iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Same-Sex Divorce Recognized By Maryland Court Of Appeals

By BRIAN WITTE 05/18/12 05:48 PM ET AP

Samesex Divorce Maryland
Alamy

ANNAPOLIS, Md. — Maryland's highest court ruled Friday that same-sex couples can divorce in the state even though Maryland does not yet permit same-sex marriages.

The Court of Appeals ruled 7-0 that couples who have a valid marriage from another state can divorce in Maryland. The case involved two women who were married in California and denied a divorce in 2010 by a Maryland judge.

"A valid out-of-state same-sex marriage should be treated by Maryland courts as worthy of divorce, according to the applicable statues, reported cases, and court rules of this state," the court concluded in a 21-page ruling.

It said Maryland courts should withhold recognition of a valid foreign marriage only if that marriage is "repugnant" to state public policy. The court says the threshold is a high bar that has not been met in the case that it ruled on.

The ruling may have limited effect because same-sex weddings, and by extension divorces, are set to start in the state in January. However, opponents of the law passed this year hope to force a November voter referendum that could overturn it. Opponents will need to collect nearly 56,000 signatures by the end of June to put the question on the ballot.

Jessica Port, one of the parties in the divorce case, said the ruling made her two-and-a-half year legal battle worth the trouble.

"This is a huge step for gay rights and same-sex marriage in Maryland," she said.

Michele Zavos, Port's attorney, cheered the ruling, because now Maryland will at least recognize same-sex marriages from other states, regardless of the outcome of a referendum, even if opponents successfully get enough signatures to put the law on the ballot and it is overturned by voters.

"Maryland's referendum laws cannot overturn a Court of Appeals decision," Zavos said. "That decision can only be overturned by the Legislature, and given the Legislature passed marriage, I think that we can expect that this decision will remain the law of Maryland."

Unlike other states, Maryland has no ban on recognizing same-sex marriages from other jurisdictions. In 2010, state Attorney General Doug Gansler issued an opinion that said out-of-state, same-sex marriages may be recognized under Maryland law. As a result, state agencies have extended benefits to same-sex spouses of state employees and issued birth certificates that recognize the same-sex spouse of a woman who gives birth as a parent.

Gansler said Friday the unanimous ruling marked another step in the evolving acceptance of same-sex marriage.

"This is another example of that," Gansler said.

The divorce case involves Port, a Maryland resident, and District of Columbia resident Virginia Cowan. Port, 29, and Cowan, 32, were married in California in 2008 during a window in which gay marriage was legal there. Almost two years later, the couple filed for divorce in Maryland, where they both then lived. Prince George's County Judge A. Michael Chapdelaine declined to grant it.

But their attorneys argued that Maryland has long recognized marriages from other states, even if Maryland itself has barred those marriages. For example, Maryland law bars an uncle and a niece from marrying, but the state will recognize that marriage if it legally occurred in another state.

Six states and the District of Columbia, which borders Maryland, currently permit gay couples to marry. The states are Connecticut, Iowa, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York and Vermont. Lawmakers in Washington state have also passed a law permitting same-sex couples to marry, but it doesn't take effect until June and could be put on hold by a proposed voter referendum seeking to overturn the law.

___

Follow Brian Witte on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/APBrianWitte

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
ANNAPOLIS, Md. — Maryland's highest court ruled Friday that same-sex couples can divorce in the state even though Maryland does not yet permit same-sex marriages. The Court of Appeals ruled 7-0...
ANNAPOLIS, Md. — Maryland's highest court ruled Friday that same-sex couples can divorce in the state even though Maryland does not yet permit same-sex marriages. The Court of Appeals ruled 7-0...
Filed by Luke Johnson  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 90
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
l78lancer
Wisdom is the principal thing
10:06 PM on 05/19/2012
""This is a huge step for gay rights and same-sex marriage in Maryland," she said."
--------------------------------------------------->

It's a bit odd to hear that divorce is a big step for an marriage, gay or straight.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
unimatrix0
01:34 AM on 05/20/2012
You can't get a divorce unless you are first considered married, so yeah, it might seem odd, but it is a big deal. It menas MD is saying they acknowledge the marriages of same-sex couples performed in other states as being legally binding right now, even if they do not perform the marriages in the state currently.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
l78lancer
Wisdom is the principal thing
02:14 AM on 05/20/2012
Yeah, I got that, but I was feeling a bit cynical. However you're right - even before they allow marriages to occur, if people move there already married, then it stands the reason that the divorce law needs to be on the books ASAP.
photo
duckpuddle
Coexist, it's easier.
08:17 AM on 05/25/2012
It is add, until you think about it. Marriage is a contract. We are working to have contracts created in one state recognized in all states and the federal government. This certainly sets a precedent, legal or otherwise, that all same sex marriages are like all marriages; they transcend state borders.

If legality for dissolution of a contracts is a way to have those contracts recognized, then this is progress indeed.

Divorce is not fun, but marriage is a contract that sometimes needs to be terminated. Divorce laws protect both parties, GLBT people need access to those laws too.
TroopAbn
Big Oil/Energy Killed Economy
01:35 AM on 05/19/2012
Because we have a governor "O'Malley" known as, "O'Money", that is running the state broke. All he can do to fix things is come up with ways to tax. Liqour by the drink, raising sales taxes, bottle taxes, bridge, toll road and tunnel taxes. So how will this play out? Let me guess, "charge each of the gay parties in the divorce a $1,000 fee". Then call it an annulment, and say, "it never happened".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AmKonDotNet
Legalize Hemp!
11:35 PM on 05/18/2012
How does one get "gay divorced" if "gay marriage" is not legal in Maryland? Makes absolutely no sense.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
unimatrix0
01:31 AM on 05/20/2012
Maryland is saying they recoginze other states' marriages. Some states cousins can marry, other states they can not. If they do marry, they are considered married in all states. Interracial marriage went through this. Some states allowed it and some did not. The US Constitution's full faith and credit clause requires all states to honor each other's marriages, just like we honor driver liceneses, and birth certificates.
Not everyone is striaght or gay, some people are bi-sexual. If someone can not get a divorce for their same-sex marriage because their state says "you are not married", then what is to stop them from marrying someone of the opposite sex. Now they are a criminal in about 10 states (those that perform or honor same-sex marriages), for bigomy. But if they stay in their current state they are not a bigomist. That is wacked. How can an employer send people out to do business if they might get arrested if they travel to certain states. I have a same-sex marriage and live in a state that will not honor it. I do not want a divorce, but if I did, I would have to move to MA for 6 months before I would qualify for one. And I live about 6 states away. Should I have to quit my job, and move out of my house to get a divorce?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AmKonDotNet
Legalize Hemp!
02:06 AM on 05/20/2012
I don't think I was very clear in my post- I completely support gay/straight/bi whatever marriage. I was just confused as to how Maryland allowed gay divorce, but not gay marriage. Thanks for the clarification.
photo
duckpuddle
Coexist, it's easier.
08:17 AM on 05/25/2012
remove the word gay and ans the question again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allen Clark
08:36 PM on 05/18/2012
This entire same sex marriage is boarderline stupid. We have only began to see the complications this is going to create. it all sounds good when you talk marriage but now the bad side of it is going to start to come out. Sick situation.
photo
Ponicrat
Freedom of, and from religion.
09:55 PM on 05/18/2012
Exactly! just look at how the institution of marriage has been completely destroyed in the first counties to adopt it a decade ago like the Netherlands. It is a documented fact that when we let gays marry it DIRECTLY affects every honest, legitimate, husband-dominating-wife marriage within a hundred miles.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:04 PM on 05/18/2012
Tell me about it. It's only a matter of time before it leads to divorce in opposite-sex marriages.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MyNameIsMickey
08:11 PM on 05/18/2012
Strange America. I love you so.
04:52 PM on 05/18/2012
I think that this ruling sets the stage for this court to rule that Maryland's constitution mandates marriage equality in the event that the people overturn the legislature there in Nov.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allen Clark
08:39 PM on 05/18/2012
there is that statement of constitutionality. What a huge assuption that is. NO where does the constituion mention same sex marriage. You can keep saying it, but that does not make it true. and if you continue to say the same lie over and over, you will convince enough people that its true. But that does not make it true.
08:53 PM on 05/18/2012
I strongly doubt that it says anything about heterosexual marriage either. However, it does have an equal protection clause. And, if the court states that the state must recognize same-sex marriages outside of the state, how could they rule it constitutional not to recognize in state marriages. That makes no sense.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
shryock
It never is what it is anymore
01:17 PM on 05/18/2012
How on earth did we get to this? Divorce is okay. Marriage is not?
What happened to marriage is 'sacred' and must be protected?
How can allowing divorce be interpreted as protecting marriage?

(once upon a time, one had to do some heavy drugs in order to get to opposite day.
now we live there all the time.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pho3n1xSun
stupidity is a disease
01:25 PM on 05/18/2012
I'd rather encourage people not to get married in the first place until they're completely sure
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AdamWest1313
Hardcore Agnostic
04:23 PM on 05/18/2012
Freedom trumps "sacred" almost every time in this country, and rightly so.

If you think divorce is wrong, don't get divorced. But don't tell other people what to do.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
shryock
It never is what it is anymore
05:14 PM on 05/18/2012
I never said I think divorce is wrong.
I said, how can a state that claims it is intent on protecting marriage allow divorce?
How does divorce protect marriage?

In Maryland, same sex couples cannot marry but they can divorce.
Does it not seem strange that Maryland can dissolve a union that it does not recognize as a union?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:49 PM on 05/18/2012
here in massachusetts, immediately after same sex marriages were enacted there was a same sex divorce, just to get the legal framework down and working.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill J4321
12:16 PM on 05/18/2012
The pettyrosexuals will NOT like this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BriS
here a quack, there a quack
12:15 PM on 05/18/2012
That's absurd. How can you divorce a union that you do not recognize?

Get your house in order Maryland.
Grunty1
Micro-bio this
12:49 PM on 05/18/2012
[Unlike other states, Maryland has no ban on recognizing same-sex marriages from other jurisdictions]
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BriS
here a quack, there a quack
12:51 PM on 05/18/2012
what's your point?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mad McFarland
01:19 PM on 05/18/2012
Thats wrong!!!!! If you don't allow something to happen then why should you have to be forced to reverse it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kiffanik
01:59 PM on 05/18/2012
That's not uncommon. You can only marry your first cousin in 20 states but all states recognize your marriage as legal. This whole not recognizing marriage across state lines is specific to g@y marriage only.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PolSci
Queerly Canadian
11:56 AM on 05/18/2012
Republicans, stop tying your country in knots with your prejudice.

Let the paradigm shift towards acceptance happen before you're left with piecemeal legislation that cripples your justice system.
photo
LintLass
"When you can balance a tackhammer on your head...
12:13 PM on 05/18/2012
Crippling the justice system is in part their aim.
Grunty1
Micro-bio this
12:49 PM on 05/18/2012
Hard to argue with that...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dev Austin
Haters are my motivators
02:46 PM on 05/18/2012
Really? So fighting for equality, in your mind, is not worthy of court time? Interesting.
11:56 AM on 05/18/2012
It's easy to see how they differ on the topic gay marriage: obama's views flip-flop depending on which way the political winds are blowing; Romney hasn't changed his opinion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
khemphill17
Games lubricate the body and the mind.
12:02 PM on 05/18/2012
Maybe..maybe not...but one thing we can count the Mitten on is to never actually say what he believes in...he's shuffled his opinion enough times depending on who he is talking to, already...Obama, nope he comes right out and says if he's evolving or not on issues. At least I don't have to watch my back with one of them...and let's just say he's currently president.
01:11 PM on 05/18/2012
Explain how one 'evolves' from pro-gay marriage, to against, to pro again. Basic biology course - evolution doesn't work that way. Flip-flopping does though!
12:31 AM on 05/19/2012
You may be right. And yes, he's pres... for a few more months :) 
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PolSci
Queerly Canadian
12:03 PM on 05/18/2012
Perhaps you should familiarize yourself with this little Romney gem from yesterday:

"I’m not familiar with precisely what I said, but I stand by what I said, whatever it was."

And this is the guy who hasn't changed his opinion? He doesn't even know what his opinion is!
01:09 PM on 05/18/2012
Doesn't that make him supremely qualified to be president for liberals?? Sounds like Kerry, and Obama, etc....