iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Is Time Travel Real? Physicists Say It Happens All The Time

Posted: 04/17/2012 7:58 am Updated: 04/17/2012 7:58 am

Time Travel

By: Adam Hadhazy, Life's Little Mysteries Contributor
Published: 04/16/2012 12:32 PM EDT on Lifes Little Mysteries

In this weekly series, Life's Little Mysteries rates the plausibility of popular science fiction concepts.

In the first "Back to the Future" movie, all it took to travel through time was 1.21 gigawatts and a flux capacitor (packed into a DeLorean sports car for style points). Despite centuries of dreams and decades of bona fide research, flux capacitors remain beyond our grasp, as do any other time travel-enabling devices.

From a pure physics point of view, travel into the future is not at all impossible and in fact happens all the . . . time. With all due respect to Doc Brown, however, backward time travel stacks up as a much tougher proposition.

"We can travel at different rates to the future," said Seth Lloyd, a professor of quantum mechanical engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "To go into the past and mess around with it, that's more controversial."

My watch or yours?

For a real, everyday example of time travel, consider the satellites of the Global Positioning System. Were it not for built-in calibrations, the GPS atomic clocks would gain 38 microseconds over terrestrial timepieces every day, throwing off their location accuracy by several miles. "Clocks on Earth tick a tiny bit slower than satellites out in space," said Lloyd.

The reason: time dilation, as described by Einstein's two theories of relativity. According to the special theory, the faster an object moves relative to another object, the slower it experiences time. For GPS satellites zooming around Earth at nearly 9,000 mph (14,000 kph), this effect cuts seven microseconds off their clocks daily (relative to clocks on Earth).

The second effect, explained by the general theory of relativity, involves gravity. Clocks closer to the center of a gravitational mass, such as Earth, tick more slowly than those farther away. GPS satellites orbit 12,500 miles (20,100 km) above the ground, and as a result have 45 microseconds tacked onto their clocks per day. The net result of the two relativistic phenomena is 38 microseconds, which engineers have accounted for with GPS technology.

Future, here we come

Both of these time dilation pathways — motion through space or a strong gravity well — permit time travel into the future.

A popular imagining of the first scenario involves astronauts cruising aboard a rocket ship at extremely high speed to a distant star. Upon their return, the ship's occupants will have aged mere years while centuries have passed on Earth. (An unintended version of this situation befalls Charlton Heston and his crew in the original 1968 movie "Planet of the Apes.")

Pulling off such a feat is really only a matter of investment, technology and will. "Doing 'century hopping' via relativity will require some engineering solutions to things like building rocket engines with enough fuel supplies for very prolonged trips," said Jeff Tollaksen, a professor of physics at Chapman University in Orange, Calif. [7 Everyday Things That Happen Strangely in Space]

Going to a distant star and back would not even be necessary — all that is required is motion. The time-traveling effect would be achieved by simply getting whirled in a giant centrifuge at near-light speeds, Tollaksen said (though it would kill whoever attempted it).

The second, gravity-based scenario poses similar lethality, at least for someone wanting an appreciable difference in his relative time frame. If you stood on a neutron star for a few years, a decade would elapse on Earth. Of course, you would not survive the supermassive star's crushing, rending gravity, making this approach truly a "Rip" van Winkle method.

Yesteryears

What of diving into the past? According to general relativity, a rotating black hole can warp space-time, forming paths to previous moments. "You have these so-called timelike curves that you could follow that would take you back to your past," said Lloyd. [What Would It Be Like to Travel Faster than the Speed of Light?]

Quantum mechanics has opened up strange avenues as well. Experiments have shown that measuring a particle property at an initial and end stage can modify its middle value, but only if the last measurement takes place. Such clues toward a possible "backwards causality" continue to be investigated.

A major showstopper for traveling back in time, however, is common sense. A classic example is the grandfather paradox, in which a time traveler goes into the past and murders his grandfather, thus preventing the time traveler from ever being born.

Yet there might be ways around this mind-bender. Lloyd has conducted quantum mechanical experiments in the last few years that suggest timelines remain self-consistent. The tests served as "the moral equivalent of sending a photon a few billionths of a second backwards in time and having it try to kill its former self," Lloyd said.

In Lloyd's experiment, as photons got ever closer to interfering with themselves, the probability of the experiment succeeding grew ever lower. "Our theory has an automatic censorship of things which are completely inconsistent," said Lloyd. "When you go back [in time], no matter how hard you try, you cannot change the thing you try to change."

In theory, then, Grandpa lives, no matter what.

Space-time busters?

A couple of other domains offer hope for would-be time travelers. Moving faster than light — the universal reference point — would do the trick, hence the excitement over last year's finding in Europe of superluminal neutrinos, a seemingly impossible finding that has been widely faulted.

Wormholes — theoretical "tunnels" through space-time — also could burrow into the past or future just as they might connect different regions in the cosmos.

Neither of these alternatives seems particularly likely. As much as many of us might hate to admit it, the past, with all of its mistakes, could remain sealed off from our efforts to redo it.

"Even if the laws of physics allowed visiting the past," Lloyd said, "it is not clear how it might actually happen in our universe."

Plausibility score: A one-way ticket to the future requires a hefty budget and a heck of a lot of engineering know-how. Voyaging into the past, however, looks to be near impossible, so we give time travel two out of four Rocketboys.

Copyright 2012 Lifes Little Mysteries, a TechMediaNetwork company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW SCIENCE

By: Adam Hadhazy, Life's Little Mysteries Contributor Published: 04/16/2012 12:32 PM EDT on Lifes Little Mysteries In this weekly series, Life's Little Mysteries rates the plausibility of popular ...
By: Adam Hadhazy, Life's Little Mysteries Contributor Published: 04/16/2012 12:32 PM EDT on Lifes Little Mysteries In this weekly series, Life's Little Mysteries rates the plausibility of popular ...
Filed by Jacqueline Howard  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 471
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
07:15 AM on 04/16/2013
Please can you analysis my web site www.timeflow.org And my formula 'Time Flow=Time/Energy' ? In addition, You can find in my web site in http://www.chronos.msu.ru/rweblinks.html 'Personal Sites and Web-Pages' . Thanks.
02:10 AM on 01/02/2013
It's very simple... The past has already happened. If, at this very moment, you were thrust back in time, it wouldn't matter what you did because every action you take is part of your present. The very idea of thinking you can change something, as soon as you set it in motion, all you have done is begun the chain of events that led to everything you're trying to change into happening the way you remember it. The butterfly effect is a nice theory, but the reality is that what ever happened, happened. If given the tools to change history, all you will succeed in doing is making sure history happens the way it happened.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DARK STAR
One small step for Man...
09:32 AM on 11/10/2012
We want time travel to be in our terms within our physical universe laws. It would be, and involve, much more than what we already know.

Time travel certainly exists, how else could we conceive of it? It is simply not accesible to our current understanding and will not be about saving a species from extinction or silly paradox like meeting yourself.

It may have been discovered in the 70's though, which would explain disco in a good way.
01:41 PM on 10/28/2012
Why not use time travel to bring extinct species that man exterminated, like the Passenger Pigeon and the Carolina Parakeet, back to our time, and repopulate them here in the 21st Century? If of course, a working time machine can be built.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Jeff Wolverton
(not my real name)
09:46 PM on 10/25/2012
The "grandfather paradox" is always bugged the hell out of me as it is so poorly stated. (Heck, go back ten years and try to kill MY grandfather-- and good luck, 'cuz you'd have to dig him up first.)

Obviously they mean "kill him before he conceives your father or mother, depending on which grandfather he is" which still begs the question; isn't it a simpler paradox to go back and kill your father before you were conceived? Why is the 2nd generation needed for this paradox?

Heck, why not make it far simpler by calling it the "try to go back in time and kill your former self" paradox, which needs to checking on pregnancies at all?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chuck The Canuck
Old too soon, smart too late.
05:35 PM on 05/27/2012
If you are willing to accept the fact that the reality you find yourself is just one many possible realities, the grandfather paradox can be disregarded. If you did travel back in time and killed your grandfather, you would not be born in that reality, but because you did exist when you returned to kill him, you must have been born in a different reality, or universe. Modern physics tells us that not only is this universe one of many possible universes, but that these possible universes do exist. If you were able to go back in time to kill your grandfather, this would be proof positive that those many possible universes do exist.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rpokeytruck
07:34 AM on 04/20/2012
What is interesting it in general the universe is constucted with common sence from the mico to the macro, there are repairing functions to keep everything in balance. I wonder what the time function is balanceing?
07:26 AM on 04/20/2012
Time and Space are two concepts that can not be defined as of now.
In fact it has not been done so till date.
At best some explanations are given.
Time Travel is real and possible at all times.
Events are taking place, have taken place are taking place and will take place-all at the same time.
For example, 'The Exodus',it took place,has taken place ,is taking place and will take place at the same time.This applies to any event.
This can be appreciated if one were to understand that Time/Space is not linear( as understood now by Science);and that it is Non-linear and Cyclic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mario andretti
I can't drive 55.
05:46 PM on 04/19/2012
Even stopped clocks travel in time twice a day.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rpokeytruck
07:29 AM on 04/20/2012
they hate hearing that
03:30 AM on 04/19/2012
So what about going to the future? According to M-Theory, and most scientists, here is what would most likely happen. If you decide to go to the future to find your old self, you WON'T. Why? Because you ARE yourself. If you are in universe [A], and leave to accelerate jump 50 years into universe [A], you will not have aged, and time would continue as it normally would, but without your existence. So you are therefore in universe [A-2], which was slightly altered by removing yourself. From universe [A-2]'s perspective, you ceased to exist until you came back not having aged a bit. But back in the untouched universe [A-1], you merely disappeared. So universe [A-1] and [A-2] originated as the same universe [A], but branched off into two alternate realities, just as universe [A] and [B] were the same until you killed your grandfather before you were born. They all stem from each other into hypothetical realities and futures. Now, if you decide to go back to where you last disappeared and decided to pick up where you left off back in universe [A-1], you remain in universe [A-1] with no change as if you never time traveled. Therefore [A-2] is no longer part of universe [A] but becomes an alternate reality giving it another designation [C]. These designations are simply to identify the branches of realities for the traveler, but it is irrelevant as there are infinite possibilities.
03:16 AM on 04/19/2012
According to M-Theory, if you alter the original timeline [A], you create an alternate timeline/reality [B], with a series of different events. Now, you remain in [B] unable to ever go to [A], even if you are from [A]. But we believe that [A] still exists the way it should be abstractly and simultaneously outside of the universe, contributing to the theory that multiple, parallel universes exist in infinite number, one differing from the other even in the slightest to catastrophic way, hypothetically "would-be's". From the perspective of universe [A], the only difference is that you disappeared forever, while in [B] you never existed until your first appearance was when you came from the hypothetical future. Although the events have changed, grandpa still had you and you still exist, you just came from another reality. So to avoid being stuck in the past and creating an alternate reality, DON'T go back, even if you can. Chances are, this is how backwards time travel would work. But don't ever try if you could.
03:11 AM on 04/19/2012
If you ever call a friend that watching the same show in another country, you will notice that the farther away in distance the friend is from you, the more inaccurate and inconsistent the sounds are between your televisions. One may seem more ahead than the other. More likely the one closer to the equator (gravity source) will be faster, even if it is by a fraction of a second. Time does not flow evenly as we notice, as aliens in another part of the universe may have a clock that moves in no way like ours, even if they feel time as we done. We perceive time and are affected by time as it is. So if you're in the Eridanus system watching Earth with Earth's clock, you may see that we are moving 10x faster than your clock. So who has the right time? EVERYONE. However, with enough speed and energy, one can witness the FAR future. Yet we still do not know how physics will allow us to go back, although it does happen in space fluctuations. If hypothetically we do go backwards, it is unclear what will happen.
02:55 AM on 04/19/2012
Sorry, but I saw too many contradictions on this page. Physics have specific laws that not only permit time travel, but prove that it happens all the time. The only reason why we can't travel through time is because we don't have the physical or technological means. Time has proven to not be an abstract idea. It isn't dictated by a clock, or an illusion in the mind. It actually exists. Although it cannot be seen, heard, tasted, smelt, or felt, our senses show us the effects that it exists. Motion, is the primary clue. The fact that you are moving is the first piece of evidence, along with aging. Without time, everything would remain fixed. Or rather, the physical universe could not exist. Time is elastic, and flows like a stream, not like water, but like a rubbery, elastic flow of seeping and stretching "goo", if you will. It can be played with and bend, as certain parts of space move irregularly as does time. Speed, distance, and gravity also show the difference in time.
08:56 PM on 04/23/2012
Do you have a blog? I enjoy reading your posts....
02:37 PM on 04/25/2012
very impressed with your theory of time.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dwight Robertson
Less is More
10:31 PM on 04/18/2012
See you tomorrow, today
06:49 PM on 04/18/2012
While Einstein-en relativity does allow for time travel under extreme conditions of
gravity or velocity, I contend time travel will never be practical for humanity due to
the insurmountable conjugation of verbs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
julesmu84
12:42 AM on 04/20/2012
A true writer's response to a scientific article. Love it! You're my funny of the day - thank you for that. Fanned & Faved!