Huffpost Politics
Luke Johnson Headshot
Sam Wilkes Headshot

Mitt Romney's Health Care Flip-Flops (VIDEO)

Posted: Updated:

On April 12, 2006 at a ceremony held at Fanueil Hall in Boston, Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney (R) signed a law mandating that nearly every resident carry health insurance.

The late Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-Mass.), who was instrumental in getting the bill passed through the overwhelmingly Democratic legislature, stood behind him as he signed the bill using each of 14 commemorative pens.

"It's law," said Romney. "Congratulations."

Nearly six years later, as Romney tries for a second run for the presidency, his signature achievement as governor has become attack fodder for his rivals and a potential liability in a general election because of President Barack Obama's embrace of it as a model for his own health care law.

The two laws share the same DNA: requiring individual and employer mandates and subsidies, establishing health insurance exchanges, allowing young adults to stay on their parents' insurance and prohibiting insurers from denying people's claims based on pre-existing conditions.

Romney has said that his plan was only for the states and not for the national level. "Very early on, we were asked -- is what you've done in Massachusetts something you would have the entire government do, the federal government do? I said no, from the very beginning," the former governor said at a recent town hall in Ohio.

However, in a January 2008 GOP presidential debate, Romney disputed that he opposed national mandates:

GIBSON: But Governor Romney's system has mandates in Massachusetts, although you backed away from mandates on a national basis.

ROMNEY: No, no, I like mandates. The mandates work.

FRED THOMPSON: I beg your pardon? I didn't know you were going to admit that. You like mandates.

ROMNEY: Let me -- let me -- oh, absolutely. Let me tell you what kind of mandates I like, Fred, which is this. If it weren't...

THOMPSON: The ones you come up with.

(LAUGHTER)

ROMNEY: Here's my view: If somebody -- if somebody can afford insurance and decides not to buy it, and then they get sick, they ought to pay their own way, as opposed to expect the government to pay their way.

ROMNEY: And that's an American principle. That's a principle of personal responsibility.

Later in the debate, Romney said that he wouldn't force other states to adopt the Massachusetts model, but reiterated his support for universal coverage.

A July 2009 USA Today op-ed -- published amid the often white-hot health care reform debate -- touted the "lessons we learned in Massachusetts," and in particular the individual mandate, as a model for Washington.

Romney has become testy about the question at times in interviews. To Fox News' Bret Baier in November 2011, he complained: "Bret, I don't know how many times I've said this, too. This is an unusual interview." He then laughed.

In an interview earlier in March with Megyn Kelly, Romney was asked about his "I like mandates" quote. "People have looked at this topic 100 times, more than 100 times, I have agreed that a state should be allowed, if it wants to, to have a health care mandate," he said. "Time and again I've pointed out I'm not in favor of a health care plan that included a national mandate."

Romney isn't the only Republican to have supported an individual mandate. In fact, his own rivals for the nomination have. Rick Santorum in the 1990s supported mandates as an alternative to Hillary Clinton's health care plan. Newt Gingirch also supported individual mandates as an alternative to the Clinton plan, but also well into his post-congressional career.

Romney's previous comments on federal health care policy, coupled with his current opposition to a "one size fits all" health care plan, have drawn skepticism in some quarters. Jonathan Gruber, an M.I.T. economist hired by Romney to craft the bill, slammed Romney last November in an interview with Capital New York:

"They're the same f***ing bill. He [Romney] just can't have his cake and eat it too," Gruber said. "He can try to draw distinctions and stuff, but he's just lying. The only big difference is he didn't have to pay for his. Because the federal government paid for it. Where at the federal level, we have to pay for it, so we have to raise taxes."

Video produced by Sam Wilkes.

Around the Web

Is Mitt Romney underrated?

At elite Gridiron Club dinner, the joke's on Mitt Romney

What Would Mitt Romney Look Like on an Etch A Sketch?

David Plouffe: Mitt Romney 'Godfather' of the Individual Mandate

Romney and the Mormon Factor

Kennedy Helped Shape Romney's Career, and Still Haunts It

For Romney, a Long Drive to a Likely Finish

 
  Obama Romney
Obama Romney
332 206
Obama leading
Obama won
Romney leading
Romney won
Popular Vote
33 out of 100 seats are up for election. 51 are needed for a majority.
Democrat leading
Democrat won
Holdover
Republican leading
Republican won
Democrats* Republicans
Current Senate 53 47
Seats gained or lost +2 -2
New Total 55 45
* Includes two independent senators expected to caucus with the Democrats: Angus King (Maine) and Sen. Bernie Sanders (Vt.).
All 435 seats are up for election. 218 are needed for a majority.
Democrat leading
Democrat won
Republican leading
Republican won
Democrats Republicans
Seats won 201 234
Click for Full Results