iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Scott Henson's Racial Profile Accusation Challenged: Austin Police Release Surveillance Video

HuffPost Crime   First Posted: 02/21/2012 7:45 pm Updated: 02/22/2012 10:00 am

Scott Henson Blogger
Scott Henson says police in Austin, Texas, cuffed him and detained him because he was walking with his black granddaughter Ty. But the chief of police says a surveillance video proves Henson is wrong about the allegations.

Austin police officials are disputing police blogger Scott Henson's claim that cops drew Tasers and roughly handcuffed him simply for walking home with his five-year-old granddaughter.

They have just released a surveillance video taken during the incident that supports their claim.

"He lied," Austin Police Chief Art Acevedo told the American Statesman, referring to Henson.

Earlier this month, Henson, who blogs about the criminal justice system at Grits For Breakfast, posted an entry detailing two recent encounters with the Austin police while walking home from a roller skating rink with his 5-year-old granddaughter Ty, who is African-American.

During the first encounter, a female deputy told him that there were reports of a white man kidnapping a black girl and he was ordered to step away from Ty as the officer questioned the girl.

After a few minutes of questioning, Henson and Ty were allowed to walk home. They were just two blocks away when they were stopped by five flashing police cars and a crowd of police.

Henson initially claimed the officers got out with Tasers drawn, demanding he raise his hands and step away from the child. Then, when he complied, he said the cops handled him roughly, jerking his arms as they cuffed him.

The allegations received international attention, but Acevedo says surveillance tape proves the allegations against his department are false. After seeing the tape, Henson conceded he was wrong about some details.

"It happened in a flash and like many eyewitnesses, when under a perceived threat, my mind filled in some pieces erroneously," Henson told Statesman.com in an email response.

Acevedo insists his officers acted according to procedure and points to a recording of a 911 call prior to the incident from a woman who called police saying she had seen a white man grab a black girl and chase her into nearby woods.

But while Henson concedes he got some details wrong about the incident initially, he said on his blog that no one has denied the basic facts of the incident.

"So, on the basis of one factual error which I readily owned after seeing the conflicting video, I am a liar, says the chief," he wrote.

Acevedo said he had to release the surveillance video, despite the pleas of Henson not to do so because a child was involved.

Although the girl's face isn't shown, Statesman.com reported that Acevedo denied Henson's request in an email, saying, "Scott, unfortunately, we can't put the toothpaste back into the tube. You called us out on our response and I am in a position that I must show those interested that our officers not only reacted properly, but in an outstanding manner."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CRIME

Austin police officials are disputing police blogger Scott Henson's claim that cops drew Tasers and roughly handcuffed him simply for walking home with his five-year-old granddaughter. They have ju...
Austin police officials are disputing police blogger Scott Henson's claim that cops drew Tasers and roughly handcuffed him simply for walking home with his five-year-old granddaughter. They have ju...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 294
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
03:54 AM on 09/06/2012
The kidnappers were the APD who cuffed him, placed him in the car, stole the girl from her grandfather and placed her in another car with a stranger. All this after having been cleared by the first officer. And when the cops rolled up after having already questioned them and letting them go there's no sign that the girl was trying to flee or fight off the old white man with whom she was ambling down the street. This is not a display of the cops protecting the public. It's a display of force mingled with sheer idiocy.
photo
White Raven
Eyeballs are tasty
01:56 AM on 02/27/2012
I like how this Henson jerk didn't want the video released because he obviously knew he was lying. Good on the Chief of Police for releasing it and proving Henson was a liar. I'm beyond fed up with people making up stories about how they're abused by police, because that makes it so much harder to discern when actual police abuse really occurs. We're always going to be wondering if the accuser is a liar, as he obviously was in this case.
12:54 PM on 02/27/2012
Except that Henson never alleged abuse or claimed that any procedures were violated. In fact, he repeatedly said in the comments on his blog that he had no intention of filing any complaint because he doesn't think they police did anything illegal. He also wasn't a liar. Mistaken about one point of fact, but that's hardly unusual for eyewitness reports (including police reports). I suspect you wouldn't require such a perfect recollection from a police officer writing a report.
photo
White Raven
Eyeballs are tasty
08:36 AM on 02/28/2012
Here's a quote from the story, that he claimed: "drew Tasers and roughly handcuffed him simply for walking home with his five-year-old granddaughter."

I suspect you wouldn't tolerate such fiction from a police officer writing a report.
09:22 AM on 02/25/2012
judge for yourself see
Full Raw Dashcam video
http://youtu.be/-7UhCYEmP48
12:46 PM on 02/27/2012
That's only four minutes, the full video is here:

http://www.statesman.com/news/local/police-release-video-of-officers-detaining-man-walking-2191187.html

I don't think it backs up an accusation that Henson was lying as it is fairly consistent with the account on his blog.

It also doesn't put the Police in a particularly bad light. While I may think the handcuffing was over the top and am of the opinion that the officer who is heard calling the Mom and then Grandma to verify the story straight out lied to them (claiming that they reacted strongly because Henson didn't cooperate with the constable, even though the police can be heard telling Henson that they had no communication with the constable prior to them handcuffing him); they were generally polite despite the fact that it was clear that every person they talked to (Henson, Henson's wife and the kid's mother) were quite upset that this had happened yet again. And once I was able to view a version that had audio, it was clear that they did clear things up in a reasonably quick manner. Something Henson couldn't have known since this occurred where he couldn't see it.

All in all, it looks like a mountain out of a molehill, on both sides.
11:20 AM on 02/29/2012
looks pretty reasonably handled...not sure what you could have done different.
10:42 AM on 02/24/2012
So what video are these commenter watching? The video largely corroborates Henson's version of events. Several cars pull up and officers swarm out. While the tasers were not drawn the officer does have his hand on his sidearm. (some "lie") He complies with the police, and they handcuff him for no good reason. (whether it's rough is a judgement call) Then another officer grabs his granddaughter and carries her to a car while shes crying "He's my Grandpa!". The video clearly shows a gaggle of officers who then proceed to just hang around in the background. None of them appear to be attempting to check his story. He sits there handcuffed for 15 minutes while his terrified granddaughter is in the car.

Seriously, why was he handcuffed? Why did it take so long to check out his story? How long did they wait before even attempting to check his story? The only thing wrong with Henson's account is that he misremembered the Taser. (Its fairly standard for eyewitnesses to get facts wrong, memories are quite imperfect) The rest of it is corroborated pretty darn well and does not show the police in a good light, IMHO.
photo
White Raven
Eyeballs are tasty
02:04 AM on 02/27/2012
He was handcuffed because he was suspected of possibly being a kidnapper. Those officers didn't know he wasn't armed, wasn't violent. All they had was a report that some white man may have kidnapped a black girl, and they came to sort that situation out.

They drew no weapon but were reasonably ready to. They cuffed the man without roughing him up, keeping him on his feet instead of forcing him to the ground (which was also an option).

The video did everything to discredit this guy's fallacious story. Let him have actually been a kidnapper and then the story would be "Police look the other way while black girl abducted by white man."
11:33 AM on 02/29/2012
I have had a similar situation happen in which me and my friend were mistaken for armed robbery suspects and it was very similar in the quick swarming and immediate handcuffing. I wasn't mad at anybody it was completely reasonable for them to hand cough and not take my word right off the bat. The all they knew were two guys about our height and description had just robbed a store. There were able to figure out it wasn't us within about a half hour. We were let go shook hands went about are day. Was it inconvenient and some what annoying? Yes of course but i was handled the same way he was and there is nothing wrong with that.

They were acting on the assumption that he was a kidnapper like raven said they had no idea whether this man was violent, armed or about to run. The only reason anybody calls it excessive is because he turned out to be innocent. 15 minutes seems pretty quick to verify that they are talking to the child's parents and verify that she is her grandson. Everything isn't instantaneous as people seem to think now a days since they are so used to the internet.

How do you think they should have done this better?
ewwthatsnasty
My micro-bio is as empty as your head.
09:39 AM on 02/23/2012
Forget about driving while black. now it's babysitting while white
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tracee Collins
APATHY = COMPLICITY
08:42 PM on 02/22/2012
OKAY, so is anybody ELSE wondering what happened with the supposed report of a white man grabbing a black girl and taking her into the woods? Was it even true? I mean, did the CALL even happen, and IF it did, did the cops--ANY cops--check it out?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djtejas
10:46 AM on 02/23/2012
If you had watched the video above, you would have heard the 911 call.
Also the call was about a "possible" kidnapping when a woman saw a man chasing a little girl from the recreation center at 7:45pm.
At that time Scott Henson says in his blog he was trotting along behind his "grandaughter" because she was running ahead of him.
So...what does that sound like?
11:47 PM on 02/23/2012
There was another white grandpa that got away through the woods while they were busy with that guy. An the real twist is he called the police.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:35 PM on 02/22/2012
This is where I get to say "I told you so." Henson's version of events reeked of BS from word one. And after spinning a meniacal yarn about the Austin PD he has the nerve to ask them not to release the footage? He's clearly a man of questionable character.
photo
Karissa36
Saving lost boys and fighting pirates.
09:46 PM on 02/22/2012
Yes, but no matter how untrue and one-sided, his story jumped to urban legend status. Why? People want to believe it. It confirms their belief that there is some vast racist conspiracy in the U.S.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djtejas
11:04 PM on 02/22/2012
People today will believe emails and blogs over actual truth shown in video or in audio...people are dumbing down.
I fear we will be just like the movie Idiocracy one day...
02:29 PM on 02/22/2012
Not everyone who gets detained gets mad, some people use common sense and realize that their actions, no matter how innocent, may not appear so from an observer. I was detained one day, as I was leaving my house by a police officer who, from a distance, saw a women lingering around the backside of a house. As I was pulling out of my driveway, the officer pulled in and blocked my way. Asked to see my identification and wanted to know what I was doing. I gave him my ID, which did not have the correct address because I had just moved there, and explained what I was doing. He called it in, recorded my information and talked to me for a bit. Not only did I not complain but I thanked him and commented on how impressed I was he was able to see me at the back of my house. I was happy and felt much safer knowing that had this actually been a burglary, it would have been prevented.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djtejas
03:53 PM on 02/22/2012
Very good comments...I've been through the same before and was not mad about the situation either.
01:54 PM on 02/22/2012
Just so it doesn't get lost in the "chatter", I would like to commend the woman who made the 911 call. True, it wasn't the situation she thought it was, but she didn't know that. She did the RIGHT thing.

So, to that woman, thanks for being a good citizen and caring about the child's welfare. This incident had a good outcome (no thanks to the man involved; he did everything he could to make the situation unpleasant).

I have been involved in incidents where a people didn't call because they didn't want to "bother the police" or they thought what they were watching wasn't "that important". In some of those incidents, it turned out it was important and the police needed to be there (but weren't, because they didn't get called).
01:06 PM on 02/22/2012
So did they ever find this mysterious white man who chased a little black girl into the woods???? Or did it turn out that the 911 call was completely bogus?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djtejas
03:59 PM on 02/22/2012
Do some research and find out from the info that is available...or read through comments that have been posted. All the info you need is out there if you just look for it instead of asking silly questions.
04:54 PM on 02/22/2012
Whoa! Who the hell do you think you are? You need to be slapped.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:37 PM on 02/22/2012
The call may very well have been a racist hoax. It doesn't change anything. The police still had to do their DD and investigate. Henson is still a liar.
01:04 PM on 02/22/2012
So it appears Henson lied about "tasers" being drawn...the most I can see if that the first officer there had his HAND on what could've been a taser...as well as being roughed up by cops...

I still am willing to bet that this whole nonsense could've been avoided had the officers simply said: "your story checks out, have a safe walk home and sorry for the inconvenience". If we are EXPECTED to be courteous to cops, why can't we expect the same thing from them?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djtejas
04:01 PM on 02/22/2012
You do realize Henson was not courteous to the first officer, right?

It seems odd that you saw him being him being roughed up...the rest of us didn't see that part.
04:12 PM on 02/22/2012
Oh, you again...

"So it appears Henson lied about "tasers" being drawn...the most I can see if that the first officer there had his HAND on what could've been a taser...as well as being roughed up by cops..."

If you had trouble understanding what I meant, all you had to do was ASK, rather than ASSUME.

I was stating that it appears Henson LIED about the tasers AS WELL AS being "roughed up" by the cops...clearly he wasn't.

But hey, thanks for the TWO useless responses!
11:52 PM on 02/23/2012
He wasn't courteous because he did nothing wrong and is tired of the police bothering him. I mean just get it.
11:49 AM on 02/22/2012
I am completely behind the police on this incident. If a child is potentially being abducted, I say go in assuming the worst. Whatever the situation, it can be cleared up quickly. If that was my grandchild, I would be thrilled that anyone even noticed! Cops doing the absolute right thing here!
11:39 AM on 02/22/2012
Scott Henson doesn't only owe the Austin Police department an apology he should also thank them because he saw first hand how they would respond if his granddaughter really was being kidnapped…..If he had a need to cause turmoil by using the racial card, he might have done better by pointing out that they didn't tackle him to the ground and that they didn't have their tasers drawn even though they thought he was kidnapping a child
11:37 AM on 02/22/2012
they were right to stop and ? him,for the little girls safety,but once the first officer ? the little girl and everything cked out that should have been the end of the story,police officers cant win a situation like this,if they had done nothing and something bad was happening they would have been crucified because they let it go,no win situation for them,but for him to twist the story is just ridiculous,his 15 seconds of fame r over as far as i am concerned,cudo's to the police chief and his officers,for a job well done
11:32 AM on 02/22/2012
the cops are no angels im sure. but who else is there ?

damned if you stop a white man with a black child and damned if its a black man with a white child..

so quickly now. everyone have a mixed race child so we can stop this jealously among the races of whom has the advantage. lets go zebra.