iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Joshua Hersh
GET UPDATES FROM Joshua:

Keith Ellison Calls For Return To Diplomacy, Debate On Iran

Posted: 02/15/2012 8:17 am Updated: 02/15/2012 5:50 pm

WASHINGTON -- The United States must not let itself slide into a war with Iran without more debate and deliberation, Rep. Keith Ellison (D-Minn.) told The Huffington Post late on Tuesday.

"The debate is not happening, and there needs to be a debate," Ellison said.

On Tuesday, Ellison -- along with Rep. Walter Jones (R-N.C.), a stalwart of the anti-war wing of the Republican Party -- began circulating among his colleagues a letter calling on President Barack Obama to demand more time for diplomacy and sanctions to diffuse the brewing crisis without military action.

"As tension with Iran continues to escalate, we urge your Administration to utilize all available tools of diplomacy to resolve the crisis over Iran's nuclear program and prevent another costly war in the Middle East," the letter reads.

"War is bodies. War is destruction of infrastructure. War is refugees," Ellison told HuffPost. "I'm not going to stand here as war is looming and not try to at least raise these issues, so that people can make a different decision."

In recent months, the prospect of a war with Iran -- perhaps sparked by an Israeli air strike on Iranian nuclear sites, before possibly drawing in the United States -- has started to seem like an inevitability, as newspapers have carried countless tales of Iran's supposed ties to terrorism and nuclear-weapon ambitions.

Earlier in the week, Israeli diplomats were targeted by car bombs in New Delhi and Tbilisi, Georgia -- attacks that the Israelis have blamed on Iran.

Iran has an operational nuclear energy project and is believed by many to be intent on constructing a nuclear bomb, although the most up-to-date American intelligence assessments have not yet concluded that Iran plans to militarize its nuclear program.

Obama said in his January State of the Union address that he would "take no options off the table" to "prevent Iran from getting a nuclear weapon," a goal he shares with the even more hard-line Israeli government.

In his conversation with HuffPost, Ellison emphasized that he is no friend of the Iranian regime, particularly when considering what he called its "ruthless" human rights record. He pointed out that he has often supported strong sanctions against the government there.

But he added that the lack of serious debate about a possible war with Iran, in the media and among leading political figures, seemed to mirror the failure of discourse before the war in Iraq, when false claims by the Bush administration that Saddam Hussein possessed weapons of mass destruction were never fully challenged.

"I think the media is being lured into the same things they got lured into with Iraq," Ellison said. "What if we found out that they're not actually weaponizing? As the buildup for Iraq was going on, if you were to say publicly, 'I don't think Saddam has weapons of mass destruction,' you'd be laughed out of town. If the price of stopping a war is me being called some names, I can handle it."

The full text of the letter is below:

Dear President Obama:

As tension with Iran continues to escalate, we urge your Administration to utilize all available tools of diplomacy to resolve the crisis over Iran's nuclear program and prevent another costly war in the Middle East.

We have supported your Administration's efforts to unite the international community to bring about the strongest sanctions on Iran to date. Now, we must redouble our diplomatic efforts to achieve robust transparency measures that can verify Iran's nuclear program is strictly a civilian one. Without a corresponding diplomatic undertaking, we are concerned that a lack of communication with Iran could lead to a dangerous escalation with potentially devastating consequences.

We hold no illusions about the abuses of the Iranian regime and are well aware that it rejected your previous diplomatic overtures. At the same time, we agree with most Americans that the United States should not enter a new war, just as we are finally ending two others. A military strike against Iran could lead to a regional war in the Middle East and attacks against U.S. interests. Even worse, such a strike would likely compel Iran to abandon the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, eject international inspectors, and rapidly pursue a nuclear deterrent.

Top military and civilian leaders have repeatedly issued warnings about the consequences of a military strike on Iran. Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta cautioned that the United States "could possibly be the target of retaliation from Iran, sinking our ships, striking our military bases," and that "would not only involve many lives, but I think could consume the Middle East in a confrontation and a conflict that we would regret."

Former Israeli Mossad chief Meir Dagan made a similar prediction when he said that attacking Iran "would mean regional war, and in that case you would have given Iran the best possible reason to continue the nuclear program."

Retired General Anthony Zinni said, "If you follow this all the way down, eventually I'm putting boots on the ground somewhere. And, like I tell my friends, if you like Iraq and Afghanistan, you'll love Iran."

To avoid war, former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Admiral Michael Mullen, called for the United States to utilize "any channel that's open" for engagement with Iran, noting, "Even in the darkest days of the Cold War, we had links to the Soviet Union."

We strongly encourage your Administration to pursue bilateral and multilateral engagement with Iran. While we acknowledge that progress will be difficult, we believe that robust, sustained diplomacy is the best option to resolve our serious concerns about Iran's nuclear program, and to prevent a costly war that would be devastating for the United States and our allies in the region.

FOLLOW POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
WASHINGTON -- The United States must not let itself slide into a war with Iran without more debate and deliberation, Rep. Keith Ellison (D-Minn.) told The Huffington Post late on Tuesday. "The deba...
WASHINGTON -- The United States must not let itself slide into a war with Iran without more debate and deliberation, Rep. Keith Ellison (D-Minn.) told The Huffington Post late on Tuesday. "The deba...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 928
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (13 total)
08:01 PM on 03/11/2012
this situation has many similarities to the 13-year, multi-administration, multi-national "rush" to war with iraq.

we have been imploring iran to stop their nuclear program for years and years without compliance.

handle this already and be done with it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sallybutt45
To thine own self be true.
04:06 PM on 02/20/2012
Mr. Ellison is on the right side of the issue, and it surprises me that the rest of congress are not blocking him on this. Robert Baird, as he stepped down, talked about what he wasn't allowed to voice in a congress so pro-Israel, that you literally put your career on the line if you dared to dissent. A great documentary on Free Speech & Link TV, "The Israel Lobby" delt with this, and it would shed some light on just how much control is wielded by AIPAC and Israeli govt in our Legislature, for those who have been led to believe that Israel is a victim.
Bernique
Solar is clean, cheap and plentiful
11:53 PM on 02/16/2012
My sentiments exactly, Mr. Ellison. Thank you.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
The Knocker
a mind is a terrible thing to waste
08:41 PM on 02/16/2012
"seemed to mirror the failure of discourse before the war in Iraq" Unfortunately the Obama adm. is allowing itself to be lured into another war by a foreign country lobbyist, interestingly right before a major presidential election. Also, pres. Obama is using the same tactic by the Bush adm, to persuade the media and the American people by portraying Iran as Soviet-style threat to the rest of the world. Though, unlike the U.S and some other country in the region, Iran never attacked or invaded another country. Let us all hope this is just posturing by our gov. and commonsense will prevail at the end of the day
03:56 PM on 02/16/2012
I think this guy should move to Iran and take his family and friends with him.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
murphthesurf3
Progressive: Like Ike and Clinton!
04:19 PM on 02/16/2012
You left a rather nasty comment for me in another thread.

Flagged it as abusive. It has been removed.

I then read 20 of your comments on your comment page. More of the same.

 Insult after insult. Name calling after name calling. Getting around the guidelines using abbreviations and other gimmicks. So I reported your entire profile requesting a HP review. 

This is not the site for this kind of behavior.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
TeeSC
04:36 PM on 02/16/2012
Damet Garm!  His profile is already gone.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kathy Levittown
I love all animals better than most people!
04:56 PM on 02/16/2012
Hi murphthesurf3!! Well said my friend....Some posts get really nasty and pointless....
wow....

I applaud you!!

Kathy ;-)
11:33 AM on 02/16/2012
If congress wants real diplomacy, they will have to get a new Sec. of state.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Mighty Cynic
11:39 AM on 02/16/2012
or audit the State Department for dual nationals. Remember, she spoke up for Women's rights in Israel and look at what happened to the Secretary (powerless)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kathy Levittown
I love all animals better than most people!
04:58 PM on 02/16/2012
Yea right..She is one of the best Secretaries-of-state we ever had.....
10:11 PM on 02/16/2012
Well, there we disagree. I do not find arrogance a quality of diplomacy.
photo
Djay0252
America needs to Bless God
10:24 AM on 02/16/2012
There is NO last word in diplomacy. Israel will not force us into another war. Let them fight their own wars.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Mighty Cynic
11:34 AM on 02/16/2012
Why aren't there more GENUINE (and by that I mean Americans who do what EVERY OTHER COUNTRY naturally does: put their interests above foreign countries) Americans voicing up about this? Dual Citizenship should be outlawed, period. What kind of revolving door are we really?
photo
roy brophy
Dyslexic F. O. "Sorry!"
09:49 AM on 02/16/2012
Keith is my Congressman and I'm really proud of him. I'm going to send him an email thanking him right now!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Mighty Cynic
08:53 AM on 02/16/2012
GO Representative Keith Ellison
GO National Iranian American Council

You are our main anti-war hopes against Israel that has hijacked our country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
02:09 AM on 02/20/2012
"Israel that has hijacked our country. " ??
Really
The 65plus% of Americans who support Israel are all ... "hijacked" ? By who? A little country the size of New Jersey?

I think if you look a bit closer then your bias, you'll find much of the pressure is coming from the Gulf States - you know those guys who supply our energy ...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Mighty Cynic
07:47 AM on 02/20/2012
Uh huh, the countries that can't even produce a battery for themselves ok
08:26 AM on 02/16/2012
There was an illuminating conversation about Iran/Israel today on Democracy Now! with Reza Marashi, the Research Director at the National Iranian American Council, and Glenn Greenwald, a constitutional law attorney and political legal blogger. Check it out at democracynow.org
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Mighty Cynic
11:35 AM on 02/16/2012
I like Reza Marashi and Trita Parsi - both from the NIAC - they are spot on and know what they are talking about. The Israeli lobby has confined them to alternative media for that reason
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
02:12 AM on 02/20/2012
How has the "The Israeli lobby confined them to alternativ­e media" ? Somehow the Israeli lobby controls the media too? So far you've claimed "Israel that has hijacked our country." and now you claim "The Israeli lobby has confined them Reza Marashi and Trita Parsi) to alternativ­e media"

What DON'T these Jews control in your opinion?
Rexter
Question everything.
08:05 AM on 02/16/2012
War is the continuation of politics by other means and diplomatic pressures are the political prelude or precursors to war. It would seem we're well on our way to some sort of military conflict with Iran and indirectly, or by proxy, their Russian patrons.

The real beef is between Israel and Iran over who cares what. Why not let them work out their differences by whatever means they choose rather than the U.S. creating this nuclear boogeyman in Iran that our leaders are setting us up to deal with? Much like the WMD's in Iraq. Are the american people to stupid to see what is transpiring in front of them?

If Israel wants a scrap, let them have at it. Why are we christians always fighting their wars for them?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
02:19 AM on 02/20/2012
"Why are we christians always fighting their wars for them? "

And what wars might that be pray tell?

Perhaps Israel destroying the Iraqi nuclear reactor thus potentially saving hundreds of thousands of lives during Gulf War 1 or maybe you're thinking of Israel destroying the Syrian reactor. Just imagine if Syria had nukes now.

Those claims are as ridiculous as your claim that "The real beef is between Israel and Iran over who cares what" Have you checked lately what the Gulf States, specifically Saudi Arabia is concerned about? SO concerned that they've stated if Iran gets a nuclear weapon they (the Saudis) will immediately purchase off the shelf their own nuke from Pakistan. You can believe soon after so will the Egyptians, Jordan and the rest of the middle east triggering a nuclear arms race in the most unstable region on the planet.

Your statement 'Why are we christians always fighting their wars for them? " is both wrong and offensive
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ferdinand Berkhof
ratio & respect
03:48 AM on 02/16/2012
America doesn't want another war. Iran definitely does not want a war. The only ones who can mess this up are the Israeli's.
12:33 PM on 02/18/2012
The proud words of Iran's genocidal leaders would tell quite a different story I'm afraid.

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2012/02/11/1063967/-Snipped-view-of-Islamic-Fascist-Republic-of-Iran-global-crimes-against-humanity-threatening-world#iran/cite_note-27
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
02:22 AM on 02/20/2012
F&F
Thanks for this
03:10 AM on 02/16/2012
A nice documentary to show why we fight.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xm1B7x5JZfE
mymy1
Freedom is not free
02:57 AM on 02/16/2012
I'm afraid the US under pressure from Isarel has made the situation so that Iran can't say yes even if they wanted to. They have made it impossible for Iran to agree to anything but complete capitulation. The current approach does not leave any room for diplomacy. Now they pro-war necons are preparing the people by talking war and how there is no other alternative. This war, if it happens, will be one of the worst in recent memory. It will be devestating for Iran and will be very dmaging to US also. Keith, hopfully people will listen to you before it is too late.
12:35 PM on 02/18/2012
When a nation is threatening to eliminate another nation, and they are trying to get the tools necessary to actually carry out that threat, nothing short of complete capitulation from genocidal aims does anyone any good, LEAST of all the Iranian people.
photo
hiker326
Welcome to the island of Misfit Toys.
01:22 PM on 02/18/2012
This was the only post I could find to respond to. You do realize I'm going along with your way of thinking, right? Because I just got two heated emails about everything I agree with.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ttsgw
Atheist and secular humanist
01:42 AM on 02/16/2012
If America renewed their friendship with the talibans, why not become friends wit Iran? Their ideas about politics and religion are almost the same.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Mighty Cynic
11:41 AM on 02/16/2012
that's not true at all, Iran helped the US successfully invade Afghanistan against the Taliban before being slapped in the face with an 180 turn of listing Iran on the Axis of Evil list (David Frum added Iran to the group on Bush's State of the Union - Frum is a dual national of..GUESS WHAT COUNTRY).

But you are right about the diplomatic jest. What's good for the goose...