iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Georgia School's 'Slavery' Math Problems Sparks Parent Protest, District Investigation

Slavery Math Problems

First Posted: 01/10/2012 3:51 pm Updated: 01/10/2012 4:24 pm

Dozens of parents and community members rallied outside a Norcross, Ga. elementary school Tuesday, calling on the school district to fire teachers involved in a 3rd grade math assignment that used slavery in examples.

Protesters chanted "Fire them now" and marched with signs outside Beaver Ridge Elementary School, WSBTV reports. Parents are outraged at both the assignment and the school district's response to the reports of those math problems, which included references to cotton, orange picking and beatings.

One problem reads: "If Frederick got two beatings per day, how many beatings did he get in 1 week?"

"The teachers, the staff responsible for allowing this to go forward should be fired," Georgia NAACP President Ed DuBose told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

One of the affected classes has been taught by a substitute teacher for the last two days, pending investigations, according to the AJC. The teachers under investigation are not being identified.

District spokesperson Sloan Roach told WSBTV that one teacher wrote the questions, four of the nine 3rd grade teachers handed out the worksheets to a total of more than 100 students, but all nine educators saw the assignment. Beaver Ridge Principal Jose DeJesus is meeting and speaking with parents.

"One of them had to question this and say, 'Look, we cannot do this, we cannot let this go out ... let's make better questions,'" Beaver Ridge parent Christopher Braxton told WSBTV.

The district's initial response to parents earlier this week was simply that the elementary school's principal will "work with teachers to come up with more appropriate lessons." Roach said the math problems were written in an attempt to incorporate social studies lessons in math for a "cross-curricular activity" and that the teachers meant no harm.

Following parent outcry and national attention, Gwinnett Schools district officials are now investigating the incident to determine whether to pursue punitive action. Roach said the questions were inappropriate and the investigation would seek to ensure that teachers are creating assignments that are "appropriate and respective," ABC News reports. She declined to speculate on what action may be taken against guilty teachers or whether additional training would be required for educators.

"We are looking at what human resources actions may be taken so I do believe that is a hard stance trying to determine what does that situation warrant," Roach told WSBTV.

She tells ABC News that there doesn't appear to be signs of intentional "maliciousness" or racism, and the incident was simply a matter of a teacher writing some bad questions.

"This was an isolated case involving these teachers at this school and at this grade level," she said.

WATCH:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST EDUCATION

Dozens of parents and community members rallied outside a Norcross, Ga. elementary school Tuesday, calling on the school district to fire teachers involved in a 3rd grade math assignment that used sla...
Dozens of parents and community members rallied outside a Norcross, Ga. elementary school Tuesday, calling on the school district to fire teachers involved in a 3rd grade math assignment that used sla...
Filed by Emmeline Zhao  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 413
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
10:48 AM on 01/19/2012
There is no way that a mind set in this type of insensitivity should be teaching our children.This is not the first mishap in these children education.Lets not be asleep or like children,we have to be the principal educators for our children.If you do not know your true history, learn it so "you"can teach it to "your"child.If you know your true history, why would you leave the job of teaching it to someone else?
01:06 AM on 01/19/2012
Did anyone notice the illiteracy ("in-oralicy"?) of the comments by Roach? "appropriate and respective"? "trying to determine what does the situation warrant"? Who (among the educated) talks like this?!

Oh, my people . . . . .
12:47 PM on 01/17/2012
This is an interdisciplinary unit, people, not just a plain ol' math test! The purpose of this type of holistic and relevant education is to show kids how math relates to the real world! Now-- if they happen to be studying a unit on Slavery or The Civil War, these are appropriate, albeit insensitive, questions to ask. In my opinion, the negative aspects of American History should not be taught until middle school (where kids are intelligent enough to know discussing something is not the same as advocating it). You can't pretend slavery never happened, and you can't be trite about it by turning someone's personal tragedy into a word problem, but I do see where they were coming from on this failed attempt at making math relevent within a greater historical thematic unit.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jamie Zupo
my babies ate my brains
04:28 PM on 02/02/2012
Well, I think you *can* teach the negative aspects (otherwise known as 'the truth') to younger kids (though it can create some hard questions to answer, as with my own son, 1st grade), but *this* is not the way! Casual incorporation of 'beatings?' Present tense references to a slave's work? Oh hell no.
04:56 PM on 01/15/2012
Was this a well-written test? It doesn't look like it. Was it insensitive to bring slavery up in a math lesson without a preface? Sure. Do these teachers deserve to be fired? No. Check out the school website. This is an ethnically diverse school that has met their AYP goals every year for seven years. Somebody is doing something right at Beaver Ridge. This problem needs to be solved away from the media spotlight. One of the things public schools do best is adapt to changing needs.
08:53 PM on 01/13/2012
i didn't realize they still employed teachers from the pre-1960's era in the USA. i thought most of these types would have been long retired and DEAD. apparently many have remained, yet are now senile. Alzheimer symptoms show great memory for the past, yet little retention for current events.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Todd Behrmann
06:44 PM on 01/13/2012
Georgia needs to stop living in the past. the Confederacy lost; slavery is gone and they need to get over it!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rabit818
10:35 AM on 01/13/2012
If a teacher's salary is $49,000/year, what is the difference between the teacher present salary and the unemployment check he/she will be getting because of the stupid slavery test he/she prepared?
05:41 PM on 01/13/2012
good one!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dcruz1122
07:03 PM on 01/12/2012
would love to know the ethnic make-up of the teachers who created and distributed this assignment. It would provide much more insight into the culture of the school.
photo
healthcarenow
RN 4 blue Arizona
04:34 PM on 01/12/2012
"... district officials are now investigating the incident to determine whether to pursue punitive action.".......whether????

" there doesn't appear to be signs of intentional "maliciousness" or racism, and the incident was simply a matter of a teacher writing some bad questions.......you think?????

I don't know what's worse, teachers using such inappropriate language or seeming to have no grasp of contemporary examples. "beatings"???? "slaves"?????
photo
TheEmptyMonty
President of Antarctica
01:37 PM on 01/12/2012
Seven! Each slave picks seven.

Wait, this happened in Georgia? No way!
foresure
Brash and Harsh
01:02 PM on 01/12/2012
Part II of II

"His was to do or Die". Alfred Lord Tennyson

What better further evidence does anyone need that the American public school system is devoid of good sense, is incapable of change, and is totally rigid and defensive?
---------.

I am now over fifty years out of the 3rd grade at James Russell Lowell Elementary. But I recognize the boredom, frustration, and useless nature of those "thought" problems.

I can almost feel and smell the unpleasant feelings that I and my fellow students felt at seeing those same worksheets being passed out. [Yes, a reference to "In Search of Things Past", Marcel Proust]

You see, the teacher had found some thought questions, believing that no one will ever notice that a nice racist message had been installed in these hoary "thought questions".

Of course the teacher knew that if, in the unlikely event that she got "busted, she could easily defend if she could remember the right jargon to use. "Cross Curricular".

Fluency in eduationbabble is the only real requirement to be a teacher.

Nine teachers saw or reported nothing wrong with the questions.
photo
healthcarenow
RN 4 blue Arizona
04:36 PM on 01/12/2012
Fanned...you are so right.
foresure
Brash and Harsh
01:00 PM on 01/12/2012
Part I of II

First of all, to the best of my knowledge I am white.

At least I appear to fill the specifications for that phenotype. Of course one never knows. I have no idea what my great-grandparents may have been up to.

My standing to comment:

Chicago Public Schools, K-12. Undergraduate degree, two graduate degreess.

Son of a long time teacher in the Chicago Public Schools. My father taught at Franklin Elementary School in what would be now called a "school in need".

Married to a high school teacher.

Teaching experience, but thank God, not in the public school system.

This Reply has two parts:

One can only feel outrage and disgust at the "passive aggressive" attempt to install racist thinking in third grade students. All the jargon, what I call "edcuationbabble", will NOT cover up that fact.

Worse, and subject to even more condemnation is the statement of "spokeman" Sloan Roach.
Roach [who] said:

"math problems were written in an attempt to incorporate social studies lessons in math for a "cross-curricular activity" and that the teachers meant no harm"

Re-read the rest of his statement to get the full flavor of a teacher giving the "standard defensive crouch". Of course spokesman Roach was not paid to think the matter through.

He himself has an excellent defense. "Where in my "job description" does it say I have to think about what I am saying"?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
maveet
AussieByChoice
05:35 PM on 01/12/2012
Thank you Thank You! F&F
foresure
Brash and Harsh
06:19 PM on 01/12/2012
:)
06:00 AM on 01/12/2012
Why would anybody think that what the teachers did was racially motivated ? Please...they don't need to be "reassigned" they need to be fired....! These teachers deserve an opportunity to find another career to pursue. 9 Teachers involved....seriously, 9 ? You mean to tell me that not one of the 8 who saw the questions didn't think that at the very least they were extremely insensitive and shouldn't be desiminated to 3rd graders ? What the hell ever happened to one bad apple....8 idiot teachers saw the questions and did nothing. Thank God the class room wasn't of fire !!!

Even Newt thinks this is f'd up.

Damn, I can't wait to see the home work assignments for Black History Month, Greek American Heritage Month, Cinco De Mayo, Ramadan and Hanukkah.......Way to go Ga Pub School System.
04:23 AM on 01/12/2012
Is it weird that my first thought is to question why everyone is assuming the slaves are black and getting outraged on behalf of African Americans? Throughout history every race has been taken and made into slave labor.
06:08 AM on 01/12/2012
Weird....not at all. Please tell us more about those Forgotten Slaves and their struggles as I'm sure none of this would be an issue if the teachers referenced above had at least one question that pointed to the european slave market and the national disgrace it created.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Craig Doing The Douggie
01:05 PM on 01/13/2012
The Native Americans!
07:19 PM on 01/12/2012
because the "cross-culture" aspect they were discussing in other classes was likely about slavery in america which overwhelmingly had to do with black people. Rarely do we discuss with such focus, slavery in other societies because it is not affecting us as much as black slavery still is today.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KikoJones
03:29 AM on 01/12/2012
Seems we still haven't quite left the 18th century, huh?