More

David Moye
GET UPDATES FROM David
 

Transgender Bodybuilder Chris Bruce Comes In Second In Female Bodybuilding Contest -- Out Of Two Contestants (VIDEO)

First Posted: 11/01/11 05:57 PM ET Updated: 11/01/11 06:33 PM ET

Bodybuilder Chris Tina Bruce didn't win her first bodybuilding competition in 18 years, but she still feels victorious.

That's because Bruce, a 43-year-old personal trainer in San Diego, is transgender and her participation in the Border States Classic Bodybuilding competition on Oct. 29 represented not just three months of intense physical preparation, but also a lifetime of coming to terms with her true identity as a woman.

The 6-foot, 3-inch Bruce dropped 40 pounds for the event, and while the organizers were OK with a former male competing as female, she admits she was nervous about the reaction her participation would engender.

Although she ended up coming in second in her event, Bruce says she still feels like a winner.

"I came in second and I understand why they couldn't give it to me," Bruce told The Huffington Post. "But I was treated with respect. People, including the other contestants, asked to pose with me. I went in there expecting the worst, but there was no booing."

However, that second-place honor may be as ambiguous as the concept of gender. According to contest organizer John Lindsay, Bruce was only competing against one other contestant, a 48-year-old female bodybuilder.

"Female bodybuilding is dead," Lindsay explained to The Huffington Post, adding that that category usually only attracts one or two contestants.

A female bodybuilder who wasn't at the event but who agreed to speak on background says its common for trophies to be handed out to the top five in each category and that it is also common for competitive bodybuilders who are only competitng against one other person to do as Bruce has and say they came in second.

Bruce says that while her event was on at the early portion of the evening, she believes her participation -- and the international attention it received -- helped attract a huge crowd.

"The parking lot was jammed," Bruce said proudly. "The promoter told me he had a dozen media requests for coverage, but turned them down out of respect to the other contestants. Which, again, I understand. It's a mental game."

Lindsay -- who emphasizes that he thinks Bruce is "a nice guy" and "am glad he participated" -- tells a slightly different story.

"I've been doing this for 25 years and sell out every year, so I see zero impact from him being in the show," Lindsay said. "I will say this, during the preliminary rounds, the other contestant had four supporters there and he had none."

Meanwhile, Bruce says the reaction and support she says she received represents a great moment in her life and she is pleased that other contestants did speak with her rather than be standoffish.

"It reinforced to me that I need to keep doing it," she said proudly.

If she does, it won't be with Lindsay's competition.

"I don't want to rain on the parade, but I was under the impression the hardware had been removed, and it hasn't been," Lindsay said. "We're not going to have men competing against women and I am not setting up a transgender category."

Bruce concedes that she has not surgically transitioned, but says that shouldn't mean anything.

"Hormones are what makes the difference between male and female," she said, adding that, at this point, her penis is just a urethra.

She also says that while she was only competing against one other person, she believes the No. 2 position is a great personal victory.

"Going through what I've gone through will make a person stronger than lifting weights," she said.

Although Bruce is keeping her eye on potential competitions, she also wants to build up her personal training business and has her eyes set on the perfect celebrity client: Chaz Bono, the transgender son of Cher, who has quick-stepped his way to controversy on "Dancing With The Stars" this season.

 
FOLLOW HUFFPOST GAY VOICES

Bodybuilder Chris Tina Bruce didn't win her first bodybuilding competition in 18 years, but she still feels victorious. That's because Bruce, a 43-year-old personal trainer in San Diego, is transge...
Bodybuilder Chris Tina Bruce didn't win her first bodybuilding competition in 18 years, but she still feels victorious. That's because Bruce, a 43-year-old personal trainer in San Diego, is transge...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 84
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christina-Xena
That little Voice in your Head...is mine.
07:39 PM on 11/15/2011
Just about all the hate and misinformation type comments, and some clarifing contra-comments (over 600 of such comments) have already been seen in the first article about this posted on October 28. Just look it up! (key word..."bodybuilding")

So the only difference here is that she came in second place in this competition, which is not very important as to the place. More importantly she was authorized to compete,...as a woman she did, and she raised the acceptance bar for transgender people in society as a whole.

That makes her and the transgender community bi-winners!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:08 AM on 11/04/2011
Born a male, always a male. Born a female, always a female. There is no way around it. I will start believing it when the first gender bender say female to male suffers from prostate cancer. It will never happen. But hey, if I dress up as a sheep dog and want to be known as a sheep dog, does that mean I will have protection from the SPCA? I doubt it seriously.
photo
Misterioso Adversario
THE THIRST MUTILATOR!
02:06 AM on 11/21/2011
Oh look this old silly line of thinking, from yet another horribly uninformed person.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:06 AM on 11/21/2011
Yeah right, somehow I am uninformed? No way! God did not come and re-engineer this person to become a different gender. So lets get real here, if you dress up a goose to look like a duck, its still a goose.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:22 PM on 11/22/2011
Hey born a male always a male, born a female always a female. If I dress up like a sheepdog doesn't make me a sheepdog. Bow wow wow! Woof!
11:40 AM on 11/03/2011
News ? Really ?
10:42 AM on 11/03/2011
gee, I should have gotten in on this contest, I could have made 3rd place. I missed my chance.
07:43 AM on 11/03/2011
What would have happened if she wasn't allowed to compete? It would have been awkward having a competition with only 1 participant. Maybe that's why they let her compete in the first place.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christina-Xena
That little Voice in your Head...is mine.
07:08 PM on 11/15/2011
blackjacki slurs with a "maybe" thought: "Maybe that's why they let her compete in the first place." Which of course attempts to sidetrack the logical idea that the competition organizers thought it was appropriate and fair. Hummmmm????

You have anything to back up that "maybe" idea?

No?.......didn't think so.

One more "maybe".....Zapped!!
85Percent
Southern Liberal & Michigander
11:06 PM on 11/02/2011
Still looks very much like a man to me. I have seen some very nice looking transgendered women (former men) who really look feminine. And we have all seen some very well muscled female body builders. This guy/girl looks like neither. I suspect he/she is not very far along in the change process. Unfair in this instance, I think. Medical science can only do so much.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christina-Xena
That little Voice in your Head...is mine.
07:27 PM on 11/15/2011
I have seen photos of transgender woman who are as tall and even taller than Tina...and they look very feminine and even beautiful.

But after a certain young age the bone structure isn't going to be affected by female hormones. But one major affect of them if increased body fat distributed in feminine areas. Unfortunately body building competition is a low body-fat sport, so even normally rounded females tend to look more masculine being so lean and muscled.

For a transgender woman they don't get the feminine effects of fat to much of a degree, so unless they just happen to have a somewhat feminine bone structure...they will have a more masculine appearance than other trans-woman in society, and in female body buidling competitions. And certainly any woman over 6' may have height/build issues for feminine appearances sake.

And remember, unless one is a regular observer of female body buiding events, you won't have the "eye" for what a woman competitor typically looks like, or how their bodies are scored to rank well.

And then again, I've taken (natal) ciswoman for being male crossdressers in society so there is really no one single body shape/height/appearance that is universal for men or woman.

And BTW, medical science can do a lot for the majority of trans woman and men, and in public you could pass by, or meet, a fully transitioned/transformed trans-woman and you wouldn't have a clue.
85Percent
Southern Liberal & Michigander
11:30 AM on 11/16/2011
Thanks for your post. I'm still confused about some of this. The first case of a man becoming a woman that I came across was in the very late seventies. I hope we have made a lot of progress since then.

I don't know what the correct term is, but a big favorite of mine is The Lady Chablis from the Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil. I have her book, Hiding My Candy.

I'm not gay or trans anything, but I am drawn to people out of the ordinary way. My ex could not stand some of my friends.
photo
BigBrickHouse
I'm no longer PC; Quit that nasty habit years ago.
09:29 PM on 11/02/2011
I was a bodybuilder in the 80's and early 90's. I'd like to hear the opinions of the great Rachel McLish and Cory Everson concerning allowing a man to compete against women. It’s ridiculous and we all know it. This has absolutely nothing to do with tolerance or acceptance. This is about physiology and fairness.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christina-Xena
That little Voice in your Head...is mine.
08:23 PM on 11/15/2011
So if it's so "unfair" then what does that say about the first place winner? Afterall she is more muscled and has better form than Chris has. Not much advantage it seems despite Chris's past.

As the song still goes...."the times....they are a'changinnnn"!
07:30 PM on 11/02/2011
Yeah, that's fair!

(Yes, I'm being sarcastic)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djnc
06:42 PM on 11/02/2011
totally delusional...all of "her" feelings about the event were completely crapped on by the organizer lol
05:28 PM on 11/02/2011
While I understand the concerns about fairness, I think some of the commentators don't understand the difference between gender and biological sex or the effects of hormones on transsexuals.

Sex marker refers to reproduction, gender is social. They are not the same. Even at the chromosomal level there are combinations other than XX and XY. Also, recent medical research suggests that most transsexuals have brain development and patterns typical of the opposite sex, and that these developed in fetus, not due to conditioning or environment. It's not seen or experienced as choice, it's an identity.

Hormones are powerful and they affect an entire body at once, not just parts of it. Male muscle mass and strength is based on testosterone, both to create the muscles and to maintain them. A MTF transsexual usually takes both estrogen and an anti-androgen, a testosterone blocker. The blocker stops the manufacture of testosterone. After a relatively short time, the body loses virtually all it's testosterone, and levels may even fall BELOW that of a genetic female. Without the testosterone, transwomen LOSE muscle mass, and within about three years tend to be at female levels for their frame. This is why transwomen athlete are allowed to compete based on where they are in their treatment, not the type of genitals. They are not usually inherently stronger at that frame size. I don't think she had any particular advantage if she had been on the usual course of treatment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christina-Xena
That little Voice in your Head...is mine.
06:26 PM on 11/15/2011
Great explanation of the gender vs sexual aspects, and the effects of hormones on MtFs.

And nice to see another rare post about the factual basis on a trans topic instead of the usual fun-making and obvious hate-bias from many commentors. I only hope the distractors bother to read this accurate information.

F& F
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Andres64
Religion is a sectually transmitted disease.
03:36 PM on 11/02/2011
Reminds me of the South Park episode where Cartman decided to cheat and enter the Special Olympics.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DoctorWhoDat
Why did I land on this planet?
03:29 PM on 11/02/2011
Ann Coulter was in third place.
03:24 PM on 11/02/2011
She's still got a weenie, therefore, she's a guy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christina-Xena
That little Voice in your Head...is mine.
08:27 PM on 11/15/2011
You may have your own criteria for who's woman or man...but society and the law may be quite different and is in many situtations/legal status cases...and more advanced in their considerations. And this competition doesn't seem to agree with your view at all.

And no doubt, "weenie" or not....your views and distain would remain the same.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:59 PM on 11/02/2011
I'm just trying to figure out how is this fair? Wouldn't she be bigger?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christina-Xena
That little Voice in your Head...is mine.
08:31 PM on 11/15/2011
Competition for woman is usually divided into height categories, and height isn't neccessarily an advantage...it takes way more muscle to compete with a tall frame.

And for her height of 6'3" 190 lbs isn't very big at all. It's about average for a woman her height in general society.
photo
Ossit
Ossit
01:32 PM on 11/02/2011
I think women's bodybuilding is wild especially the 'heavyweights' who look like they can break a guy in two and yeah I've got no doubt they might be using undetectable steroids. But this is no fair. I've got no problem with transgender, but he had the testosterone to build muscle mass. Him taking estrogen just 'softens' his lines a trifle. He probably had to retrain his voice to sound like a her voice. The hormones grow a lady's chest. But he had an unfair advantage whether he won second or not. It would be no fair if a woman 'changed' to a guy and competed in Mr. Universe or Mr. America. Any testosterone treatments she'd take when she became a he, won't give him amazing muscle mass. They'd lower his voice perhaps, allow facial hair to grow like a guy she as a he won't become as strong as a guy naturally is. Now bodybuilding competitions for transgenders only, when all are on the same footing, got no problem with. Bodybuilding is definitely a commitment.