iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Greek Bailout Could Easily Go Off The Rails, Confidential Study Shows

Posted: 02/21/12 07:27 AM ET  |  Updated: 02/21/12 05:17 PM ET


* Debt/GDP could rebound to 160 pct in 2020 if reform delayed

* Experts say austerity imperative clashes with boosting growth

* Political resistance, bureaucratic inertia threaten programme

* Risks seen "mostly on downside"

By Jan Strupczewski

BRUSSELS, Feb 21 (Reuters) - Greece's second bailout programme could easily go off the rails and send the nation's debt rocketing back to today's unmanageable levels, a confidential study by its international lenders shows.

The 9-page debt sustainability analysis, on which euro zone finance ministers based their decision on Tuesday to approve a 130-billion-euro rescue programme, is anything but a vote of confidence in Athens' ability to put its public finances back on a sound footing.

Indeed the report, dated Feb. 15 and first obtained by Reuters on Monday, describes in the disembodied prose of economic bureaucrats how uncertain Greece's recovery will remain for many years, and how Athens will likely need international aid for an indefinite period.

Experts from the European Commission, the European Central Bank and the International Monetary Fund highlighted the risks and questioned the assumption that Greece will be able to return to capital markets in the coming years.

"There is a fundamental tension between the programme objectives of reducing debt and improving competitiveness, in that the internal devaluation needed to restore Greece's competitiveness will inevitably lead to a higher debt to GDP ratio in the near term," the analysis said.

"Given the risks, the Greek programme may thus remain accident-prone, with questions about sustainability hanging over it."

The authors voiced particular concern that continued delays in unpopular structural economic reforms and privatisations could further deepen a recession now in its fifth year.

"This would result in a much higher debt trajectory, leaving debt as high as 160 percent of GDP in 2020." That is roughly the current level, before an agreed writedown of about 53.5 percent of the face value of bonds held by private investors, which with other measures is due to cut the debt to 120.5 percent in 2020.

Euro zone finance ministers cut the interest rate on official loans to Greece, forced private bondholders to accept deeper losses and agreed to harness European Central Bank profits on Greek bonds to make the numbers add up.

But the analysis cautioned that Greece may veer off the central scenario on which those figures are based if it is unable to implement all the necessary changes quickly enough.

"The Greek authorities may not be able to deliver structural reforms and policy adjustments at the pace envisioned in the baseline," it said.

"The debt trajectory is extremely sensitive to programme delays, suggesting that the programme could be accident prone, and calling into question sustainability," it said.



RISKS "MOSTLY ON DOWNSIDE"

In a blandly understated summary of the political risks to the programme, the experts note that "economic agents" (workers) may resist wage cuts and flexibility, "strong vested interests" may continue to resist opening up closed professions and liberalising product markets, and bureaucracy may continue to shackle business reforms.

Low market prices, legal obstacles and political resistance may continue to delay the sale of state assets which has barely begun almost two years after it was first promised.

Much of the report focused on ways to find a few billion euros in further debt reductions to get the headline number down to 120 percent of GDP - the level set by European leaders last October and regarded by the IMF as sustainable.

However, the most alarming parts concerned the danger of a bailed-out Greece continuing to fall behind on its targets.

The report warns that the balance of risks is to the downside -- if Greek primary balance does not rise above 2.5 percent of GDP, from -1 percent in 2012, debt would be on an ever increasing trajectory.

If revenues from privatisation are only 10 billion euros rather than 46 billion by 2020, Greek debt would be 148 percent of GDP in eight years.

If Greek economic growth is permanently higher than 1 percent a year, debt would fall to 116 percent of GDP by 2020, but if it is permanently lower, debt would rise to 143 percent.

Because Greece will be financing itself mainly through the EFSF, a rise in the borrowing costs for the fund of 100 basis points would mean Greek debt at 135 percent in 2020.

FOLLOW BUSINESS

* Debt/GDP could rebound to 160 pct in 2020 if reform delayed * Experts say austerity imperative clashes with boosting growth * Political resistance, bureaucratic inert...
* Debt/GDP could rebound to 160 pct in 2020 if reform delayed * Experts say austerity imperative clashes with boosting growth * Political resistance, bureaucratic inert...
Filed by Maxwell Strachan  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 3,132
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (46 total)
08:42 PM on 02/23/2012
Privatisation is another kind of demand-dampening austerity. The people will pay inflated prices for services and this will mean they have less to spend. The demand here is dampened by siphoning profits over to foreigners. It's terrible for competitiveness.
08:00 PM on 02/22/2012
Pretty much sums it up.

http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2012/02/hugh-hendry-of-eclectica-discusses.html

I as I have said and repeated Eventually, Will Come a Time When ....

Eventually, there will come a time when a populist office-seeker will stand before the voters, hold up a copy of the EU treaty and (Correctly) Declare all the "BAIL OUT" DEBT FOISTED ON THEIR COUNTRY to be NULL AND VOID. That person will be ELECTED.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:05 PM on 02/22/2012
Does anyone know if big American banks, including Citibank and Chase, own big positions betting that Greece will not fail by the end of 2012?

I have heard -- do not know if it is true -- that American banks bet billions that Greece would not default, be unable to repay, whatever... If Greece does, American banks stand to lose huge amounts of money.

Therefore, the Fed is effectively guaranteeing Greece's payments with U.S. tax dollars until the contracts owned by the Americans expire later this year. One of the reasons Geitner has been in Europe is to reassure governments and Eurobanks that the Fed will lend them whatever they need at near-zero interest if they just let Greece slide until the American contracts expire.

Anyone heard this one?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tony Moschetti
12:08 PM on 02/22/2012
"Greek Bailout Could Easily Go Off The Rails, Confidential Study Shows"

It took a "confidential" study for the liberals to figure that out? I predicted this, on this site, just a day ot two ago!
04:19 PM on 02/22/2012
What do "liberals" have to do with this? Actually, the problem here is that Conservatives cannot understand that (1) the problem in Greece has been non-payment of Taxes; ie. reduced revenues and (2) that austerity will not generate growth required for the economic health that will dig them out of their current situation.

Liberals get it.
11:48 AM on 02/22/2012
Greece is not the issue here. The issue is that Europe as a whole is broke, facing massive unfunded liabilities, and running out of viable creditors to band-aid its banking crisis. We are literally talking about a banking system collapse over there.

In plain terms, what’s coming to Europe (and then the US due to the interconnected nature of the financial system) is going to make 2008 look like a picnic.

This might take longer than people expect but Europe as a concept is trully finished,
08:45 PM on 02/23/2012
The problem in Europe is the lack of a lender of last resort. As long as they don't have one default is possible and investors become 100% essential and can demand higher interest rates if they see too much risk. As the US, Canada and Japan can print money at their leisure and their central banks can buy bonds if investors won't all investors know that the bonds are 100% safe so interest rates are set by the banks and investors accept them as they know it's 100% safe. The EU's problem is a right wing ideology that claims that a lender of last resort is bad for "discipline" and is based in part on Germany's obsession with 1924 when the most important year was really 1931.
11:46 AM on 02/22/2012
Bailouts are temporary band-aids - kind of like the stimulus packages - cash for clunkers - solyn drya ? Vote this man out for heaven's sake. He is not good for our country - if he wants socialism - look for a small country and go there.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oldent
How dare you question a liberal!!!
11:32 AM on 02/22/2012
John F Kennedy self declared liberal." Ask not for your your country can do for you but what you can do for your counrty." Too many people never got that message.
11:47 AM on 02/22/2012
That is exactly opposite of the democrats agenda!
04:23 PM on 02/22/2012
No, that is the Democrat's agenda. It is not,however, the agenda of the Right -- led by folks like Mitt Romeny -- who agitate for the next big, costly War ( which will line their pockets) while they take their assets (and their sons) and offshore them so that they do not have to support their nation.
11:18 AM on 02/22/2012
Its common sense. If ones elected Government officials can't do the job they were placed in office to do.
Its time for the people/voters to remove these individuals from their position. PERIOD.

Individuals in Government positions seem to fail to realize or perhaps forget.. They are in fact employees of, and work for the people who elected them into office in the first place.
11:31 AM on 02/22/2012
The problem with government is, there is to many damn politicians in it!
11:17 AM on 02/22/2012
Getting the populace focused on poor pitiful Greece and its woes is one way the lib med ia has of not reporting on gas prices - food prices - the national debt - the constitutional issues - and the unemployment numbers (which are not being accurately reported) Remember whe o's czar said that they wanted to see gasoline prices go the the European prices? Are we there yet - and green energy though it looks good on paper is just not quite ready. The chevy Volt. a joke.
04:31 PM on 02/22/2012
Oh Malarky. UE numbers are being reported the Same Way they were being reported for Bush & Reagan...they same way they were being reported when you "Patriots" were celebrating how Terrible they were. Now that they've improved...they are "not being accurately reported". Except INDUSTRY reports them. As a business owner, I get a survey every month.

And I suggest you try a fuel efficient car -- America's # 1 export in 2011 was OIL. So you can drill baby drill all you want. If the GOP wants to subsidize an industry that is exporting our oil and call that free enterprise, your gas is NEVER gonna be cheap.
05:42 PM on 02/22/2012
I would like proof that the Us's biggest export was oil? Maybe gasoline?
11:12 AM on 02/22/2012
When you continue to get something for nothing - you inevitably run out of the something - TAke heed libs and those who want continued government handouts -- freebies --- whatever.
11:04 AM on 02/22/2012
The Greek people had their hand out - more government freebies - more money for less and less work - great retirement (early) packages - Something for nothing - it has consequences as sadly - the US will soon see.
08:46 PM on 02/23/2012
Greeks work more than Germans do.
10:53 AM on 02/22/2012
Why enable Greece any longer, haven't they been drunk on debt long enough?
08:47 PM on 02/23/2012
No they haven't. Their debt problems are 100% caused by the financial crisis and its aftermath that included a run on Greece resulting only from the EU's lack of a lender of last resort because of some right wing dogma that influenced the setting up of the EU's monetary system.
09:55 AM on 02/24/2012
They spent more than they take in, and they have been doing that for 2500 years.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nattxn
10:45 AM on 02/22/2012
It can and will happen here if the Republicans have their way on saying no everything.
10:50 AM on 02/22/2012
Newsflash - the Republicans arenot the ones saying NO -- read and learn little lib er al.
If anything they are trying to protect yours and the rights of your progeny. Read up a little. Think about a 16 trillion dollar debt ... How does that grab you????
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nattxn
12:30 PM on 02/22/2012
New flash--- The republicans 98% of them promised Norquist (even signed a pledge) to not raise taxes on millionaires and are holding to this pledge to a lobbiest instad of what most of their constituents want.
10:51 AM on 02/22/2012
You have it backwards, It will happen because democrats say yes to everything!
10:58 AM on 02/22/2012
LRN - Oh My - YOu are so FANNED AND FAVED thank you well said. Keep telling the truth.
10:37 AM on 02/22/2012
The EU and the euro were very bad ideas from the start,anyone could have seen this coming.
10:10 AM on 02/22/2012
Lets see... you have a country that has zero ability or intent to pay back the billions already "loaned" to them... you have a majority of the population of the country who have no work ethic, take no personal responsibility and demand everything be given to them.... and you have a socialist mentality rampant in Europe - (and unfortunately being promoted in the USA by lunatics like the bloggers on the huff and puff post and the pretender in the oval office) that EXPECTS others to pay for whatever they want, whenever they want. The gimme gimme gimme brigade has ruined Greece... they are well on the way in Italy and have established a beach head in the USA.... now why was a "study" needed to determine the latest gift to Greece will be a failure?????
10:14 AM on 02/22/2012
Headed to our country - thanks to a government that wants a subdued needy people.
photo
jrb359
Big government is not your friend
12:49 PM on 02/22/2012
Worse part is, the politicians tell folks what they want to hear, get voted in, then do NOTHING to help anyone but themselves.
08:50 PM on 02/23/2012
No it hasn't. Greece's debt to GDP ratio was way under 100% (British Empire was as high as 250%) but then a recession caused by the global financial crisis pushed it up a bit and because there's no lender of last resort in the EU, there was a run on Greece. This was used to force through "internal devaluation" on Greece that shrank its GDP by 25% so now its debt to GDP ratio is higher than ever, passing 160%. It was about 90% in 2009.