Huffpost Media

New York Times Public Editor Arthur Brisbane Defends 'Truth Vigilante' Column (VIDEO)

Posted: Updated:

New York Times' public editor Arthur Brisbane appeared on "Reliable Sources" to defend his controversial column asking whether the paper "should be a truth vigilante."

The blog post, published earlier in January, had asked whether "reporters should challenge 'facts' that are asserted by newsmakers they write about." Brisbane drew swift condemnation from the public and other members of the press, who accused him of appearing to question a basic function of the media,

Speaking to Howard Kurtz on Saturday, Brisbane called the negative public reaction "very strange" and "one that I was not expecting." He also maintained that his original inquiry raised an important issue. "Of course the New York Times should check facts and claims by politicians, but it was a question of degree," he said.

In a follow-up to his original post, he clarified his concerns about inserting counterclaims to sources in news articles. "You come across as a combatant in the political fray when that's really not the role for the straight news reporter," he explained on Saturday.

"Ubiquitous argument in daily news coverage, I think, risks creating the appearance of fighting with your newsmakers and your sources," he said. See his defense in the clip above.

Around the Web

Meet Arthur S. Brisbane, Truth Vigilante! | NYTimes eXaminer

Should The Times Be a Truth Vigilante? | The Public Editor ...

Update to My Previous Post on Truth Vigilantes | The Public Editor ...

Arthur Brisbane | Jack Shafer

NYT Public Editor Criticized for “Truth Vigilante” Column | FDL News ...

Arthur S. Brisbane: Should The Times be a truth vigilante? - :: Future ...

Arthur S. Brisbane - Public Editor's Journal Blog -

New York Times Public Editor Defends 'Truth Vigilante' Column On CNN's ...

Should The Times Be a Truth Vigilante?

Will fact-checking go the way of blogs?

Digging deeper into The New York Times' fact-checking faux pas

The Questions Some People Ask Really Are Dumb

Filed by Katherine Fung