were no salaried managers to cover for them when they ate."

So basically what this is saying is that the managers don't know how to plan. It sounds here that there could be other managers to be there, but they are all eating at the same time.

Bottom line is that he needed to follow the rules until he could convince them to change the rules.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Olderandwiser55
getting older and wiser....
12:47 AM on 10/19/2011
Omg, I needed the laugh, thanks!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ryan Schmidt
03:06 AM on 10/19/2011
Usually the managers do eat their lunches at the same time..
03:09 PM on 10/18/2011
Buy from small mom&pop shops instead!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mercedes1947
GOP: "We don't got to show you no stinking facts."
08:44 PM on 10/18/2011
There aren't any - big box stores have driven them out of business.
02:59 PM on 10/18/2011
This issue was discussed on some online forum too. I wonder if JK posted it...

http://www.thebreakroom.org/showthread.php/517-LOD-for-10-hours...hourly-TM