iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Global Warming: Earth's Orbit Blamed For Ancient Hot Spells

Posted:

By Wynne Parry, LiveScience Senior Writer:

About 55 million years ago, an intense heat wave hit the planet. Earth's surface temperature surged by 9 degrees Fahrenheit (5 degrees Celsius). Then, after a relatively short time, the heat subsided, only to be followed by at least two similar, but smaller heat waves.

Based on chemical clues preserved in rocks, scientists believe a surge of carbon dioxide warmed the planet. But where did all of this greenhouse gas come from?

A team of scientists is proposing that it came from the melting of permafrost, frozen soil packed with organic matter, after cycles in the Earth's orbit warmed up the areas near the poles. The melting released a massive amount of carbon into the atmosphere, keeping reflected sunlight from escaping and causing the heat wave.

Previously, other scientists have theorized that the release of the carbon compound methane trapped in marine sediments — in a form known as methane hydrates — changed the atmosphere. But the study published in the April 5 issue of the journal Nature argues that not enough methane would have been released to account for the magnitude of the warming.

Other theories include a comet impact, extensive fires, or the drying of shallow continental seas — "all these difficult ideas," said study researcher Mark Pagani, a professor at Yale University. None of these explain the sequence of progressively smaller heat waves that followed, Pagani and his colleagues argue.

Examining a rock outcrop near Gubbio, Italy that contains evidence of these heat waves, also known as hyperthermals, the team found they lined up with cycles in the Earth's orbit.

The path of Earth around the sun and the planet's orientation can vary slightly in cycles that last up to 100,000 years. The researchers found that the timing of three large hyperthermals — beginning about 55 million years ago — aligned with periods when the tilt of the Earth's axis was greatest and when the planet's orbit was most eccentric (that is, least circular). [50 Amazing Facts About Earth]

This combination meant the high latitudes — the area closest to the poles — had warmer or longer summers, "with the potential to thaw vast areas of permafrost once a warming threshold is reached," wrote the researchers. The cycle became self-reinforcing, as more carbon entering the atmosphere encouraged more warming, which encouraged more melting and the release of more carbon.

"Then our climate models show if you have permafrost and you warm the temperatures slowly, there is sort of a sweet spot in the model: When you cross it, the whole thing just goes," Pagani said.

Modern discussions of melting permafrost focus on the Arctic. But about 50 million years ago, the world was warmer overall than it is now, and Antarctica was not yet ice-covered, so the researchers argue that the southernmost continent probably had its own large stock of carbon tucked away in the permafrost.

This process produced the successive hyperthermals, the team suspects: After a warming stint lasting some 10,000 years, the carbon from the permafrost would be depleted, resulting in atmospheric carbon dioxide that stuck around for about 200,000 years until natural processes drew it out, cooling the planet down, according to Pagani.

Then, about 1 million years later, the process most likely repeated itself, but this time with less permafrost available to melt. This led to a smaller warming pulse, until the hyperthermals ran themselves out, he said. 

These ancient hyperthermals are described by the researchers as intense bursts of warming, but nowadays the planet is warming more rapidly. Scientists anticipate that the melting Arctic permafrost is likely to exacerbate things.

"This source of carbon is a large and important source of carbon that has not been released yet; that is just one of those extra things that is waiting around the corner for us," Pagani said. 

The research was led by Robert DeConto at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst.

Editor's note: This article was updated at 4:20 pm Eastern Daylight Time to correct an error regarding the timing of the study's publication. It was published in the April 5 issue of the journal Nature, not March 5. 

You can follow LiveScience senior writer Wynne Parry on Twitter @Wynne_Parry. Follow LiveScience for the latest in science news and discoveries on Twitter @livescience and on Facebook.

Copyright 2012 LiveScience, a TechMediaNetwork company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW GREEN

By Wynne Parry, LiveScience Senior Writer: About 55 million years ago, an intense heat wave hit the planet. Earth's surface temperature surged by 9 degrees Fahrenheit (5 degrees Celsius). Then, aft...
By Wynne Parry, LiveScience Senior Writer: About 55 million years ago, an intense heat wave hit the planet. Earth's surface temperature surged by 9 degrees Fahrenheit (5 degrees Celsius). Then, aft...
Filed by Jessica Leader  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 177
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
stargazer13
To Love One Is To Love All
03:56 PM on 04/09/2012
still does not explain why ??

all the planets in our solar system are heating up as well
07:56 PM on 04/09/2012
"all the planets in our solar system are heating up as well"

Can you provide a source that backs your claims that ends with .edu or .gov?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
stargazer13
To Love One Is To Love All
09:04 PM on 04/09/2012
N.A,S.A.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
stargazer13
To Love One Is To Love All
09:05 PM on 04/09/2012
J.P.L. jet propulsion laboratories
10:53 PM on 04/09/2012
They are not. Nice try though.
06:54 PM on 04/13/2012
Actually, Mars is documented as having their polar ice caps melting and have been for some time now.

http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2003/07aug_southpole/

will this little tidbit from NASA suffice for you?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:16 AM on 04/09/2012
In the past, melting of the permafrost may have been caused by natural perturbations in the Earth's tilt and orbit.

Today, melting of the permafrost may be caused by man-made global warming. If we put too much pollution into the atmosphere, it may cause a self-reinforcing warm spell such as we humans have never seen before.

Sounds like a pretty good reason to avoid any more man-made global warming. I am too old to have to worry about what might happen a hundred years from now, but I can still understand what is going on.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:43 PM on 04/22/2012
Can you also understand the world has been warming since the the end of the last ice age , most likely is why it ended . melting of permafrost ,warming of the ocean and melting of glaciers all contribute to Co2 .
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ty2010
08:51 PM on 04/25/2012
Exactly, although there are periods of temps going up and down the overall long term we are in is emergence from an ice age.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
10:29 AM on 05/01/2012
A gradual warming from an ice age is radically different from what is currently occurring. The ice age CO2/warming cycle goes between 180 and 280ppm. We've recently passed 390ppm. This is FAR outside the norm for "coming out of an ice age".

Here's a good explanation: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKDVC4HJg7c
photo
ILoveFiction
That's unbelievable!
07:11 AM on 04/08/2012
Tragic tree terminations in Texas.

It's terrible.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2012/04/05/MNGK1NVD42.DTL
08:05 PM on 04/08/2012
I wanted to grow cactus pears in my back yard.
Cant wait till it gets warm enough.
08:41 PM on 04/08/2012
Most half-wits know that trees and arable land are much more valuable than Prickly Pear. Apparently you do not.
12:35 AM on 04/10/2012
Up to half a billion dead trees. Crop and livestock losses of $7.62 billion and counting.

But the heat and drought is apparently a good thing because now Vakh here can plant cactus pears.

Selfish much?
05:18 PM on 04/14/2012
I have a brother that lives and works very near Houston. He's told me of several patches of trees that suddenly died that are on his commute to work. Something similar happened in Australia a couple of years ago when there was a severe drought. Some deciduous trees in Melbourne dropped all their leaves far ahead of schedule.
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
09:41 PM on 04/07/2012
Good science. Yet it does show how little we really know.

We should be thinking about how to harvest the permafrost methane, that's what holds the carbon, for energy. Burning otherwise released methane cuts the GHG by 20 times. We need the energy anyway.
Kommonman
Blame it on Dyslexic fingers..next question
02:09 AM on 04/08/2012
Aye I have thought of that but at this point the only way to do that would be to tent vast regions of the permafrost areas...probably with a reflective tent material and during the cold months which is most of the year there would be no production...I doubt the material would hold up to the artic winds as well...still it is a different concept
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
04:09 PM on 04/08/2012
A group of scientists actually tried that and were able to cover a couple football fields of area, but it was a bear to keep down.

It would be one or the other. Preserve the ice, of take advantage of fast melting at the edges to catch the methane.

Seems like first we aught to stop all the methane released from livestock and ngas drilling, maybe that will stop the ice melting.
08:06 PM on 04/08/2012
throw a match on it.
on a nice warm day.
photo
Winterseeker
For the trees...we need them, not vice versa.
02:24 AM on 04/07/2012
We're on our way...cold phase or not the permafrost is inevitably retreating right now across the boreal forest in the Northern Hemisphere, chucks of ice sheet are falling off now faster than we can predict and the ocean has become more confusing and unpredictable than ever before...
05:08 PM on 04/06/2012
What happened in the past is nothing to what mankind is now doing to the earth's orbit.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
09:50 PM on 04/06/2012
We're not doing anything to Earth's orbit...
12:57 PM on 04/07/2012
But we sure are doing things to the atmosphere ...
05:20 PM on 04/07/2012
True, True! Every new wind turbine farm is an increment closer to that fateful tipping point. Once we get there, ol' planet earth is going to start sailing on its own course Why, just think of the opportunites! We can finally go where we decide and not be held hostage for ransom by evil solar gravity. We, the planetary we, can finally start tracking down the death star planet Nibiro and kill itl I credit the ONN with providing me with secret details on this matter.
11:18 PM on 04/08/2012
Need a tail or rudders.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Just4theHalibut
11:32 AM on 04/06/2012
It doesn't say where the earth is now in this cycle?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
B Wood
01:24 PM on 04/06/2012
There is a study from the 1980s that indicates we are about 23% the cycle when ignoring other factors that affect climate. We are on a cooling trend. A more recent study indicates that the current "warm" phase is for another 50,000 years.

What this article as well as research on this cycle is that it is slow and its effects are gradual. Skpetics love to trot out Milankovitch Cycles as a straw man.
11:21 PM on 04/08/2012
Wishful thinking on that 50 k yrs.
You mean there is no Milankovitch cycle????
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
09:50 PM on 04/06/2012
We're not in a "hot" phase.
07:11 AM on 04/07/2012
We're heating up the planet about 50,000 times faster than the warming trend which triggered the PETM and other hyperthermals of the early Cenozoic.
10:29 AM on 04/06/2012
As a well known American economist likes to say: "The fix is in". We have a situation now of "committed climate change" and are doing nothing to stave off the effects despite the warning signals. There is inertia in the Earth's system so the consequences of the last couple of decades pumping out of CO2 are only just starting to be felt. It is now almost certain that the summer sea ice in the Arctic will collapse in 2015 triggering a runaway climate change event (or Tipping Point. This will rapidly accelerate global heating. Bye bye Florida, Bangladesh, many small island states and so on. The rest of the world has lost faith in America to take leadership on this issue and to the sane people around the world the Chinese are likely to become the thought leaders and major action takers on these issues. Sadly the US shrouded in denial and corruption and mass-media deception. A great shame for a once great nation!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chipher
08:10 PM on 04/07/2012
"We have a situation now" ... of a "Committed Carbon Caliphate's" mandatory carbon tithe-taxes in the form of anti-democratic carbon 'credits', allowing industry to *continue* to drill and frack, to *continue* to strip mine and clear cut, to *continue* to burn coal, oil and natural gas, then extra-legislatively, by IPCC 'super-committee', transfer those carbon 'credits' to 3rd world despots, who grow richer by driving aboriginals and campesanos off their freeland holdings, *clearcutting* old growth tropical forests, aggregating the holdings and leasing them to Big Agribusiness for biofuels production, creating 'carbon volcanoes'.

You've been gloriously *conned*! Watch Willie Smits 'Restoring a Rain Forest' on TED.
Your IPCC is clear-cutting the planet. A great shame for a once great Science (sic), that it's been taken over by 'End TImes' religious fanaticisn!

Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyoto~!
11:28 PM on 04/08/2012
I better tell my bro to get out of Fla in the next 300 years or he'll drown.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
03:52 PM on 04/12/2012
Tell his great great grandkids...
photo
ILoveFiction
That's unbelievable!
07:07 AM on 04/06/2012
According to grappler the crops did just fine.

By the way, the article didn't even mention how much people enjoyed the balmy weather.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
grappler1987
Heaven is a gift, not a reward
08:21 PM on 04/06/2012
There were farmers 55 million years ago? :)

More to your point, the earth was almost entirely covered by forests and lush plant life, even toward the poles. Mammals flourished, but there was no farming yet. Man wasn't around yet to take advantage of it.

http://eocene.dmns.org/
http://www.sas.upenn.edu/earth/arctic/forests.html
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0031018206006158

Crop production may have been impossible during much of the Pleistocene that came later. It was too dry and low on CO2. The Eocene climate would have been better for farming though some of our crops hadn't evolved into existence yet.
http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/anthro/faculty/boyd/AgOrigins.pdf
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
11:01 PM on 04/06/2012
*satire*
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
eaarth2
“An era ends when its illusions are exhausted
05:35 AM on 04/06/2012
Earths orbital eccentricities have caused the ice ages (Milankovitch cycles) as well over the last million years. That the PETM was also possibly caused by warming in the arctic and antarctic by orbital change and the planets tilts is not a huge surprise. Permafrost has a huge amount of gases, that when released covert to C02.

Of course what is happening today is not caused by orbital variation- the melting in the arctic now, if left unchecked could release plenty of carbon from permafrost, along with the stuff we are burning for energy- creating a nightmare scenario in a few decades to come. And this is all happening thousands of times faster then the PETM.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
yeti7
don't need no stink'n badges
09:25 AM on 04/06/2012
Permafrost has a huge amount of gases, that when released covert to C02. " gases convert to co2?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
eaarth2
“An era ends when its illusions are exhausted
10:47 AM on 04/06/2012
yes
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
09:53 PM on 04/06/2012
The Permafrost has a huge amount of CARBON that is released as CO2 and methane when it starts to decay. Not sure exactly what eearth2 meant to say, but I think that's it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chipher
08:15 PM on 04/07/2012
"Permafrost has a huge amount of gases, that when released covert to C02. "

Yeah, there's a typical IPCC-esque 'scientific' statement!

Permafrost is frozen soil beneath the tundra. When it thaws, tundra plants growing on the thawed permafrost can "fix more carbon' as they grow, the *opposite* of your assertion.

Perhaps you're thinking of methane ice, far at the bottom of the sea buried in sediments,
and of such insignificance that no way's been found to extract the fuel with warm water.

Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyoto~!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
eaarth2
“An era ends when its illusions are exhausted
05:24 AM on 04/08/2012
What happened in the PETM is ample evidence of what can be released from permafrost.
There are vast amounts of it in the arctic and sub arctic. As far as frozen methane in the seas, known as Methane Clathrates they where largely responsible for the huge run up in global temperatures during the end Permian extinction 251 million years ago.As well as the PETM.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/2011/12/06/two-degree-global-warming-limit-is-called-a-prescription-for-disaster/

Please spare me the usual denier anti IPCC anti C02 connection to warming. With me it will stop here.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
03:53 PM on 04/12/2012
Wrong again. Much of what was permafrost turns into muskeg, which is swamp, dotted with lots of ponds, streams, and lakes. You end up with LESS vegetation, not more.

And the ponds fairly belch methane. You can go and see for yourself.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Neapolitan
Reality has a liberal bias.
05:32 AM on 04/06/2012
The headline is misleading. Changes in Earth's axial tilt didn't cause previous warm spells; CO2 and other GHGs did. Milankovich cycles were the catalyst that caused those sequestered GHGs to be released, but GHGs did all the heavy lifting.
photo
uniqumm
Hot Snark served with relish
02:08 AM on 04/06/2012
It's a plausible theory!

BTW - "The melting released a massive amount of carbon into the atmosphere, keeping reflected sunlight from escaping and causing the heat wave."

It's not REFLECTED sunlight that can't escape but the IR from the environment HEATED by the sunlight. CO2 and methane block IR. More of those and less IR can radiate out into space.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chipher
08:18 PM on 04/07/2012
Reality isn't IPCC's strong suite. Just one hysterical and unsupportable claim after another towards One World Caliphate, 10,000s golden rice bowl drones, and $20 a gallon gasoline.

Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyoto~!
photo
uniqumm
Hot Snark served with relish
09:02 PM on 04/07/2012
Where is the IPCC mentioned in the article?

It seem to me that when it comes to reality, it and you are in different counties, at a minimum!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:36 AM on 04/06/2012
Given the article I read on how pesticides are affecting pregnant women and unborn babies, I am not nearly as worried as I was about the effects of climate change. We may kill ourselves off with pesticide poisoning before the global weirding gets us.
08:13 AM on 04/06/2012
I doubt we'll kill ourselves off with pesticides, just look for lots of birth defects and cancer.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:49 PM on 04/06/2012
The problem I was referencing was that babies are being born prematurely. If this keeps up we are going to have a lot of reproductive problems. Think "Silent Spring". I wonder why people thought that we could kill off the birds and the bees and not be affected?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
03:50 PM on 04/06/2012
Oh joy is me!
11:08 PM on 04/05/2012
My big lesson learned is this. Nothing ever returns to the way it was. If, CO2 is ever controlled and reduced to pre-industrial revolution levels, (hah), the world won't be the same as before. Our climate has been launched onto a trajectory that even the best guesses are now a scatter chart of immense dimensions. We have cursed our children and grandchildren and theirs to live in interesting times.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chipher
08:22 PM on 04/07/2012
"We have cursed our children and grandchildren and theirs to live in interesting times. "

No, that would be Fed and Treasury, that is pawning off their $16 trillion deficit debts on our Social Security TRUST FUND, already half in the bag, and more hocked off every day.

Our children and grandchildren will never know social security, only a techno-theocracy.

A Techno-Taliban kinda like Afghanistan, ironically. Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyoto~!
06:10 PM on 04/08/2012
You seem to have a flair for instantly pivoting and moving far away from the subject. Then, you start psycho-babbling. I suspect you are communicating from within a resilient room.
Kommonman
Blame it on Dyslexic fingers..next question
02:26 AM on 04/08/2012
I don't know that interesting would have been the word to use
06:12 PM on 04/08/2012
Thank the british for the interesting choice of words. They are attributed with bastardizing the Chinese proverb about wishing bad times on enemies or something like that.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SmartladyDem
Not a fan of the new format-
07:49 PM on 04/05/2012
Hmmm, I thought my hormones were to blame....
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
GWG27
07:51 PM on 04/05/2012
Heeheeheee ,,,,
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SmartladyDem
Not a fan of the new format-
07:53 PM on 04/05/2012
You have no idea=) (And thanks)
Kommonman
Blame it on Dyslexic fingers..next question
02:28 AM on 04/08/2012
Bah your womanly hormones may plague you but my manly hormones plague the world....testoterone has led to more fool hardy decisions than estrogen ever has
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SmartladyDem
Not a fan of the new format-
10:05 AM on 04/08/2012
That's funny, I caught my father saying the same thing-he can't wait to have a woman president.
11:54 PM on 04/08/2012
And helped mankind survive.