iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Foxconn Apple Factories Violated Chinese Labor Laws, According To Fair Labor Association

By PETER SVENSSON 03/29/12 04:54 PM ET AP

Foxconn Apple Factories Labor
Participants dressed up to represent Foxconn workers take part in a protest against Taiwanese technology giant Foxconn, which manufactures Apple products in mainland China, outside an Apple retail outlet in Hong Kong on May 7, 2011. AFP PHOTO / Antony DICKSON

NEW YORK -- The Chinese workers who often spend more than 60 hours per week assembling iPhones and iPads will have their overtime curbed and their hourly wages raised after a labor auditor hired by Apple Inc. inspected their factories.

The Washington-based Fair Labor Association says Hon Hai Precision Industry Co., the Taiwanese company that runs the factories, is committing to reducing weekly work time to the legal Chinese maximum of 49 hours.

That limit is routinely ignored in factories throughout China. Auret van Heerden, the CEO of the FLA, said Hon Hai is the first company to commit to following the legal standard.

Apple's and FLA's own guidelines call for work weeks of 60 hours or less.

The FLA found that many workers at the Hon Hai factories want to work even more overtime, so they can make more money. Hon Hai, also known as Foxconn, told the FLA that it will raise hourly salaries to compensate workers for the reduced hours.

Heerden said that it's common to find workers in developing countries looking for more overtime, rather than less.

"They're often single, they're young, and there's not much to do, so frankly they'd just rather work and save," he said.

The FLA auditors visited three Foxconn complexes in February and March: Guanlan and Longhua near the coastal manufacturing hub of Shenzhen, and Chengdu in the inland province of Sichuan. They employ a total of 178,000 workers, with an average age of 23.

Average monthly salaries at the factories ranged from $360 to $455. Foxconn recently raised salaries by up to 25 percent in the second major salary hike in less than two years.

Foxconn employs 1.2 million workers in China to assemble products not just for Apple, but for Microsoft Corp., Hewlett-Packard Co. and other pillars of the U.S. technology industry.

Foxconn's move to lift wages is likely to have an impact across the industry. Given Apple's unusually high margins, it's able to absorb higher manufacturing costs. But other electronics companies, particularly PC makers, have very slim margins, and may need to look elsewhere to have their products assembled.

Workers who make Apple products have been the subject of increasing scrutiny, in part due to a one-man Broadway play by Mike Daisey. Public radio program "This American Life" used Daisey's monologue in a show about Foxconn on Jan. 6, but retracted it two weeks ago, saying that Daisey had fabricated key parts of it, including that he saw underage workers emerging from Foxconn factories.

The FLA didn't find instances of child or forced labor.

Apple has kept a close watch on its suppliers for years, and in January took the further step of joining the FLA. The organization has audited overseas suppliers for clothing manufacturers, but Apple was the first electronics company to join. It also commissioned the FLA to produce a special audit of Foxconn's factories.

"Our team has been working for years to educate workers, improve conditions and make Apple's supply chain a model for the industry, which is why we asked the FLA to conduct these audits," Apple said in a statement.

Apple CEO Tim Cook visited a Foxconn factory in Zhengzhou, China, on Wednesday.

The FLA has its roots in a 1996 meeting of multinational companies and nonprofits convened by President Clinton, who challenged them to improve conditions for garment and shoe workers. Its 19-member board is composed equally of representatives from member companies, universities and nonprofits like the Global Fairness Initiative. The organization is funded by participating companies.

Labor unions have criticized Apple's use of the FLA, insisting that audits are a "top-down" approach. Foxconn's workers would be better served, they believe, by being able to organize.

"The report will include new promises by Apple that stand to be just as empty as the ones made over the past 5 years," said SumOfUS.org, a coalition of trade unions and consumer groups, ahead of the release of the report.

The FLA found few safety violations, noting that the company had already dealt with problems like blocked fire exits and defective protective gear. It's also taken step to reduce the amount of aluminum dust in the air, after the metal created an explosion at the Chengdu factory last year, killing four workers.

The FLA said Foxconn has been recording only accidents that caused work stoppage, but is now committing to recording and addressing all accidents that result in an injury.

Heerden said his auditors found Foxconn workers are the happiest with their jobs when they work 52 hours a week, well below the amount they often put in. Reducing their hours to 49 hours should help Foxconn retain workers in the long run, he said.

The auditors examined one years' worth of payroll and time records at each factory, conducted interviews with some workers and had 35,000 of them fill out anonymous surveys.

Apple has started tracking the working hours of half a million workers in its supply chain, and said that 89 percent of them worked 60 hours or less in February, even though the company was ramping up production of the new iPad. Workers averaged 48 hours per week.

The Foxconn factories are the last step in the process of manufacturing an iPhone or other Apple device, most of which have hundreds of components. Research firm IHS iSuppli estimates that Apple pays $8 for the assembly of a 16-gigabyte iPhone 4S and $188 for its components. It sells the phone wholesale for about $600 to phone companies, which then subsidize it to be able to sell it for $200 with a two-year service contract.

Related on HuffPost:

Take a look at the slideshow (below) to view some of the most surprising facts revealed during an ABC special report at a Foxconn factory in China.
Loading Slideshow...
  • Handmade Gadgets

    On February 21, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/22/nightline-apple-supplier-foxconn_n_1293393.html?ref=technology" target="_hplink">ABC aired a "Nightline" segment featuring Bill Weir's visit to a Chinese Foxconn factory</a> responsible for making some of Apple's popular devices. During a tour of the factory, Weir says he "expected more robots" but in fact most of the gadgets at Foxconn are made the old-fashioned way: The high tech parts are put together by hand. For example, iPhones are assembled by hand in 141 steps. One iPad takes five days to assemble and passes through 325 sets of hands.

  • Insane Output

    Two shifts of workers toiling in 12 hour shifts can make 300,000 iPad camera modules in one day, not to mention shape sleek iPads out of "raw hunk[s] of aluminum" at a rate of 10,000 per hour. <a href="http://abcnews.go.com/watch/nightline/SH5584743/VD55173552/nightline-221-apples-chinese-factories-exclusive" target="_hplink">Image via Nightline</a>

  • 7 To A Room

    Many workers live at the factory, where they pay $17.50 per month to live 7 to a room in Foxconn dormitories. <a href="http://www.forbes.com/sites/connieguglielmo/2012/02/22/nightline-goes-inside-apple-factories-in-china/" target="_hplink">The average starting salary is $285 per month,</a> and workers must pay for their food. <a href="http://abcnews.go.com/watch/nightline/SH5584743/VD55173552/nightline-221-apples-chinese-factories-exclusive" target="_hplink">Image via Nightline</a>

  • No Free Lunch

    Workers get two hour-long meal breaks during each 12-hour shift. They eat together in a cafeteria where they pay $.70 a meal. This is about a quarter of their hourly wage. <a href="http://abcnews.go.com/watch/nightline/SH5584743/VD55173552/nightline-221-apples-chinese-factories-exclusive" target="_hplink">Image via Nightline</a>

  • Tim Cook Investigated Suicides

    In 2010, after a spate of suicides at Foxconn's Shenzen plant, then COO Tim Cook flew to China to investigate the matter. <a href="http://abcnews.go.com/watch/nightline/SH5584743/VD55173552/nightline-221-apples-chinese-factories-exclusive" target="_hplink">According to Nightline,</a> Cook put together a team of psychiatric experts to examine the issue. It was at that team's suggestion that the infamous nets were installed between the buildings to prevent suicides. There have been 18 worker suicides at Foxconn since 2010. <a href="http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/15/us-china-apple-idUSTRE81E1FQ20120215" target="_hplink">According to Reuters' interview with Fair Labor Association president Auret van Heerden, the group's initial findings from its audit of Foxconn</a> suggested that the suicides could have been "a function of monotony, of boredom, of alienation perhaps."

  • Young Workers

    Weir said he was surprised to see how young the workers were. He said many were in their late teens and no one looked like they could be over 30. Many had left their hometowns, oftentimes in the countryside, in order to get jobs at Foxconn. Weir also toured Chengdu and spoke with the relatives of workers who had left for jobs at Foxconn. According to Cult of Mac, <a href="http://www.cultofmac.com/147878/foxconn-employees-say-underage-workers-were-hidden-before-fla-inspection/" target="_hplink">Foxconn may have hidden underage employees</a> when the Fair Labor Association conducted its inspections. While Apple allows for workers as young as sixteen to assemble their products, those eighteen and under are afforded "special protections," <a href="http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/12/02/22/factory_workers_claim_foxconn_hid_under_age_employees_before_fla_inspection.html" target="_hplink">according to Apple Insider.</a> These include not being allowed to perform some tasks and working shorter hours than older workers.

  • Foxconn Exec Wants To Pay More

    When asked how Foxconn would react if Apple suggested doubling workers' pay, Foxconn executive Louis Woo told Weir that the company would welcome a raise for employees. "Why not?" Woo said. "That would be good for the employees and also definitely good for China and good for us."

  • Air Showers

    Workers have to wear static-proof jackets and take "air showers" to make sure the work area remains dust-free. Even one spec of dust could prove ruinous to the iGadgets' delicate innards. <a href="http://abcnews.go.com/watch/nightline/SH5584743/VD55173552/nightline-221-apples-chinese-factories-exclusive" target="_hplink">Image via Nightline</a>

  • WATCH A CLIP FROM THE NIGHTLINE SEGMENT

FOLLOW TECH

From our partners


Filed by Peter Finocchiaro  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 692
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (15 total)
wsdave
Abusive or Insulting? I won't be responding.
01:32 PM on 03/31/2012
The pic is a spy shot of the new iPad MAXX. It's a new portable with a 27" touch screen, weighing only 37#, and that can easily fit in the trunk of a typical mid-sized car.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Artamentous
Workplace Democracy!
12:24 AM on 03/31/2012
Foxconn has some of the BEST conditions in China. Think about that.

China Labor Watch did a report last year, every single factory they investigated violated Chinese labor laws.

It's a systemic issue.
photo
4TJefferson
Promote the General Welfare
08:27 PM on 03/31/2012
Yeap. Turns out the This American Life and Mike Daisy were on point. Remember two weeks ago when the Apple Zombies got their panties in a knot throwing insults at Mike? How the worm in Apple has turned.
03:08 PM on 03/30/2012
As long as I get my new iPhone, I don't care if 8 year-olds are used as long as they do a good job. What else are these people in these 3rd world countries going to do. Maybe if they are worked hard in a factory, they will be too tired to become terrorists.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NoNameDude
07:14 PM on 03/30/2012
sometimes i wonder how the child labor rumor started. China has never had any child labor scandal, but people keep talking about it. strange.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ur2nutty4me
11:22 PM on 03/30/2012
And that's what you find wrong with his comments!
photo
4TJefferson
Promote the General Welfare
08:28 PM on 03/31/2012
Wow, how 16th Century of you. 8 year olds around the world need to be in school then they will be to smart to be terrorists.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dennis Adams
03:07 PM on 03/30/2012
Just stepping back a bit and looking at the logistics of the issue with Apple is interesting. Foxconn has complexes in 3 locations in China employing 178,000 people making product for Apple. Considering 60K people per complex, which city/state could support that labor requirement?? Where would they find the people?? OK, how about complexes in 6 or 10 locations. That is ~ 20K to 30K per location. Again, which city/state could support that?? Manufacturing companies are in Asia and China for many reasons and it is not only labor costs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NoNameDude
07:17 PM on 03/30/2012
In Kansas, only 2~3 cities have over 60K population.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ur2nutty4me
11:30 PM on 03/30/2012
How about Detroit as a starter. What a defeatist and unimaginitive comment. And the jobs supporting Apple far exceed what you state. And one last comment............There are mutiple technical jobs and management jobs for every one assembler.

Bring the Stinking jobs home NOW............ People like you need a massive reality check.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dennis Adams
03:56 PM on 03/31/2012
I would suspect the 178K jobs includes the production support and technical jobs but the article does not state that fact. Regarding reality, people like you really need to have it checked. I am not sure if you have ever been in a high tech, high volume elect factory but I have and have managed several. There are many things I would mfg in this country, but high volume of that sort is not one of them. Obviously, Apple came to that same conclusion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dennis Adams
02:06 PM on 04/01/2012
Youare great onemotion andblather but light on facts. You might want to try a rational discussion sometime.
photo
Mister Grumpy
An Angry American
02:29 PM on 03/30/2012
Left up to the GOP all factories in the US would have the same work rules and conditions as Foxconn.
wsdave
Abusive or Insulting? I won't be responding.
01:34 PM on 03/31/2012
But as it stands, only that liberal sweetheart, Apple, has them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian Childers
What we've got here is a failure to communicate
02:28 PM on 03/30/2012
Over $400.00 profit per phone. With well over 172,000,000 units sold, thats a lot of bank.
04:16 PM on 03/30/2012
Talk about hitting-the-frikkin jack-pot on daily-basis!!. Right & APPLE will relocate here? Just squeeze those Coolies for all they're worth. Priceless.
01:19 PM on 03/30/2012
American workers cost more because it costs a heck of a lot more just to live and work in America. The cost of living is rising as the value of the dollar goes down and pay has stagnated or become lower. Plus with the CEO's and speculators raking in billions there's not much money left to actually pay people what they need to live in the U.S.

People that work are blamed but that's a cheap shot. Apple certainly didn't wind up with 100 billion in cash because they paid any workers fairly. That's obscene mark up on products plain and simple, price gouging consumers and under paying labor.

Then folks don't want to pay for a social safety net. However if corp's provided more jobs in the U.S. they wouldn't have to and companies would have more consumers. It's a crazy business model as you'll see with deflation picking up. They still make profits when Chinese goods are sold for a fraction of the original cost. It's a pandemic problem.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
reasonable84
02:00 PM on 03/30/2012
You're right, no company should ever make a profit. No company should make investors money. No company should have a plan for recalls, repairs or lawsuits. Price gouging is for items that people need. People don't need iphones.
Who is anyone to say how much is too much. What is greed to you? An 'obscene' mark up is a mark up nobody is willing to pay. If you have a better idea how to run a company, go ahead and start one. Let's see how you do.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Artamentous
Workplace Democracy!
12:27 AM on 03/31/2012
I think Greed is pretty apparent isn't it? Greed is disgusting when you debase other humans in the pursuit of profit.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
legitane
Mankind's biggest sin, Ignorance
01:05 PM on 03/30/2012
Apple could have made NEARLY as much had their products been manufactured right here at home...
Created thousands of good paying jobs..instead sold their souls for a few pennies...
Never bought one, never will...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
reasonable84
01:40 PM on 03/30/2012
Yes, I agree it's awesome that a company provides jobs all over the world. You're not upset about that, are you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
legitane
Mankind's biggest sin, Ignorance
02:46 PM on 03/30/2012
Would you rather make $5.5 billion putting Americans to work or $ 6 billion with few Americans job ? I know what I would do..but that's what makes the world go round..
Views from the Middle
Politicians seem to only listen to the extremes
03:10 PM on 03/30/2012
American companies should provide jobs to Americans.
12:59 PM on 03/30/2012
$455 yuan (chinese) = about $72 (canadian)
but the cost of living in taiwan is about $5000/ year, and thats nice
you can get buy student style for under $3000/ year there so really
it takes them about 6 months of working to be able to afford the 3000$ living expence the rest they can save
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
legitane
Mankind's biggest sin, Ignorance
12:48 PM on 03/30/2012
Chinese had Labor laws ?
Don't believe it....
Communist plot if I ever heard one....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NoNameDude
07:19 PM on 03/30/2012
there are a lot of false rumors about China, and americans keep creating them.
photo
Chatt
Has anyone seen my micro-bio?
12:47 PM on 03/30/2012
I'd much rather pay a little more for a product that was manufactured here...we need the jobs. I must admit though, I do have an iphone and I love it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CamelPaw357
12:44 PM on 03/30/2012
I'm so happy GM is moving its Volt operations to China. I think we'll find the Chinese Volt to be much less costly and of much higher quality.
Views from the Middle
Politicians seem to only listen to the extremes
03:11 PM on 03/30/2012
Maybe you should move to China, too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jakpot
That was then, This is now
04:48 PM on 03/31/2012
ASAP
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Artamentous
Workplace Democracy!
12:28 AM on 03/31/2012
Henry Ford was once asked why he paid his workers so much, his comment? "Someone needs to buy these cars"
Samearn
Educated, liberal Southerner...(we DO exist!)
12:15 PM on 03/30/2012
I see 2 clear reasons here why companies would be drawn to have factories overseas.

1. It's cheaper - (duh, we all know this) - you can pay them less, and, even if you're paying them a fair salary for their country's economy, it's still way less than you would have to pay workers here... which keeps costs down... and Americans aren't willing to pay more $ for "maed in the USA" (which is not realistic because we have to acknowledge it costs more to make stuff here)

2. We simply don't have the kind of work ethic that we used to that had us as a major producer of goods 50 years ago. I mean, what I read about these workers in China would never be applicable in the US today:

"Heerden said that it's common to find workers in developing countries looking for more overtime, rather than less."
"Heerden said his auditors found Foxconn workers are the happiest with their jobs when they work 52 hours a week."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Zriv123
01:33 PM on 03/30/2012
" 2. We simply don't have the kind of work ethic that we used to that had us as a major producer of goods 50 years ago. I mean, what I read about these workers in China would never be applicable in the US today "

This is ridiculous. There's no reason for them to work themselves like dogs. Apple makes more than enough money to hire an entire american manufacturing company instead. I dont understand this crazy notion that we have to gut our middle class to save large companies a few pennies.
Samearn
Educated, liberal Southerner...(we DO exist!)
05:34 PM on 03/30/2012
And if the Middle Class were the #1 priority for such companies, we wouldn't be in this situation.

But is seems clear that $$$$ is always the #1 priority. They get more product (more work hours) for less cost (lower wages). That translates into the balancing of 1) cheaper for the consumer, and 2) more profit for us.

The Middle Class is a casualty of people demanding lower prices and companies wanting the maximum profit. Sad, but true.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Artamentous
Workplace Democracy!
12:29 AM on 03/31/2012
We don't have the work Ethic? You do realize Americans are way more productive than most countries? We DEFINATELY WORK MORE than any westernized country. We sure lack that work ethic.
photo
badboyzs
If you are a cheater.......then you are a liar.
12:13 PM on 03/30/2012
The only Apple I buy is the one we eat!

I would never purchase an Apple product....all nothing but overpriced and hyped chit!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ginpowell
01:12 PM on 03/30/2012
careful of the worms!
photo
badboyzs
If you are a cheater.......then you are a liar.
01:53 PM on 03/30/2012
Those worms are better than anything from inferior China. They are all about the money and the hell with the USA. Look at the trade deficit.....I don't trust one of those yellow beings.
photo
badboyzs
If you are a cheater.......then you are a liar.
12:10 PM on 03/30/2012
No wonder AAPL Stock is over $600 a share....it is all full of yellow!