iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

John Edwards Trial: Testimony Reveals Elizabeth Edwards' Dramatic Confrontation With Husband Over Affair

By MICHAEL BIESECKER 05/ 2/12 09:12 PM ET AP

Elizabeth Edwards

GREENSBORO, N.C. — A former adviser to John Edwards recounted Wednesday how the former presidential candidate's now-deceased wife indignantly confronted her husband, baring her chest in front of staff members the day after a tabloid reported that he was cheating on her.

During a session at Edwards' corruption trial that saw his 30-year-old daughter flee the courtroom in tears, Christina Reynolds described how a very upset Elizabeth Edwards stormed away from her husband in October 2007, then collapsed in a ball on the pavement outside a private airplane hangar. Reynolds and another woman guided the anguished wife into a nearby ladies room to compose herself, but she soon returned to the private hangar to again confront her husband.

In front of several staff members, the woman who had endured grueling treatments for breast cancer took off her shirt and bra, exposing her chest.

"'You don't see me anymore,'" Reynolds quoted Elizabeth Edwards as screaming. "He didn't have much of a reaction."

As staffers scrambled to cover up Edwards' wife and huddle her into a car, Reynolds heard the Democratic candidate use a cell phone to call his wife's doctor to ask for help.

Edwards then boarded a waiting jet and took off for his scheduled appearance in South Carolina, Reynolds said.

She testified that Elizabeth Edwards had known about her husband's affair with Rielle Hunter before The National Enquirer made it public. Hers was the most stirring testimony of the day at Edwards' trial on corruption charges, as prosecutors worked to build a timeline of the affair and efforts to cover it up.

Shortly before Reynolds began her account of what happened that day at the Raleigh airport, Edwards turned to his daughter Cate, a lawyer who has been seated in the front row for much of her father's trial.

"I don't know what's coming," Edwards was heard saying. "Do you want to leave?"

She responded to him in a whisper, grabbed her purse and walked out, wiping away tears. Edwards was heard saying, "Cate, Cate" as she left. She returned to court about a half hour later, after a brief recess.

Shortly before her testimony about the airport argument, Reynolds recounted that Elizabeth Edwards asked her over to the couple's gated estate near Chapel Hill in the summer of 2007 to tell her that her husband had confessed to an affair the prior year.

"I was very surprised by what she told me and I didn't want it to ever become public so the kids wouldn't have to know about it," the former aide said.

Reynolds, now 37, had worked on John Edwards' successful U.S. senate campaign in 1998 and had quickly bonded with his wife. Both women grew up in military families and had moved around a lot as children. Reynolds worked as the research director and a senior communications adviser to the 2008 presidential campaign and recently joined the board of the educational foundation named for Elizabeth Edwards, who died in December of 2010.

Edwards has pleaded not guilty to six counts related to campaign-finance violations. He faces up to 30 years in prison and $1.5 million in fines if convicted on all counts.

At issue are payments from wealthy donors used to help keep his pregnant mistress out of public view. Edwards' attorneys have said he didn't know about the money.

Earlier Wednesday, jurors heard from another aide who discussed topics ranging from the night the candidate met his mistress to how he charmed the wealthy donor whose money would be used to cover up the affair.

Josh Brumberger, now 33, was having drinks with Edwards in the bar of an upscale New York hotel in February 2006 when they were first approached by Hunter. He frequently traveled with Edwards and said it was not unusual for strange women to come up to him. The former aide said he politely helped extricate the candidate from the conversation.

Sometime later, Brumberger saw Edwards returning alone from dinner and surrounded by a group of women that included Hunter. He ran outside to once again politely get his boss out of the conversation.

"My normal bag of tricks included, `Got a big day tomorrow, got to rest,'" he recalled.

Weeks later, Brumberger said, the woman began traveling with Edwards to film behind-the-scenes footage. At the time, Edwards had yet to declare his candidacy.

Brumberger couldn't place her at first, but within days he realized that she was the woman from the hotel. Hunter was paid through a political action committee supporting Edwards.

"It was a cause of concern," the former aide testified, adding that he told Edwards the new videographer "looked a little nutty." He said he Googled Hunter's name and found her personal web site, the contents of which he described as "sex, drugs, rock n' roll astrology."

Brumberger said his misgivings grew after Hunter demanded to travel with Edwards on private jets, rather than commercial flights like other staff and consultants.

"Ms. Hunter felt she pretty much had an all-access pass to everything," he said. "I disagreed."

Brumberger said he attempted to bar Hunter from the flights, but the candidate overruled him.

Edwards also ordered Brumberger to make sure the PAC paid for Hunter's health insurance, unheard-of for a consultant not on the full-time staff. Concerns were also raised among senior staff that Hunter didn't appear to know much about shooting video. Tapes filmed by Hunter played for the jury showed shaky camera work where those speaking were sometimes not in focus or not in the frame at all.

"It was shoddy and unprofessional," Brumberger said.

Brumberger also described accompanying Edwards on his first trip to the Virginia estate of donor Rachel "Bunny" Mellon in December 2005. The visit unfolded pleasantly with her recounting her visits to the Kennedy White House, where she helped plant the rose garden.

Soon after, the wealthy heiress made the first in a series of substantial donations to Edwards' political committees and his anti-poverty foundation that would eventually total more than $6 million.

Prosecutors said Edwards used money from Mellon, who's now 101, and another wealthy donor to hide the mistress. Edwards' attorneys have said he didn't know it was being used to hide her and that another former aide, Andrew Young, spent much of it on his dream house.

Brumberger described how Edwards and his associates made efforts to stay in touch with Mellon, including calling on her birthday and sending flowers. Brumberger said that it was typical for Edwards to have "call time" with major donors.

Months after the first meeting with Mellon, Brumberger was traveling with Edwards when he called her on her birthday from North Dakota. Brumberger sent Young – a key adviser – an email that it had gone well.

"JRE called. Bunny is still in LOVE," Brumberger wrote in the email, referring to Edwards by his initials.

After the email was displayed in court on Wednesday, prosecutors asked Brumberger what it meant.

"I believe what I meant by that is Ms. Mellon was still supportive of Mr. Edwards's causes," Brumberger testified to laughter in the courtroom.

Prosecutors have said Mellon offered under-the-table cash to cover Edwards' personal expenses after the candidate was embarrassed by media reports that campaign funds were used to pay for $400 haircuts.

Weeks later, Hunter informed the candidate she was pregnant. According to the account in Young's 2010 tell-all book about the affair, Edwards was unable to access his own money to support Hunter without his wife, Elizabeth, finding out. So, Young says, Edwards decided to take Mellon up on her offer.

For most of 2006, Hunter traveled with Edwards for months to meetings across the country, as well as on an overseas trip to Africa.

Concerned about the affair, Brumberger said he twice tried confronting his boss. After Edwards made no effort to send Hunter away, Brumberger said he talked to two senior staff members.

Edwards learned of the meeting and confronted Brumberger in a private lounge at the Chicago airport just before the men were supposed to board a plane to China.

Using expletives, Edwards began yelling and his face turned red.

"He said he couldn't trust me anymore," Brumberger recounted. Edwards informed the aide that he might be fired.

Brumberger said he quit, instead.

"I told Mr. Edwards I was no longer interested in working for him," Brumberger said. "I was kind of in shock."

It was almost exactly a year before news of Edwards' affair began to tumble out in the heat of the Democratic primary campaign.

___

Follow AP writer Michael Biesecker at twitter.com/mbieseck

Below, highlights of Hunter's 2010 GQ interview detailing her affair with Edwards.
Loading Slideshow...
  • Love At First Sight?

    "And when they left, my friend went over and asked Tony if that was John Edwards, and he said yes. And my friend turned to me and said, 'See, I told you it was John Edwards.' And then I came over to the table, and I said, 'I can't believe that was John Edwards; he's so hot. He's really got it going on. He's got something unusual about him, and I never would have recognized him.' And Tony said, 'Oh, my God, you should have come over and told him that. He would have loved to have heard that.'"

  • An Extraordinary Night

    "We had an extraordinary night, and I did know that this was unlike anything either of us had ever experienced. And as we have all learned, that was accurate! [laughs] He in fact did say to me the first night, 'Falling in love with you could really [screw] up my plans for becoming President.' And of course I said, 'If you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans.'"

  • The Oddest Connection He Had Ever Felt

    "Well, what Johnny later told me was, he went to dinner and could not stop thinking about me, like, 'Who was that woman, and why didn't I go over and talk to her?' ... So when he walked around the corner and saw me standing there, he lit up like a Christmas tree. And I thought his reaction when he saw me was just so cute. I mean, he looked like a little kid at Christmas. And I just uttered to him, 'You're so hot.' And he said, 'Why, thank you!' And he almost jumped into my arms. Literally. And um, that's how we met. On the corner of 61st and Park Avenue."

  • 'I Had To Sleep With Him'

    "I used to make a joke that I could have helped save the world, but I had to sleep with him. You know? It was kind of like that."

  • Falling In Love

    "I fell in love with Johnny ... He called me the next day. We talked on the phone almost every night for four hours. We met on February 21. On February 25—on the phone, from Davenport, Iowa—I fell in love with him. Head over heels in love. I was a goner."

  • Here's ... Johnny!

    "Isn't that funny? You know, when I first met him, the first week of our relationship, I said to him, 'For some reason I cannot call you John, it doesn't come out. Could I call you Johnny?' And he said, 'That's my name.' And I didn't know that, but that's his actual birth name."

  • Knight In Shining Armor?

    "I had this thing in my head like a lot of women, where you want your man to stand up on a cliff and scream, 'I LOVE HER.' You know, the knight in shining armor. And that wasn't what was going on."

  • On Her Relationship Status

    "I am not engaged."

  • Why She's Talking Now

    "I feel comfortable talking now, because Johnny went public and made a statement admitting paternity. I didn't feel like I could ever speak until he did that. Because had I spoken, I would have emasculated him. And I could not emasculate him. Also, it is not my desire to teach my daughter that when Mommy's upset with Daddy, you take matters into your own hands and fix Daddy's mistakes. Which I view as one of the biggest problems in all female-and-male relationships."

  • Not A Gold Digger

    "I mean, just for starters, I never 'hit on' Johnny. I'm not a predator, I'm not a gold digger, I'm not the stalker. I didn't have any power in that way in our relationship. He held all the power."

  • 'The Wrath Of Elizabeth Is A Mighty Wrath'

    "And I believe what happened in his marriage is, he could not go to his wife and say, 'We have an issue.' Because he would be pummeled. So he had a huge fear. Most of his mistakes or errors in judgment were because of his fear of the wrath of Elizabeth. He's allowed himself to be pushed into a lot of things that he wouldn't normally do because of Elizabeth's story line. And the spin that she wants to put out there. He was emasculated. And you know, the wrath of Elizabeth is a mighty wrath."

  • 'I Was A Bit Promiscuous'

    "I was never, as it's been reported, a drug addict. The word addiction means inability to stop. I stopped doing drugs in my twenties. As for being promiscuous, I would say that I was a bit promiscuous for about six months. But it was because I was partying, and there were a lot of very good-looking available 20-year-old men around that you'd be partying with, and there was a lot of, you know, hooking up going on."

  • A Toxic Relationship

    "[Elizabeth] was in denial about a lot of facts. And I say she was in denial because, you know, their relationship has been dysfunctional and toxic and awful for many, many years. And she was aware of, um, problems and chose to ignore them."

  • 'I Don't Really Believe He Was A Politician'

    "Well, I don't really believe he was a politician. I believe his ego and ambition drove him to that field. I believe he's more aligned with being a humanitarian. That suits his true nature. Just like I wasn't a mistress. You know, I'm not a mistress, but I played the role? I believe he played the role of a politician. It's not who he is. Being a politician was a path of transformation for him, I believe. It's not really what he was put on the planet to do."

  • Not A 'Home Wrecker'

    "And, well, first of all, infidelity doesn't happen in healthy marriages. The break in the marriage happens before the infidelity. And that break happened, you know, two and a half decades before I got there. So the home was wrecked already. I was not the Home Wrecker."

  • Naming Frances Quinn Hunter

    "Her name is Frances Quinn Hunter, and I love the name Frances. Johnny wasn't over the moon about Frances. So I was coming up with names, and Quinn is a name that I loved, and that was the only name that he thought was cool. And so I named her Quinn because Daddy really liked it."

  • Was Andrew Young In Love With Edwards?

    "Andrew [Young] was in love with Johnny...In love with him. Beyond. And I believe he loved Johnny more than he loved Cheri. So Johnny was the third person in their relationship. And I'm sure she hates Johnny, because Andrew took a lot of obvious actions that were for Johnny and not for Cheri. But Cheri went along with them. And they both have a way of spinning things. But a lot of their motivation is money."

FOLLOW POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
GREENSBORO, N.C. — A former adviser to John Edwards recounted Wednesday how the former presidential candidate's now-deceased wife indignantly confronted her husband, baring her chest in front of...
GREENSBORO, N.C. — A former adviser to John Edwards recounted Wednesday how the former presidential candidate's now-deceased wife indignantly confronted her husband, baring her chest in front of...
Filed by Mollie Reilly  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 3,057
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (56 total)
05:56 PM on 05/07/2012
That poor woman went to her grave humilated and here still he is still dragging her and HIS children through it some more. ENOUGH John, when will you admit you made a mistake and face the music. What are you teaching your children? How to apply grease and slink and slim your way throught it...WOW your a lucky man that your grown children will even speak to you! You don't deserve such a kindness.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ACarole
Liberal-Progressive-In Search of Critical Thinkers
07:41 PM on 05/04/2012
I wondered, at the time, why John Kerry conceded so quickly to GW. Now I think we know why. Kerry must have been told about this mess and knew it was over once this all hit the mainstream in a big way, and it would. GW didn't defeat Kerry .... John Edwards did. What a mess, and an all to familiar story.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Ian Gord
Resist we much !
12:00 PM on 05/04/2012
As Edwards said, "There are two Americas, and I'm having sex in both of them."
11:25 PM on 05/03/2012
He was an idiot in all things, if he ever cared for his wife he shoud have divorced her.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jdollinter
11:00 PM on 05/03/2012
How can John Edwards be trusted to run a Nation when he can't even be trusted to control John Jr ? This egotistical sociopath belongs behind bars where he can't hurt any more people.
10:51 AM on 05/04/2012
He cannot and incidentally IS NOT trusted to "run a nation." You may recall that he was not on the ballot at election time. He stands a really good chance of being behind bars, also.
10:57 PM on 05/03/2012
Why is the daughter allowing herself to be used as a prop at this trial?
10:52 AM on 05/04/2012
He is her father and she probably loves him.
01:09 PM on 05/04/2012
that doesn't answer the question
02:54 PM on 05/07/2012
Why is her father allowing her to be part of this filth? If he loves her, he should tell her to stay away.
10:53 PM on 05/03/2012
I reject the Elizabeth Edwards beatification movement! She was a tough, vulgar broad who was completely self-absorbed and willing to do anything to get to the White House (where she expected to be calling the shots from the East Wing). This woman betrayed the Democratic party and the American people with her full and active participation in the coverup of the affair. Shame on her and shame forever on her memory. She spent her last months on Earth doing everything she could to salvage her ruined reputation (laughably self-serving book, the St Elizabeth press tour, etc). I'm not buying any of it. This was a cold, calculating dame that never deserved to be on the national scene.
11:23 PM on 05/03/2012
She might not have been a saint, I don't know, but as awful as you think she was she is not the one who cheated, had a child outside of the marriage and she’s not the one who broke the law by using campaign funds to support a mistress and a seedy lifestyle. He’s a creep!! No compassion for the mother of his kid who was fighting a horrible disease. My heart goes out to their kids but I hope they throw the book at him.
11:48 PM on 05/03/2012
it's not a case of one or the other being a self-serving loser ... they BOTH are ... she just as much as he!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kagu632418
Live and Let Live .....
09:23 PM on 05/04/2012
Thank you - I wholeheartedly agree ... You have been fanned and faved....
10:31 AM on 05/04/2012
Now that's a bit crude! She isn't the looser here. It sounds more like Miss drugs & rock & roll is the one who was the master minipulater here . His love for Miss drugs & rock & roll, was no more than an invasion of the lower prostation !!!!! Thank God he never was never elected!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mllea14
10:39 PM on 05/03/2012
There is no smoking gun that the donations made were not intended for Mr. Edwards' personal morass. Tax payer dollars should not be spent on pursuing the demolition of this man as Mr. Edwards has already lost everything; the only salvation he can provide is to be a father for his children. Why should more tax dollars be lost on putting Mr. Edwards behind bars? How are his children supposed to cope with the death of their mother, the public humiliation of their family, conflicted emotions toward their father as well as survive the vulturous condemnation of the public. Fine Mr. Edwards to the hilt and then let him make as many reparations toward his children as he possibly can. This borders on a public hanging. Enough is enough.
11:03 AM on 05/04/2012
"How are his children supposed to cope with the death of their mother, the public humiliation of their family, conflicted emotions toward their father as well as survive the vulturous condemnation of the public?"

Good questions--his children will cope as best they can (as did Richard Nixon's children some years ago). He is still their father and they may love him in spite of his failings as a person. I don't believe most people will blame his children for any of his actions; it is certainly no fault of theirs.
09:47 PM on 05/03/2012
Well, at least the country dodged having another serial killer stalking around -- he went into politics...you can hurt and control a lot more people there...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:48 PM on 05/03/2012
I just don't buy the St. Elizabeth thing. It takes two to make a marriage miserable. They should have divorced decades ago
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kepowell5
07:08 PM on 05/03/2012
All he needed to do was leave. He was a coward.
notamused1001
I probably won't reply to angry responses.
09:00 PM on 05/03/2012
She could have left as well. Come on..."My rich, attractive husband had an affair. Oh no! I would have never guessed! Let me milk this as long as possible..."
09:19 PM on 05/03/2012
Sounds like he wanted both women, too afraid to tell his wife or did not want to. Jane
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kagu632418
Live and Let Live .....
09:25 PM on 05/04/2012
Yup - right on .....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kgay
06:28 PM on 05/03/2012
I want my money back.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ApprxAm
Oh, dam_…the dam is broke!
06:10 PM on 05/03/2012
Edwards is obviously a sc*m bag, but this trial is so out of bounds.

Doesn't the have an ex-Vice President to indict? They're making the tBaggrZ look right.
05:54 PM on 05/03/2012
Further evidence of the REAL war on women by morally bankrupt men like Edwards, Gingrich, Clinton, et al.
09:20 PM on 05/03/2012
Not really, every one of them had the option to leave the marriage. If the Repubs have their way we soon won't have the right to decide what happens to our body.
10:52 PM on 05/03/2012
If you don't know the truth, how can you act on it? Thes spouses of these pigs were victims before they knew they should leave the marriage.

And as far as deciding what happens to our bodies, you should ask an unborn baby, before the scalpel cuts it to pieces, about deciding what happens to their bodies. The crime of not providing another avenue of free birth control for organizations who conscientiously object hardly compares.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fenrir Lokison
I luv the sci fi of Evolution and the Big Bang
05:50 PM on 05/03/2012
Adultery, such a nasty little demon.
photo
Weeweed Up
YOU have a drink with Mitch McConnell!
12:05 PM on 05/04/2012
It's about weakness
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
amaboss52
Jesus died for your sins...get your moneys worth!
05:34 PM on 05/03/2012
John Edwards is the scum of the earth, IMO! Elizabeth Edwards was a solid, caring, smart and savvy woman, he should have been proud and he should have made every effort in the world to deserve her. Hunter is a money grubbing tramp and I hope she lives the rest of her life in hiding. I understand cheating, what I don't understand is how someone with a wonderful wife and family will throw it away with both hands to get with an ugly women with no class or ethics. I hope they throw the book at him, sick or not he deserves no sympathy, he deserves is scorn and derision.
11:11 AM on 05/04/2012
Not only someone with a wife and children to consider but the office of the Presidency or even the VP spot might have been his. I agree wholeheartedly that he deserves no sympathy, or support from his children or anyone else. If his children choose to stand by him, I commend them but if it were my father I wouldn't choose to do that.