iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Income Mobility In U.S. Decreased In Recent Years: Boston Fed Report

Income Mobility Us

First Posted: 11/07/11 12:02 PM ET Updated: 11/07/11 01:39 PM ET

The American Dream, that well-worn belief that anyone can pick themselves up by their bootstraps, just isn't what it use to be.

Income mobility, or the ability to move from one class to another, declined by a "statistically significant degree" between 1995 and 2005, especially compared to the 1970s and 1980s, when mobility hit its peak, according to a recent study from the Boston Federal Reserve. Families were more likely in recent years to stay within their income class than they were decades ago, regardless of if they start out poor or rich.

That means the poor and middle-class are having trouble moving up, while the rich are staying rich.

And income mobility isn't the only promise that's being whittled away. Though homeownership is at its lowest level since the Great Depression, most Americans still consider it part of the American Dream.

The study's findings have especially sour implications for the nation's poor, as the gap between them and rich continues to widen. The top 1 percent of American earners saw their incomes grow 275 percent between 1979 and 2007, a recent study from the Congressional Budget Office found. During that same period, incomes for those in the bottom fifth of earners grew by only 20 percent.

For many, paychecks have only gotten smaller during the recovery. The national median income fell last year for the second year in a row to $26,364 -- the lowest level since 1999. In contrast, millionaires currently control nearly 40 percent of global wealth and in the U.S. the 400 richest Americans have more wealth than half of all Americans combined.

That distance between the rich and the poor has most Americans concerned. Protests raging in Zuccotti Park and around the world are in part aimed at highlighting growing income inequality. In addition, more than half of Americans consider income inequality a problem, according to a recent poll conducted by The Hill.

Recent research validates such concern. Rising income inequality could hinder a broader U.S. recovery, according to a study released last month by the International Monetary Fund.

One way to address the widening income gap could be through tax reform. A more redistributive tax system may have increased mobility in the 1980s, but its impact has since work off, according to the Boston Federal Reserve study.

Famed billionaire investor Warren Buffet proposed a change to the tax system in August that would make millionaires pay taxes at the same or higher rate than middle-class earners. Nearly three-quarters of Americans support the so-called "Buffett rule," according to a DailyKos poll released in September.

If Republican presidential candidate Rick Perry had things his way, politicians wouldn't concern themselves with income inequality when reforming the federal tax code. The Texas governor himself told The New York Times last month that he doesn't care if his own tax plan increases the wealth gap.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST BUSINESS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Money newsletter!
The American Dream, that well-worn belief that anyone can pick themselves up by their bootstraps, just isn't what it use to be. Income mobility, or the ability to move from one class to another, de...
The American Dream, that well-worn belief that anyone can pick themselves up by their bootstraps, just isn't what it use to be. Income mobility, or the ability to move from one class to another, de...
Filed by Jillian Berman  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 79
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
05:08 PM on 12/31/2011
Trust HuffPost to misreport. Here's what the Treasury Dept report says:
â– There was considerable income mobility of individuals in the U.S. economy during the 1996 through 2005 period with roughly half of taxpayers who began in the bottom quintile moving up to a higher income group within 10 years.
â– About 55 percent of taxpayers moved to a different income quintile within 10 years.
■Among those with the very highest incomes in 1996 — the top 1/100 of 1 percent — only 25 percent remained in this group in 2005. Moreover, the median real income of these taxpayers declined over this period.
â– The degree of mobility among income groups is unchanged from the prior decade (1987 through 1996).
â– Economic growth resulted in rising incomes for most taxpayers over the period from 1996 to
2005. Median incomes of all taxpayers increased by 24 percent after adjusting for inflation. The real incomes of two-thirds of all taxpayers increased over this period. In addition, the median incomes of those initially in the lower income groups increased more than the median incomes of those initially in the higher income groups.

Nearly 58 percent of households (i.e., 57.6 = 100 — 42.4) in the lowest income quintile in 1996 had moved to a higher quintile by 2005. While 29 percent moved up to the second quintile, the same percentage moved up at least two quintiles, and about 5 percent moved all the way to the top quintile.
04:03 AM on 11/10/2011
This only highlights the fundamental flow in the "trickle-down" myth the Right continue to somehow sell to people who, in return, vote against their own interests. My Great Grandfather who I was privileged to know had many truisms. One of which was that "... you can only sleep in one bed at one time and sit down to one meal at a time". If the people who continue to manipulate the system and widen the income disparity by attacking unions and fundamental human rights really were "trickling" down their money at one time, it has come to a halt.

Once you've bought two or three house - employment for the construction industries - and four or five cars - good for the U.S. auto industry, if we're lucky! - what then with the millions left over? Of course speculate! And let's deregulate the financial industry and government so that our ways of earning it and our tax burden on those earnings falls and falls.

But its coming crashing down! Working Americans and those who are not, are not spending and feeding the beast. Its going to be ugly and I hope e can all hang on. But it has to end!
photo
quickchick
No patience for stupidity
12:45 PM on 11/08/2011
This income gap rose the fastest during the Clinton years...where's that being reported?
10:21 AM on 11/08/2011
Simple legislation - simple solution - The bottom workers pay can only be 100 times less than the top executives . I have just solved all of America problems . Disposable incomes at the bottom - no longer unrealistic incomes at the top .
nothingchanges
too soon old, too late smart
08:59 AM on 11/08/2011
Ah..............the American dream.

Possibly best explained by George Carlin in 2005

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=acLW1vFO-2Q

Warning: Mr. Carlin uses some language that some might find offensive, if crude language offends you, please do not use the link.

Personally I think the problem he describes is the real obscenity.
08:50 AM on 11/08/2011
Here is the problem with our financial structure right now.
Jim in the accounts department is making $40K per year. Kim in Operations is making $43K per year.
Joe Exec is taking home $700K in salary and $3 million in bonus money.
Simon CEO is taking home $1.5 million in salary and $5 million in bonus money.

Next year Joe Exec and Simon CEO can take home even more in bonus money if they turn a larger profit. Easiest way to do that is to cut costs.
So, Joe Exec and Simon CEO cut some people from the accounts and operations departments and also cut some employee benefits.
Now, Jim and Kim are working longer hours, got no raise whatsoever and had their benefits cut, while Joe Exec and Simon CEO are taking home $1 million more each in bonus money because they "cut costs" and turned a larger profit.

That folks is the main issue, and unless the common workers all around the country start really rising up against this sort of thing, the gap between the rich and poor will just continue to grow.
photo
GeorgieGirl9
Liberty, In God We Trust, and E Pluribus Unum
10:28 PM on 11/07/2011
Just how many dividing, class wa_rfare articles can h p post in one day? What exactly does all this agitation accomplish?
photo
webwzrd
Reality is liberal indoctrination
02:09 AM on 11/08/2011
Agitation? Is this what you call it when your mistaken notions are challenged with the truth? The American dream you folks advertise and use as a reason to deride others has been under attack and is suffering. People are protesting because they KNOW it. You are welcome to continue living in denial. We wouldn't want you to become agitated, now would we?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ashok Hegde
02:39 AM on 11/08/2011
The american dream is suffering because of the lack of competitiveness of american unskilled and semi skilled labor.

When you have a population growing ever more obese, watching 6+ hours of tv a day, not picking up a book, and generally knowing more about reality tv than they do about global political economy - you have decay.

The truth is also about the behavior of the unskilled. Blaming the wealthy is only part of the story.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stay Up Shabazz
Meet me on 110th street
10:00 PM on 11/07/2011
The Dream has always been a metaphor -- and now it's out of reach of the people who aren't born or unjustly have the future of their hard labor taken away from them as the gap grows daily.

But that's just me. We've fallen SO FAR and we've got SO MUCH to go, but the people who are in teh position to help and change, don't want to because it doesn't affect them.

Dah well. Robberies and depression will increase. Then people will blame the people.
08:51 PM on 11/07/2011
Only Stupid people vote for Republicans, and only Ignorant people vote for Democrats. Thus we have a Government Of the Rich, By the Rich, and For the Rich. Where are the American People that Georgie Porgie Bush loved to talk about? Trying to stay even with the game, since they will never get ahead. Why? The American People have NO Representation in Congress!
08:45 PM on 11/07/2011
Greed and stupidity have finally taken it's toll on this country!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kye154
08:00 PM on 11/07/2011
The American Dream has always been a fabled dream, and nothing more. Just ask any of the 49.1 million poor people, or the millions facing foreclosure on their homes now, or the 22 million who cannot find a job. When the U.S. ranks 43rd among the worst countries in the world with disparities, (right along side of Uganda), yet there are 92 countries that are better off than us, it shouldn't leave any question in anyone's mind we have been fed allot of propaganda over the years about how well off we are. Although back in the 1950's and 1960's, when there was less income disparities in America, the American dream could become a reality then, but it has become a nightmare since!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jmorgan1981
Veni, Vidi, Vici.
08:46 PM on 11/07/2011
Ask any Republican, that is what makes us exceptional. #fail
07:45 PM on 11/07/2011
I am not surprised by the lack of involvement on this subject. For those like myself that have neither the will or the desire to punch through to the promise land. I/we Thought that hard work, being frugal along with loyalty and dedication were going to be enough to develop a standard of living that if not comfortable at least adequate for my needs. The harsh reality has been a bitter pill. Now at fifty something I find that my loyalty and dedication has benefited my employer to a far more enriching degree than myself. It is my understanding that I am to blame for desiring stability over riches. That to be satisfied with life was not acceptable is a new experience. To my dying days I will not understand that concept. Leaving me a burden on a society that I worked to avoid my whole life. The penalty for not assimilating will be harsh. The pain and suffering will be intense. The fault falls upon my shoulders in a burdensome yoke of debt and despair. What remains of my life will be filled with uncertainties and heartbreak. The once optimistic lad has grown old with labor. Sour with pain and disappointment. My/our voice will not be heard over the din of political posturing. My predicament will be shared but not discussed. Avoided yet accepted as poor choices.
photo
cue
Ichi-go, ichi-e
01:27 PM on 11/08/2011
F/F'd. Thanx for pointing out that the American Dream is NOT to join the 1%, but rather to have enough to live the life you envisioned, pursuing the experiences, relationships and sufficient creature comforts to be fulfilled without being a burden. Those "sufficiencies" are what is being denied by the inequities in our political, economic and social justice systems.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:41 PM on 11/07/2011
Income inequality is a crucial thing to consider when discussing the economy. That Perry shows no regard for it only adds to the arguments against having him as president, or even as governer.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rdsmith627
08:41 PM on 11/07/2011
Perry smokes pole.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nkurland
I'm going to leave this planet alive
05:42 PM on 11/07/2011
Since roughly 1973, overall inequality has increased while upward mobility and real wages have decreased. Whether it was the Democratic party of the mid-1970's arguing rising inequality wasn't a problem since it was within post-WWII norms, or the GOP simply arguing that all suffering is relative, both parties have employed a variety of excuses to ignore the problem. All of this dodges a crucial truth: a degree of wealth redistribution not only improves economic growth, but also quells potential unrest.
photo
bookreader451
"You can't ever have my books," she said.
05:25 PM on 11/07/2011
So much for me voting Republican just knowing that someday I would be rich too.