More

HuffPost Social Reading

Costa Allegra Fire: Cruise Ship Arrives In Seychelles (PHOTOS)

JASON STRAZIUSO   03/ 1/12 04:37 PM ET  AP

VICTORIA, Seychelles — The worst moments for Gordon and Eleanor Bradwell came immediately after the alarm sounded. Eleanor rushed to their cabin to get a life vest. Gordon was pushed in another direction. The scent of smoke grew stronger aboard the disabled cruise ship. Then the lifeboats dropped.

The Athens, Ga., couple – married 50 years last June – couldn't find one another.

"Those were the worst moments," said Bradwell, a former alumni director at the University of Georgia.

The Costa Allegra docked in the Seychelles on Thursday, three days after a fire broke out in the ship's generator room, leaving passengers without working toilets, running water or air conditioning in a region of the Indian Ocean where pirates are known to prowl.

Cabin temperatures reached 100 to 110 degrees, forcing passengers to sleep on deck chairs.

"Things became very primitive," Bradwell said, a far cry from what the couple had expected when they embarked on the $8,000 multi-week cruise.

The blaze came just six weeks after another luxury liner, the Costa Concordia, capsized off Italy, leaving 32 people dead, a fact that was on many passengers' minds. Both ships were operated by Costa Crociere SpA, which is owned by Florida-based Carnival Corp.

When the ship's alarm sounded around 1 p.m. Monday, passengers knew it wasn't a drill. They had already had one, and knew that the short-short-long wail meant to prepare to disembark.

Passengers couldn't see the fire, but they could smell and see smoke. Crew members extinguished the blaze within an hour, but the alarmed continued to wail for two more hours.

Some passengers panicked, shouting out family members' names. It was two hours before the Bradwells were reunited.

Capt. Niccolo Alba told a news conference Thursday the emergency response went relatively smoothly.

The average age of the 627 passengers on board was 55, said Guillaume Albert, head of Creole Travel Service. Many of the older passengers in particular had trouble with the sweltering heat.

Back in Georgia, the Bradwell's daughter, Karen Bradwell Cobb, received two calls Monday from the cruise operator to update her on the ship's situation.

"Initially when I got the call it was very stressful and I teared up," she said. "But because my parents are such seasoned travelers I felt like they would be OK. The main concern for me and my brothers was the piracy issue."

The waters off East Africa are Somali pirate territory. The attacks crippled the Seychelles tourism industry after wary cruise companies stopped coming to the island paradise in 2009.

Cruises have since returned, and Costa Vice President Norbert Stiekema said Thursday that anti-piracy measures were in place on the Allegra, though he wouldn't detail what they were. A Seychelles official said earlier that armed guards were traveling on board.

Cobb said the cruise company called her with an update again on Tuesday. On Thursday, at around 2 a.m. Georgia time, she received a fourth call.

"Hey!" her father joyfully shouted into an Associated Press reporter's phone. "We wanted to let you know that everything is OK."

After the first hours of chaos, life settled down on the Allegra. But more bad news was to come. An emergency generator not involved in the fire failed, leaving the ship with only six hours of battery power.

That brought an end to any semblance of the good cruise life. There were no more hot meals, only cold sandwiches. The water used to extinguish the fire flooded the galley between the first and second decks. The toilets couldn't be flushed, blanketing the bathrooms in stench.

Cawan Finn summed up the bathroom situation using a British slang expression. "I haven't had a whoopsie for about four days now," the 65-year-old said.

Finn said it could have been worse. "We were just drifting. ... What if there had been a major storm?"

Tuesday and Wednesday brought little drama, said Thomas Faller, a 66-year-old Austrian doctor. "It was just boring," he said.

"The first moment I didn't believe it," Faller said of the initial alarm. "I had just started my lunch and I thought it wasn't real."

Stiekema, the Costa vice president, said the company had made the passengers an "extremely fair" compensation offer: A refund of the costs of the cruise, any related flights and any spending on board, plus an additional payment equal to the cost of the cruise and associated travel expenses.

Passengers were also given the chance to remain in the Seychelles for a free one- or two-week vacation, which the company said about 70 percent of guests had chosen to do. All passengers were to be flown home at company expense.

Guests not staying in the Seychelles were to be flown to Paris, Rome, Milan, Vienna and Zurich, arriving Friday morning. Those passengers will also receive a voucher equivalent to the value of the Allegra trip, to be used on any Costa ship in the next 24 months.

"Costa is sincerely sorry for the discomfort caused to its passengers, but happy to have found them in good conditions," a company statement said.

After the Concordia's accident, the company saw bookings fall by 35 percent. They had just started to rise and may now take another hit. The Bradwells, for instance, said they were looking forward to their next cruise – but that it won't be with Costa.

Three Italian investigators were in the Seychelles to probe the cause of the fire. Company officials have said there is no reason to suspect foul play.

The Allegra left northern Madagascar, off Africa's southeast coast, on Saturday, carrying 413 crew members and 627 passengers, including 212 Italians, 31 Britons and eight Americans.

Most were staying on in the Seychelles, a chain of white-sand resort islands with a population of just 87,000, and island officials were thrilled to have them.

"The fact we have a carnival on, the weather is great, and the fact they want to continue their holidays is great for them and great for us," said Srdjana Janosevic, spokeswoman for the Seychelles' president. "It means this potentially tragic situation has a happy ending."

The rescue – carried out by a French fishing vessel – was not without controversy. A Seychelles official told the AP the journey may have taken longer than necessary because the French vessel refused to give way to two faster Seychelles tugs. Although assistance to people at sea is free, assistance to ships is often paid.

During the slow ride into the Seychelles' main port, life on the cruise ship was mostly civil, Gordon Bradwell said, despite a few testy moments, "which you would expect because life was difficult."

He suggested that after resting a few days in the Seychelles, he and Eleanor may even form fond memories of their hardship cruise.

"I think if you were to interview any of these people, the foremost thought in their mind is, 'We're here, we're alive,'" Bradwell said. "If the fire had gotten out of control it could have been a disaster."

1  of  30
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
Costa Allegra cruise ship Captain Niccolo Alba wipes a tear during a news conference in Victoria, Seychelles, Thursday, March 1, 2012.

Hot and tired passengers disembarking from a disabled cruise ship Thursday in the Seychelles said they had prepared to abandon ship when fire broke out in the engine room three days ago, causing smoke to billow from the vessel that was suddenly adrift in waters prowled by pirates. (AP Photo/Gregorio Borgia)
FOLLOW HUFFPOST TRAVEL

VICTORIA, Seychelles — The worst moments for Gordon and Eleanor Bradwell came immediately after the alarm sounded. Eleanor rushed to their cabin to get a life vest. Gordon was pushed in another ...
VICTORIA, Seychelles — The worst moments for Gordon and Eleanor Bradwell came immediately after the alarm sounded. Eleanor rushed to their cabin to get a life vest. Gordon was pushed in another ...
Filed by Kate Auletta  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 248
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
02:10 PM on 03/06/2012
Victoria Seychells is a beautfull place.During my US Navy years, my ship ( USS Dupont,DD941 ,
Tin Can desteroyer about 400 feet long and 44 feet wide) pulled into this harbor in 1976. Several days on the island was a real treat. Staying in a upper room beach side hotel overlooking a giant life size chess board dwon below was a picture postcard. The water was like the carribean that you never got tired looking at.
These tourists have been given a diversion treat and have no need to complain. The ship did not burn up at sea and they did not have to float in a raft. Enjoy the vacation, be positive because its a once in a llifetime thrill.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Ludin
Child advocate
10:28 PM on 03/02/2012
I am going on a cruise in 6 weeks -- can't wait. I am even looking for the prices to go lower on Costa Cruises -- they are owned by Carnival -- a too big to fail cruise company -- think Seaborne, Windstar, Costa, Princess, Holland America, Cunard and maybe a couple more -- In the meantime I am cruising like a Norwegian to Barcelona!
04:38 PM on 03/02/2012
I believe the French fishing vessel has developed a new and profitable market - fishing for stranded Costa liners.
11:22 AM on 03/02/2012
Never did see anything appealing about being stuck in the middle of the ocean with a small town's worth of strangers. All these mishaps make it even more unappealing.

Glad they are all safe.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Denizio
05:29 AM on 03/02/2012
Alegra huh. Yeh, you need some after taking a cruise on that ship.
02:19 AM on 03/02/2012
You mean ANYONE is still booking cruises on Costa? Now THAT'S incredible!
01:56 AM on 03/02/2012
The dirty underbelly of the cruise industry has been exposed. Ill-trained third-world crews hired because they're willing to work like dogs for peanuts; incompetent engineering personell; inadequate, badly designed, and poorly maintained backup systems. One of these days, there is going to be a major disaster, and a thousand passengers are going to get killed. Remember, it was the obsolete safety standards that caused the deaths of half of Titanic's passengers. No one was killed by the iceberg.
07:52 AM on 03/02/2012
The emergency Generator that was in a different location failed ???? What is this? Is this going to be addressed - I hope in the investigation. Come on - there has got to be some very sloppy mantainance here. When was this generator tested the last time? Did it perform proplerly when it was tested (If it was). 2 ships in a row by the same company inside a few weeks? What does that tell us. In this lousy economic time I don't doubt it at all that High Priority saftey items are neglected. "Rear ends in the seats and Plan's in the Air" the Motto of the Air lines can sure be a similar slogan of the Cruise Lines.
12:47 AM on 03/02/2012
Perhaps the Costa brand will need to be mothballed for good. No one will want to cruise on a Costa ship for now on.
12:19 AM on 03/02/2012
I will absolutely be cruising in the very near future, and many times in the future, but I'm thinking that it is unlikely in the extreme that I will ever book a Costa cruise. I feel sorry for the crew, too, and the captain, in this case, deserves some pity as well.
01:57 AM on 03/02/2012
At least he stayed with his ship.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Denizio
11:56 PM on 03/01/2012
I'm surprised that these new ships don't have redundant systems to back up their main functions, such as sanitation, communications, electrical and navigation. How backward of them.
02:01 AM on 03/02/2012
They are in business to make money. So were the Titanic's owners, and the owners of the Triangle Shirtwaist Co. Keep that thought in mind the next time that some conservative tries to tell you that business is overregulated.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Denizio
04:06 AM on 03/02/2012
Having served in the Navy and being aboard ship I just know that there are many backup systems to keep a ship operational. I realize of course that I'm talking about war ships. But even the Titanic had back up systems and didn't lose power until she finally flooded and went down. I do know that (from personal experience) that Royal Carribean ships all have backup systems.
04:37 PM on 03/02/2012
Many American businesses ARE overregulated, as a recent article in the Britsh magazine "The Economist" recently stated in great detail (Jan 18th issue). It was their cover article. True Conservatives, unlike the liberal propaganda, are for the CORRECT amount of regulation, and also believe in holding people accountable.
11:48 PM on 03/01/2012
" A refund of the price of all associated flights, the cost of the cruise, any spending on board, and the company offered the choice of a free one- or two-week vacation in the Seychelles or a free flight home."

Take that 2 week vacation in the Seychelles! We spent 10 days there, and it rivals the Maldives in places. If you're going to be stranded by a cruise ship, there are much worse places to be.
02:03 AM on 03/02/2012
They weren't stranded BY a cruise ship, they were stranded ON a cruise ship. Big difference.
anilimili
compassion trumps hatred
11:34 PM on 03/01/2012
Gladly all are ok, and it sounds like for the most part the passengers took this in stride and tried to make the most out of a very taxing situation. I cannot imagine three days in a steamy tub without running water and stopped up toilets...but seems they got through it.. Cannot imagine it was easy on the crew, either, and they may not be getting any 'compensation' for their hardship.
In the end, glad all are ok, and that there were no fatalities or injuries. IT could've been MUCH much worse.
Cruies in a Costa ship, anyone?
12:06 AM on 03/02/2012
There should be some good bargains now.
anilimili
compassion trumps hatred
11:24 PM on 03/02/2012
I bet you are right! :)
10:40 PM on 03/01/2012
As unpleasant and disappointing as all of this was, to call is "harrowing" is ridiculous. Harrowing is landing on the beaches of Normandy. Harrowing is being at the bedside of a severely injured child. Harrowing is hearing that the school your child attends has just been shot up. Harrowing is being on the edge of a cliff when it caves in. Harrowing is not eating cold sandwiches and not being able to shower.
12:14 AM on 03/02/2012
Amen. Too much overstatement in the headline.
02:04 AM on 03/02/2012
Harrowing would have been if some Somali pirates had showed up. These people were lucky.
05:14 AM on 03/02/2012
Somali pirates have shown up before. This ship had a nine man military force on the ship. They could have handled the small groups of pirates that troll those waters. Pirates have been driven off before with machines that blast very loud noises toward them.
They are not exactly Patton's Fifth.
photo
ahnree
blind me with your lies
09:53 PM on 03/01/2012
Sounds like a blast! why people take trips on a disease riddled cesspool toilet is beyond me
09:23 PM on 03/01/2012
I can understand the fear people had when the crew scrambles and doesnt have it together. I just got off the Costa Serena last week and found the muster they held to be crazy. With over head speakers shouting out 6 to 8 languages while people were talking I was not able to hear. Our cabin the whole lighting shield fell out of the ceiling. My sister & husband the door handle came out of the door to the deck while her husband tried to get back into the room. Food well that was another story. UCK, the worst food, not even warm. Never again on Costa for me.