More

Restaurants Around The World To Use DNA Barcoding To Prevent Seafood Mislabeling

By ROD McGUIRK   11/27/11 07:12 AM ET   AP

CANBERRA, Australia -- Restaurants around the world will soon use new DNA technology to assure patrons they are being served the genuine fish fillet or caviar they ordered, rather than inferior substitutes, an expert in genetic identification says.

In October, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration officially approved so-called DNA barcoding – a standardized fingerprint that can identify a species like a supermarket scanner reads a barcode – to prevent the mislabeling of both locally produced and imported seafood in the United States. Other national regulators around the world are also considering adopting DNA barcoding as a fast, reliable and cost-effective tool for identifying organic matter.

David Schindel, a Smithsonian Institution paleontologist and executive secretary of the Washington-based Consortium for the Barcode of Life, said he has started discussions with the restaurant industry and seafood suppliers about utilizing the technology as a means of certifying the authenticity of delicacies.

"When they sell something that's really expensive, they want the consumer to believe that they're getting what they're paying for," Schindel told The Associated Press.

"We're going to start seeing a self-regulating movement by the high-end trade embracing barcoding as a mark of quality," he said.

While it would never be economically viable to DNA test every fish, it would be possible to test a sample of several fish from a trawler load, he said.

Schindel is organizer of the biennial International Barcode of Life Conference, which is being held Monday in the southern Australian city of Adelaide. The fourth in the conference series brings together 450 experts in the field to discuss new and increasingly diverse applications for the science.

Applications range from discovering what Australia's herd of 1 million feral camels feeds on in the Outback to uncovering fraud in Malaysia's herbal drug industry.

Schindel leads a consortium of scientists from almost 50 nations in overseeing the compilation of a global reference library for the Earth's 1.8 million known species.

The Barcode of Life Database so far includes more than 167,000 species.

Mislabeling is widespread in the seafood industry and usually involves cheaper types of fish being sold as more expensive varieties. A pair of New York high school students using DNA barcoding of food stocked in their own kitchens found in a 2009 study that caviar labeled as sturgeon was actually Mississippi paddlefish.

In a published study a year earlier, another pair of students from the high school found that one-fourth of fish samples they had collected around New York were incorrectly labeled as higher-priced fish.

Mislabeling of fish – which account for almost half the world's vertebrate species – also poses risks to human health and the environment.

In 2007, several people became seriously ill from eating illegally imported toxic pufferfish from China that had been mislabeled as monkfish to circumvent U.S. import restrictions. Endangered species are also sold as more common fish varieties.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST FOOD

CANBERRA, Australia -- Restaurants around the world will soon use new DNA technology to assure patrons they are being served the genuine fish fillet or caviar they ordered, rather than inferior substi...
CANBERRA, Australia -- Restaurants around the world will soon use new DNA technology to assure patrons they are being served the genuine fish fillet or caviar they ordered, rather than inferior substi...
Filed by Carey Polis  |  Report Corrections
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:04 PM on 12/18/2011
This is a good idea, as there are many sketchy people out there trying to sell lower quality fish for high quality costs. My mother mentioned that this was a ever-growing problem in China for years ie: selling "counterfeit" hairy Dungeness crab. Such a shame.

http://beckymonster.blogspot.com/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MyResponsibility
To Disagree,one need not be disagreeable
11:57 PM on 11/29/2011
There is zero need to DNA test a sample lot from a trawler. Fish species are easily identifiable in whole form or even skin-on fillet form. It is when the skin is removed that identification becomes sometimes difficult. Today I was searching for tuna saku blocks for a Foodservice distributor. When I requested a supplier for it, I only requested Saku blocks, negating the tuna part. They came back to me with Escolar Saku blocks. For those which do not know, the vast majority of sushi/nigiri/sashimi that has "white tuna" is actually rarely tuna, it is escolar, no relation at all yo tuna. Tuna Saku blocks cost over $10/lb, while escolar is less than $3/lb. It is a popular fish in Russia where it is known as "oil fish." If you had some intestinal problems after eating white tuna, you can be certain it was escolar.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cincity Cin
12:18 AM on 11/29/2011
Pretty Cool
10:02 PM on 11/28/2011
That's what "free enterprise" is all about. "Catch me" if you can!
Self regulation-are you kidding?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sanity Always Prevails
No more American blood for Israel!
04:56 PM on 11/28/2011
I bet they find out a lobster killed Ron and Nicole.
12:07 PM on 11/28/2011
Operationally speaking, exactly how is the consumer going to verify the bar code and its connection to the meal they are currently eating? This sort of self regulation never works. The only solution would be to random sample the suppliers and importers through a federal program. I'm thinking this is what the industry is trying to avoid by coming up with this hair-brained idea.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MyResponsibility
To Disagree,one need not be disagreeable
12:06 AM on 11/30/2011
It can be done without a federal program. I am a fish importer, and I do not cheat - never. I constantly run against fish mongers who are selling the "same" species as me, but significantly lower priced. Fish in the round has a market value, and selling at less than market value is usually a sign of some deception - most often as over-soaked (sodium tripoly phosphate) or less than declared weight (Net weight declared on box is 10.0 lbs, but 8 lbs of fish coated with 2 lbs of ice glaze). We report these violations regularly, and other honest dealers do as well. There is actually an industry association called the Better Seafood Bureau that is a very large group of dealers/Fisheries/processors that are committed to combatting fish fraud. The number of arrests, seizures, and felony prosecutions have skyrocket by self-policing rather than through government inspection.
11:48 AM on 11/28/2011
Okay....another HUGE reason to buy as local as possible.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:35 AM on 11/28/2011
Of course if GOP had its way, there'd be no regulation of anything.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:35 AM on 11/28/2011
Great news! So important. So much needs to be done to strengthen how our food can be inspected.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MCTSilverlakeCA
retired Sr Litigation Insurance Fraud Manager
12:00 AM on 11/28/2011
This is a very good idea - lately there have been a lot of grocery chains discovering that what they think they have been sold - and have labelled for consumer purchase - isn't what it was thought to be. Prime examples are blue fin tuna - which is much higher in toxic mercury than albacore tuna - and yet in the can - they look fairly similar. If packed in oil - there is virtually no difference in taste, but blue fin is much cheaper to obtain, and so the seller and middleman's profit is much higher. Often the grocers have no idea if their salmon fillets are from the Atlantic or the Alaskan waters- but again -Atlantic salmon is often farmed and that means cages (think chicken cages underwater) which encourage unhealthy growing conditions. Yet when died "orange" - they look remarkably like Alaskan King Salmon - and again make a very big profit for unscrupulous sellers and middlemen re-sellers.
11:39 PM on 11/27/2011
I'm all for the FDA going in and doing flash inspections and shutting down companies selling mislabeled fish. Reputable fish merchants will have no problem with this, and I think that any chef who does not know what fish look like, feel like, smell and behave like, down to the cells - is a hack. I'd say the same of mislabeled game, mushrooms, berries - etc. Know your stuff.
Here in the Bay Area there is this private company buying millions of dollars of air time on KQED to tout testing seafood for contaminant standards higher than the FDA's. Oh really? Maybe we should just support the FDA. I find it ironic that a "public" radio station promotes this company trying to shake down stores and restaurants (by getting listeners to ask if they use the testing service? - Is that the idea?) at the same time that it implies our own "public" standards are inferior.
It is about trust.
Go FDA - I still believe in our public regulators.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DANIELISTICALL
HISTORY IS BUT A FABLE AGREED UPON,,NAPOLEON
04:14 PM on 11/27/2011
quite often stingray fins are cookie cut and labled as scalops,,, a easy one to spot,,, in a real scallop the grain will run horizonily,, in the fake stingray the grain will run verticaly,,, although tast are similar the stingray is the cheaper of the two
photo
GraphicMatt
Somebody make me a sandwich!
11:20 AM on 11/28/2011
That is true. I always tell people that if you order scallops and every single one on the plate is the same exact size, chances are pretty good you're eating a ray wing.
photo
Parkite
Still haven't found what I'm looking for
01:20 PM on 11/28/2011
If something is round, if you turn it one way the grain is horizontal, turn it a half turn and it's vertical, turn it a quarter turn and it's diagonal. The same exact size/shape is the give away.
03:11 PM on 11/27/2011
Well, it's good to back up integrity or trust with dna, isn't it?

Kevin Chamow
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Realist2011
beware false profits....
10:49 AM on 11/27/2011
There is simply no substitute for integrity. Solve the problem, not the symptom.

Restaurants...Go to your suppliers and explain that if you find that they have provided seafood that is mislabeled one time, they are history, No regrets, no chance to kiss and make up.

Seafood suppliers...Go to the people who supply you and explain that you will not accept errors, period. If they lie to you, then they will be cut off and sued out of existence.

This isn't rocket science folks, it's just plain old common-sense. Don't do business with people you can't trust, whether it's a restaurant, a store, anyone.
01:56 PM on 11/27/2011
Most restaurants don't use DNA testing. They have no way of knowing the seafood is mislabeled.