World Trade Center: Consulting Firm Has Allowed Project's Costs To Soar Out Of Control, Auditors Say

By By CHRIS HAWLEY 02/ 7/12 09:18 PM ET AP

World Trade Center
One World Trade Center, now up to 90 floors, rises above the lower Manhattan skyline and the Hudson River, Tuesday, Jan. 24, 2012 in New York. The tower is scheduled to be completed in 2013. (File, AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)

NEW YORK -- The agency that is building the new World Trade Center is "dysfunctional" and has let costs get out of control on the $14.8 billion project, auditors said Tuesday.

The projected cost of the complex has risen $3.8 billion since 2008, when it was estimated at $11 billion, Navigant Consulting, Inc., said in its audit of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.

Third parties have promised to reimburse the Port Authority for much of the construction, but the agency's remaining bill is still expected to reach $7.7 billion, up 28 percent from the last estimate of $6 billion, auditors said.

The audit was ordered by the governors of New York and New Jersey. It strongly criticized the Port Authority, which also runs New York area airports, seaports and Hudson River crossings.

The Port Authority is "a challenged and dysfunctional organization suffering from a lack of consistent leadership, a siloed underlying bureaucracy, poorly coordinated capital planning processes, insufficient cost controls, and a lack of transparent and effective oversight of the World Trade Center program that has obscured full awareness of billions of dollars in exposure to the Port Authority," auditors wrote.

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo and New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie called the increase "staggering" in a joint statement.

"This record of historic failure must be reversed," they said.

Scott Rechler, vice chairman of the Port Authority's Board of Commissioners, said costs went up after the Port Authority stepped in to manage delayed projects that were being built by third parties, including the 9/11 memorial and a performing arts center.

"We got the memorial open by its 10-year anniversary, and I think it's something we were all very proud of and proud of how it turned out," Rechler said. "But now we're at a crossroads and we have to take a step back and focus on where we are from a cost standpoint."

The authority's new director, Patrick Foye, said Tuesday the agency was taking the findings seriously and would begin an overhaul of the agency's structure. Administrators were already considering one of the auditors' recommendations, putting capital spending decisions in the hands of one person, he said.

"Recommendations like that are going to be very helpful in maximizing the value of every dollar we spend at the World Trade Center and every other capital project in the port's portfolio," Foye said.

The agency's debt has risen from $9.1 billion in 2001 to $19.5 billion, auditors said. The Port Authority receives no tax money, so those funds will have to be paid off through airport surcharges, bridge and tunnel tolls, port fees and rent from the agency's other properties.

Cuomo and Christie ordered the review after the agency's board voted to raise bridge and tunnel tolls in August.

The Port Authority has lost millions of dollars in revenue because of lower traffic at its ports, airports and river crossings due to the economy.

Meanwhile, the World Trade Center has suffered a number of construction setbacks.

The company that is laying steel for One World Trade Center, the signature tower, has run into financial problems, and the Port Authority has stepped in to pay some of its bills. A mistake in the design means the Port Authority will have to spend millions of dollars on temporary loading docks for the building. And the builders of the 9/11 museum are fighting with the agency over infrastructure costs.

The 104-story One World Trade Center is now 90 stories high, but the pace of construction has slowed. Foye has blamed winter weather and says it is still on schedule to open in late 2013.

The World Trade Center plan calls for five office towers, a 9/11 museum, the 9/11 memorial, a large subway station and a performing arts center.

But construction of Two World Trade Center, the second-tallest building in the complex at 88 stories, has been postponed because of a lack of tenants.

Three World Trade Center, which was supposed to be 80 stories high, is under construction but has also struggled to find tenants. Developer Larry Silverstein has said he may have to cap the building at seven stories if he cannot get more companies to move in.

Silverstein's company also owns two other buildings on the site, Four World Trade Center and the already-completed Seven World Trade Center.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST NEW YORK

NEW YORK -- The agency that is building the new World Trade Center is "dysfunctional" and has let costs get out of control on the $14.8 billion project, auditors said Tuesday. The projected cost of t...
NEW YORK -- The agency that is building the new World Trade Center is "dysfunctional" and has let costs get out of control on the $14.8 billion project, auditors said Tuesday. The projected cost of t...
Filed by Jade Walker  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 319
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
10:58 AM on 02/09/2012
Just wait until these clowns out here in California force through our used to be $40 billion now up to $110 billion will probably end up being $200 billion bullet train that virtually nobody wants. The people have lost complete control to the illegal immigrant, union and Democratic government triumvirate in this state. Brown talks about raising taxes and pension reform. He puts the tax increase on the ballot and turns the pension reforms over to the 63% Democrat Assembly and Senate. Good luck with those reforms. Thank god we have great weather!
10:08 AM on 02/09/2012
thus the reason for the doubled tolls on january 1st for the turnpike and bridges and tunnels into NYC. and the working suckers who have to pay for it. $12 to go over a 80 year old bridge..ridiculous.
12:32 AM on 02/09/2012
Winter weather? What winter??
11:41 PM on 02/08/2012
Are you kidding me Silverstein up to his tricks again!! You have got to see he is the man behind the money curtain "Pulling" the puppets strings!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
parabq
09:35 PM on 02/08/2012
Oh thats a big surprise !!!! You get a prima donna architect who is clueless about costs and an agency who is incompetent - this is the result ! Hows it feel to get ripped off New Yorkers !
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:53 PM on 02/08/2012
An outside, private contractor to oversee the project with incentives built in if the project came in under budget and on time would have been the better choice than giving it to the Port Authority.
Between the bloated union contracts and a lack of incentive to get the job done it will flounder under a lack of leadership and the ability to finish a project on time because there are no consequences. Another fleecing of taxpayer's and donor's hard earned cash! Private sector will always do a better job than public sector! No responsibility = no consequences!
05:00 PM on 02/08/2012
The empire state building was built in the thirties from cellar to top in13 months! No Unions, just a steady supply of men who needed the work during the depression. Sound familiar?! and, it came in under time AND under budget!
photo
SolarPowerGuy
Ph.D., Immunology; Solar power @ home; Green Party
04:36 PM on 02/08/2012
Hey, this building is a matter of NATIONAL PRIDE, right, conservatives?

How many of your Heartland, "Real America" politicians have wrapped themselves in the flag, and pointed at that smoking hole in the ground on West Street?

I think you guys should take up a collection and make sure this project gets done right, and done soon. After all, it's your 1776-foot tall, one-fingered salute to the Islamic Threat!
03:36 PM on 02/08/2012
The new plan is to raise bridge tolls to $65.00 one way. That should help the PA raise pensions for it's workers, allow them to continue using the bridges for free and make it less painfull for commuters next year when the tolls get raised to $105.00 to help pay for the WTC project.
02:06 PM on 02/08/2012
Did anyone ever seriously think that this would never be one more trhogh for the pigs to feed on?
12:42 PM on 02/08/2012
Greedy 1%ers at work again ?!?!?
MansfieldX
Marine, Capitalist, Job Creator, Libertarian
12:47 PM on 02/08/2012
If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
v650
12:22 PM on 02/08/2012
Man those Soprano's are really driving up costs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alohageedub
12:20 PM on 02/08/2012
With the highest State/City taxation in the U.S., no one wants to be in NY.
MansfieldX
Marine, Capitalist, Job Creator, Libertarian
12:30 PM on 02/08/2012
1.6 million people moved out of New York State between 2000 and 2010. More than any other state in the union. I guess is that will accelerate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alohageedub
01:02 PM on 02/08/2012
Similar to Detroit and/or California!
photo
ludichris212
Happy Halloween, ladies!
02:55 PM on 02/08/2012
New York State, yes.

New York City, the population went up nearly 200K in the same time period and stands at an all-time high.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jackdaniel58
12:19 PM on 02/08/2012
"House of Lies"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:14 PM on 02/08/2012
Construction companies and builders need to be held acoountable for their fees ansd costs once construction has started. Their "proposals" are generally worthless and not worth the paper they are written on. They need to be sued.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alohageedub
12:22 PM on 02/08/2012
Construction companies form a new subsidiary for the construction. Sue all you want, the subsidiary has nothing, once the job is completed the subsidiary is shut down.