iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Paul Kunzler Arrested: Utah Police Call Mouse 'Hero' In Rescue Of 13-Year-Old Rape Victim


First Posted: 12/23/11 05:50 PM ET Updated: 12/23/11 06:11 PM ET

The disturbing misdeeds of a Utah man accused of raping a 13-year-old girl were exposed this week when the man's roommate accidentally shot a third roommate during an impromptu mouse hunt, police said.

Paul Daniel Kunzler, 34, is being held without bail in the Salt Lake County Jail on suspicion of two counts of rape, three counts of sodomy and three counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child.

The bizarre case began to unfold about 2 a.m. Tuesday, when police were dispatched to a call of an accidental shooting at a home in the 2500 block of W. Brucemont Drive in Taylorsville.

"When officers and fire personnel arrived, they discovered a 28-year-old male that had been shot in the abdomen," Taylorsville City Police Sgt. Tracy Wyant told The Huffington Post.

Wyant said that the incident took a bizarre twist when the victim's 27-year-old roommate explained the circumstances of the shooting.

"The victim's roommate had witnessed a mouse run across a counter and shot at the mouse with a 9 mm handgun," Wyant said. "The round went through a wall and into an adjacent restroom, striking the victim."

The victim, who suffered a punctured lung and other internal injuries, was transported to a local hospital in critical condition. He was later upgraded to fair condition.

According to police, alcohol was determined to be a factor in the shooting.

The already bizarre case took another unusual turn when police conducted a search of the home, which is shared by four adult male roommates, to ensure no one else had been injured by the shooting. It was during that welfare search that authorities made a shocking discovery in the basement.

"[Officers] discovered a 13-year-old female hiding in a closet," Wyant said. "It was quickly learned that this 13-year-old did not belong to any of these adult men."

Through police questioning, detectives learned that Kunzler had allegedly been sexually involved with the girl. That alleged abuse, police said, had been going on for about four months.

"At this point, it appears the young female victim had been sneaking out of her home, which is about 12 to 15 miles away from where this incident occurred, during [the course of] this relationship," Wyant said.

The victim's parents told police that they were unaware of the situation. Investigators believe the victim met Kunzler through a common friend. Other than to say the victim is not related to Kunzler, police are not releasing any further details on the association between the two.

Kunzler's three roommates have denied knowledge of the relationship. One of the men, Zach Baker, expressed his surprise during an interview with KSTU-TV.

"I'd never seen the girl there before and I don't know how long she'd been there. They said she'd been hiding in a closet and that creeps me out," Baker said, adding, "I knew the guy was weird, but I didn't expect anything like that to happen."

According to Wyant, detectives are still trying to determine what, if anything, anybody knew about the relationship between Kunzler and the young girl.

"We don't know yet," he said. "Certainly, that's one part of the investigation that we are looking into. Obviously, if we can prove the roommates or anyone else was aware of the sexual abuse and did not come forward, we will certainly look at filing charges on those individuals."

The roommate who fired the handgun has not been arrested. The prosecutor's office is examining the incident to determine whether any criminal charges should be filed against him.

Wyant said the case is the most bizarre one he has been involved in during his 15-year career. Prior to this, another recent case had been the talk of the town.

"The day before [the shooting], we were in the national news because we had a case where a lady sprayed an ice cream truck driver in the face with a cleaning chemical. Now we have this. It's like, what the hell is going on?" Wyant said.

And, what of the mouse -- the small mammal at the center of the entire case?

"I've had more inquires on the mouse than anything," Wyant said. "It is my understanding he missed the mouse, and it fled."

Regardless of the details, the creature is considered by some to be a rodent of great valor.

"We had one call suggesting the mouse receive an award," Wyant said. The veteran police officer added, "I guess the mouse is the hero in this matter."

WATCH:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CRIME

The disturbing misdeeds of a Utah man accused of raping a 13-year-old girl were exposed this week when the man's roommate accidentally shot a third roommate during an impromptu mouse hunt, police said...
The disturbing misdeeds of a Utah man accused of raping a 13-year-old girl were exposed this week when the man's roommate accidentally shot a third roommate during an impromptu mouse hunt, police said...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 2,163
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (36 total)
01:23 PM on 03/07/2012
Look, I'm going to say this as a defense here. I actually know paul, the accused, and have been friends with him for a while. He is a nice wonderful man, and he's also pagen in a heavily morman area (which makes not only the girls parents, but the community as a whole suspect to discrimination). The odds that he was having sex with a little girl not that much older than his daughter are preposterous. He was more than likely trying to help her out. He is the sort of man who hears a little girl (again very similar to his daughter's age) asking for help he would jump at the opportunity. Just like he would jump to help anyone else out. I can tell you from knowing him, that the little girl in question probably had some bad things going on at home and was trying to run away. It's easier to say "this is my boyfriend" than it is to say "hey, my parents are abusive (either emotionally or physically)" because think about it, if you were a child who would you rather get in trouble and locked away for good? your mommy and daddy, or the man who was trying to save you from them? the man obviously, because even if your parents have done you wrong (which her being 13, and an extremely unstable age could mean anything) "parents are god" to the eyes of a child.
06:59 PM on 05/08/2012
If this is the case then she had no reason for hiding in the closet. police probably wouldn't have looked that far into it had she been sitting on the couch watching TV.
and the girl "was trying to run away" sorry but if she was going to run away she would have done it instead of sneaking out and traveling 15 back and forth for 4 months.
sounds like a 34 year old adult (who knows better) taking advantage of a little girl.
12:26 PM on 06/08/2012
meggie, just to speak realistically...your friends witha rapist, are you comfortable with that? bc its happened. nothing you say can defend this, feel free to try all night tho.
12:43 PM on 12/29/2011
Nice! In this article a girl gets raped and sodomized but at the end, the writer and the police are joking about making the mouse a hero. Sorry, I fail to see any humor in this case.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DarkandLuvly
06:49 AM on 01/03/2012
yes lets leave out the fact that she actually wanted to be there. i mean its horrible! what young girl wants a bf with a car a job and money that can buy them stuff and take them places?! NONE. oh ok
02:07 AM on 01/09/2012
Yeah... it's like the girl hit the jackpot, and they took it away from her! Outrage. But he had a paycheck AND he moonlit as an exterminator and demanded nothing in return -- (sigh...) always the provider.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lithium12
Fighting ignorance makes you an enemy of the right
12:36 PM on 12/29/2011
these 3 roomies strike me a triad of stupid.... guess like seeks like.
photo
IrieMoon
Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.
10:13 AM on 12/29/2011
I remember being 13 about 20 years ago and knowing that I was not ready for sex with someone of my own age let alone sex with an adult. Today we have a society that is much more open about sex and more educated on the subject.

I just don't understand why today we allow ignorance to be an excuse for bad behavior.

Yes the man having sex with this 13 year old should be charged with a crime and punished to the fullest extent of the law but what about the 13 year old?
Does she get away with no charges or punishment simply because shes underage?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ava Johnson
10:31 AM on 12/30/2011
While I know the guy should be punished, this is the reason why the media shouldn't automatically label these teens as automatic victims who don't know any better because of the brain growth situation. I'm sorry, but this "child" left her home all the time at night, 12 -15 miles away to meet with this man to have sex. I don't think she was told to do it. She has no fear of her parents or should I say no respect. Maybe she has what we call a hard head. I also want to say that I don't feel sorry for the stupid 14 yo who went over to the guy's house and let him inject her with heroin. Hell I wonder about stuff too, but I won't do it or let anyone do it to me. I am not going to say that this is new, because it has always gone on. The reason why it is popular is because of the 24/7 news cycle.
01:25 AM on 12/28/2011
It kinda bothers me when they say "rape". Every situation with an adult and a minor is unique and sometimes its a 30 year old with a 13 year old, sometimes its a 20 year old with a 17 year old. Sometimes the minor comes on to the adult and sometimes the adult manipulate­s the minor. Each situation has its own set of circumstan­ces and I don't think they should be treated exactly the same. If a 17 year old girl comes onto a 20 year old guy and seduces him to have sex, should that really be considered "rape"?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sydneymoon
Dismiss what insults your own soul - WW
07:48 AM on 12/28/2011
Chris,
I fully understand your concern over false rape charges. The % of false reports seems to be 8% - 10% (whereas the old stat of 2 % appears questionable). This 8% - 10% is not different from false reports for other types of crime. That is still unnerving. However, some stats as high as 40% are pretty much debunked as the pool for the 1994 study was very low.

http://www.awolau.org/2010/04/05/myth-busters-false-rape-reports/http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/crimprof_blog/2004/12/2_false_rape_st.html
What I did find interesting from the first article cited is this statement about false rape claims:
“These research findings support the theory that people who falsely allege rape do so not out of desire for revenge against a specific person, but because they seek general attention and sympathy.” and that “involve only a vaguely described stranger.”
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sydneymoon
Dismiss what insults your own soul - WW
08:22 AM on 12/28/2011
I broke this comment up due to the word limit.
As far as the 13 year-old is concerned.
“If a 17 year old girl comes onto a 20 year old guy and seduces him to have sex, should that really be considered "rape"?”
I understand what you are saying. It truly depends on the state’s age of consent, but a 17 year old nearing adulthood giving consent to sex is not as problematic as a 13 year-old for reasons I noted in my very first post to you on 12/27. A 13 year-old, no matter how precocious, no matter how physically mature, lacks the cognitive maturity to understand the ramifications of such an alliance. The burden falls on the adult not to encourage this kind of relationship. Just because he can, doesn’t mean he should.
Posters have pointed out she may have lied or that she looks older, etc. I’ve got it. However, over the course of 4 months why wouldn’t Kunzler demand proof of her age? During casual conversation, why wouldn’t Kunzler pick up clues that she wasn’t as old as she claimed? Why did he hide her in the closet if nothing was wrong with their being together? Why did he hide the relationship with the roommates. (Okay, I suspend disbelief here) Let’s say the roommates actually didn’t know, why did Kunzler hide it?
As an adult, the onus is on him/her to make sure the partner is of legal consenting age.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larsami1
JUST SAYING
01:22 AM on 12/29/2011
A 13 year-old, no matter how precocious­, no matter how physically mature, lacks the cognitive maturity to understand the ramificati­ons of such an alliance.


I wish the law saw it the way you do as they will try 10 year olds as adults. I thought 10 year olds were still kids. It amazes me how many people will turn their heads when they hear this but are only concerned when sex is involved. Nice.
01:03 PM on 12/29/2011
Does the judicial system recognize the difference between the severity of certain "rape" cases versus others? For example does the court view a situation where a minor is forcibly raped against their will the same as a minor who comes onto and willingly has sex with an adult? Does the court view a situation where a 13 year willingly has sex with a 34 year old the same as a situation where a 17 year old seduces a 21 year old to have sex? There are obviously significant differences in these situations but are they each treated the same in the judicial system; "RAPE"? When society hears the word rape they have a tendency to view it in one way and is it fair to call all these situations rape? Is it fair for all these situations to receive the same treatment and punishment?
01:55 PM on 12/27/2011
4. It's 100% plausible that none of the other occupants had the slightest clue that girl was ever there. I watched the news report and it showed the area she was hiding, it was some weird crevice under the stairs. No idea how the police had the idea to look there, the owner of the house didn't even know it existed. You can be in the house for a week and never see another occupant because the bedrooms are so spread out and the roommates work opposite hours. The creepy pedo was a father and had several kids; if anyone ever saw other kids over with him, he would just claim he was babysitting. Also i asked one of the roommates and the pedo guy had only been living with them for 1.5 months (and this relationship had apparently been going on for 4 months.) It seems like it is always the "normal people" who are caught doing this shit (THE UNIVERSITY COACH COMES TO MIND).

How do you ever know for sure that someone you know isn't hiding a dark secret like this? Doing this shit behind your back and hiding it from everyone?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larsami1
JUST SAYING
01:28 AM on 12/29/2011
How do you ever know for sure that someone you know isn't hiding a dark secret like this?



We don't. It's too often the ones we don't suspect.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lithium12
Fighting ignorance makes you an enemy of the right
12:40 PM on 12/29/2011
I think it is 100% plausable that all 3 occupants had no clue about anything.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:12 AM on 01/07/2012
I think it is 100% plausible that all 4 occupants have no clue as to what their zip code is.
01:50 PM on 12/27/2011
I know the people involved, and let me clear up a few things.

1. The roommate who got shot is going to make a 100% recovery and deserves a Purple Heart for taking the shot that inadvertently wound up jailing a child molester.

2. The roommate who did the shooting was best friends with the shootee, and obviously was torn apart by his idiotic mistake. I talked to him the day after and he was devastated.... I don't believe he was the one drinking (Ive never seen him drink) but I think other people at the house might have been, prolly why the article says "alcohol was involved". He sold all of his guns and I think he's using the $ to take the shootee to Vegas or on a vacation somewhere Idiotic mistake that could have been a lot worse, yes. Deserves to die? Seems like a stretch. Remember this was an accident.... the guy obviously knows he shouldn't be around guns anymore. Thank God this ended in justice and not tragedy. Ironicly, if this guy hadn't made this mistake the cops wouldnt have ever shown up and this girl would still probably be getting raped today.

3. The mouse wound up dying, they later found bloodstains on a few of the things in the pantry.

4 (continued)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jojo5
11:13 AM on 12/27/2011
I don't understand how your 13 yr old can spend so much time with this guy and her mother didn't know where she was.....I always knew where where my kids were....
07:09 AM on 01/01/2012
Are you REALLY sure?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jojo5
01:32 PM on 01/01/2012
YES...Im really sure!!
04:12 AM on 12/27/2011
Should consensual and non-consen­sual sex with a minor have the same punishment­?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sydneymoon
Dismiss what insults your own soul - WW
08:11 AM on 12/27/2011
Adolescent girls who engage in sex generally have a partner 1 to 3 years older so, with this disparity of age, a red flag goes up. What 34 year-old engages in sex with someone 21 years younger? Someone of diminished IQ perhaps or a predator.
Predators target the vulnerable and will coax a relationship along by promising love, security and/or providing things parents forbid such as drugs/alcohol, etc. It’s called child grooming.

“According to Harvard Medical School's O'Connell, adolescents "often haven't achieved the emotional, even neurological, maturity necessary for making autonomous and self-aware sexual choices." Emotional, social and cognitive development continues well past adolescence. “
http://www.k12academics.com/sex-education/adolescent-sexuality-united-states/psychological-effects
A 13 year old lacks the cognitive development to fully understand consequences, thus as a society, we don’t accord them the ability to consent. By law, this is considered statutory rape.
10:38 PM on 12/27/2011
It kinda bothers me when they say "rape". Every situation with an adult and a minor is unique and sometimes its a 30 year old with a 13 year old, sometimes its a 20 year old with a 17 year old. Sometimes the minor comes on to the adult and sometimes the adult manipulates the minor. Each situation has its own set of circumstances and I don't think they should be treated exactly the same. If a 17 year old girl comes onto a 20 year old guy and seduces him to have sex, should that really be considered "rape"?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mrshowell2001
Do or not do- there is no try
09:30 PM on 01/01/2012
Yes. Sounds like you might be seeking permission.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larsami1
JUST SAYING
11:56 AM on 01/03/2012
Sounds like you might be a Lemmings.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Dude67
Question the official narrative
03:42 AM on 12/27/2011
It was serendipitous they found the girl when in reality they were looking for drugs, stolen property, or other illegal contraband.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Doctress Julia B
NUNYA BIDNESS.
08:15 PM on 12/26/2011
"BELONG TO"? SINCE WHEN DOES A 13 YEAR OLD GIRL BELONG TO ANYONE?!
08:43 PM on 12/26/2011
I think what they meant was, she wasn't the daughter of any of them.
11:56 PM on 12/26/2011
Belong as in associated with (family) not as in ownership.... When you say I belong to this family or that association it doesn't mean they own you...
05:44 PM on 12/26/2011
I wonder how many of the people defending the rapist are defending their own dirty little secrets. I have a 13 yr old niece. If I caught her with a 33 year old, he had better pray the police get there before I do.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
VictoryBlue
Motorcycle rider, Legalization supporter, Texan
02:12 PM on 12/28/2011
Like my father-in-law said to me,"There is a lot of Texas to get lost in if you hurt my little girl."

Utah, Texas, whatever but you will be lost.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:22 AM on 01/07/2012
Actually, you will be twice as lost if you are in Utah.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larsami1
JUST SAYING
01:45 AM on 12/29/2011
And what would you do with your niece? Just asking.
01:39 PM on 01/11/2013
I would probably take her to see a psychologist. It sounds like you are trying to imply that the child is mostly to be blamed here. Children will do dumb things, especially under the influence of an adult who doesn't have their best interest in mind. That is why they are considered to be "minors" and under the legal protection of their parents or guardians.
04:25 PM on 12/26/2011
To all of those talking about different guns to hunt mice with... ever hear of a BB gun or a pellet gun? A Crossman 760 pumped 6 times will kill a mouse with out going through a wall.

As for the girl... this is another case of law of man vs law of nature.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:51 AM on 01/07/2012
Why not throw one of those sticky traps at the mouse? As far as I can tell no human has ever been injuried or dealt a mortal blow by a sticky trap.
12:19 PM on 03/07/2012
:)
04:20 PM on 12/26/2011
Twenty-one years older than her. Awful. What an awful man.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sydneymoon
Dismiss what insults your own soul - WW
06:31 PM on 12/26/2011
21 years older.
04:05 PM on 12/26/2011
I'm guessing the girl's father isn't around