iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Josef Stalin Notebooks Cause Stir In Russia

By NATALIYA VASILYEVA 04/ 4/12 10:57 AM ET AP

MOSCOW — School notebooks with a portrait of Soviet dictator Josef Stalin on the cover have been causing a controversy in Russia since they went on sale this week.

While human rights activists and historians have warned that the notebooks wrongly instill a positive image of Stalin in children's minds, eager customers have been snapping them up in Moscow bookstores.

In response to numerous pleas to take action, Education Minister Andrei Fursenko said that he disapproves of the notebooks, but has no legal way to stop their publication or sale.

Stalin, who ruled the Soviet Union from 1922 to 1953, is a controversial figure in Russia today. Although he was responsible for the deaths of millions of his own citizens, Stalin is still highly regarded for having led the Soviet Union to victory in World War II and overseeing its rise as an industrial and military superpower.

The notebooks are part of a series called "Great Russians," which places Stalin among famous composers and czars. He is featured on the cover wearing an army uniform studded with medals.

"When children see this magnificent cover with handsome mustachioed Stalin, they perceive him as a hero," Nikolai Svanidze, a television journalist and historian, said in a statement posted on the website of the government's Public Chamber.

Artyom Belan, art director of the Alt publishing house that produced the notebooks, described the series as an "educational endeavor" and said Stalin deserved to be included as a major figure of the 20th century.

"If we do a series of great Russians, should we strike the 20th century from the list altogether?" Belan asked.

An information page at the back of the Stalin notebook mentions the hundreds of thousands of people who were executed during his purges and the millions who were sent to labor camps, but it also praises the Soviet Union's achievements under Stalin's leadership.

Russian textbooks also have taken a more positive view of Stalin since Vladimir Putin came to power in 2000. Putin, who has been prime minister for four years and returns to the presidency in May, has worked to restore Russians' pride in their country and its history as a great power.

A large Moscow bookstore that specializes in textbooks ran out of the Stalin notebooks by Wednesday afternoon and was awaiting a new shipment.

The Stalin notebooks "sell extremely well," said Yelena Shurukova, an employee at Pedagogical Books. Most are bought by adults, she said.

FOLLOW WORLD

MOSCOW — School notebooks with a portrait of Soviet dictator Josef Stalin on the cover have been causing a controversy in Russia since they went on sale this week. While human rights activists ...
MOSCOW — School notebooks with a portrait of Soviet dictator Josef Stalin on the cover have been causing a controversy in Russia since they went on sale this week. While human rights activists ...
Filed by Eline Gordts  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 899
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (14 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:04 PM on 04/06/2012
The headline made me think some unknown notebooks kept by Stalin had turned up. That
would have been interesting.....this story not so much.
TomMartin
Freedom and equality.
03:37 AM on 04/06/2012
Clearly many Russians are brought up very badly. I would not want to live in such a country. It is true that America was similarly bad 200 years ago, but we have matured a little. But the fact that so many Americans approve of torture shows we still have a long way to go.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wrongway62
Good night Mrs Calabash wherever you are
01:35 PM on 04/05/2012
Like him or hate him he moved a backward country into the 20th century super power. Granted it was over the body's of possibly millions of his country man, but every dictator has a few faults, his just seemed to be a bit bigger than most.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
R2D2-51
Flower Power Forever
05:57 PM on 04/05/2012
Justifying genocide is indefensible by any means. You could make that lousy excuse for most any dictator whether it was Mussolini, Hitler when he put so many Germans back to work and raised their standard of livening considerably, gave us incredible technologies we used to keep Russia at bay, notwithstanding the autobahn.

Then there is Queen Victoria and the imperialist policies to exploit nearly every nation on earth, for which Churchill was well known for defending, and had it not been for FDR's demand to end colonialism through the adoption of the UN Charter would have gone on had Churchill had his way. But WWII bankrupts them anyway.

Humanity hopefully after a post-carbon future may be the right nix to make an evolutionary leap for humanity to learn to cooperate versus always spending every bit of energy in the pursuit of self & screw everyone else which has brought us to the brink of self-destruction with no help with the likes of these people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wrongway62
Good night Mrs Calabash wherever you are
10:53 PM on 04/05/2012
I applauded your moral indigence provided by your kaleidoscopic traipse of disjointed loquaciousness. If it is you point to say, you hope one day we live in a better world, get to the point, just say that. On the other hand if your trying to say genocide is indefensible, you might want to check the bible, the history of every winning side in wars and world history in general, you'll see there has always been more than enough justification, religious and historical.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NrthrnLord
Prince of a very small part of the universe.
10:50 AM on 04/05/2012
Slap ol' G Dub on a textbook cover, and we've got the same thing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Greg Bell
05:35 AM on 04/05/2012
Sheep to the slaughter...still.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rg9rts
Carpe Diem! This aint rehearsal
05:30 AM on 04/05/2012
Ivan IV, Peter, Catherine and yes Stalin, all have shaped the Russian psyche for good or evil no one can tell but Russia has paid a high price that the West still cannot understand. We really have no equivalent in our experience.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Neil Murphy3111
06:30 AM on 04/05/2012
4 more years of obama and we will.
USBrit
And GOP Jesus said, I am come to help the rich.
09:46 AM on 04/05/2012
Seriously? you twits of the rightist persuasion need to get a lot more balance in your view points. I'm no fan of Obama but he is neither Hitler nor Stalin, or even close.
03:16 PM on 04/05/2012
I guess you're voting for Ron Paul, then.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
jscratz
Heja Sverige!
04:38 AM on 04/05/2012
Crazy. If you haven't read this book already, I highly recomend it.
"Stalin – The Court of the Red Tsar" by Simon Sebag Montefoire.
04:37 AM on 04/05/2012
Suppose someone came out with a book about Great Germans with Hitler being treated the same way. Could you imagine the justified outrage? This deserves to be treated the same way.

Of course there is an important difference that does have to be recognized. Stalin won while Hitler lost.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
smoknjoe
Condemnant quod non intellegunt.
04:17 AM on 04/05/2012
He killed millions but that is overlooked because he was a WWII hero? Who will rewrite history next?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Fourniadis
Spin this.
04:50 AM on 04/05/2012
Texas School books.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
scriibe
Liberal but not PC
03:56 AM on 04/05/2012
It would be more comfortable if everyone was entirely good or entirely evil. Sadly humanity does not work that way. Everyone, even utterly despicable folks like Stalin and Hitler, had their good points And even those remembered as saints like Gahndi and Mother Theresa had their flaws. Realizing this helps prevent the narrow, black-or-white thinking that is responsible for so many of todays political problems in the US.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bullwinkle88
04:44 AM on 04/05/2012
You would be hard pressed to find any good in Stalin. At least Hitler loved his dog.
photo
memery
I used to be disgusted; now I'm just amused.
05:27 AM on 04/05/2012
"At least Hitler loved his dog."

Well, up to a point. It was Hitler's dog Blondie that served as the guinea pig to determine if the cyanide capsules that Hitler, Eva Braun and the entire Goebbels family (including six children) planned to take (as their own version of a "final solution") would actually work. The dog died.
08:48 PM on 04/06/2012
He managed to turn what was at the time more or less a third world country into a superpower, that should acount for something?

All in all thought I would not want him, but then again it is very few of the 'great' people in history I would want...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:11 AM on 04/06/2012
Even Stalin's daughter hated him and it was believed he killed her mother.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Corban
My Weimaraner is smarter than your honor student
03:12 AM on 04/05/2012
In Soviet Russia, Stalin notebook reads you!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:45 AM on 04/05/2012
Stalin was a hero. He killed bankers before he lead the government. Now the bankers spend a lot of money slandering him.
04:17 AM on 04/05/2012
Just what brutal acts is Stalin NOT guilty of that constitute slander?
photo
MichaelMcKLA
I'm moving to Pandora.
02:20 AM on 04/05/2012
I hear he won for Dictator of the Year in 1951.

;)
photo
memery
I used to be disgusted; now I'm just amused.
05:30 AM on 04/05/2012
Yeah, he won it in a walk but it was a weak field that year.
01:57 AM on 04/05/2012
Oh how those Russians know how to suffer.

Stalin admirable in any way??? Maybe if you admire Hitler-types.
01:57 AM on 04/05/2012
Stalin wasn't even Russian! He was a Georgian.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rg9rts
Carpe Diem! This aint rehearsal
05:33 AM on 04/05/2012
And Bush was a Texan.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bullwinkle88
05:14 AM on 04/07/2012
And Hitler was an Austrian. So what?