More

HuffPost Social Reading

HIV/AIDS Activists Complain Of Unfair Treatment By U.S. Attorney's Office

Antonio Davis

First Posted: 02/ 8/2012 6:21 pm Updated: 02/ 8/2012 6:21 pm

WASHINGTON -- Last April, a dozen HIV/AIDS activists chained themselves together inside the office of House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-Va.) and were arrested on federal charges. They were protesting cuts to HIV/AIDS programs and a proposal that would have prevented the District of Columbia from spending its own money for needle exchange programs. (The needle exchange restriction was ultimately dropped in the final budget deal.)

The same day, 41 D.C. voting rights activists, including Mayor Vincent Gray, also were arrested on Capitol Hill. They were charged with misdemeanors by the D.C. attorney general. Most, including the mayor, paid a $50 fine.

Some of the HIV/AIDS protestors, along with their supporters, gathered Wednesday on the steps of the D.C. government's Wilson Building in an effort to get the charges against them dropped by the U.S. Attorney's Office. They complained that compared with the voting rights activists, the HIV/AIDS protestors have been treated harshly.

One of the HIV/AIDS activists is Antonio Davis, a paralegal from Philadelphia who said he's been subjected to especially punitive treatment by prosecutors. Davis was diagnosed with HIV/AIDS in 2002. He was also recently diagnosed with a painful joint disease. His doctor recommends that he use medical marijuana to manage his pain and to increase his appetite, Davis said.

The first prosecutor handling the activists' case ordered each person who had been arrested to pass three drug tests as a condition for having charges dropped. Davis' tests showed the presence of marijuana. There have been three prosecutors on the case by now, and the activists complained that each has set new conditions and failed to fulfill promises made by previous prosecutors. The other activists have been offered community service in exchange for the charges being dropped -- though they complain that prosecutors have twice refused to recognize the service.

Matthew Kavanagh said he completed 64 hours of service, twice the amount prosecutors said he had to do, and is now being required to do another 32 hours.

Because of his failed drug tests, Davis doesn't have that option. His trial is scheduled to begin May 7. He faces up to six months in jail if convicted.

Meantime, Davis said he has stopped using marijuana, causing mental and physical pain.

"I've been off of my medical marijuana for the last few months," he told The Huffington Post. "It has put me in great jeopardy with my health as well as my mental health."

"We think [marijuana] is a medicinal thing, and doctors are ordering people to do it. We think the U.S. attorneys should relax their views on it," said lawyer Ann Wilcox, who attended the press conference on behalf of the National Lawyers Guild. "But, you know, it's the federal government."

The activists' attorney, Mark Goldstone, told HuffPost he is "looking into a motion to dismiss," but hopes the U.S. Attorney's Office will decide to simply drop the case instead. Calls to the U.S. Attorney's Office were not returned Wednesday afternoon.

"The guy's got AIDS," Goldstone said. "He has a doctor's letter indicating that she's keeping track of him. It's inexplicable why they're treating him harshly."

RELATED VIDEO: HIV/AIDS activists protest Eric Cantor at Harvard in February 2011.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST DC

 
 
  • Comments
  • 36
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:34 PM on 03/04/2012
The biggest lie the world was told begin with the letters HIV. Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BwgmzbnckII
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:03 PM on 02/28/2012
"They complained that compared with the voting rights activists, the HIV/AIDS protestors have been treated harshly."

...and now these twelve "HIV/AIDS activists" have learned the difference between a local and a federal law.
08:10 PM on 02/28/2012
HIV-AIDS is a condition caused by the solvents that are used in the processing of cocaine. Cocaine's connections to AIDS is often seen as a secondary factor. Most people will say that cocaine use leads to bad behavior and thereby this is a connection to the cocaine. However most people who have AIDS has a connection to cocaine and when you look at the fact that it is process would solvents that are not intended for human consumption this with a connection lines. The cocaine cartel will use anything in order to manufacture their drugs. People who consume cocaine have no idea what they put into their bodies. This needs to be investigated this thing is not a virus and if you look at the record of when this epidemic started you will find that it started at the same time the cartels decided to flood the US market would cocaine. A solution to the AIDS crisis is hiding in plain sight, but due to the fact that the CDC in NHI have classified a virus and refused to look a contrary opinion this epidemic has been going on for 30 years. While many will deny that HIV-AIDS exists in the past, they were not able to say what the cause of this disease is. I am saying it here and I'm challenging you to investigate and you will see coincidence that can't be denied.
Rick
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
scarletxoxoxo
I was born in a ditch and I eat babies.
10:28 AM on 02/09/2012
This is sad.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
doris french
Technically we are beyond survival?
08:40 AM on 02/09/2012
The US Government be unfair? Our Government today is so bad they all deserve to be thrown out of office and put on trial like the Nazis.
11:27 AM on 02/09/2012
Another fan in the future..Sorry link not working today!
jerryatthebeach
Till Death Do You Barrier Island...
08:29 AM on 02/09/2012
The most important thing to remember is 50-70% of the population wants marijuana legalized. The old folks are dying off so any wise politican should take notice, of course they're probably being paid to keep it illegal, and by the way, I don't smoke but feel it should be available to those who need it with chronic illness, etc...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
doris french
Technically we are beyond survival?
08:40 AM on 02/09/2012
Our "representatives" don't care what we want.
jerryatthebeach
Till Death Do You Barrier Island...
09:26 AM on 02/09/2012
They better start caring or be voted out of office....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sol76
07:42 AM on 02/09/2012
Those afflicted with AIDS should be given all the assistance possible until a cure is found, not treated like criminals over nothing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
doris french
Technically we are beyond survival?
08:41 AM on 02/09/2012
They don't even want to give women birth control pills!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
nygcruz80
"Craziness is like heaven"..J.Hendrix
11:25 AM on 02/09/2012
Ask your president! Hes busy sending billions to other countries to help them.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shankapotomus
Hold on "Day One" is coming.
07:31 AM on 02/09/2012
They just can't accept the words it other people money.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Stephen Stafford
Be the answer to somebody's prayer!
07:56 AM on 02/09/2012
That would be because it is a lie. They contribute to the government's purse in the way the other people you think they are not part of do as well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shankapotomus
Hold on "Day One" is coming.
08:37 AM on 02/09/2012
But take more from it, how about everytime anyone gets something everyone else does.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:00 AM on 02/09/2012
Karma is going to have a field day with you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shankapotomus
Hold on "Day One" is coming.
09:34 AM on 02/09/2012
I don't think so, because Karma's is ideology mine are facts.
07:21 AM on 02/09/2012
I have absolutely zero sympathy for Mr. Davis

First, Mr. Davis has absolutely no constitutional right to a plea deal. As long as there is no evidence that he is being singled out for different treatment, the prosecutor is free to offer whatever deal he wants-or none at all- and Mr. Davis can accept it, plead guilty like the Mayor or go to trial. Only in liberal Alice in Wonderland world does failure to get an accommodation equal disparate harsh treatment.

Second, although prosecutors often plea-bargain these cases for utility reasons (the system couldn’t handle all the trials) there is no evidence in the story to indicate Davis is innocent (e.g. a case of mistaken identity). Further, there is no 1st Amendment defense here. One does not have a 1st Amendment right to violate time, place and manner laws that are content neutral i.e. one doesn’t have the right to trespass in a Congressman’s office even if they are espousing some political viewpoint.

Finally, Mr. Davis’ arrogant disregard for the law is striking. Although the Obama administration has said it won’t enforce the law, marijuana for any use is still illegal under federal law and hence illegal in all 50 states. Mr. Davis is essentially asking the court to condone law breaking (marijuana possession) to conform to a plea deal more to his liking. This is striking. Although I doubt he'll get it I hope he gets 6 months.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Stephen Stafford
Be the answer to somebody's prayer!
07:58 AM on 02/09/2012
A cogent example of what it means to be cold blooded, cold hearted, and inhumane. What a wrenching monument to all of that.
11:48 AM on 02/09/2012
If you understand the rule of law- a foundational principle- I honestly don't know how you can say I'm cold hearted. No one has provided any evidence that Mr. Davis didn't break the law or even that he didn't know he was breaking the law. Based on that he should receive some punishment-even if its just a slap on the wrist- for breaking the law. You are suggesting that the charges against Mr. Davis be dropped but you provide no basis for such an aspiration other than what, that Mr. Davis is a sympathetic figure? Unfortunately for Mr. Davis being a sympathetic figure is not a legal defense in determining guilt or innocence.
08:12 AM on 02/09/2012
Boy, you sure can go on and on about a misdemeanor............you need to chill
11:57 AM on 02/09/2012
First, if the story is that trivial why did the HP put it on their website?

Second, I commented on it for a simple reason. Although this is a small case it involves a basic principle- the flouting of the rule of law which appears in many cases today e.g. the OWS sitins. Trespassing is a crime albeit usually a minor crime. One can either argue that one didn't commit the offense or one can raise an acceptable legal defense. Being a sympathetic figure- like Mr. Davis- or doing it for a good cause are not acceptable legal defenses. If one were to accept these as defenses society would breakdown. For example, should a poor person be allowed to rob a bank because as a sympathetic figure he needs the money?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Stephen Stafford
Be the answer to somebody's prayer!
02:38 AM on 02/09/2012
There is an astounding silence on this thread. On February, 8, at 6:21 p.m., this story was posted. I am looking at three comments posted, on February 9th, at 2:26 a.m.

I gauge the interest of an article by the number of comments. Seems that this readership is not interested in this kind of protest, and these forms of injustice. On another thread, a talking head was suspended for commenting on twitter. There was high pique over there about those tepid outrages.

That crowd probably did not see this story.

(I did not feel like editing a word, so this is Part One of Two; hopefully Part Two is adjacent)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
captainrick
11:13 AM on 02/09/2012
I have begun to call the lack of interest in HIV/AIDS "arrogant apathy". Stephen, I have been living with AIDS since 2008. I have tried to be an activist, but down here in Mississippi there is such stigma and ignorance it's always an uphill battle. Human Rights Watch . org compares AIDS care in Mississippi to Rwanda, Ethiopia, and Botswana.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OTjHS3UvQps
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Stephen Stafford
Be the answer to somebody's prayer!
02:37 AM on 02/09/2012
Part Two of Two:

On the main now, there is a story about the cut up and carry on crew bound and determined to make some changes. Several hundred have already commented on that recently published story.

Yoo hoo. Here is something to cut up and carry on about. And it involves life and death issues, and justice and equality. Funny how those things are in vogue for some applications and not apparent for others.

The differences in treatment of the two groups highlighted is what currently is known as "disparities". Much good money is used to examine what disparities exist and how to breach those barriers. I have some savings for the government right now on these.

Resolve these cases immediately, in a way that is favorable to these aggrieved protesters. Set uniform approaches for all who cut up and carry on.

Beyond that, hear their cry about what made them engage in such dramatic protest antics in the first place.

I have a high regard for people who are HIV/AIDS activists. They do not have one of the cute, marquee causes. They have at tough road to hoe. Let's give them some needed encouragement, support and help. Apply pressure to the places where you feel it needs to go, and soon.

My highest hopes to these ignored and aggrieved campaigners.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:07 AM on 02/09/2012
Thank you very much for your sentiment. I have been living with HIV since 1985 and AIDS since 1994 and have suffered more indignities than most. I have been an activist since 1987. We accomplished quite a bit through "ACT UP" back then. It seems that the younger generation does not feel the need to pick up the baton and keep moving the cause forward. I have been pleading with younger people to step up to no avail.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
nygcruz80
"Craziness is like heaven"..J.Hendrix
11:27 AM on 02/09/2012
How did you get it?
11:54 PM on 02/08/2012
Remember these stories when you cast your votes! While it may be difficult to alter the justice system, we can indeed make better informed decisions regarding our representatives! ...we are all voting -right???
07:27 PM on 02/08/2012
Liberty and justice for the few who can afford it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
olitenup
08:27 PM on 02/08/2012
It is interesting how quickly the excellently health insured congressmen/women dismiss people showing concern for health causes and diseases and they seem to do so with such disdain.