It arrived at his Northern Virginia home last month.
McMurry told WTTG-TV/FOX5 he has "no idea" how the postcard, sent from Chicago's Shedd Aquarium, became lost for all these years, before being delivered to him in a large white envelope by a Virginia postmaster.
"I was just very pleasantly surprised," McMurry told the television station. "I can't say I was overwhelmed with emotion. I was just very pleasantly surprised. I was glad to have it."
"We'll probably be home before this gets there!" the postcard reads. "We are having a real good time. Hope you are all right."
WJLA-TV/ABC7 reports that the post office hasn't yet explained why the postcard took more than half a century to reach its intended recipient.
McMurry, a retired historian, told Fox5 he plans to frame the postcard. He's also planning to visit the Shedd Aquarium, which ABC7 reports has offered to give McMurry special tour.
The Morning Email helps you start your workday with everything you need to know: breaking news, entertainment and a dash of fun. Learn more