iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

John Edwards, Rielle Hunter Will Not Testify At Trial

By MICHAEL BIESECKER 05/16/12 06:20 PM ET AP

John Edwards Rielle Hunter Testify

GREENSBORO, N.C. — John Edwards' team wrapped up their defense Wednesday without calling the ex-presidential candidate, his mistress or daughter to testify, a move experts say was intended to shift focus from a political sex scandal to the nitty-gritty of campaign finance law.

"The defense wasn't sexy, but the defense doesn't want sexy. It wants an acquittal," said Steve Friedland, a professor at Elon University School of Law and former federal prosecutor who has attended much of the trial.

Experts said Edwards' bare-bone defense, which lasted just over two days, may be enough to avoid conviction on charges he authorized more than $1 million secretly provided by two wealthy donors to help hide an affair with pregnant mistress Rielle Hunter as he sought the White House in 2008.

The prosecution presented nearly three weeks of evidence and testimony from a former Edwards aide and campaign advisors that painted Edwards as a frequent liar, but showed no direct evidence, he intended to break federal campaign finance laws, the experts said.

Many observers believed Edwards would testify so the jury could hear directly from the former U.S. senator and trial lawyer, who had a reputation for his ability to sway jurors. But putting Edwards and Hunter on the stand would have exposed the defense to withering cross-examination about Edwards' past lies and personal failings.

"The defense may very well have felt that their case was solid enough to go to the jury without the risk of the personal testimony of these witnesses, which would undoubtedly resurrect the salacious details of the affair for the jury," said Catherine Dunham, another Elon law professor who has been attending the trial.

The defense also elected not to call Edwards' oldest daughter, Cate, a 30-year-old lawyer who has sat behind her father nearly every day, as a character witness to help humanize him.

At one point during the trial, Cate Edwards ran out of the courtroom in tears during testimony about her cancer-stricken mother, Elizabeth, confronting her father about his extramarital affair.

Closing arguments in the case are set for Thursday; U.S. District Court Judge Catherine C. Eagles gave each side two hours to make their case. The jury will likely begin deliberations Friday.

Edwards is charged with six criminal counts including conspiracy to violate the Federal Election Campaign Act, accepting contributions that exceeded campaign finance limits, and causing his campaign to file a false financial disclosure report. He faces up to 30 years in prison and $1.5 million in fines if convicted of all charges.

The former Democratic presidential candidate has sat quietly at the defense table throughout his trial, whispering with his lawyers and rarely showing reaction to the often emotional testimony from witnesses who were once among his strongest supporters and closest friends.

He has made no public statements since October, following a pre-trial hearing where a judge refused to throw out the case.

At the trial, prosecutors have shown two members of Edwards' inner circle, campaign finance chairman Fred Baron and once-close aide Andrew Young, engaged in a yearlong cover-up to hide the married presidential candidate's mistress from the media.

The married Young falsely claimed paternity of his boss' baby and received $725,000 in secret checks from an elderly heiress, using some of the money to care for Hunter.

Baron, a wealthy Texas lawyer, provided Young and Hunter with more than $400,000 in cash, luxury hotels, private jets and a $20,000-a-month rental mansion in Santa Barbara, Calif.

Prosecutors have introduced phone records, voicemails and other evidence showing Edwards in frequent contact with Baron, Young and Hunter while Hunter was in hiding.

Former members of Edwards' campaign also testified that Baron spoke of "moving Hunter around" in the candidate's presence and that Edwards told his speechwriter he knew "all along" what Baron was up to.

But in 14 days of testimony, no witness ever said Edwards knew he was violating campaign finance laws, a key element of criminal intent the government must prove to win a conviction.

"There was no direct evidence that John Edwards knew he was violating campaign contribution laws," Friedland said. "Juries like smoking guns. There were no smoking guns here."

Prosecutors on Wednesday finished cross-examination of Jim Walsh, a retired FBI agent hired by the defense to analyze the financial records of Young and his wife, Cheri.

Walsh used banking records to show the Youngs siphoned off most of the money from heiress Rachel "Bunny" Mellon to build the couple's expansive $1.6 million dream house. Baron wired another $325,000 to the company building the home.

Jurors were read a stipulation Wednesday about a sex tape found by Young that was purportedly filmed by Hunter when she was with Edwards. Jurors were told Andrew Young considered selling the tape, and told Edwards he had it in a 2008 meeting on a North Carolina roadside.

Defense lawyers have suggested the aide intended to use the tape to blackmail his former boss.

Another stipulation dealt with medical records indicating the exact date Edwards and Young likely conceived their child, May 28, 2007. The date conflicts with Young's testimony of the date he said Hunter first told Edwards she was pregnant.

Before his indictment, Edwards rejected a potential plea agreement with federal prosecutors that would have allowed him to serve as little as six months and keep his law license.

Edwards made his fortune handling medical malpractice and corporate negligence cases before turning to politics following the death of his 16-year-old son Wade in a 1996 auto accident. He was elected to the U.S. Senate in 1998 and was Sen. John Kerry's running mate in 2004.

Elizabeth Edwards died of cancer in December 2010. Edwards is a single parent to his daughter and son, aged 13 and 11, at the family's gated estate outside Chapel Hill.

After years of denials, Edwards admitted fathering his Hunter's baby in January 2010, shortly after agreeing to pay child support. The girl, now 4, lives with her mother in Charlotte.

___

Allen Reed contributed to this report from Greensboro, N.C.

___

Follow AP writer Michael Biesecker at twitter.com/mbieseck

Earlier on HuffPost:

FOLLOW POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
GREENSBORO, N.C. — John Edwards' team wrapped up their defense Wednesday without calling the ex-presidential candidate, his mistress or daughter to testify, a move experts say was intended to sh...
GREENSBORO, N.C. — John Edwards' team wrapped up their defense Wednesday without calling the ex-presidential candidate, his mistress or daughter to testify, a move experts say was intended to sh...
Filed by Luke Johnson  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 637
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (15 total)
11:35 PM on 05/17/2012
A reply to gjmjoe017 " All Democrats lie and cheat, just another example."
Have you forgotten Richard Nixion aka "Tricky Dicky" The Watergate Scandal & George Bush his
Weapons of Mass Destruction, etc... think before saying All Democrats...
What about Republicans? Enough said.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:49 PM on 05/17/2012
I wonder if John Edwards has a date lined up for his victory party. Now that he's single and all
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rmweld
10:57 AM on 05/17/2012
Another Democratic favorite son heading to the pokey. John Corzine will be next, and all the dems want to talk about is Jamie Dimon.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
philoec
10:45 AM on 05/17/2012
Promiscuity is the characteristic of the new "democracy" under momma barracka obama!
10:27 AM on 05/17/2012
sounds like clinton...."i didnt have sex with that woman" lol just cigar dipping
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Macfarlane
Proud to have been allowed to serve in Vietnam
10:08 AM on 05/17/2012
Does any more need be said than "showed no direct evidence, he intended to break federal campaign finance laws, the experts said."

Edwards walks or our system is broken.
photo
decat2
"He who governs best,governs least"
08:17 AM on 05/17/2012
The defense rests ? Good now maybe this self-serving ego maniac will be convicted,...and give the rest of us a "rest" as well!
tccat4
We all have a right to our opinion, like it or not
07:26 AM on 05/17/2012
If you are a politician, and accused of fraud, and expect as slap on the hand... If your Jane/John Doe and do 1.5 million in fraud, you spend 20 years in prison and a record as a felon.
Bet if they put Hunter or Edwards on the stand both would plead the 5th.. If Edwards get to walk, it just shows us Justice can be bought by the highest bidder.
Edwards got caught, many sitting on Capital Hill are doing yet the same thing.......
07:16 AM on 05/17/2012
"I swear to tell the truth and nothing but the truth so help me God". Somehow John getting up on the stand razing his right hand swearing to God to tell the truth just as he when he promised to "Love honor and obey" would add little credibility to his case.
07:07 AM on 05/17/2012
staying silent speak volumes..no one close to him came to his defense..says alot about the man
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MiMi LLawsonn
Just my opinion****
06:34 AM on 05/17/2012
Perhaps Edwards is GUILTY.....BUT THIS HAS TO BE PROVED....so where is the PROOF that EDWARDS is GUILTY...and what exactly is he GUILTY OF????????????????????? BEING A SLINGBALL.....well....THAT'S NOT A CRIME.....sorry, but it fits...he fits several different groups of people....but committing a crime....I would like to know exactly HOW THIS MAN WAS INDICTED???????? And wonder just HOW MUCH MONEY WAS WASTED ON THIS TRIAL THAT THE TAXPAYERS PAID???????????????????????
10:09 AM on 05/17/2012
MiMi, dear, you're not listening & paying attention. He's not being prosecuted for being a "SLINGBALL" as you put it. He's being prosecuted for diverting approximately a Million dollars from his campaign funds to support his mistress.

If he diverted the funds to buy a boat it would have been the same. The money was for his Presidential campaign, not for his "recreational" activities.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MiMi LLawsonn
Just my opinion****
12:40 PM on 05/17/2012
Supposedly....Edwards did NOT consider the money a *POLITICAL CONTRIBUTION*....verified by several people.....Oops....perhaps the media got it WRONG....I was not there and did not hear or see what took place....
04:48 AM on 05/17/2012
Time will tell! History is right when people are wrong.
04:39 AM on 05/17/2012
Everyone knows he is guilty. But the law insists on more.....He will walk. )-: At the end of the day, he has to live with himself. In some cases, the "System" just doesn't work.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gryphon10
03:21 AM on 05/17/2012
I knew Edwards would not take the stand. The jury would see him as a cheap lying Democrat. But that is redundant.
04:39 AM on 05/17/2012
Like Nixon.
tccat4
We all have a right to our opinion, like it or not
07:32 AM on 05/17/2012
And people wonder way the generation born in the 1950's think politics is nothing to be trusted... period..
09:58 AM on 05/17/2012
No, like Ted Kennedy - Chappaquiddick
02:55 AM on 05/17/2012
I did not have sexual relations with that girl!!! Ya, ok Clinton whatever. What these idiots do after 5:00pm is just as important as what they do before 5:00pm. If they could hurt there families this way you really think they careless about there country and all of us depending on them to do the right thing for our families. Can you imagine how alone and worthless Edwards wife felt knowing what he was up to. She did and know and so did their sweet daughter. The whole time. Edwards daughter came foward and spoke in an interveiw about her mother and her amazing accomplishments and the struggles and suffering she faced in her last days. Yet again he denied this new child who happens to female. It seems he has no respect for any important women in his life. How very sorry I feel for the children and he is only sorry now because he was caught. Till death do us part unless you get cancer should be added to the vows.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sasseyfrass
09:04 PM on 06/17/2012
It almost seems as if the daughter is betraying her mother to stand up for her lying cheating daddy and his very uncompassionate woman friend with fringe benefits. You would think a man who is smart enough to be president would be smart enough to use protection. He should have known she would try to tie him to her by not taking hers.