More

HuffPost Social Reading

Chicago City Sticker Controversy: Contest Winner Speaks Out About Design (VIDEO)

First Posted: 02/10/2012 9:36 am Updated: 02/10/2012 9:48 am

The 15-year-old Chicago boy at the center of the city's vehicle sticker contest controversy said Wednesday that his design, criticized by some for allegedly containing gang signs and ultimately dumped by the city in favor of the contest's second-place winner, was "clean."

Herbert Pulgar, in an interview with CBS Chicago Wednesday, maintained that, his submission had nothing to do with any sort of gang affiliation.

"Not true at all," Pulgar, a Lawrence Hall Youth Services freshman, told CBS. "I'm trying to show love to those first responders."

He added that, after winning the contest and meeting Mayor Rahm Emanuel, he felt proud. But now, he is sad, disappointed and wishes that City Clerk Susana Mendoza had met with him so he could better explain his design's inspiration -- or even be given an opportunity to redraw the controversially shaped hands.

Though Mendoza has not met with the teen, she did announce Thursday that, although the $1,000 savings bond Pulgar was to have won through the contest would now be given to second-place artist Caitlin Henehan, she would personally pay for a separate $1,000 bond to go toward the boy's education, the Chicago Tribune reports.

"I believe that the student who provided the original design should also be recognized for his talent and participation in the contest. I want to encourage him to pursue a degree where he can continue to develop his skills. ... It will not be at taxpayer expense," Mendoza said, according to the Tribune.

Had Mendoza not offered to pay for the bond out of her own pocket, it appears that the Rev. Michael Pfleger of St. Sabina would have.

Pfleger said, prior to Mendoza's announcement, that Pulgar "should still get the $1,000 bond. ... He did his best. He did what he thought. He won. And we should still honor him. We can disagree on the sticker. We can pull the sticker. We should not dishonor this child," the Chicago Sun-Times reports.

The decision to scrap the contest's winning design was reportedly not an easy one and Mendoza said, "frankly, we had a lot of tears in that office making that decision," according to Fox Chicago.

That decision came after an investigation and consultation with gang experts affiliated with the Chicago Police Department and the Chicago Crime Commission, whose president, former CPD superintendent Jody Weis, said the design likely referenced gang signs and iconography. The allegation came from a post on a blog popular with police officers.

His mother, Jessica Loor, on Wednesday said she was very upset about how the controversy has played out.

Pulgar's design was selected by 18,000 Chicagoans who voted in the city's 2012-2013 vehicle registration sticker contest. The boy reportedly was inspired to dedicate his design to first responders after they saved his life when he was badly burned during a fire at the age of 4.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CHICAGO

The 15-year-old Chicago boy at the center of the city's vehicle sticker contest controversy said Wednesday that his design, criticized by some for allegedly containing gang signs and ultimately dumped...
The 15-year-old Chicago boy at the center of the city's vehicle sticker contest controversy said Wednesday that his design, criticized by some for allegedly containing gang signs and ultimately dumped...
Filed by Joseph Erbentraut  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 58
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
O K Ali
Wash your hands, seriously.
02:33 PM on 02/19/2012
Wow. That's ridiculous.
01:44 PM on 02/16/2012
The symbols were just a pretext for the real issue. The kid and his fugitive father were considered a much bigger potential embarrassment than the sticker design, which the kid could have been redone on the quiet at the request of the city. And don't you think that putting any symbol on a city sticker changes the context, and thereby the meaning in a way that just might neutralize it's supposed magical power to trigger gang violence? The law-and-order die-hards involved here have already consigned the kid to the criminal class. He's not supposed to win contests!
02:11 PM on 02/12/2012
It takes a lot of imagination to say that the hands on the sticker are throwing the fork. I hope they at least let this kid keep the money.
tissa
Chicago Liberal /Sales/Marketing Director
12:22 PM on 02/12/2012
You know I thought this was just so silly until I heard his father is a huge gang member, in jail for trafficking cocaine, and that this kid had been in trouble as well.  So the former gang members who identified this as a gang symbol, may be right.


The simple solution would have been to just change how the hands look, just change the hands, that's it. Simple.

They are letting him keep the money.
08:17 PM on 02/11/2012
Oh yeah, and why is a failed chief of police now on the city's "Crime Commission"? What exactly is a crime commission anyway? Does it have anything to do with the commission of crimes? Only in Chicago.
08:14 PM on 02/11/2012
His art is much more compelling than the runner up's art. He should get the money, but the art shouldn't be used for the city sticker. Whatever he meant to communicate is a moot point. The dominant interpretation is what it is, fairly or not. It's been interpreted as a glorification of gangs. If the artist is a serious artist, then he just learned a valuable lesson - his work will be interpreted and criticized and he should engage in the dialogue. If he does, his art will endure way longer than the city sticker will.
photo
Romano54
honor does not have a price
04:48 PM on 02/11/2012
The city does not excercise due dilligence in research, whether it be policy changes, privatization, passing regulations or understanding street culture. All are experts in nothing. To someone not familiar with hand signs, screatching your nose the wrong way will get you shot in some neighborhoods. I guess no one is mentioning the sudden FBI interest in the kid's father(?) since the story broke. The kid also has an attorney? What 15 year old needs an attorney?
03:57 PM on 02/11/2012
I think it is some serious B.S. that this wonderful drawing can't be the official sticker. I have reviewed that picture over & over but the only thing I see is out stretched hands. I think the bias-ness needs to stop.
12:38 AM on 02/11/2012
I've looked at the facebook evidence. I'm not inclined to believe that he's in a gang himself but he probably associates himself with people who are. He's probably thrown up gang signs in pictures and talked the talk. In the end, he's a kid, growing up in the ghetto. It's something I feel personally familiar with. To me, this was a kid who's grown up around this stuff and decided that to enter a contest. The influence of his lifestyle affected the art but I doubt that his intent was to promote the gang or have the symbol misconstrued for the gang logo. Clearly he put some work into it and I feel sorry that they took away his title as winner. This may have finally been something that he was proud of that was a legitimate accomplishment. You can condemn him as a gangbanger all you want but in the end he's a 15 year old kid whose fate isn't decided yet.
08:49 PM on 02/10/2012
The people who robbed this lad of the prize are a bunch of *slang word for cats.*
There are no gang signs on that poster. It takes a lot of longitudinal infering to see gang sign on that poster.

George Orwell warned us that we are headed in this direction.
photo
sylkol
You can't buy soap on aid if you don't have kids.
03:55 AM on 02/11/2012
You need to look at his FB pics and try to tell me the kid wearing the tie is not the same kid flashing the g a n g signs and giving h e ll a attitude. It is the same kid. You would never believe it.
11:21 AM on 02/11/2012
I saw his fb page the day Huffpo posted the story.
There are no gang signs on the poster.
The logic for resinding the prize wsas "there are gang signs on the poster," NOT "because of whats on his fb page."
This is 21st centry McCarthyism.
04:52 PM on 02/10/2012
Second City Cop pretty much thinks any non-white kid is a gang banger.
10:49 AM on 02/12/2012
and what color is this kid?
02:33 PM on 02/10/2012
Read the true details here: http://sec­­­ondcityc­o­p­.blogs­po­t.­com/
(scroll the last few days for all of the facts)
This police blog has even more details: http://www­.shavedlon­gcock.blog­spot.com/
(understan­d the URL is a bit obscene but it it a Chicago police blog)

See his FB gang posts...
Herbert choir boy was arrested this past Oct for burglary..­.
See his ganged up pictures/c­­hats...
See his father wanted by FBI/Interp­­ol...
Herbert has gang affiliatio­n tattoo on right shoulder (oops)...

Do a little investigat­­­ion...th­e true PC spin is the mainstream medias reporting of this story.

The kid is an admitted active gang member. You can be blind to the imagery but anyone who lives in these neighborho­­­ods immediatel­­­y understand­s the symbolism. The Chicago street cops were the ones who immediatel­­­y recognized the imagery and broke this story. As a resident I do not want this gang trash sticker on my vehicle. There an estimated 150,000 active gang members in this city and the gang this kid is associated with is one of the worst of the worst. Gangs terrorize this city. Save your pity for the victims of gang violence.

Generally I am an anti-PC person...b­ut in this case...the city did the right thing.
05:09 PM on 02/10/2012
My thoughts exactly. I don't know why the whole story isn't being reported. No mention of his FB page, which has since been taken down. The city did the right thing.
08:58 PM on 02/10/2012
Maybe concerned adults are trying to help the lad take a different direction in his life. Like, you know, "spend your time creating fine works of art instead of gang-banging. Who knows, maybe you COULD win, iduno ... a $1,000. Would an experience like that might motivate you to be an artist insted of a gangster."
I saw his facebook page with him dressed in the grb, smoking drugs, his father poseing with pistols, etc.
That does NOT preclude him from participating in the contest.
Chicago missed a great teaching oppertunity by taking that prize from him. Rather than show a living example of what happens when you focus on positive activities like art, Chicago chose to go the "exclusion route."

I am embarrased by the actions of my city.
10:08 PM on 02/10/2012
The funny thing is the pictures/FB stuff was from January of this year. Long after he entered/won the contest. Sure did not seem like Herbie was straightening out his life.

Maybe.....him getting exposed and facing some consequences for gang banging makes him realize he is headed in the wrong direction and he chooses a more positive route in his life...could be the best thing that ever happened to him.

I am embarrassed by the actions of the media and many of the residents of my city. It is like many of these people do not live in this city and do not witness the violence and problems these gangs cause.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ckdogs
01:18 PM on 02/10/2012
This young man should be honored by the city for his accomplishment. The editorial in today's Chicago Sun Times says it best - if this depiction of hands and heart showed gang signs, then all art from the Mona Lisa to Munch has to be re-evaluated.
04:00 PM on 02/10/2012
It is not the artwork/symbols alone it is the connection to an artist who has been proven to be a gang member...hardly seems coincidence that the symbols in question are the prominent symbols in the gang the kid associates with.

For example a heart is fine...hands are fine...a heart and hands that are making a pitchfork gesture drawn by a known gang member...no thanks...I do not want that gang trash on my vehicle.

Read some of the insider blogs on this story and stop believing the horse crap/PC nonsense the media is feeding us.

http://sec­­­­ondcity­c­o­p­.blo­gs­po­t.­c­om/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
markspence
10:59 PM on 02/10/2012
You would do that as a result of this boy's sticker? You would reevaluate all the world's art?
01:02 PM on 02/10/2012
Please stop pandering to this gang banger. Whining liberals: visit the south side and face the reality of dealing with gang violence destroying a neighborhood on a daily basis, then get back to me on how you feel about representing MLD on the windshield of your car.
01:25 PM on 02/10/2012
Hate to say it, but: http://secondcitycop.blogspot.com/
Appears there is more to this story than meets the eye.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mayrose
12:51 PM on 02/10/2012
Weis should leave Chicago and hang his head in shame for picking on this kid - big bully.
He didn't understand Chicago as Police commissioner and still doesn't.
01:25 PM on 02/10/2012
And clearly neither do you if you are unable to recognize the clear references to the Maniac Latin Disciples, a prominent Chicago gang, in this drawing. There is a majority consensus in the law enforcement community on this subject; If you're not familiar with gangs or their symbolism then take it from the people who are responsible for being knowledgeable of such information.