iOS app Android app More

Filipino Catholic School Withholds Boys' Diplomas For Facebook Kissing Photos

Graduation Caps

By OLIVER TEVES   03/30/12 06:54 AM ET  AP

MANILA, Philippines -- A Philippine Catholic school is withholding the diplomas of six high school boys who uploaded Facebook photos that appear to show them kissing one another, an education official said Friday.

A day earlier, a Philippine court rejected another Catholic school's decision to bar five girls from graduation ceremonies because they had posed in bikinis for photos posted on Facebook. The cases test the limits of privacy in a conservative Catholic nation that is also among the world's most prolific users of social networking sites.

Department of Education officer Samuel Mergenio said the six boys told him they had taken prank photos to make it appear that their lips touched. One of the boys uploaded the pictures on Facebook and mistakenly made them available to others, Mergenio said.

The pictures were not taken at the boys' school, Infant Jesus Academy in the Manila suburb of Marikina, but the students were wearing school uniforms, he said.

Mergenio said the school's chancellor informed the department late Thursday that the boys will be allowed to participate in the graduation ceremonies but "the release of their diplomas will be delayed." He said the school did not say when the diplomas will be handed over and that he was awaiting a formal written report from the school.

The school chancellor was not available for comment Friday.

The mother of the boy who uploaded the photos said she works as a nurse in Saudi Arabia and went home only to attend the graduation of her son, one of twins.

She said she refused to attend the graduation ceremonies because her son would only be subjected to ridicule since he won't be called to the stage to receive his diploma. "It will be like an insult," she told The Associated Press.

On Thursday, a judge in central Cebu city issued a restraining order against St. Theresa's College High School, ordering it to allow the five students who appeared in the bikini photos to take part in Friday afternoon's graduation ceremonies.

The school, which declined to comment to the AP, asked the court to reconsider. The girls' lawyer, Cornelio Mercado, said Friday that the school was still insisting on banning the students while its motion for reconsideration is pending.

Mercado said one Facebook photo at issue showed a girl holding a cigarette and a liquor bottle, while others showed all five wearing bikinis at a beach party on the 16th birthday of one the girls in late December.

The mother of the girl who hosted the party said a security guard barred the group Friday from entering the school campus.

"They were really hurt," she said.

School officials took action against the girls for what they called "engaging in immoral, indecent, obscene or lewd acts," according to court records. They said the students would graduate but could not participate in activities or ceremonies.

Earlier this month, the five girls were summoned by the principal and other school officials, "dressed down" and called "sluts," Mercado said.

The judge, Wilfredo Navarro of the Regional Trial Court, castigated school officials for calling the girls "inappropriate names." He said not allowing them to participate in graduation activities "would indeed be most un-Christian if not entirely inhuman."

Loading Slideshow...
  • U.S Navy Petty Officers Share Same-Sex Kiss

    A Navy tradition caught up with the 2011 repeal of the U.S. military's "don't ask, don't tell" rule when Marissa Gaeta And Citlalic Snell, two U.S. naval petty officers, became the first to share the coveted "first kiss" on the pier after one of them returned from 80 days at sea.

  • Spanish Gay Couple Upstages Al-Jazeera Reporter

    One couple certainly got their opinion about the victory of Spain's Mariano Ranjoya and his conservative People's Party cross in an unusual way by "videobombing" an Al Jazeera reporter, kissing passionately as the hapless correspondent spoke on the election.

  • Kurt & Blaine's 'Glee' Kiss

    Gleeks rejoiced after the much-anticipated kiss between Kurt and Blaine. Several months later, the characters' first love scene drew additional praise (and controversy).

  • Prop 8 Ruled Unconstitutional

    Breana Hansen (L) and Monica Chacon kiss as they celebrate outside of San Francisco City Hall on Feb. 7, 2012 in San Francisco after a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the voter-approved Proposition 8 measure violates the civil rights of gay men and lesbians.

  • Tim Tebow & Demaryius Thomas

    Although the Denver Broncos quarterback filmed a Superbowl commercial in 2010 for the anti-gay, anti-abortion organization Focus On The Family (FOTF), he seems to have no problem sharing a male-on-male lip-lock in front of thousands (millions?) of onlookers when he kissed teammate Demaryius Thomas.

  • Gay 'Wedding' In China

    In March 2011, gay couples kiss during a ceremonial 'wedding' as they try to raise awareness of the issue of homosexual marriage, in Wuhan, in central China's Hubei province.

  • 'As The World Turns' Makes History

    The first gay kiss on daytime television was shared between characters Luke and Noah on "As The World Turns" in 2007.

  • Euro Pride In Poland

    Participants kiss as they march during the 2010 Euro Pride gay parade in Warsaw, Poland.

  • Heinz Ad

    This ad featured two fathers kissing and drew over 200 complaints from concerned parents who were upset they "had to explain same-sex relationships to their offspring." Heinz ended up pulling the ad.

  • Spain's 'Kiss-In'

    A gay couple kisses as Pope Benedict XVI (R) waves to faithful from his popemobile on his way to Cibeles square in Madrid, on Aug. 18, 2011, before a welcoming ceremony.

  • Adam Lambert's Controversial Kiss

    After sharing a kiss with his male bandmate on the 2009 American Music Awards, Lambert's performance due to take place later that week on 'Good Morning America' was canceled. The morning show said he was too racy for their viewers, but many believed homophobia was at play.

  • Belgium's Kiss-In

    A gay couple kiss during a kiss-in flashmob to denounce the violence against members of the homosexual community in Brussels last year.

  • First Gay Kiss On Primetime Television

    In 2000, "Dawson's Creek" featured a groundbreaking gay kiss on primetime when characters Jack and Ethan locked lips.

  • Gay Protest In Greece

    A gay couple kisses on Feb. 14, 2011 during a protest against the Greek state's refusal to recognise same-sex marriages on Athens' Ermou St, the capital's main shopping thoroughfare.

  • 'Brokeback Mountain' Reunion Kiss

    Sorry, Michelle Williams -- our favorite part of this Oscar-winning epic was the passionate reunion kiss between Ennis Del Mar (Heath Ledger) and Jack Twist (Jake Gyllenhaal)

  • Roseanne's Lesbian Kiss

    In 1994 "Roseanne" aired a lesbian kiss between the title character and Sharon, played by Mariel Hemingway. The episode was almost pulled by ABC who was worried about reactions to the kiss, but ultimately it was aired and seen by 30 million people.

  • Gay Couple Enjoys Purim

    Israelis and foreigners of the gay community enjoy a Purim party as they celebrate in Tel Aviv.

  • 'Modern Family' Gay Kiss Controversy

    After fans noticed that gay couple Cam and Mitchell hadn't shared a kiss, they started a successful Facebook campaign to get the producers of "Modern Family" to have the characters share more intimate moments.

  • Chuck Bass' 'Gossip Girl' Kiss

    As is the case with most of his storylines, Chuck Bass' man-on-man smooch had a secretly devious intention. Still, we couldn't help but love watching the hit show's resident bad boy (played by the ever-dashing Ed Westwick) lock lips with a man in this much-hyped sequence.

  • Washington DC Approves Same-Sex Marriage

    Darlene Garner (L) and Candy Holmes (R), both are reverends of Metropolitan Community Churches, exchange kisses during their wedding ceremony on the first day same-sex couples were legal to wed under a new law March 9, 2010.

  • Ally & Ling on 'Ally McBeal'

    Certainly groundbreaking for its time when it aired in 1999, a hot kiss between Ally (Calista Flockheart) and Ling (Lucy Liu) took place after the latter character's erotic dream. As <a href="" target="_hplink">After Ellen notes</a>, both women ultimately concluded that what they really want out of a relationship is 'a penis,' but were at least willing to consider the possibility that they might be 'gay.'

  • 'Cruel Intentions' Girl-Girl Kiss

    "After the hours that Selma Blair and I practiced, we felt ready to go out there," Sarah Michelle Gellar said of her steamy "Cruel Intentions" kiss in 1999. "And I think it showed. Our motto was 'Rehearse, rehearse, rehearse." Looks like the rehearsal paid off: the pair were awarded the Best Kiss award at the MTV Movie Awards the following year.

  • 'Kiss In' At San Francisco's Harvey Milk Plaza

    J. Inness (L) and Drew Staffen kiss in front of the Castro Theatre during a 'Kiss-In' to recognize the International Day Against Homophobia in San Francisco.

  • Kiss-In In France

    People kiss at the Trocadero, in front of the Eiffel Tower in Paris during a "kiss-in" operation for the world day against homophobia.


Filed by Curtis M. Wong  |