iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Job Market Recovery Led By Low-Wage Sectors

Posted: 04/ 5/2012 2:00 pm

Job Market
The job market's improvement has been led by jobs in restaurants and other low-paying industries.

The job market these days is sort of like that old Catskills joke: The food is terrible, and the portions are so small.

The jobs are lousy, and there aren't enough of them.

More than half of all the jobs created during the past six months have been in low-paying industries such as retail and temporary help, Joseph Brusuelas, senior economist at Bloomberg LP, noted on Thursday.

That helps explain why wage growth hasn't kept up with inflation, despite the economy having created 1.2 million jobs in the past six months.

"Those low-wage paying jobs are not translating into better spending," Brusuelas said in an interview with The Huffington Post.

Friday morning, when those of us lucky enough to have jobs will probably be on vacation, and even Wall Street's trading robots will have a much-needed day off, the Labor Department will release the jobs report for March.

Economists think nonfarm payrolls grew by 200,000 jobs, just a bit less than the 227,000 jobs added in February, according to Briefing.com. Expectations were solidified on Wednesday by a report from payroll processing firm ADP that the private sector created 209,000 jobs in March. The unemployment rate is expected to hold steady at 8.3 percent.

One key thing to watch will be wage growth.

The average hourly earnings of American workers grew just 1.9 percent in February from the year before, according to the February jobs report. That's better than nothing, and certainly better than during the recession, when wage growth dipped to, well, nothing.

But wage growth was not enough to keep up with consumer price inflation, which rose 2.9 percent year-over-year in February, according to the Labor Department. That means "real" earnings, or earnings that are adjusted for inflation, are actually shrinking. A lot. That needs to change in order for the economy to keep recovering.

The problem is that most of the decent job growth we've seen in the past few months has been in sectors that do not pay all that well.

The economy has created 1.2 million nonfarm payroll jobs in the past six months -- great news.

But nearly 668,000 of those jobs -- more than 55 percent -- have been created in the retail, temp, "health care and social assistance" and "leisure and hospitality" sectors, notes Brusuelas.

These sectors account for only 29 percent of the total labor force, he adds, meaning that they take up a small portion of the economy, but are having an outsize effect on job growth.

That's likely to continue. The restaurant sector, for example, is expected to hire more than 400,000 people this summer, MSNBC's Economy Watch blog reported this week: "For all you foodies hoping to land a gig in the glamorous restaurant industry in the months and years ahead, there will be plenty of jobs to be had. The problem is, many of the jobs don't come with a glamorous paycheck."

We can hope that these lower-wage sectors are leading the way for employment in higher sectors. Relatively cheap temp workers in particular are often seen as leading indicators for permanent hiring.

But there is also a risk that lower-wage industries are doing most of the hiring because higher-wage industries like technology can't find enough skilled people to hire.

"For the past year we're hearing anecdotal evidence of a shortage in higher-skilled workers," Brusuelas said. "We're hearing it from CEOs and other real-economy clients, and that's a problem."

Two other things to watch in Friday's jobs report:

  • Some economists say that the mild weather in January and February helped job growth. Will this effect continue in March, or did hiring in those months take away from hiring that would've happened in March, which is typically more seasonable?
  • How many people joined or left the labor force during the month. How many workers have given up looking for jobs forever, and how many have started to look for work again because they're reading news reports of better hiring?

FOLLOW BUSINESS

The job market these days is sort of like that old Catskills joke: The food is terrible, and the portions are so small. The jobs are lousy, and there aren't enough of them. More than half of all...
The job market these days is sort of like that old Catskills joke: The food is terrible, and the portions are so small. The jobs are lousy, and there aren't enough of them. More than half of all...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,178
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (18 total)
  1 of 3  
COMMUNITY PUNDITS
photo
freethinkergirl 03:57 PM on 04/05/2012
READ!!!!!!!

"I am a 21 year-old student from Finland........It makes me sad to hear how Americans are suf-fer!ng........Here, our taxes are high but we all benefit from them.

My university is known around the world in my field and my education is not only free, but my government pays ME to go to university.  Everyone has a right to this.

Everyone has a  Read More...
12:08 PM on 05/06/2013
Everyone at All Reverse Mortgage Company was extremely helpful and accommodating from the very first contact. Both their personal and professional care were outstanding and we feel they performed with our best interest as their uppermost concern. We were kept advised every step of the way and they made sure we understood the entire process. We recommend them to anyone thinking of obtaining a reverse mortgage
http://www.reversemortgagelendersdirect.com/reverse-mortgages-how-they-work/
http://www.reversemortgagelendersdirect.com/reverse-mortgage-information/
http://www.reversemortgagelendersdirect.com/reverse-mortgage-calculator/
http://www.reversemortgagelendersdirect.com/reverse-mortgages-pros-and-cons/
http://www.reversemortgagelendersdirect.com/florida-reverse-mortgage/
05:47 PM on 04/07/2012
VERY unfortunately, the Obama White house and economic team are focused, not on jobs and poverty, but on the 1% and keeping interest rates low.

The Bank Bailout/TARP --COULD HAVE-- included provisions to stimulate job growth through aggressive M2 money supply expansion/direct spending/jobs programs like wind power investments or expanded home insulation tax credits, etc. But instead, they just sent the money to the banks and wealthiest wealth hoarders who locked it up...leading to our current LIQUIDITY TRAP.

And Romney policies would surely be worse or at least more of the same. What to do, what to do?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:51 AM on 04/07/2012
A 2004 op-ed by Senator Schumer and Paul Craig Roberts...

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/06/opinion/second-thoughts-on-free-trade.html
Second Thoughts on Free Trade - New York Times

"...Yet in that essay of 70 years ago, Keynes himself was beginning to question some of the assumption­s supporting free trade. The question today is whether the case for free trade made two centuries ago is undermined by the changes now evident in the modern global economy.

Two recent examples illustrate this concern. Over the next three years, a major New York securities firm plans to replace its team of 800 American software engineers, who each earns about $150,000 per year, with an equally competent team in India earning an average of only $20,000. Second, within five years the number of radiologis­ts in this country is expected to decline significan­tly because M.R.I. data can be sent over the Internet to Asian radiologis­ts capable of diagnosing the problem at a small fraction of the cost.

[snip]

We are concerned that the United States may be entering a new economic era in which American workers will face direct global competitio­n at almost every job level -- from the machinist to the software engineer to the Wall Street analyst. Any worker whose job does not require daily face-to-fa­ce interactio­n is now in jeopardy of being replaced by a lower-paid­, equally skilled worker thousands of miles away..."

How prescient.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:43 PM on 04/06/2012
What's most interesting, besides the low paying nature of the jobs, is that 3/4 of the jobs are going to people over 55 years old. Teenage unemployment number just go higher and higher. With the lower value of the dollar and bond rates near zero, older people are having to work and employers prefer them to the new crop of entry level applicants.
rdk70816
Yellowhammer
02:16 PM on 04/06/2012
Correct the problem. Fire Obama.
photo
JWerner
Beware Macduff; beware the thane of Fife!
08:38 PM on 04/06/2012
Wrong.
rdk70816
Yellowhammer
10:52 AM on 04/07/2012
So you don't think there is a problem.
05:39 PM on 04/07/2012
Wrong. Go drink your tea on the highway.
rdk70816
Yellowhammer
04:24 AM on 04/08/2012
No tea for you!
photo
teardownthiswallst
Only Truth will set us Free
11:37 AM on 04/06/2012
Low wage jobs are the only type corporations are interested in creating. Henry Ford’s philosophy is as dead as he is in the corporate realm. Major corporations are unwaveringly committed to the empty philosophy of maximizing profits by: eliminating jobs, driving up productivity by threatening job loss, minimizing benefits and wages for existing employees, reducing pay standards for new workers, busting unions, and outsourcing. We have entered the Wall Mart zone.

Major corporations sit on a trillion dollars in cash, while small businesses who still show some interest in creating decent jobs, and remain more committed to their workforce, are cash strapped and cannot get a loan. The vast majority of hiring is being done by corporations determined to slash wages and benefits.

The one truth coming out of corporations is that demand is low. Create some decent jobs and demand will go up. Give you employees a raise and demand will increase. Build alternative energy products and demand will rise.

The greatest fallacy being spread is the notion that the people without jobs are not skilled enough to fit corporate needs. This is not new; when unemployment rates are high, companies raise their hiring standards to unrealistic levels. They currently hold such an advantage on this front, they are able to insist a prospective employee should be capable of preforming brain surgery to be qualified to empty a bedpan.

They roll out every excuse in the book to excuse themselves from hiring.

Greed and gluttony know no bounds.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:47 PM on 04/06/2012
What a clueless view of reality. Henry Ford made it possible for blue collar workers to afford homes and still keep prices such that they could afford to buy the car they built. It was revolutionary and Detroit was an economic miracle of its time. And then the unions, using the false rhetoric you just spewed, bled it dry until Detroit is the post apocalyptic hell hole it is today.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MSROADKILL612
love auto biographys. any appS to write mine?
11:43 AM on 04/07/2012
possibly, but management was not innocent

what ridiculous xenophobic cars they made - the japanese ate them alive
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
liberalcomesfromliberty
Stand Strong for Change!
11:28 AM on 04/06/2012
That's because the US has hit a ceiling and has a saturated economy. People can't afford houses costing $400,000 dollars and expect to make wages that will support it. America has hit the growing ceiling. Prices need to start coming down to match wages but we know the investors who depend on grow do not want that you happen.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:51 PM on 04/06/2012
People never could afford the homes at that price. The prices did what they did because of artificial subsidies by a government that insured poor lending practices leading to a bubble. Prices, and sizes, need to come down to supportable level. We've been living in a standard of living bubble for decades and that bubble is going to deflate, one way or another. Stimulus efforts and government programs (see student loan bubble) are only making that bubble a little bit bigger and the eventual pop a whole lot more dramatic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MSROADKILL612
love auto biographys. any appS to write mine?
11:53 AM on 04/07/2012
yep - & the cost of basic tax & services also - its all a function of wages - u can only squeeze the golden goose so hard

a survivalist mate reckons u gotta get land w/ a septic, water on site - do u own power & heat - am beginning to think he is right
photo
exchef100
Reality has a liberal bias.
10:43 AM on 04/06/2012
Corporations refuse to make any sort of sacrifices in order to help the citizens of the country that allowed them to become as powerful as they are. Profits over everything. What happened to giving back to the community?
11:29 AM on 04/06/2012
They are giving back to the global community of luxury and wealth. All the expensive brands are booming. Art and luxury property booming. Luxury cars and yachts booming. That is their idea of giving back.

There are very expensive stereo systems using hi-tech sampling of music which is far superior to digitized sound ordinary folk listen to. There are super HD TV systems only the rich can afford. There are 7 star hotels over $1000 a night.

Hyper-consumption is their way of giving back.
photo
exchef100
Reality has a liberal bias.
01:52 PM on 04/06/2012
So they are only benefiting luxury retailers.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Midnight Cry
Tax Reform Now!
10:39 AM on 04/06/2012
This admin doesn't have a clue for job creation. Community organizing and A C O R N doesn't pay much.
01:39 PM on 04/06/2012
Henri Ford realized that you have to pay employees enough to buy your products. We are in the greed race to the bottom. Obama has nothing to do with this!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:35 AM on 04/06/2012
Low paying jobs are those that allows one to afford the basic necessities of life ... barely. Many times one has to juggle if it's possible to float a bill for 2 weeks to use the money for some other necessity that's more urgent. And if a serious medical situation arises, one has to ask forgiveness for being late on payments due with the promise to make up the differences within a 30 day period hoping there's not going to be added interested added to the late payment making it more difficult to meet that new obligation..
photo
JWerner
Beware Macduff; beware the thane of Fife!
08:41 PM on 04/06/2012
And all the while, we have 'small government' folks seeking to make things worse for those who are barely keeping their heads above the water.
kevinclennon
print the money ben
09:57 AM on 04/06/2012
We've made people soft in this country. I remember when people would work two jobs to provide for thier family. The only good thing about progressive policys is they make people lazy so the hard working people can succed. Its time people put on their big boy pants and do something about it. The goverment is not the answer its in the individual not the collective.
PROGRESSISGOOD
Without Economic Justice, There Is No Justice!
10:13 AM on 04/06/2012
I remember in the 1970's when a high school graduate (my father) could have a job that would support his entire family on one income, with full medical coverage and a pension. We owned our own home and had two cars in the garage (and so did every other family in our community).

Then Reagan and the conservatives took over and look what happened. You can't provide that quality of life with two college graduates working full time.
photo
exchef100
Reality has a liberal bias.
10:31 AM on 04/06/2012
F&F.
kevinclennon
print the money ben
10:36 AM on 04/06/2012
Your right I tell my Father every time I see him that his generation really screwed us over. He just smiles and tells me about that reverse mortgage the goverment backs. How many more like this? Progressive Ideas have put us in this sitituation. you think a conserviative ideas make people think this way? How much money have we spent on the war against poverty sense President Johnson. How much has poverty gone down? 4%? My opnion differs from your I believe we've made people soft and have destroyed the family.
01:41 PM on 04/06/2012
And a system the has been legislated and bent to funnel wealth to the 1% (Remember our wealth inequality is worse than some third world countries) has nothing to do with it? Illogical at best!
kevinclennon
print the money ben
07:25 PM on 04/06/2012
thats a excuse, Its someone elses fault i can't prosper? social justice leads down a slippery slope.
photo
Angrykitteh
You're on double secret probation....
07:41 AM on 04/06/2012
When these figures first broke a couple of months ago, I asked where are these jobs? For how much pay? Are they temp or perm? I was accused of Bo bashing. lol Seems my questions were on target.....
01:43 PM on 04/06/2012
Yes, we need to ask these questions of our Plutocrat corporate masters, not Obama. He is just a paper boat in a sea of greed.
photo
Angrykitteh
You're on double secret probation....
01:48 PM on 04/06/2012
Well, the thing is, those questions I asked a couple of months ago were of a general nature. Not directed at Bo. I was genuinely curious. And then I got smacked.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BinghamLofts
07:35 AM on 04/06/2012
my first job was just ten hours per week working work study through my high school doing some standard office work in a government office. the pay was 2ds per hour and my parents opened a savings account and put the money there for me. from then on, i had a love of work. i was in my early teens in high school of course and i loved it.
kevinclennon
print the money ben
10:09 AM on 04/06/2012
This is the only good thing about progressive policys. They make it easier for the hard working people. How? What is the percentage of white working males today? Progressive policys first destroyed the black family now they want to destroy the white family. The spanish maybe the saving grace because family is strong with this group.
photo
exchef100
Reality has a liberal bias.
10:34 AM on 04/06/2012
How did progressive policies destroy families?
10:09 AM on 04/06/2012
I had a nice $4.25 an hour job as a cart boy when I was 13 and worked about 20 hours a week. Sadly, I make 10x that now and seemingly have less money to spend on things I want.

I think kids these days need a lesson in what things will cost when they are independent. It might make a large difference in what kind of class and career choices they make.

30K sounds great when your 18.. until you try to live on it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BinghamLofts
07:32 AM on 04/06/2012
the media is only reporting the incredible economic recovery taking place.
photo
Angrykitteh
You're on double secret probation....
07:39 AM on 04/06/2012
God, I hope that's sarcasm.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:27 AM on 04/06/2012
America is Easter Island. We have erected great edifices and now we are approaching the last tree.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DocJoseph
A bleeding heart will heal; a cold heart will not
03:02 PM on 04/06/2012
Very interesting analogy. Scary even. I might have picked a different one, but the prognosis isn't that different.

In my vision, we will become an agrarian economy with masses of people either without jobs or working for low wages.

Oops, looks like we're approaching low wage nirvana.