More

Puerto Rico Referendum Approved To Decide Political Status

Puerto Rico

By DANICA COTO   12/28/11 08:46 PM ET   AP

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico -- Puerto Rico's governor approved a two-part referendum on Wednesday to help decide the island's political status, but supporters of remaining a U.S. commonwealth criticized the decision to hold both votes on the same day as unfair.

The first part of the referendum will ask voters if they want a change in status or prefer to remain a U.S. commonwealth. The second part will ask that voters choose from three options: statehood, independence or sovereign free association.

The original proposal was to hold the first part of the referendum in August 2012 and then, only if the majority sought a change in status, hold the second part during the November 2012 general elections.

But under the new proposal, the both parts will be held on Nov. 6, said Gov. Luis Fortuno, who leads the pro-statehood New Progressive Party.

Regardless of what voters decide, any change requires approval by the U.S. Congress and president.

Sen. Eduardo Bhatia said holding both parts of the referendum on the same day makes no sense because it assumes that the pro-status quo option doesn't win and the second round will be necessary.

"This law is proof that the leadership of the pro-statehood movement turns to trickery, deceit and the technique of confusion as political weapons," said Bhatia of the Popular Democratic Party, which supports the current commonwealth status. "What opportunity do voters have to seriously reflect between one vote and the other? None."

The questions will be on the same ballot, and critics fear that being forced to choose from the three options could influence how people vote in the first part.

Kenneth McClintock, secretary of state for Puerto Rico, denied accusations that pro-status quo supporters would be ignored, saying that people were free to leave the second part of the ballot blank. He said Bhatia's party had previously agreed to holding the referendum in one day.

McClintock said the U.S. Congress would interpret the results if the majority chose something other than maintaining the status quo.

Fortuno also discarded criticism of the referendum.

"All processes aimed at resolving Puerto Rico's political future assumes that the current situation no longer has majority support," he said.

Fortuno spokeswoman Ana del Valle said his administration chose to hold the two-part referendum on the same day to get a sense of what people prefer for the island's political future.

The referendum received praise from Luis Delgado, leader of a group that is pushing for Puerto Rico to have a sovereign free association with the U.S. But Delgado urged Fortuno to demand that the U.S. outline terms and conditions for each of the choices before the referendum is held.

Puerto Rico has long debated its political status, with no majority for any particular status emerging in referendums held in 1967, 1993 and 1998.

Rafael Cox Alomar, a PDP member who is seeking the island's nonvoting Congressional seat, dismissed the referendum as expensive and unnecessary.

"This referendum does not work and does not involve nor compromise in any way the U.S. Congress," he said. "In a moment of economic crisis... the cost of this referendum is an insult to the people who reject it."

Alejandro Garcia Padilla, who is running against Fortuno, said the Popular Democratic Party would soon issue its official stance on the referendum.

Critics also noted that if Fortuno's party loses the election, millions of dollars spent on the referendum will have gone to waste.

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico -- Puerto Rico's governor approved a two-part referendum on Wednesday to help decide the island's political status, but supporters of remaining a U.S. commonwealth criticized the...
SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico -- Puerto Rico's governor approved a two-part referendum on Wednesday to help decide the island's political status, but supporters of remaining a U.S. commonwealth criticized the...
Filed by Clare Richardson  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 131
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
01:15 PM on 03/07/2012
Great new book publishing in April 2012 that presents compelling arguments for Puerto Rico's independence. Decolonization Models for America's Last Colony: Puerto Rico by Angel Collado-Schwarz is sure to intensify the dialogue in the United State about the future of Puerto Rico. The book presents compelling strategies for Puerto Rico's independence and its ability to become the Singapore of the Carribean.
Sean Porter
I support the right to arm bears.
04:08 PM on 01/03/2012
If history is any teacher, the Puerto Rican pro and con statehood voters will probably cancel each other out as they did in 1967, 1993 and 1998.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ohioliberal
The Steelers and Mopar cars
03:04 PM on 01/01/2012
Please vote independence so we can free up some US government dollars for our own citizens
02:12 AM on 01/01/2012
Umm..why would P.R. want to change anything? The people there aren't stupid. Independence will only turn P.R. in to another poor caribbean island nation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chi Man Sam
Liberal, Pro-Choice,Union,Women,Anti Religion-GOP
11:11 AM on 12/31/2011
We have voted many times, it doesn't
make a difference, it would take an act of
congress for us to become a state, they haven't
voted on the issue before and they won't now.
Its good political fodder, but its just a show.
Under the terms of the Treaty of Paris of 1898,
we were ceded the to the United States and became
U.S. citizens in 1917. the reality is that we will remain
as a commonwealth for many years to come if not
forever.
03:12 PM on 12/31/2011
In fairness, Chi Man, there's been no reason for the Congress to vote on the issue.

There's never going to be a reason for the Congress to vote, until a majority of the voters in Puerto Rico request some change in the island's status.

In fact, until that happens, there isn't anything for Congress to vote on.

This isn't about the Congress, this is about the people of Puerto Rico. And they haven't indicated widespread support for making any changes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chi Man Sam
Liberal, Pro-Choice,Union,Women,Anti Religion-GOP
06:27 PM on 12/31/2011
It depends on which congress we have, but
it won't be voted on thats for sure. Even if the people wanted it, its view as a stratigic site, yes even though russia doesn't play with Cuba anymore. My point was that if you read the article and have no futher knowledge you might come to the conclusion that a majority yes vote would make it so, most won't do the homework, just read some of the comments, you should see what I mean.
photo
jf12
Occupying myself
06:43 PM on 12/31/2011
One thing that's new is Vieques got cleaned up, pretty well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chi Man Sam
Liberal, Pro-Choice,Union,Women,Anti Religion-GOP
06:49 PM on 12/31/2011
Yes, it was a fight that was well worth it.
On the surfice its clean and the bombing is over, I hope those that were affected get proper treatment, but yes its a great thing.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cmr86
Reality. Progressively-based.
10:45 AM on 12/31/2011
PR will likely continue to be a freely associated territory.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lenguss
02:34 AM on 12/31/2011
If Puerto Ricans really want out, let them go. Since we pour money into this bottomless bucket, we'll save millions. Of course, close to a million PR in the US will pose citizenship and have to leave and/or apply for citizenship. Spanish may disappear from thousands of NYC store fronts (se habla español aqui).

I believe in separatism. If Quebec wants to leave Canada, great; the remaining provinces will do better and poor folks in BC won't have to learn French they will never use. Belgium and Holland will probably each split into two countries (a la Czech and Slovakia), Iraq should split into three countries which would save tens of thousands of lives, Catalonia wants to leave Spain, etc. Think of all the money to be made in printing new currencies and postage stamps. There is no reason for Sicily to be a part of Italy. And perhaps we could finally split California into two, letting the northern part go to hell in its own way - without plastic bags of course.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ringo3khan
10:30 AM on 12/31/2011
Total agreement from me!
08:13 PM on 04/07/2012
WE pour money !!!! ,jajaja do some research! STOP BEING IGNORANT U.S. give 4.5 billion dollar a year to P.R. and take 75 Billions back!!.... if Puertoricans become A republic , U.S 's. mercantile marine will bankrupt , Walt-mart will lose over 20 billions of dollars A YEARS!! and U.S. is gonna lose billions of $$ in pharmaceutical products, plus they will HAVE to close a few federal and military complex, which will be critical to the national security!...losing economical , military and political power in the caribean and South america......and the way things are going, U.S. can't afford that!.........YOU DONT HAVE TO AGREE W/ MY POSTING , JUST DO SOME RESEARCH! YOU WILL BE SUPRISE WITH THE TRUTH!
02:46 PM on 12/30/2011
I hope PR becomes the 51st state if only to anger the American bigots and racists. Let America get saturated with Latinos, especially with Boricuas in the East coast and Mid-West, more Cubans in Florida once Castro opens the borders, and the Mexicans and other Latinos in the West and West coast. Let the Latino mixture eradicate the gringo arrogant mentality in America and bring in Latino enrichment and enlightment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RickCadena
Born & raised in the Anglo neighborhoods (Mid-City
05:15 PM on 12/31/2011
I love the concept that you are espousing. However, let us hope that the culture of Puerto Rico and the Spanish language do not become a casualty in the process. Saludos desde México.
07:44 PM on 12/31/2011
Why would PR and ther Spanish language necessarily become casualties...? It would do America good to have a Latin-American country as a state complete with the Spanish language.
Sean Porter
I support the right to arm bears.
03:24 PM on 01/02/2012
So you want P.R. to become the 51st state just out of spite?
07:19 PM on 01/02/2012
That and the fact that it would do America good to have a Latin-American country as the 51st state, it would enrich America, and it needs enrichment.
11:49 AM on 12/30/2011
What good are they doing the rest of the country?? It's a burden we can't afford anymore! Their vote should not matter in the least.. only the U.S can change the contitution.
Either they help or let them lose.
08:15 PM on 04/07/2012
JUST DO SOME RESEARCH!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nypapajoe
10:36 AM on 12/30/2011
Instead of engaging in republican political endeavors that will enrich certsin politicians and bankers why doesn't the politicians and the citizens of the island address the criminality that has consumed the island? The island has become a haven for a criminal element that is is neck in neck with the war that is going on in Mexico! There is no doubt that greed and corruption and the lack of prosecutorial and police oversight is what exacerbating the problem! Clean your house first before seeking even more complex social issues!
08:21 AM on 12/30/2011
I hope they vote for Statehood. I think it is past time they became a full member of the Union. I think it would be of mutual benefit for both the US and the commonwealth.
06:38 AM on 12/30/2011
every house with tile roofs abd barred windows. Stray dogs, chickens and loudmouths
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GingerlyColors
This is what goes around, and comes around
03:20 AM on 12/30/2011
The 51st State of America perhaps? They will be running out of room for stars on the U.S. Flag soon!
10:56 PM on 12/29/2011
SOS and No it will never happen! Next!
08:16 PM on 04/07/2012
DO SOME RESEARCH!
10:47 PM on 12/29/2011
There is another option and that is having the population vote to return to being subjects of Spain.
The Spanish-American War - like the Iraq war - was started on false evidence. The 'USS Maine' blew up because of faulty US Technology. That war was based on bogus facts like the Bush-Cheney catastrophe. If Puerto Rico wants to return to Spain, let her go with peace.
photo
freedom1947
sarcasm, cynicism
11:07 PM on 12/29/2011
They want all the candy without the price. Anyone looking to deport these LATINOS?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fran Jaime
Yo Soy 132!
04:05 PM on 12/30/2011
They can't! They are American citizens.