iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Toyota Sudden Acceleration Document Withheld From Feds: CNN

The Huffington Post  |  By Sharon Silke Carty  |  Posted: 03/02/12 05:53 PM ET  |  Updated: 03/02/12 05:59 PM ET

Cnn On Toyota Sudden Acceleration
CNN interviewed Tanya Spotts, who says her Lexus surged forward and hit a wall while she was stepping on the brake.

Toyota withheld a key document from federal investigators probing electronic causes of unintended acceleration in the automaker's vehicles, reported CNN on Thursday.

According to internal documents obtained by the network's "Anderson Cooper 360," Toyota was aware of a cruise control issue on a pre-production car internally called the 250L which caused the vehicle to start moving forward on its own. "The cruise control activates by itself at full throttle when the accelerator pedal position sensor is abnormal," stated the document, which CNN had translated three times from Japanese into English.

The car was later sold in Japan and Europe as the Lexus 460. Toyota refused to offer its own translation of the document.

Last month, The Huffington Post took a look at underlying electronic issues that could have caused Toyota's sudden acceleration problems. The automaker has contested there is nothing wrong with its electronics, a claim backed by a federal investigation form the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and NASA that purportedly cleared Toyota's electronics.

Toyota's responses and reactions to the unfolding sudden acceleration crisises in 2009 and 2010 are likely to play significant roles in lawsuits against the company that will come to trial starting early next year.

In late 2009, Toyota issued a recall citing evidence that floor mats in the Camry and the Prius were apparently getting stuck under the gas pedal, causing acceleration. In early 2010, Toyota issued a second recall, saying some gas pedals could stick, continuing to add gas to the engine even after a driver took their foot off the pedal.

To address concerns that Toyota's electronics were also causing sudden acceleration, NHTSA asked NASA, which has experience investigating electronics issues in spacecraft and airplanes, to take a look at what might be going on. NASA's report detailed several areas of concern, including a problem surrounding tiny tin whiskers. But NHTSA and Toyota declared that the report cleared the automaker's electronics system.

But NHTSA and NASA did not have a copy of the document detailing the unintended acceleration issue in the 205L, reports CNN. Toyota said the document had nothing to do with the investigation.

Before the segment aired, Toyota posted a one-sentence response to CNN's story:

"In the face of overwhelming scientific evidence to the contrary, CNN has irresponsibly aired a grossly inaccurate segment on Anderson Cooper 360 that attempts to resurrect the discredited, scientifically unproven allegation that there is a hidden defect in Toyota’s electronic throttle control system that can cause unintended acceleration," the company said.

FOLLOW BUSINESS

Toyota withheld a key document from federal investigators probing electronic causes of unintended acceleration in the automaker's vehicles, reported CNN on Thursday. According to internal document...
Toyota withheld a key document from federal investigators probing electronic causes of unintended acceleration in the automaker's vehicles, reported CNN on Thursday. According to internal document...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:46 PM on 12/13/2012
this problem does exsist not only toyotas but other cars too. i have a 2008 cadillac cts with this same problem,it has happened 4 times in 2012 its at the dealer right now,but they claim no code showed up so theres nothing they can do to fix it. that is a flat out lie they know of a brake overide system, its on some of their 2012 model cars. they have known about this for a long time. so far they wont do anything, we reported this complaint to a buch of agencies.seems to me they are trying to avoid a major recall you know GM(goverment motors) this is too much!!
06:59 PM on 07/15/2012
10 months of investigation by NHTSA didn't found any electronics defect but an Iowa Senator Raising his Concern Towards more Government Investigation recently sounds ethical to be sure if Toyota don't have electronics Here is an internal article posted by The Tracy Firm blog on Friday 13th http://vehiclesafetyfirm.com/blog/archives/342 We just want to be sure for public safety.
photo
JBS
Part time misanthrope & full time curmudgeon
10:57 PM on 03/13/2012
I'd have called a lawyer, but it wouldn't have been a TOYOTA lawyer!
08:33 AM on 03/08/2012
I'm very happy with my Toyota Yaris. I bought it when all the idiots were complaining about the safety of Toyota in June 2010 and got one heck of a deal, along with the Toyotacare and 0% APR financing.

The real problem with sticking accelerators was driver-error. Also, don't forget about that guy in California that was filming his Prius....he was wanting a big payout from Toyota because he'd already filed bankruptcy and was still needing cash.
08:30 AM on 03/08/2012
Toyota cars have no sticking accelerators. In 99.9% of the case, it was probably the idiot behind the wheel.
photo
JBS
Part time misanthrope & full time curmudgeon
10:58 PM on 03/13/2012
Yeah. If they hadn't been stupid enough to buy a Toyota it never would have happened.
01:44 AM on 03/07/2012
Mr. Leviss during Dr. Souri's interview:
We're going to have to have a conversation about Exponent's production, because we've now seen several examples of plainly responsive documents that were not produced.
...this is not a satisfactory production.
01:38 AM on 03/07/2012
Dr. Souri, again: We are looking at magnetic interference. We are looking at what potential hardware defects can occur and what their effect is on the system, potential software errors and what their effect on the system is, simulating interactions between hardware and software errors and what their effect on the system is, and so on and so forth.
Q: Are there any others?
A: ...Environmental factors, temperature cycling, humidity, vibration, cosmic rays, latch-up in the semiconductor devices, electrostatic discharges, overvoltages, overcurrents. This is just to list my area.
01:31 AM on 03/07/2012
This is from the transcript of sworn testimony of Dr. Shukri Souri of Exponent, taken in on May 12, 2010 by the staff of the Commerce and Energy Committee:
Mr. B. Cohen [Senior Investigator and Policy Advisor]:
Q I am asking about when you or your associates conduct an experiment, do you write down the results of that experiment and your observations?
Dr. Souri:
A Yes..
So, where is this? When can the public see Dr. Souri's findings and report as Mr. Lentz promised?
12:18 AM on 03/07/2012
In testimony before the House Energy Committee in early 2010, Toyota President James Lentz repeatedly promised to make public the Exponent report on their exhaustive scientific investigation of the causes of Sudden Intended Acceleration. This promise was repeated in a private interview under oath by Dr. Shukri Souri, the hardware and software testing expert in charge of that aspect of the testing at Exponent. Two years have passed, and where is the report? Not public! What is in that report? What is Toyota hiding?
08:15 PM on 03/04/2012
OK, what am I missing, your yelling to the world that toyota had a PRE SALES model that possible had problems with the cruise control, correct? Now what does that have to do with the floormats? when the original lawsuit the dealer put in the wrong floormats, but your telling us and I quote a (pre-production car internally called the 250L) had probelms with cruise control and your trying to connect them to floormats, a memo saying a pre-production car, one in testing, in pre production, talking about the dumbing of america, IS this creating the story or reporting the story?
Realist2011
beware false profits....
09:31 AM on 03/03/2012
Toyota's PR staff should be fired. Toyota may win the lawsuits, but I will probably not ever buy another one as they SEEM to be deliberately misleading everyone on this issue.

They win in the short run, and lose in the long run. Stupid corporate behavior.
02:58 PM on 03/04/2012
This is some of the worst reporting by CNN in recent years. There are trying to create an issue where there is none. A pre-production test worked exactly as expected for a part that never ended up in American cars, but because of a selective translation of a Japanese memo they are trying to link this to sudden unintended acceleration. Obviously they were fed this memo by the lawyers suing Toyota. I can't believe CNN took the bait. Now Huffington Post just copies the story without verify its veracity. Explain to me again what the value of this website is.
Realist2011
beware false profits....
03:26 PM on 03/04/2012
Read the story. CNN had MULTIPLE translations done AND offered Toyota the opportunity to translate the document itself to make sure the translations were accurate. Toyota refused.

I'll just stay away from Toyota vehicles, I can't afford to take the risk that Toyota seems willing to pass off to their CUSTOMERS. I own a 2001, but that was before Toyota "lost their way".