iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Austin Carroll, Indiana High School Student, Expelled For Tweeting Profanity

Posted: 03/25/2012 1:32 pm Updated: 03/25/2012 1:32 pm

Profanity Tweet

An Indiana high school senior has been expelled for a Tweet he says was posted from home on his personal account.

"One of my tweets was, f--- is one of this f---ing words you can f---ing put anywhere in a f---ing sentence and it still f---ing makes sense," Garrett High School senior Austin Carroll told Indiana's NewsCenter.

The expulsion comes when Carroll is on the home stretch toward graduation. Carroll's mother Pam Smith said she doesn't agree with her son's Tweet, but doesn't agree with an expulsion either. To her, a suspension lasting several days is more appropriate.

Carroll says he doesn't think he should be punished by the school for what he posts on his own time and on his own computer. The student is finishing high school at an alternative school and will be able to graduate.

"I thought it was pretty funny, the school didn't think so, they thought it was inappropriate," Carroll told Indiana's NewsCenter. "I think it's inappropriate, too, but I just did it to be funny…. I just want to be able to go back to regular school, go to prom and go to everything that a regular senior would get to do in their senior year."

Carroll's expulsion follows another incident at an Indiana school in which two students faced similar disciplinary action in January for creating fake Twitter accounts impersonating their principal. Tweets from the accounts, the Indianapolis Star reported, were sexually and racially charged.

School districts across the country have implemented or are considering policies that opens dialogue on what the school's role is in social media and what action should -- or shouldn't -- be taken against what students and teachers post online outside of the classroom.

A bill that would allow schools to punish students for off-campus activities has advanced in the Indiana legislature, permitting schools to suspend or expel students for engaging in activities away from school and after hours that "may reasonably be considered to be an interference with school purposes or an educational function."

West Virginia recently adopted an anti-bullying policy that would punish students with detention or suspension for "vulgar or offensive speech" online if it disrupts school, and the U.S. Supreme Court last month let stand rulings that said schools could not discipline two Pennsylvania students for MySpace parodies of their principals that the students created at home.

A Kansas high school senior made the news when she tweeted disparaging remarks about Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback, posting to her account, "Just made mean comments at gov brownback and told him he sucked, in person #heblowsalot." Emma Sullivan was called into the principal's office, reprimanded and asked to write the governor a formal apology. Sullivan refused, and Brownback later issued an apology for his staff "overreacting" to the Tweet.

Disciplinary action for disagreeable online posts are not unique to students. A Florida high school's "Teacher of the Year" was suspended last August for an anti-gay post he wrote on his Facebook page. On the west coast, a new policy at the Los Angeles Unified School District states that teachers can be disciplined for "posting inappropriate, threatening, harassing, racist, biased, derogatory, disparaging or bullying comments toward or about any student, employee or associated person on any website."

FOLLOW EDUCATION

An Indiana high school senior has been expelled for a Tweet he says was posted from home on his personal account. "One of my tweets was, f--- is one of this f---ing words you can f---ing put anywhe...
An Indiana high school senior has been expelled for a Tweet he says was posted from home on his personal account. "One of my tweets was, f--- is one of this f---ing words you can f---ing put anywhe...
Filed by Emmeline Zhao  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 3,168
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (83 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
paulhunterjones
A new age Republican
08:32 PM on 12/05/2012
Carroll’s tweet doesn't threaten violence. He does not tweet anything that can remotely be considered offensive or insensitive to particular group. Actually…is he correct. In this case the school has no overriding public interest to suppress a student’s rights to free speech and expression. To a certain degree it is none of the school district’s business what one of its students tweets. I think Carroll’s expulsion should be rescinded and he should be reinstated in school.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
retromoderne
Born right the first time
08:29 PM on 12/05/2012
If it were my kid I'd be on the phone with the ACLU faster than you can say "twitter".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigWillyG
08:08 PM on 12/05/2012
What is wrong with that schools administration? What petty tyrants.
photo
ravenslvr
No point replying back, I won't read it
05:20 PM on 12/05/2012
I got kicked out of school my sophmore year. I was getting harassed by a former friend, first by calls then by emails. I emailed him back, all of this was off school property btw, and used profanity. He printed it out and took it to the dean of students. I got kicked out. We were both tied for top of our class, but I was a few disiplinary problems, skipping here and there and talking back. He was a suck up, so they didnt even listen to me, nor read any of the other emails from him. In the alternative school, they even told me to appeal it and went to bat for me because they told me that I did not belong there. I ended up tutoring all the kids there and just fniished the year being homeschooled. The next year I went to the highschool on the other side of town and graduated top 1% of my class...out of 3500+. He fell to the bottom of his.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thaddeus Jude
Veteran of Occupy An Office Chair
01:44 PM on 12/05/2012
Well. that was just stupid of the school.
09:37 AM on 05/22/2012
Please, can someone tell me whatever became of this? I have been searching but haven't been able to find out anything at all on it so far since the original incident. Did Austin Carroll get to graduate? Were there changes made to school poloicies since this? ...Anything? Thank you so much in advance! All of your responses are so greatly appreciated :)!
01:26 AM on 05/20/2012
Unfortunatly, I can relate to this. I posted something along the lines of "I could just kill such-and-such teacher after they did such-and-such" on my Facebook wall, and my college treated that the same as if I had directly threatened to shoot up the school. They searched my dorm room, made me get psychologically evaluated, put me under police surveilance all day, and then suspended me for a year even though they didn't find any reason to believe I was actually planning violence. The dean of students even told me that she didn't believe I was a threat. Now no other school will even consider me for admission until 2013, and my $10,000 of tuition is gone forever.
photo
ravenslvr
No point replying back, I won't read it
05:22 PM on 12/05/2012
Oh wow!!! It is so terrible that we have to censor EVERYTHING we say.
05:17 PM on 03/30/2012
Why is it that inalienable rights, such as freedom of speech, only apply to adults? I hope that people begin to realize how much age discrimination their is today, particularly toward younger people.
05:07 PM on 03/30/2012
so is every kid who drops an "F" bomb in the hallway getting expelled too? If not that seems like a discriminatory act - punish only the kid who can work the twitter machine?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigWillyG
08:11 PM on 12/05/2012
The principal was probably freaking out about "those kids and that Elvis they're all listening to, next thing you know TVs will have color and girls will wear pants."
photo
DaughterOfAKing
Sinner Saved by God's Grace
11:35 AM on 03/30/2012
Why do so many people assume that all teenagers use the "F" word. There are plenty of teenagers that choose not to use this word. Let's not stereotype all teenagers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
retromoderne
Born right the first time
08:23 PM on 12/05/2012
Perhaps, but plenty do and they shouldn't be expelled for it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stacy M
10:08 AM on 03/30/2012
No suspension in this case is appropriate.
There is such thing as a first amendment.
By the way from the linguistic standpoint the kid is right. The word *uck is unique in English language.
It is also the only word that can be used as infix (a word part that you can insert inside the root of the word) For example: abso*uckinglutely.
10:38 AM on 03/29/2012
I thought this was American, where you not only have the freedom to say what's on your mind, but also you can do and say what you want in your own home....I guess safety overrules the rule of law...
photo
ravenslvr
No point replying back, I won't read it
05:23 PM on 12/05/2012
Well, you have the right to say it, but people also have the right to sue you for being offended. You can say whatever you want, but you arw not constitutionally protected. You can say it, but you cannot offend people. That is the tricky part.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
retromoderne
Born right the first time
08:27 PM on 12/05/2012
Ah, but a public school is held to a different standard than, say, a private employer. The school is operated by the government. The government can only restrict your right to free speech in a few very specific ways (such as yelling fire in a theater). You can absolutely say anything that offends people. The issue is that you are not protected from their actions that result; just ask Hank Williams Jr.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kacarpentry
Mom to many
06:49 AM on 03/29/2012
And...
Good!
11:05 PM on 03/28/2012
I TOTALLY *UCKING UNDERSTAND THE GUYS *UCKING COMMENT;AND NOT ONLY DO I AGREE WITH IT,BUT I LIKE IT AS WELL !!!
12:00 PM on 03/28/2012
Read this on Facebook:

Currently circulating around the Garrett-Keyser-Butler school district:

"The entire student body at Garrett High School is organizing a protest to support Austin Carroll's constitutional right to free speech. We are planning to have ALL students in the school tweet the EXACT SAME MESSAGE at 6pm this Friday night (3/30) from their homes. Either the school will have to expel all of us, or defend why they expelled only Austin, while ignoring the "crimes" of the rest of the student body..."
09:46 PM on 03/28/2012
GO student body at Garrett High School! It is GREAT when you have a whole group of kids defending what they believe is right. And what you are doing is RIGHT in my book. I would also write a letter to all of my local and state officials and have everyone sign it oposing the right to Freedom of Speech in his privacy and invasion of his privacy. You guys are GREAT!!!!!!
05:33 PM on 03/29/2012
It sounds like that would be fine if they dont use school computers/networks to do it, which he did, with a his computer logged in over school networks. He was probably VPN'ed into the school network without realizing it. That was his mistake. If you use someone elses network you have to abide by their rules. Just like using a network at your work, sending emails, IM'ing and such. The company can scrutinize what you send. Expulsion!?! WAYYYYYY Overreaction! Suspenson!?! Still too much. A stern warning or detention sounds more appropriate.
02:08 AM on 04/03/2012
It was his own personal PC. Who gives a damn if its on the school's network, if he was allowed to bring his PC to school he can use all functions and websites he can access anyway he likes. I for one used school PCs to play counter strike constantly at school. And brought my laptop and gamed all class. Unless he was disrupting class, or got caught by a teacher over his shoulder for not doing the assignment or paying attention in class he is perfectly within his rights. And I continued to do this throughout college too. I have my certs in business and ebusiness with a 3.8GPA.