More

HuffPost Social Reading

Apple Cash: CEO Tim Cook Says Company Has More Than It Needs

Apple Cash

By MICHAEL LIEDTKE   02/23/12 07:50 PM ET  AP

CUPERTINO, Calif. -- Apple CEO Tim Cook says he believes the world's most valuable company has more money than it needs. His next challenge is to figure out whether Apple should break from the cash-hoarding ways of his predecessor, the late Steve Jobs, and dip into its $98 billion bank account to pay shareholders a dividend this year.

During a question-and-answer session Thursday at the company's annual shareholders' meeting, Cook indicated he and the rest of Apple's board are nearing a decision.

The board and management are "thinking about this very deeply," Cook said. "This isn't a case where 100 percent of people are going to agree with what we do."

The question of how to handle Apple's cash stockpile is a touchy one, partly because company co-founder Jobs had steadfastly brushed aside suggestions that the company restore its quarterly dividend. Apple stopped making the shareholder payments in 1995 when it was in such deep trouble that it needed to hold on to every cent.

Things got so bad that Apple turned to rival Microsoft Corp. in 1997 for a $150 million infusion to stay afloat. Microsoft came to the rescue at the same time Apple named Jobs as its CEO – a decision that turned out to be one of the smartest business moves ever made.

Haunted by memories of Apple's grim times, Jobs kept accumulating cash even as the company's fortunes soared during the final decade of his life.

Cook, though, appears willing to return some of the cash to shareholders since he succeeded Jobs as Apple's CEO last August. Jobs died Oct. 5 after a long battle with cancer.

During Thursday's meeting, Cook dropped his strongest hint yet that Apple will part with some of the money. "Frankly speaking," Cook said, "it's more than we need to run the company."

One Apple shareholder, Asif Khan of Sugar Land, Texas, urged Cook to resist committing to a dividend every three months. He said he thinks it makes more sense for Apple to pay a one-time dividend later this year before the expiration of a provision that limits the federal tax rate on dividends to 15 percent.

If Apple opts for a regular quarterly dividend, Khan is worried it might be misinterpreted by some investors as a sign that Apple is losing confidence in its ability to keep propelling its stock price higher as the company churns out hit products such as the iPhone and iPad.

During the past year, Apple's stock has surged 50 percent to create about $160 billion in shareholder wealth. Apple now has a market value of $480 billion – more than the combined value of Microsoft and prominent rival Google Inc.

Apple shares gained $3.35 Thursday to close at $516.39. The high price sparked a question Thursday about whether Apple plans to split its stock to make it more affordable to buy. Cook indicated it's unlikely to occur, saying the board has studied the history of other companies that regularly split their stock and concluded "it does nothing" for long-term returns. Apple last split its stock seven years ago. The shares have increased 11-fold since then.

Although most of those gains occurred under Jobs' leadership, Apple's stock and financial results have remained stellar under Cook, Job's hand-picked successor. Cook has worked as a top Apple executive since 1998.

Given how well Apple has been doing, shareholders had little reason to complain at Thursday's hour-long meeting.

While shareholders waited in a 40-minute line to get inside the meeting at Apple's Cupertino headquarters, a few protesters carried signs urging the company to ensure that workers building its products in Taiwanese and Chinese factories are paid more and treated humanely. "Stop iSweatshop," one sign implored. Another stated: `iWant an ethical phone." No questions about the conditions in Apple's overseas factories were posed during the meeting.

In other matters, Apple agreed to adopt a proposal from the public pension fund Calpers that will require all of the company's directors to receive a majority of shareholder votes to remain on the board. The proposal was backed by more than 80 percent of the shareholder votes counted in the preliminary results announced by Apple Thursday.

All eight of Apple's current directors were re-elected with at least 81 percent of the shareholder votes in the preliminary results, so the switch to majority-voting rules wouldn't have changed this year's outcome if the new rules had already been in effect.

Also on HuffPost:

Apple first revealed it had amassed almost $98 billion in cash at its most recent earnings call, back in January. Until Tim Cook announces how the company will spend that money, we've got a few fun suggestions (below).
FOLLOW HUFFPOST TECH

CUPERTINO, Calif. -- Apple CEO Tim Cook says he believes the world's most valuable company has more money than it needs. His next challenge is to figure out whether Apple should break from the cash-ho...
CUPERTINO, Calif. -- Apple CEO Tim Cook says he believes the world's most valuable company has more money than it needs. His next challenge is to figure out whether Apple should break from the cash-ho...
Filed by Catharine Smith  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 236
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
01:10 PM on 02/26/2012
Hey I know, bring the work that has been sent overseas back to North America, pay decent wages so more people can afford to purchase the products being produced.

Oh wait, that would mean no hoarding of money, no redistribution of wealth from society into the hands of the upper 1%, no unsustainable exorbitant executive bonuses, no wait bad idea that would suck. (Sarcasm)

Apple is and has been a poster child for outsourcing American jobs in the name of unsustainable executive bonuses for years.

The poor, working poor, working and middle class have lousy lobbyists, unlike the wealthy who have the best that money can buy.
photo
Yank in France
Thomas Paine, expat in France 1792-1802
11:06 AM on 02/26/2012
Some four years ago, I regretted not having bought Apple at $76 per share because the experts all assured us that share price had risen too much.

A year or so ago, I regretted not buying Apple at $270 per share because the experts ALL assured us that the time had come to take profits (Sell).

Today, I regret not buying Apple before it hit over $500 per share and most of the experts again assure us that this price run has gone on just too long.

But Apple's Price/earnings 2012 ratio is still below 10x which compares to over 17x for the tech industry as a whole. And yet, Apple's comprehensive quality (from software to hardware) and selective product approach (no need to dominate an entire market a la Microsoft or Samsung) seems to be working better than any business plan in modern American economic history!

Honestly, folks, if I had any money, I would at least buy some call options with put options as insurance. If the iPad tablets really penetrate the scholastic sector, we will NOT be talking about the end of a long winning streak but a whole new ballgame.

And that's leaving aside the enormous potential of the Chinese market!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mochaview
Big Money Talks Too Much...OCCUPY!
04:34 AM on 02/26/2012
Okay Tim Cook, if you have too much cash there I can help you with this because I have NO cash so whenever you feel to give some away I'll gladly line up for it. Just tell me where, let's see at the Grand Central store or the one on Fifth avenue? As I've been unemployed and looking for three long years I can't afford your computers just yet but with cash, well, hey, anything is on the table although I'm not really into the whole slave labor thing making expensive equipment. However, as I'm in need with Con ed and National Grid breathing down my neck I'd greatly appreciate a few bucks. A few bucks for you means a million or two. I'd prefer that in cash since I'd prefer not to tango with the IRS. Please pack in a ratty old green canvas bag so muggers won't care about it. Nothing fancy. Thanks for your generosity and a hearty thanks is sent from all my bill collectors.
12:35 AM on 02/26/2012
How about giving a few billion to charity? World hunger's still a problem.
07:23 PM on 02/27/2012
Yes, and it will only get worse for these countries, as world population increases even further, this tiny planet Earth is struggling to cope with the millions world wide who don't have enough food to live on due to climate change, as once lush fertile plains are turned into deserts and world recourses are being depleted at an alarming rate, even here in London England we have experienced the affects of clmate change, last year we had heatwaves in spring and autumn, and now parts of the country are under drought warnings, as we desperatley need rain, our reservoirs are only half full and our rivers are running dry, we need rain soon, the sad thing is we are powerless, as we rely on nature.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rotorhead1871
who are you jivin' with that cosmic debris?...
12:34 AM on 02/26/2012
sounds like a good time for a special dividend......
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
llibsetag
10:09 PM on 02/25/2012
“Mr. Cook: Apple should dramatically increase the discounts for education & business for purchasing Apple hardware & software as this would continue Apple's commitment with education since day one of Apple plus stimulate businesses to buy more hardware & software for small / SOHO / large businesses while strengthening Apple's penetration into corporate sector with iPhone + iPad iOS based devices.
06:01 PM on 02/25/2012
Have you seen the Apple board and executive suite? All wealthy white men (with one exception) with absolutely no desire to share the wealthy. They have no empathy for those individuals who work for them or who stand in line to buy their products. I for one will not be standing in line to buy any more Apple products until they share that enormous wealth. If the question were a raise for those executives or board members, there would be no such hesitation.
10:14 AM on 02/26/2012
Define what you mean by "share that enormous wealth"
Specifically what would you like to see them do?
photo
Yank in France
Thomas Paine, expat in France 1792-1802
11:16 AM on 02/26/2012
Yb, no business in the world has as its purpose to "share the wealth", and Apple is no different. They do however do a very good job at inventing, designing and producing software and hardware that help people in their everyday lives.

As for the social aspects, it is up to people like you and I to think of solutions that protect jobs in America or, at least, improve the quality of jobs abroad. Unfortunately, some very naive people have been caught up in anti-Apple campaign operating under the guise of humanity. Foxconn workers are there because they want to be and because working conditions, when accounting for salary, are better than in plants operating for Chinese manufacturers!

So instead of complaining about an individual company, THINK GLOBAL and THINK POLITICAL, because the very legitimate issues you raise are political not company issues! -:)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sanders McGrillin
12:55 PM on 02/25/2012
Maybe since STEVE JOBS DIED FROM CANCER, and he didn't want to donate to find a cure.
They could give some of that $$$$ To advance more research on cancer
oh wait... I forgot.... Apple is super anti-charity & anti-donations
what a sh*tty company
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
llibsetag
10:11 PM on 02/25/2012
Steve donated personally his time & money to the CA Organ Transplant drive with Gov. Arnold + Maria after his liver transplant surgery.
01:36 PM on 02/28/2012
And he got to be the first in line. Money talks!
photo
Yank in France
Thomas Paine, expat in France 1792-1802
11:20 AM on 02/26/2012
Steve Jobs did not donate much to charity, although Sonny Bono has praised his enormous work on behalf of AIDS victims in Africa.

But whether Steve Jobs gave to charity should not be the issues, since corporations only give to charity to boost their corporate image, and we are talking chickenfeed in the global scheme of things!

That said, no one can stop you from buying such "charitable" manufacturers, such as Chinese firms Lenovo or HTC...
11:40 AM on 02/25/2012
Everyone's complaining about them having all that money and not bring jobs or giving it to others..Well obviously, like most companies they love their money. As long has they are rich why does anyone else matter? Everyone for themselves..sucks, but it's life:(
11:24 AM on 02/25/2012
Why dont they use some of this money to pay for a college education for all the 8 year old Chinese slaves who actually make their products?
photo
Yank in France
Thomas Paine, expat in France 1792-1802
11:23 AM on 02/26/2012
I didn't know they had 8-year-olds working for them at Foxconn! But, regardless, are you just mad at the labor conditions at plants used by American companies? 

Doesn't anyone find it curious that this whole labor campaign is focused on one single American company, and not the thousands of Chinese manufacturers who have eaten the heart out of America's industrial base?!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JoeAnomie
11:00 AM on 02/25/2012
Its wrong that Apple wont bring back jobs to the country that made it so wealthy and protects its interests overseas.
11:04 PM on 02/24/2012
It would be nice if they invested in some US manufacturing of the products they sell in the US.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JoeAnomie
10:58 AM on 02/25/2012
Funny how that doesn't seem to come up, even with all that cash.
11:03 PM on 02/24/2012
Apple should buy Comcast then they would have all the content they need for the IPAD and the Apple TV.
09:16 PM on 02/24/2012
To Apple CEO Tim Cook:
To "ease" the load consider and send 1B or whatever to Saint Jude Children Research Hospital in TN. for their cancer research program and treatment of children with cancer. A child not having medical insurance for treatment is no problem at that hospital. Would'nt it be nice if the kids had those billion apples to help them and for the research?