iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Angela Merkel, Austerity Policies Dealt Blow In Local German Election

Reuters  |  Posted: 05/13/2012 2:37 pm Updated: 05/13/2012 11:59 pm


* Projections show worst post-war result in state for CDU

* Result could harden opposition to Berlin's austerity policies

* Centre-left SPD ride popular incumbent Kraft to big victory

* Upstart Pirates set to enter fourth regional parliament

By Stephen Brown

DUESSELDORF, Germany, May 13 (Reuters) - Chancellor Angela Merkel's conservatives suffered a crushing defeat on Sunday in an election in Germany's most populous state, a result which could embolden the left opposition to step up attacks on her European austerity policies.

The election in North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW), a western German state with a bigger population than the Netherlands and an economy the size of Turkey, was held 18 months before a national vote in which Merkel will be fighting for a third term.

While she remains popular at home because of the strength of the economy and her steady handling of the euro zone debt crisis, the sheer scale of the defeat in NRW leaves her vulnerable at a time when a backlash against her insistence on fiscal discipline is building across Europe.

According to first projections, the centre-left Social Democrats (SPD) won 38.9 percent of the vote and will have enough to form a stable majority with the Greens.

Merkel's Christian Democrats (CDU) saw their support plunge to just 26.3 percent, down from nearly 35 percent in 2010, and the worst result in the state since World War Two.

"This is not a good evening for Merkel," said Gero Neugebauer, a political scientist at Berlin's Free University. "The SPD is strengthened by this election, which will stir things up in Berlin."

Elections in NRW have a history of influencing national politics. Seven years ago, a humiliating loss for then-Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder's SPD in the state prompted him to call an early election, which he lost to Merkel.

For the past two years, the SPD and the Greens have run a fragile minority government under the leadership of the SPD's Hannelore Kraft, a tram-worker's daughter with a common touch whose victory on Sunday could propel her to national prominence.

Sigmar Gabriel, national leader of the SPD, said the convincing win could prompt speculation that Kraft would take on Merkel in the federal vote next year, even though she has vowed to stay in NRW. The SPD is due to pick a challenger to Merkel by the end of the year.

"This is a clear signal to Berlin," said Kraft, wiping tears from her eyes in a disco in the state capital Duesseldorf where jubilant SPD supporters held celebrations.


HOLLANDE VISIT

France's new president, Socialist Francois Hollande, is due to visit Berlin shortly after he is sworn in on Tuesday to press Merkel to shift away from austerity and place more emphasis on growth-oriented measures in Europe.

Other big countries like Italy also want Merkel to take a more balanced approach to the debt crisis and an election in Greece last week showed massive public resistance to tough austerity that has pushed unemployment close to 25 percent.

A Socialist victory in France, coupled with the NRW result, will give the SPD, which trails Merkel in national opinion polls, new momentum before the federal vote in September 2013.

The chancellor needs the support of her centre-left rivals to pass a new "fiscal compact" that is meant to anchor budget discipline across the EU.

But the SPD is pressing her to delay a parliamentary vote on the pact, keen for the government to commit to new growth measures beforehand.

NRW, which shares a border with Belgium and the Netherlands, is one of Germany's most diverse states.

It is home to one third of the country's blue-chip companies but also some of its poorest cities. Coal and steel firms in the Ruhr region where Kraft grew up once fuelled Germany's post-war economic miracle. Now many have been shuttered and unemployment in some areas is double the national average.

Many in Merkel's party will blame the result on regional leader Norbert Roettgen, Germany's environment minister, who bungled his campaign early on by refusing to commit to staying in the state in the event of a loss.

NRW is Germany's most indebted state and Roettgen ran on a platform of budget consolidation. Kraft advocated a go-slowly approach to debt reduction, emphasising the need to invest in cities, education and childcare.

The result will be seen by some as a double defeat for Merkel. Voters in NRW not only rejected her party but also the austerity measures that she has forced on struggling southern states like Greece, Spain and Portugal.

"The question arising from this election is whether people still follow Merkel's way of doing politics in Germany," said Erik Floegge, 26, a student and SPD supporter, who attended the party rally in Duesseldorf.

"People don't want us to make hard cuts in social funding, what we want is a 'New Deal' where both the social welfare state and fighting debt will work."

Opinion polls show, however, that a majority of Germans back Merkel's focus on debt reduction and that many don't want her to soften her stance towards struggling euro partners.

The Free Democrats (FDP), a pro-business party that rules in coalition with Merkel's conservatives at the federal level, scored 8.3 percent to make it back into the state assembly.

The party ended a string of humiliating regional performances in a state vote in Schleswig-Holstein last week and it hailed the NRW result as proof of a renaissance after a slide in national polls over the past three years.

The upstart Pirates, a party that campaigns for internet freedom and shot onto the national stage last year, continued a strong run at regional level, making it into the fourth straight state parliament with 7.8 percent of the vote.

The Greens scored 11.8 percent.

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW WORLD

* Projections show worst post-war result in state for CDU * Result could harden opposition to Berlin's austerity policies * Centre-left SPD ride popular incumbent Kraft ...
* Projections show worst post-war result in state for CDU * Result could harden opposition to Berlin's austerity policies * Centre-left SPD ride popular incumbent Kraft ...
Filed by Reuters  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 32
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Joe Mando
Oh say...Can you see?
05:30 AM on 05/14/2012
This is good news for Europe. I predicted no good would come of the mission of those ol' pals Merkel & Sarkozy. That was a bad omen...I mean, think about it: When in history did France ever actively work with someone so closely and avidly as Sarkozy did with Merkel? Something was up there, and hopefully we'll never iknow what the result may have been.

As for the subject of Austerity vs Success or Failure...I'm not certain today's business mentality (a simple case of I, me, mine) will ever give true austerity a fighting chance. Too many people 'on the take'.

Spain and Greece? Please, give me a break. Get the majority to actually work and somehow pay ANY taxes at all in those countries...and then let's talk bail-out money...which I would still be against for any country.Bailing out banks & auto magnates is bad enough -- but an entire country????
photo
Colonel Sherburn
WSDE’s = Economic Democracy
05:10 AM on 05/14/2012
Potently good news, austerity has never worked anywhere...
12:33 AM on 05/14/2012
I think judging austerity by Europes failures would just increase more failures. They are low on the economic freedom scale. It does not suprise me they fail at austerity, it is consistantly sabatoaged by their political system. Much like what happens here when we attempt it. The only difference is when it works here, it is shaded by lies and brushed under the carpet for a more political power. Does austerity work, sure does , but only when everyone is on board. If we have a party that wants it to fail, it will. Now , I cannot say that it always works that way, Socialism is on the rise in America. Try as we might, it may still succeed. Too bad the people that want the "Lazy" system have no idea what they are getting us ALL into. In 10-20 years they will regret it, but by then it will be too late. The one for all And all for one does not work when everyone does not pull an equal load, and not everyone can. So who will pick up the slack of the 49% that cannot and will not pay their own way? Or is it 99%?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
smallpawsdk
Hillary 2016
11:00 PM on 05/13/2012
Start taxing the rich all over the world. They have know where to go now.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
brayhaven
11:26 PM on 05/13/2012
Sure, take away the incentive and punish productivity.. That will be great for jobs... not. Even Buffet is against the Buffet rule now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PCPrincess
I'm probably gaming.
01:07 AM on 05/14/2012
Wrong.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
smallpawsdk
Hillary 2016
12:30 PM on 05/14/2012
After the great depression they raised taxes very high on the rich and it got them out of it faster. When I say rich it should be anyone over a million dollars. There would be know where they could run and get away from being taxed. EXCEPT maybe China or Russia, but I bet if our relations with those countries were to go really bad they would pleading to come back here. All the countries in Europe are now finding that out and as we watch people, like you will still believe the crap the EXTREMEST SAY EVEN WHEN IT'S IN FRONT OF YOUR FACE.The half you say don't pay taxes do pay them. You follow fauxnews.
12:59 AM on 05/14/2012
The Republicans do not have a problem of raising the tax's on the rich. It is just what the left calls rich. And how they declare someone rich. They should go by personal tax's. NOT personal and business. We all know the Wealthiest of the wealthy are Democrat, but many of the Democrats do not make their Billions by income tax, they make it be Capital gains. Which is taxed at a lower rate then income. Thus how people like Democrat Billionair Warren Buffet pay less than their secretaries. Democrats like Bernie Madolff, and Democrat controlled companies like Goldman sachs. They Gamble for their money by way of stocks in trade, so their tax's are not as high. So what happens when the tax's skyrocket for the people that own a small business and employ a lot of people? And the Billionairs income does not change? The business owners cut back or shut down. The rich billionairs life will not change, so what do they care if the tax's went up anyway. If anything the billionairs would buy up the middle class when they cut back. KINDA LIKE NOW. We can live without the Billionairs , we cannnot survive without the small business and their owners.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
smallpawsdk
Hillary 2016
12:32 PM on 05/14/2012
Anyone over a million dollars should have to pay. I have an Uncle who's a millionaire 5 times over and he needs to pay more and no more loopholes for them either. No tax write offs either.
11:00 PM on 05/13/2012
i fear this will spill over to our shores , and its a shame the greeks dont understand personal responsibility .
12:34 AM on 05/14/2012
I think our feet is already wet.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:47 PM on 05/13/2012
Pres Obama is proven right. Austerity (cuts) without asking everyone to pay their fair share of taxes will fail again and again. This happened in France, Spain, Greece and now Germany. The Ryan Plan is based on that premise. Cuts meaning to one group as the rich like Romney pay less and hide their money in foreign banks.
MarkRB
Yea, though I walk through the valley of the libs.
12:42 AM on 05/14/2012
Oh please....the top 10% earners pay like 70% of the taxes now. BO has only proven that poor people around the world have no problem taxing those that have worked hard and make a good living. What's going to happen when the rich people say enough, and close up shop? I don't know about you, but I've never worked for a poor person before.
07:26 AM on 05/14/2012
I suspect mauler has never worked at all.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:44 PM on 05/13/2012
Pres. Obama is again proven right. Austerity and cuts without asking the righ to pay a bit more is doomed to fail. We have now seen this in France, Spain, Greece and Germany. Let's not let Romney and the Ryan Plan of austerity cuts take charge here.
12:11 AM on 05/14/2012
I think that your analysis is wrong. What we have seen is that people who are dependent on state granted funding are very reluctant to give it up, and to hell with long term consequences. Somehow people will have to understand that ultimately the bill has to be paid, and you cannot continue to kick the problem down the road. Greece did it for years till it caught up with them. Spain is likely to be next, then Italy. Now it looks like even the Germans, who had been the only rational people in Europe for the past five years are doing it too.
10:14 PM on 05/13/2012
Merkel needs to face the reality that the EURO was a bad idea from the beginning and it needs to be dumped A.S.A.P.
photo
visconti24
See everything; overlook much; correct a little.
10:57 PM on 05/13/2012
No one with any sense, but no one, wants to go back. A united Europe, the Euro, the European Central Bank, and in the future the European Military Forces. The euro is not just a currency that facilitates commerce, it is the central monetary instrument of a united Europe and the US will be the first to suffer if it were to disappear. Next will be the creation of a Pan-European presidency that will absorb the European Commission executive power and the presidency of the European Union.
08:22 AM on 05/14/2012
You may be right and you may be wrong. I don't agree with you on the Euro or it's ability to facilitate commerce. In fact I see it as the detractor. As for the Pan-European Presidency, it sounds like your talking from the One World Order stance. Another reason the Euro needs to go because without a united currency they cannot create the One World Order.
09:34 PM on 05/13/2012
Perhaps America also need to have weekend elections. Sunday in the U.S. would create greater turnout due to more people being off work. Many Americans attend church, but are then free to pursue voting. After a hard day of working, many Americans simply aren't willing to stand in long lines to vote, so changing voting to Sunday appeals to many sensible minds.
photo
visconti24
See everything; overlook much; correct a little.
11:00 PM on 05/13/2012
Ah, but we don't have a parliamentary system and what we have is a geriatric and dysfunctional "Senate" a House of Representatives and a presidency, each one fighting for turf.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stlbrz
09:20 PM on 05/13/2012
The Germans say hell no to the Ryan budget.
photo
visconti24
See everything; overlook much; correct a little.
11:00 PM on 05/13/2012
Exactly.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Micheal Frisbie
09:13 PM on 05/13/2012
austerity is just slowed down merkel, just slowed down...
photo
visconti24
See everything; overlook much; correct a little.
11:01 PM on 05/13/2012
No, that foolish East German has overstayed her welcome.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Micheal Frisbie
11:28 PM on 05/13/2012
my point wasn't made as to the political value of merkel, but austerity is here to stay, but will yoyo up and down with the political will of the voters.  and the political fortunes of leaders like merkel will be tied into those up and downs.
photo
visconti24
See everything; overlook much; correct a little.
11:18 AM on 05/14/2012
And mine has to do with the efficacy of pursuing austerity measures at at time of recession. Merkel is bound to the principles of her center right (in European terms) party which functions best in time of explosive growth. Or at times of heavy influx of foreign investment as in the era of Konrad Adenauer. Her policies, while workable in Bavaria, are not working so well in the former East. Just as the Sarkozy policies that did well at Ile de France, Toulouse and Alsace Lorraine are less effective in the western part of the country or even Marseilles. Merkel is not a flexible and inventive leader and offers the same remedies for the Ruhr as for Munich. She is not as rigid and obtuse as Margaret Thatcher, no one is, aside from Ronald Reagan, but ever Sarkozy had understood, finally that Europe stands on her own majesty now (in the words of Winston Churchill) not only because Belgium Netherlands and Luxemburg are united in the Coal, Postal and Steel Union, but because Schlesvig-Holstein and Normandy, Liguria, the Ticino, Provence, Madrid and Southern Spain have the same interests. Lombardy, Bavaria, Benelux, Alsace and Finland have many of the same problems. Munich, Milan and Manchester are concerned with things that unite them like Rome, Paris, Berlin, London, Berlin, Hamburg and Amsterdam.
My Europe, of Charlemagne, Rome, Visigoths and even Vikings, has finally gotten away from the post-war politicians and the United States of America.
08:28 PM on 05/13/2012
I have noticed a lot of countries in Europe have elections on Sunday and always have a good turn out.
The US has elections during the work week and turn out is low. hummmmmm
09:25 PM on 05/13/2012
You are right..It is a conspiracy.. Blame Bush..it is his fault...
photo
visconti24
See everything; overlook much; correct a little.
11:01 PM on 05/13/2012
Blaming that man would be giving him far too much credit.