More

HuffPost Social Reading
Alexander Eichler
GET UPDATES FROM Alexander:

Working Poor: Almost Half Of U.S. Households Live One Crisis From The Bread Line

Posted: 01/31/12 12:00 AM ET  |  Updated: 01/31/12 01:17 PM ET

What does it mean to be poor?

If it means living at or below the poverty line, then 15 percent of Americans -- some 46 million people -- qualify. But if it means living with a decent income and hardly any savings -- so that one piece of bad luck, one major financial blow, could land you in serious, lasting trouble -- then it's a much larger number. In fact, it's almost half the country.

"The resources that people have -- they are using up those resources," said Jennifer Brooks, director of state and local policy at the Corporation for Enterprise Development, a Washington, D.C., advocacy group. "They're living off their savings. They're at the end of their rope."

The group issued a report today examining so-called liquid asset poverty households -- the people who aren't living below the poverty line, but don't have enough money saved to weather a significant emergency.

According to the report, 43 percent of households in America -- some 127.5 million people -- are liquid-asset poor. If one of these households experiences a sudden loss of income, caused, for example, by a layoff or a medical emergency, it will fall below the poverty line within three months. People in these households simply don't have enough cash to make it for very long in a crisis.

The findings underscore the struggles of many Americans during what has often seemed like an economic recovery in name only. While the Great Recession officially ended more than two years ago, unemployment remains high and wages have barely budged for most workers. For more people, whether they draw a paycheck or not, a life free of deprivation and financial anxiety seems perpetually out of reach.

That's not to say that everyone who is liquid-asset poor spends all their time fretting. On the contrary, because many have regular paychecks coming in, they may not grasp the precariousness of their situation.

"They don't necessarily realize how close people can be to one interruption to income or one interruption to health benefits," said David Rothstein, the project director for asset building at the non-profit Policy Matters Ohio. "They're one paycheck away from being in debt."

Rothstein, who also serves on a steering committee at the Corporation for Enterprise Development, told The Huffington Post that payday lenders -- who loan money to desperate borrowers at high interest rates, drawing people into hard-to-escape cycles of debt -- are "a huge problem" in Ohio, as in many other states. People often turn to payday lenders to cover one-time, unexpected expenses, but can end up in a long and costly relationship.

"People say things like, it's just one mechanical problem with their car," said Rothstein. Before they know it, he said, "every other week, they're back at the payday lending shop."

The Corporation for Enterprise Development findings echo other recent studies showing that many Americans are ill-prepared for financial emergencies. Analysts said the reasons include flat wages, the high cost of medical treatment and the nationwide drop in housing values leaving homeowners with less wealth than they believed they had.

Andrea Levere, the president of Corporation for Enterprise Development, told HuffPost that greater financial literacy might have helped prevent the current situation.

People can "graduate high school and not know how to write a check," Levere said, adding that an increased emphasis on personal responsibility for budgeting and spending should be an important part of any step forward.

At the same time, Corporation for Enterprise Development officials were quick to argue that public policy needs to address the scope of the problem. Levere cited the example of asset limits in public benefit programs, which restrict services like food assistance and public health insurance to households with few or no assets -- a policy that critics say denies help to many people in need.

"In some cases," said Levere, "it means they can't even own a car that is in good enough shape to get them to work."

Brooks agreed. "A family that loses its job, that was maybe solidly middle class, in a state where they have restrictive asset tests, is going to have to liquidate all their assets, all their savings for the future" in order to qualify for benefits.

The report maintains that there are a number of measures that could alleviate liquid asset poverty, from strengthening consumer protections against payday lenders to making greater assistance available to first-time homebuyers. Levere said even minor policy adjustments could have "revolutionary implications."

"There's a lot of ways forward. It doesn't mean it's not tough," Levere said. "I'm a great believer in one step at a time."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST BUSINESS

What does it mean to be poor? If it means living at or below the poverty line, then 15 percent of Americans -- some 46 million people -- qualify. But if it means living with a decent income and har...
What does it mean to be poor? If it means living at or below the poverty line, then 15 percent of Americans -- some 46 million people -- qualify. But if it means living with a decent income and har...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9,937
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (120 total)
  1 of 11  
COMMUNITY PUNDITS
photo
ResearchtheFacts 01:43 PM on 01/31/2012
Fine job the government has been doing running the country for at least the last 50 years. While other citizens don't want others to protest unless THEY agree with their politics nor do they WANT other citizens to vote outside the two party system to continuously CATER TO THEIR FEARS of letting the other party win.

GUESS WHAT? NEWSFLASH, read the  Read More...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
04:44 PM on 03/29/2012
No jobs, not enough money, middle class in withering away, 2.4 million jobs lost to China, health care system out of wack, sleeping in your car, if you are lucky enough to have one, paying on your student loan, no medical insurance, and willing to work. If that is not bad enough, you should see this slide show: How the 1% live; it will make your day: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/31/working-poor-liquid-asset-poverty_n_1243152.html?ref=mostpopular,recession
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DanaGarrett
10:54 AM on 03/03/2012
I once said to a Marxist, "Marx's predictions about capitalism weren't always correct. For example, Marx never saw the emergence of a large middle class." The Marxist said to me, "But Dana, how many paychecks could the middle class lose before they joined the ranks of the poor? One? Maybe, two?" The article above provides the answer. The middle class in the USA is a mile wide but an inch deep.
06:58 AM on 02/21/2012
When I read this shocking statistic, there is no question in my mind, ask yourselves: 1.WHICH POLITICAL PARTY PUT THESE PEOPLE IN THIS POSITION ? 2.WHICH PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE BEST REPRESENTS THE INTEREST OF THESE PEOPLE ?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
04:47 PM on 03/29/2012
It started way back in 1933 with the demise of the gold standard, since then, the U.S. dollar has been plunging, to the great amount of .15 in value in 2010. this process has been on going for quite a while. http://afterthewar.blogspot.it/2012/03/history-of-value-of-us-dollar-and.html
01:45 PM on 02/07/2012
Crooked lending institutions, greedy bankers and lying salesmen have always been around; remember in ancient Rome, they had that famous phrase, CAVEAT EMPTOR (Let the Buyer Beware) The monetary problems many Americans face are partly due to the lack of financial education in the public schools. If we are graduating high schoolers who don';t even know how to,write a check, how many more are we graduating that don't know what compounding the interest in a mortgage really means, and who cannot understand that the purpose of advertising is to make you want to BUY, often luxuries that you cannot afford.. How many have any idea of what it costs to support and maintain a car? Or to raise a child? Or to buy groceries for a family of four for a single month? How many know that the stock market is on Wall Street, and not in the stock yards? But hundreds of hours of high school class time are spent on teaching kids about the birds and the bees, compared to a couple of slide shows about family budgeting. Many of these people who get underwater on mortgages for houses that were overpriced at time of purchase, or who inevitably face forclosure after job loss, accident or illnes because they have no investment income to fall back on, or who run up credit card debts for giant TV sets, luxury cars, jewelry and vacations, can blame their schools for their ignorance.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
09:48 PM on 02/06/2012
God is Great.
God is in Control!
Give to God and He will take care of you!

We are living examples.
We have lived on the same small wage for 15-20 years and have 2 children in Private schools, no DEBT (Praise God) and still have some savings.
Furthermore, frugal living & all types of insurance have kept our 4 heads above water especially during the leanest years.longer.

God is defintely in Control of our lives!
Thankyou Jesus & The Holy Spirit (Greatest Counsellor of all!)
03:46 PM on 02/06/2012
Why isn't President Obama giving Americans hope by making it easier for business to succeed?!?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
04:48 PM on 03/29/2012
The corporations took over.
02:56 PM on 02/03/2012
Healthcare is a joke now. If the hospital or doctor's office make a coding mistake it will take forever to get it corrected because the 2 will blame each other and will not correct their mistake. But they will both want to get paid ASAP. Make sure to go over your medical bills thoughly and question everything. You may be getting billed for things/procedures you didn't receive Whatever happen to people being accountable for their mistakes and good customer service.
10:08 AM on 02/06/2012
It's what happens when you nationalize something. All accountability goes away. See: US Post Office; TSA; National Health Care.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:30 PM on 02/06/2012
I take issue with the US post office being a joke. Mandated by our constitution, it has been nationalized from the beginning and has been the most accurate, inexpensive and timely mail delivery system on earth for most of its existence. It's main problem at this point is that it is massive (the US is big) and it can't compete with the internet -- just like all those privately owned printing presses that are going under. I don't think the presses that are suffering are particularly not accountable; they just are unlucky enough to be the 21st century's buggy whip manufacturers.
01:41 AM on 02/03/2012
Me & the missus; we've got our own start-up business. We've been working hard and doing well.

My wife made just enough to lose he medicaid.

I'm about to do the same.

Suddenly we're facing potential serious debt from medical costs - and not from huge surgeries. From common, everyday treatable conditions. Life saving medications that we won't be able to afford.

Thanks to the Conservatives we're realizing we'd be better off if we hadn't started our own business and succeeded.

That just put us in debt.

Instead we should have applied for welfare.
05:12 PM on 02/04/2012
That's why we need universal health care. Nobody in Western Europe or Canada faces bankruptcy because of medical costs.
Congrats and good luck to your business.
09:54 AM on 02/06/2012
Universal healthcare will lower the care standards for everyone and bring up only the bottom portion of the economic strata. The people in countries like Britain and Canada complain about their wonderful care all the time. Those who can afford it come here and pay for better care. They die or suffer otherwise. I agree this gentleman has a bad situation. There should be some process of helping people wean themselves off gov't assistance. Like lowering coverage incrementally as they do better from their own personal ambitions.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
04:53 PM on 03/29/2012
I agree, I actually had to move to Europe to live a better and more "secure" life...at least from the medical point of view! I can breathe at least without worrying if I were to fall ill or get in a car accident, then go bankrupt. I pay one lump sum of taxes that pays for it all...musch less than the estimates I received state side...and with a large sum that I would have had to pay before the insurance would help. In the end, my foot is in both doors, state side to visit my family and Europe to survive. of all things. who would have known?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SportyJim
procrastination app coming soon
06:09 PM on 02/04/2012
I spent a long time right where you are at. Making just enough that you don't qualify for assistance but paying for healthcare eats up so much of your check.
10:40 AM on 02/02/2012
If there is such a thing as reincarnation I hope I come back as a poor person.
05:15 PM on 02/04/2012
LOL, you know you can do it right now. Give all your money to charity, start to live on the street and get back to us in a year or two, if you are still in this reincarnation.
11:35 AM on 02/05/2012
I'll think about it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:24 AM on 02/02/2012
Meanwhile, Michelle Obama wears $560.00 sneakers to pass out food at a food bank.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/04/29/michelle-obama-wears-silv_n_193138.html

While staying at the most expensive Hotel money can buy in Spain, on a separate vacation from hubby. Add another 100K ion taxpayer funded Air Force 1 round trip.

Yeah baby! Hope and Change!
10:41 AM on 02/02/2012
Michelle is a true hypocrite.
05:17 PM on 02/04/2012
Why? She can afford it, it is her money.
03:01 PM on 02/03/2012
So what it's their money. Why didn't people complain about Laura Bush or Barbara Bush's attire and how much it cost. I didn't hear people complained when Bush went to his ranch or to Camp David. Get over yourself people. Everyone deserves a vacation. Quit being petty!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:16 PM on 02/03/2012
Nah, the Hope and Change couple have taken the bilking of the tax payer to another level, just like the US debt, and the last 3 deficits. Not even close.
02:43 AM on 02/02/2012
I'm 70 years old and have suddenly found himself in that bread line. When I got divorced at age 58, I had no savings and no retirement and had to start over with nothing. Since then I've been a self-employed freelancer. Every time that I have started to get ahead, something has happened to knock me back on my butt again.

Usually it has been a health problem that has kept me from working for three months or so. If you're a freelancer, when you don't work, you don't make any money. I've constantly had to rob Peter to pay Paul and in the process run up huge credit card bills. Now Peter has nothing left.

Most recently, I was unable to work between September and the end of last year because of a series of infections and inflammations in my legs. Thankfully these problems have been resolved and I'm looking for work once again, but I had to use up all of my savings and all of my lines of credit just to pay my mortgage and other bills. Yesterday I had to take out a loan against a small whole-life insurance policy that I have and today I had to cash in my small, and only, Roth IRA CD. This will buy me another month, after which I will have nothing at all.

I'm looking for full-time work, but I keep hitting a wall because companies are reluctant to hire a 70-year-old.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:14 AM on 02/02/2012
Good luck in your search.

My doctor's office has a sign:

"Doctor XXXX is getting old, but he's not retiring"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
04:55 PM on 03/29/2012
Good luck to you, at least you can earn something from your freelance work...it shows that you are capable. Too bad that the companies do not realize this fact. Sometimes, I think that HR is...not in this planet?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jamie Zupo
my babies ate my brains
07:24 PM on 02/01/2012
I think this is pretty similar to the health insurance debates. The vast majority of the comments deriding the significance of being financially insecure (or without medical insurance), especially for families, come from people who have never been there, and therefore have no relevant opinion.
09:42 PM on 02/01/2012
I've been there and my opinion would be relevant even if I hadn't: Mass starvation in this country is a politically stage-managed myth.
07:11 AM on 02/02/2012
Fortunately people don't starve in the US, but not having enough food, shelter and health care is bad enough.
10:41 AM on 02/02/2012
Agreed.
10:13 AM on 02/06/2012
How do you know if they've never been there? I've read the Pro-choice (for health care options) comments and I don't recall one person saying "I've never been where you are, but this is what I think". I'm very against socialized medicine and I've been homeless several times. Didn't qualify for gov't help because I had a job. Still broke and poor. I still think it's better to ask for help and try your best instead of complaining. I was thankful for a car, a homeless shelter, kind police offiers and friends. Even though I had to sleep in my car being moved around by police on occasions. It sounds to me like you are assuming an awful lot.
06:19 PM on 02/01/2012
People discuss the poor and poverty but are not aware of the change in living conditions for the poor. In the last 40 years, in constant dollars, consumption by those in the lowest 20% in this country has grown by 40%, The former indicators of poverty - no indoor plumbing or heating, underweight children - have slowly given way. To be poor in the US is not the same as to be poor in Haiti.
The middle class is irate at the 1% as may be natural tendency, but the weight on the middle class is unfortunately the poor. Those areas with the highest public assistance also have high income inequality and high tax rates. These taxes get pushed into every product and commodity. Oklahoma has low income inequality, low taxes, low cost of living and the lowest amount of public assistance. The poor still survive in OK. The middle class consumes the higher cost products and they too pay income taxes, sales taxes and property taxes that the poor do not. The poor, middle and weatlhy are not static. Fully one half of the poor in 2001 had moved up to the next strata within six years. Even the rich turn over. Of the top 1% in 1996 less than half were still in the top 1% just ten years later. America still works and the dream is still real. However it takes education, skills, and parenting to meet the criteria that are most prevalent among the successful.
07:18 AM on 02/02/2012
You seem to forget the 1.5 million homeless people who don't have indoor plumbing or heating. Poor people are not underweight, they are overweight because of the junk they eat instead of real food.
I don't know where you get your number from but America doesn't seem to work so well, our upward mobility is worse than ever.
http://www.endhomelessness.org/content/article/detail/3668
http://moneyland.time.com/2012/01/05/the-loss-of-upward-mobility-in-the-u-s/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
05:01 PM on 03/29/2012
I can understand that our standards have been higher, so poor in america, can be considered wealthy in Haiti, or Africa. However, we have one major difference...when a person looses their homes, must sell their car and all the shelters are full, they must sleep in the streets. If they try to set up camp, and create a stable place for themselves in a tent, somewhere, they get arrested. There is no place for them to go, to re-establish and try to start over.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KWiedemer
Denver Unemployment Examiner
05:54 PM on 02/01/2012
This is such a true story. We had to liquidate all assets (which wasn't much) that my grandmother had in order to put her in a nursing home after she required care that couldn't be given at home.

The story doesn't end there, though. I'm here to tell you that even if all assets are already long gone many people - ie single adults such as myself that have no minor children - don't qualify for assistance. Not sure how it works if there is a spouse involved, but if there's income from a spouse's job, then I would assume that qualifying for assistance is just as difficult if not outright denied.
02:47 AM on 02/02/2012
How true. Some things depend on the state where you live. In Virginia, you have to be at the poverty level before you can qualify for most assistance programs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
05:02 PM on 03/29/2012
try being homeless as a single, childless woman. There is no place for you. They are the forgotten part of society.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KWiedemer
Denver Unemployment Examiner
05:15 PM on 03/29/2012
I know that, 'sbrannan'. I am one of them too. The only difference is that my mom allows me and my dog to stay at her home (as has since my UI ran out in 2010).

Believe me, I'm living it every single day of my life. Read some of my articles if you want and you'll see that I've written about or mentioned this in my articles many, many times.
http://www.examiner.com/unemployment-in-denver/kelly-wiedemer