iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app

Race And Class: Teen Investigates 'How The Other Half Lives'

  First Posted: 02/10/2012 3:24 pm Updated: 02/12/2012 8:49 am

Race

This is a youth-written article from our friends at Represent Magazine, a platform for and by young people in foster care.

By Natasha Santos

I read on the front page of today’s New York Times that the poor are dropping further behind the rich in school. I grew up in Brownsville, a very poor neighborhood in Brooklyn. I didn’t know what kind of neighborhoods and education and opportunities middle class kids got, but I knew it had to be much better than mine and it made me angry. As a teen I was writing for Represent, a magazine for teens in foster care, and my editor suggested that I visit a well-off school district in Connecticut and describe my reactions. The trip was troubling for me -- I saw the benefits that those kids had, but I also saw how hard many of them worked to take advantage of them.

That was seven years ago. I’ve since worked for Americorps in New Orleans and completed two years of college. I’m working in a teen pregnancy prevention program -- a job that I love -- and struggling to save money so I can help my mom and finish college. Things were tough when I was in high school, as you will see when you read my story. It is scary to me that things may be getting even worse.

For a long time I believed that roaches, violence, and chaos were part of everyone’s childhood memories. In my neighborhood, Brownsville, Brooklyn, poor blacks and Latinos live isolated from wealthier minorities and other races. I’ve often been afraid to walk down my block alone for fear of being attacked.

As I got older, I realized that other people weren’t living in fear like I was. I began to feel like a statistic -- a black girl who lived in a place where mothers dote on drug-dealing sons and ignore the gun hidden under dirty laundry in the closet. I wondered if I had less of a chance to achieve the American dream because I had had less of a childhood. I wondered whether my race and the poverty I grew up in would hold me back from success and happiness. I had guidance counselors and teachers who sang the same old song about reaching for the stars and being determined, and I bought it enough to get good grades and plan to go to college. But those dreams were starting to sound like fairy tales.

I wanted to interview other teens to find out how they thought their neighborhood, race, and class might affect their lives. The editor at my after-school journalism program told me that she had been brought up in a suburban town where many races and classes attended the same school peacefully. I wanted to visit this place, partly see how the other half lived (the wealthy, suburban, BMW-driving, as-seen-on-TV people) and partly to prove my editor wrong. The idea that many races and classes could live together in a kind of unified community seemed unreal to me.

Growing up, I’d been taught that most black people live in poor neighborhoods in cities, while the suburban life is a kind of Caucasian paradise. Even though I attend a racially and economically diverse high school in New York City, I just couldn’t picture a school in the suburbs looking like mine.

I brought all my skepticism with me the morning we got off the train in Norwalk, Connecticut, expecting the cliché of private houses owned by scared upper-class Caucasians ready to move out as soon as a family of color moved in. Indeed, much of Norwalk looked the way I expected. I saw neatly manicured lawns with houses tucked serenely into foliage and generously spaced apart, giving the inhabitants enough room to have a 50-person cookout in the backyard without disturbing their neighbors.


FOLLOW HUFFPOST HIGH SCHOOL

This is a youth-written article from our friends at Represent Magazine, a platform for and by young people in foster care. By Natasha Santos I read on the front page of today’s New York Times...
This is a youth-written article from our friends at Represent Magazine, a platform for and by young people in foster care. By Natasha Santos I read on the front page of today’s New York Times...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 111
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
06:06 PM on 02/18/2012
I'm sorry that you feel that way, but there are some things you should medidate on :

- You grew up into a poor neighbourhood, in a broken family, with an absent dad and a unreliable mother. Don't you think those factors are actually much more relevant to explain your difficulties (real or perceived) than your race? Trust me, a white girl in your situation would have faced the same kind of hardship.

- You say something I found disturbing : basically white people don't really "care" about black people being black and are now mainly color-blind - only black people are still self-conscious of their "blackness" and enforcing old stereotypes and that is what hold them back. What do you think black people should do about that?
03:15 PM on 02/14/2012
Recent immigrants to this country seem to work harder and do better across the board. I would be interested to read an article from someone whose family has not recently immigrated here and get that perspective.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mailman
11:42 PM on 02/12/2012
I've said it a hundred times and I'll say it hundred more, it all starts with the Dad in the home and if there isn't one you're already at disadvantage. With 70% unwed mothers in the black community that's where you start before racism, crime, education and self pride. Address this problem first and stop ignoring it great things will happen just like all other neighborhoods.
11:35 PM on 02/12/2012
Not your race or color of skin will hold you back ONLY THE WAY YOU THINK may hold you back.
11:08 PM on 02/12/2012
I also grew up in Brooklyn, went to 3 high schools (one in suburban Long Island) & i saw a MAJOR difference from the LOCATIONS. Economics has a lot to do with it BUT it's the person's free-will that drives them up to what extent they choose.
ALL the schools DID indeed have opportunities for EVERYONE to prosper to their full penitential (ex: AP courses/ Honors courses which i was a part of).

If you put the work and effort into it AND IGNORE SOCIETIES STEREOTYPES then your bound to achieve your platform of greatness.

Also, very important note: TALK & BEFRIEND people of OTHER RACES/ ETHNICITY's. Thats the Only way to CURE RACISM/ Prejudice/ Stereotypes
11:26 PM on 02/12/2012
potential* sorry
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yam716
For Natural Hair CurlTalk, Visit: lillian-mae
12:54 PM on 01/17/2013
RE: TALK & BEFRIEND people of OTHER RACES/ ETHNICITY's. Thats the Only way to CURE RACISM/ Prejudice/ Stereotypes

I agree completely! There have been so many comments suggesting that diversity doesn't work. That's BS!

F&F!
09:32 PM on 02/12/2012
In my opinion Natasha's biggest disadvantage was not economical or race based, but as she said "My dad was in jail or never around. When I came home from school, my mom was usually in her bed watching TV or sleeping. I was unhappy, unkempt, and malnourished. I felt like an outcast among the perfectly clean, perfectly white 6-year-old kids with parents who noticed every skinned knee and missing tooth. My mother didn’t know my birthday, much less if I had a skinned knee." Hopefully what was her biggest disadvantage will become her advantage as she gets older and perhaps has her own family. Remember how you felt. Don't let your kids grow up feeling the way you did. Certainly don't believe the notion that your race plays a role in how you raise your kids. Don't let anyone (including yourself) put you in a group based on race,economic status, where you live. You are you Black,white, yellow, brown, purple people all have the same basic need to be loved and raised the right way. Not trying to disparage the author's parents I'm sure they love their daughter. Being a parent is hard work. It's the hardest job and most important one we ever take. To know a piece of us goes on. With values hopefully we can be proud of (and partially responsible for) To me its the most rewarding thing we can do in our lives. I wish the best of luck to the author.
05:45 PM on 02/12/2012
A very well written article.

While racism does exist, it is not the root of all evil.

You set out to prove your preconceived believe that race/wealth were the sole reasons for the ills in your life/ills plaguing your community. However, when you didn't hear what you wanted to hear, you dismissed those who wouldn't confirm your preconceived beliefs as being naive and "lucky". First rule in journalism: Tell the truth...not make up a new set of "truths" (as you see it) when others don't see the problem from the same perspective as yourself.

Personal choices play a big role (if not the biggest) in both the situation we find ourselves in as well affecting change. I am speaking of your parents. Neither race, nor wealth, have anything to do with your mother's apparent lack of involvement in your life as it doesn't take money to show love/attention/concern for your child...the color of our skin does not limit our ability to provide these basic needs.

As for your father...it is certainly true that crime and poverty go hand in hand...it's a vicious cycle. However, while difficult, it is not impossible to break the cycle...it's a matter of how bad we want it. Your father made personal choices which landed him in jail/prison.

Perhaps a look at what makes your parents different from those interviewed would be a worthwhile endeavor.

I wish you all the best.
photo
mlaiuppa
Pres. Sarcasm Society. Like we need your approval.
03:44 PM on 02/12/2012
Success does have less to do with race. But it has more to do with poverty, education and family support.

Those in poor neighborhoods may not have two parents who both work hard to see that they have three meals and clean clothes. They may not have parents that read to them at night or can read at all. They may not have parents that push them in school, monitor their homework, make sure they are learning. They may not have parents they teach them how to work hard, that teach them the value of a good education, that push the schools to provide that education. These children of poverty may not know what they're missing so how can they strive for it?

It's the poverty. Whether you're black, latin, asian or white, it's the poverty.
photo
weebils
I like jalapenos and hot sauce
03:23 PM on 02/12/2012
So in Natasha's world she is the only intelligent black person from her neighborhood? Seems she is stereotyping herself.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
moonlightesq
12:47 PM on 02/12/2012
Daphney said "black kids at that school hold themselves back more than the system does. “I think it’s because they have fallen into their own stereotypes. They criticize the people who want to get ahead.” Typical excuse for underachievers, who would rather believe in the stereotype than trying to break out of it, despite racial backgrounds.

I'm glad you had the chance to visit a well-to-do school and see that the reality is not stereotypical of what you had thought from the t.v. shows such as 90210.

Work hard, study hard, believe in yourself and make your own destiny. When you are brave enough to break out of the stereotype, you can be a role model for others to follow.
08:12 AM on 02/12/2012
Congrats to a young woman who looks a tough issue in the eye, examines it from differing perspectives, mulls it over, writes a draft, discards it, writes another, discards it, and persists for a year before considering it ready for publication. That, my friend, is true grit. You'll go far.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hontas Farmer
Stargazer
06:02 AM on 02/12/2012
What those kids are saying is very true of too many minorities. Among black people there is a short parable.

To keep crabs in a barrel you don't need a lid. The reason is if one crab is climbing out to escape, another crab will grab them and pull them back in.

That's how too many black, Hispanic, and other minorities are here in the USA. We may have been put in a barrel. That much was the white mans doing. However, no one white is holding down the lid.
04:59 AM on 02/12/2012
How many suburban moms would tolerate a gun found hidden among dirty clothes in the laundry hamper? How many suburban fathers sell and/or take drugs. You get out of life what you put into it.
03:32 PM on 02/12/2012
Ask Dylan Clebold's parents and stop being so naive.
08:52 AM on 02/14/2012
The Klebolds did have some neglect and stupidity issues. The kid steals a car five months before Columbine yet he's still allowed to hang out with the kid he stole the car with and is allowed out of the house after school.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
beverly149
Nurse Practitioner/Proud Army Vet
05:17 PM on 02/12/2012
How naiive you are. Look at "To Young To Kill." It is featured or ID Discovery. All of these kids were raised in suburbia and they all ended up murdering other kids. Drugs are everywhere, Even in suburbia, and as for selling drugs and taking drugs you haven't heard of the crime family The Mafia I suppose?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mr Anonymous
Mumpsimus, I am not entertained!
10:02 PM on 02/11/2012
The attitude of these "suburban" kids seem like a wide held suburban belief. That if your poor or don't do well in school it's your fault. It doesn't matter what race they are, because they're all suburban. I think it's more of an economic issue as opposed to a race issue.
10:39 AM on 02/12/2012
Poor asians do much better then poor blacks in philly. They go to the same schools.
Asians aren't afraid of "acting white"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mr Anonymous
Mumpsimus, I am not entertained!
11:39 AM on 02/12/2012
.........

I said it was a wide held belief, not that poor people do bad, because they are poor. There are some poor people that do very well in school. However, poverty does have an impact on education.
10:32 AM on 02/11/2012
Poverty is often created by bad life choices. A woman with no education and no job skills has 5 children with 3 different men. She always has a new boyfriend in attendance. Rehab and jail time are nothing short of being called state sponsored vacation time. The dysfunction at home carries into the schools. No one works. Drama and violent behavior is considered normal. Anyone who works hard and achieves is punished by the community. Tribes of people create their own reality.