iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Personal Saving Rate Plunges As Americans Get Back To Spending More Than They Earn

The Huffington Post  |  By Posted: 03/30/2012 1:05 pm Updated: 04/18/2012 2:43 pm

Spending Debt
In this Nov. 9, 2011 file photo, a shopper carries purchases while shopping at Dolphin Mall, in Miami. The personal saving rate fell to the lowest level since August 2009 in February.

Back in the good old days of the mid-2000s, before that whole unpleasantness with the global financial crisis and the near-depression and what have you, Americans lived like kings. Kings, I say, with big-foyered mansions and six-wheeled Humvees purchased entirely with borrowed money because being fiscally prudent is the sort of thing terrorists do.

Then when the whole near-depression thing hit and the banks repossessed our mansions and Humvees, we were forced to live like cave-dwelling Taliban, "saving" our money instead of spending it. When we had money, that is.

Well, those days seem to be over. We're back to spending more money than we earn. Yay?

The Commerce Department reported this morning that Americans jacked up their spending in February by 0.8 percent from the month before, even while their incomes only increased 0.2 percent. Take inflation into account, and we actually lost money in February, the third decline in the past four months, while still managing to raise inflation-adjusted spending at the fastest rate since September. Boom. Take that, Osama's ghost.

As a result of this kick-ass mismatch between spending and income, the personal saving rate, which is the government's measure of how much Americans save -- the percentage of disposable income we don't blow on lottery tickets and smokes -- tumbled to 3.7 percent, the lowest rate since a similar 3.7 percent back in August 2009.

To find a lower saving rate, you have to go all the way back to December 2007, when the rate was just 2.6 percent. Hmm, what's special about December 2007? Well, that's when the recession officially began, according to the National Bureau of Economic Research.

Not long after the recession started, the personal saving rate soared to a peak of more than 8 percent.

The saving rate settled down during and after the recession, but hung around 5 percent for most of the past two years -- well higher than the record-low rate of 1 percent, set back in 2005, which happened to be the peak of the housing bubble.

See the pattern there? Credit-fueled spending orgy results in super-low saving rate. Come-to-Jesus hellfire of a recession results in a super-high saving rate.

Even after the hellfire recession, the savings rate stayed high as consumers tried to work off their Staten Island Fresh Kills landfill of debt.

Now the saving rate is drifting down again. Good news, right? Maybe not, say economists, who are not called "dismal scientists" for nothing:

"It is a little worrying that, as real incomes are still falling, faster real consumption growth is due to households reducing their savings," worried Capital Economics in a note to clients.

"This [spending] is not sustainable without deterioration in savings and/or better income gains," wrote David Ader of CRT Capital.

To tell the truth, for better or worse, it seems unlikely that consumers are really getting back to their drunken spending ways. What's more likely is that consumers are having to eat their seed corn just to cover expenses, thanks to fairly stagnant wages and rising gasoline prices -- up to $3.925 nationally, according to AAA.

There are lots of ways this could end well. An improving job market should lead to stronger income gains in the future, economists say. That could help consumers keep spending while also bulking their savings back up. Gasoline prices could fall, another boon to the savings rate.

It is encouraging that consumer sentiment is rising, according to the latest Thomson Reuters/University of Michigan survey.

But there are also lots of ways for this to end badly: If job growth stalls, or if incomes continue to stagnate, or if gas prices don't fall. Or, far less likely, if banks decide to start lending to consumers again to fuel more drunken spending binges.

No matter how you cut it, it's hard to really take much pride in a falling savings rate.

FOLLOW BUSINESS

Back in the good old days of the mid-2000s, before that whole unpleasantness with the global financial crisis and the near-depression and what have you, Americans lived like kings. Kings, I say, with ...
Back in the good old days of the mid-2000s, before that whole unpleasantness with the global financial crisis and the near-depression and what have you, Americans lived like kings. Kings, I say, with ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 55
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
Captain Hindsight
Seeking the truth is my only agenda.
06:17 PM on 04/01/2012
Checking = .05%
Mutual Funds = 0.8%
CD's = 1%
Why bother?
09:32 PM on 10/10/2012
Any excuse you need to not save, right?

While inflation may depreciate the value of your dollar, just about anything you buy, save for sound investments (your car is not one) will most surely depreciate at a rate much faster than inflation. But don't listen to me. Boost our consumerist economy by keep spending.
03:22 PM on 02/07/2013
guns and ammo do not depreciate.
05:11 PM on 04/01/2012
Gee, I wonder why Americans spent more money in February. I don't know, could it be that gas prices have gone up? Why, yes, that may be the reason. It's the sanctions, stupid.
09:40 PM on 10/10/2012
Ah, yes. With the average American spending 20-25 dollars more monthly, they surely couldn't sock away ANY money at all. You're understanding of macroeconomics is astounding.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dawn Devins
I can't tolerate intolerance.
04:25 PM on 04/01/2012
Or it just could be people are spending, rather than saving, any income tax return. February would be a month that folks generally have that extra money bump.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
feelingdisposable
Obama 332 - Romney 206
10:12 AM on 04/01/2012
More people are being forced into using what savings they have to cover their basic living costs, and if they still don't have enough to cover the bills, out come the credit cards to pay for necessities such as utility bills, gas, groceries, etc. It's a scary world out there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lyredragon
Obey My Dog!
01:55 AM on 04/01/2012
We could be getting back to our spending ways . .. OR things have gotten so expensive that we're burning through our savings just to survive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TaxpayingVoter
Support Marriage Equality
11:12 PM on 03/31/2012
I don't have it to spend much less save.

I barely scrape by as it is.
09:36 PM on 10/10/2012
Do you smoke? Drink? Do you get the occasional espresso? Do ever make purchases without comparing them with other similar, perhaps more affordable items? If any of the above three apply to you, you could surely save. If not, I find it doubtful you couldn't even save a single dollar. If I'm totally wrong on all these accounts, I apologize before you now, but the vast majority of Americans CAN save. I know this because I see them with iPhones and car payments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TaxpayingVoter
Support Marriage Equality
09:45 PM on 10/10/2012
Honestly, when you're talking to a person who can't even afford deodorant right now, your words just flow by without making much impact.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TOPCAT711
What a Long Strange Trip It's Been
09:34 PM on 03/31/2012
If 'the economy' had to rely on my spending habits, we'd be in real serious trouble.
09:38 PM on 10/10/2012
It does. We live in a consumerist economy. If you happen to spend a lot while simultaneously working (not receiving unemployment benefits of any kind), you're actually supporting job growth, but at the expense of your own financial freedom.
photo
Simply put
Vell, he's just zis guy, you know?
07:43 PM on 03/31/2012
And all the while Wall Street is creating what will be called the "consumer confidence bubble". Investment is climbing based on lower unemployment and higher consumer spending numbers that have not been tempered by the near historical low workforce participation and flattening wage numbers. Get ready for the next crash and burn.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Olderandwiser55
getting older and wiser....
04:42 PM on 03/31/2012
"The U.S. economy grew at an annual rate of 3 percent in the final three months of 2011, the best pace in a year and a half."

How dare these people be optimistic? How dare they buy cars?
03:28 PM on 03/31/2012
Don't spend it if you don't have it.

Save and buy on sale.

If you get it on sale at 20% off vs paying full price and buying on credit at 20% interest you save a lot. Going thru life paying 120% for things you can get for 80% will always leave you broke and poor.
kansaswoman
Love the plains, hate the crazy
05:07 PM on 04/01/2012
You can get some amazing things at thrift stores too.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Hare
One day closer to Utopia
12:53 PM on 03/31/2012
There is a huge difference between getting into debt before 2000 and now. Now days people use credit cards for food essentials, rent, doctors, college bills and living expenses like gas and car payments. It is better to save but who can these days?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ruolivert
04:36 PM on 04/01/2012
What really worse is that Federal monetary policy admittedly hurts savers. Because of our inflationary policy when a poor person puts some money in the bank it buys less the next day and even less the day after that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
69superbike
12:18 PM on 03/31/2012
Less stuff, less problems. Americans are buyers not shoppers. Impulse buyers for sure.
05:54 AM on 03/31/2012
American sheeple will follow marketing off a cliff. Propaganda works.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:40 AM on 03/31/2012
Until we as a collective nation wake up, wise up and realize that until we commit to rearranging, restructuring and reshaping our economy so that it's benefits are more broadly shared, we will be stuck in this rut and in the weeds. Wall Street is making millions. The 1% (or excuse me, the - Job Creators) continue to get richer. Corporations and the wealthy have complete influence on our legislators which in return, mold and sculpt the rules to favor themselves. They are in charge of the messaging that get's doled out to the rest of the 99er's who follow along like sheep. So until we all decide we've had enough, we will reap...

Get Up, Stand Up...
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
JScott
John Galt's last name is McGuffin-Smithee
10:53 PM on 03/30/2012
Personal Saving Rate Plunges As Americans Get Back To Spending More Than They Earn

That's the way corporate RW america likes it.