iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

John Edwards Trial: Jurors Will Resume Talks Monday

By MICHAEL BIESECKER 05/19/12 04:19 AM ET AP

John Edwards Trial
Jurors in the John Edwards' campaign corruption trial are taking a break for the weekend.

GREENSBORO, N.C. -- Jurors in the John Edwards' campaign corruption trial are taking a break for the weekend and their requests for evidence and office supplies may be a sign that they are in for detailed discussions when they reconvene on Monday.

Jurors began talking about case Friday after hearing 17 days of testimony about money from wealthy donors that was used to hide Edwards' pregnant mistress during his 2008 White House bid. Much of the testimony focused on the details of the lurid sex scandal between the Democratic candidate, his mistress Rielle Hunter and his once-trusted aide Andrew Young, who initially claimed he was the father of his boss's baby.

They also reviewed phone and financial records from a period of about two years.

Edwards is charged with six criminal counts including conspiracy to violate the Federal Election Campaign Act, accepting contributions that exceeded campaign finance limits, and causing his campaign to file a false financial disclosure report. The 58-year-old faces up to 30 years in prison and $1.5 million in fines if convicted of all charges.

Jurors asked for eight exhibits and all of the notes from a wealthy heiress who provided about half of the money at issue. They also wanted a transcript of the heiress' lawyer's testimony, but the judge told them to rely on their memory. They said they need markers and a board to write on, too.

Jurors will have to weigh whether to believe Edwards, who argued that he didn't knowingly break the law, or his aide, Andrew Young, who said Edwards recruited him to solicit secret donations in excess of the legal limit for campaign contributions, then $2,300.

The choice before them comes down to picking which liar to believe.

Young, the prosecution's star witness, falsely claimed paternity of his boss's baby in December 2007, after tabloid reporters tracked a visibly pregnant Hunter to a doctor's appointment.

Edwards repeatedly denied having a relationship with Hunter, only to go on national television in August 2008 to admit having a brief affair with Hunter but that it was physically impossible he was the father of her baby girl. In fact, his relationship with Hunter had lasted more than a year. A recording of that interview was played for the jury last week as the prosecution rested its case.

The bulk of the alleged illegal campaign contributions flowed to Young, including $725,000 in checks from heiress Rachel "Bunny" Mellon, who is now 101 years old. Young spent some of the money to care for Hunter, but financial records introduced at the trial showed the aide siphoned off most of the money to help build his family's $1.6 million dream home near Chapel Hill.

Another $400,000 in cash, luxury hotels, private jets rides and a $20,000-a-month rental mansion in Santa Barbara, Calif., were also provided by wealthy Texas lawyer Fred Baron to help cover up the affair. Baron served as Edwards' campaign finance chairman.

Prosecutors say Edwards knew about the money and directed the cover-up, showing the jury phone records indicating he was in constant contact with Hunter and Young while they were in hiding.

The defense countered that it is Young who should be on trial, not Edwards, accusing the aide of using Edwards' name without his knowledge to bamboozle Mellon out of hundreds of thousands of dollars for his personal use. Young received immunity from prosecutors.

During closing arguments Thursday, lead defense lawyer Abbe Lowell admitted that Edwards had lied to his wife and the American people. But his client didn't violate federal campaign finance regulations, Lowell said.

"This is a case that should define the difference between a wrong and a crime ... between a sin and a felony," Lowell told the jury. "John Edwards has confessed his sins. He will serve a life sentence for those. But he has pleaded not guilty to violating the law."

___

Associated Press writer Allen Reed contributed to this report.

___

Below, a slideshow detailing the history of John Edwards' relationship with Rielle Hunter:
Loading Slideshow...
  • Love At First Sight?

    "And when they left, my friend went over and asked Tony if that was John Edwards, and he said yes. And my friend turned to me and said, 'See, I told you it was John Edwards.' And then I came over to the table, and I said, 'I can't believe that was John Edwards; he's so hot. He's really got it going on. He's got something unusual about him, and I never would have recognized him.' And Tony said, 'Oh, my God, you should have come over and told him that. He would have loved to have heard that.'"

  • An Extraordinary Night

    "We had an extraordinary night, and I did know that this was unlike anything either of us had ever experienced. And as we have all learned, that was accurate! [laughs] He in fact did say to me the first night, 'Falling in love with you could really [screw] up my plans for becoming President.' And of course I said, 'If you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans.'"

  • The Oddest Connection He Had Ever Felt

    "Well, what Johnny later told me was, he went to dinner and could not stop thinking about me, like, 'Who was that woman, and why didn't I go over and talk to her?' ... So when he walked around the corner and saw me standing there, he lit up like a Christmas tree. And I thought his reaction when he saw me was just so cute. I mean, he looked like a little kid at Christmas. And I just uttered to him, 'You're so hot.' And he said, 'Why, thank you!' And he almost jumped into my arms. Literally. And um, that's how we met. On the corner of 61st and Park Avenue."

  • 'I Had To Sleep With Him'

    "I used to make a joke that I could have helped save the world, but I had to sleep with him. You know? It was kind of like that."

  • Falling In Love

    "I fell in love with Johnny ... He called me the next day. We talked on the phone almost every night for four hours. We met on February 21. On February 25—on the phone, from Davenport, Iowa—I fell in love with him. Head over heels in love. I was a goner."

  • Here's ... Johnny!

    "Isn't that funny? You know, when I first met him, the first week of our relationship, I said to him, 'For some reason I cannot call you John, it doesn't come out. Could I call you Johnny?' And he said, 'That's my name.' And I didn't know that, but that's his actual birth name."

  • Knight In Shining Armor?

    "I had this thing in my head like a lot of women, where you want your man to stand up on a cliff and scream, 'I LOVE HER.' You know, the knight in shining armor. And that wasn't what was going on."

  • On Her Relationship Status

    "I am not engaged."

  • Why She's Talking Now

    "I feel comfortable talking now, because Johnny went public and made a statement admitting paternity. I didn't feel like I could ever speak until he did that. Because had I spoken, I would have emasculated him. And I could not emasculate him. Also, it is not my desire to teach my daughter that when Mommy's upset with Daddy, you take matters into your own hands and fix Daddy's mistakes. Which I view as one of the biggest problems in all female-and-male relationships."

  • Not A Gold Digger

    "I mean, just for starters, I never 'hit on' Johnny. I'm not a predator, I'm not a gold digger, I'm not the stalker. I didn't have any power in that way in our relationship. He held all the power."

  • 'The Wrath Of Elizabeth Is A Mighty Wrath'

    "And I believe what happened in his marriage is, he could not go to his wife and say, 'We have an issue.' Because he would be pummeled. So he had a huge fear. Most of his mistakes or errors in judgment were because of his fear of the wrath of Elizabeth. He's allowed himself to be pushed into a lot of things that he wouldn't normally do because of Elizabeth's story line. And the spin that she wants to put out there. He was emasculated. And you know, the wrath of Elizabeth is a mighty wrath."

  • 'I Was A Bit Promiscuous'

    "I was never, as it's been reported, a drug addict. The word addiction means inability to stop. I stopped doing drugs in my twenties. As for being promiscuous, I would say that I was a bit promiscuous for about six months. But it was because I was partying, and there were a lot of very good-looking available 20-year-old men around that you'd be partying with, and there was a lot of, you know, hooking up going on."

  • A Toxic Relationship

    "[Elizabeth] was in denial about a lot of facts. And I say she was in denial because, you know, their relationship has been dysfunctional and toxic and awful for many, many years. And she was aware of, um, problems and chose to ignore them."

  • 'I Don't Really Believe He Was A Politician'

    "Well, I don't really believe he was a politician. I believe his ego and ambition drove him to that field. I believe he's more aligned with being a humanitarian. That suits his true nature. Just like I wasn't a mistress. You know, I'm not a mistress, but I played the role? I believe he played the role of a politician. It's not who he is. Being a politician was a path of transformation for him, I believe. It's not really what he was put on the planet to do."

  • Not A 'Home Wrecker'

    "And, well, first of all, infidelity doesn't happen in healthy marriages. The break in the marriage happens before the infidelity. And that break happened, you know, two and a half decades before I got there. So the home was wrecked already. I was not the Home Wrecker."

  • Naming Frances Quinn Hunter

    "Her name is Frances Quinn Hunter, and I love the name Frances. Johnny wasn't over the moon about Frances. So I was coming up with names, and Quinn is a name that I loved, and that was the only name that he thought was cool. And so I named her Quinn because Daddy really liked it."

  • Was Andrew Young In Love With Edwards?

    "Andrew [Young] was in love with Johnny...In love with him. Beyond. And I believe he loved Johnny more than he loved Cheri. So Johnny was the third person in their relationship. And I'm sure she hates Johnny, because Andrew took a lot of obvious actions that were for Johnny and not for Cheri. But Cheri went along with them. And they both have a way of spinning things. But a lot of their motivation is money."

FOLLOW POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
GREENSBORO, N.C. -- Jurors in the John Edwards' campaign corruption trial are taking a break for the weekend and their requests for evidence and office supplies may be a sign that they are in for deta...
GREENSBORO, N.C. -- Jurors in the John Edwards' campaign corruption trial are taking a break for the weekend and their requests for evidence and office supplies may be a sign that they are in for deta...
Filed by Paige Lavender  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 57
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adam of CA
Independent Information Hunter
02:29 PM on 05/25/2012
This is a peculiar situtation on so so many levels. Since Mr. Edwards is an experienced trial lawyer, he knows better than to be in this situation at all.

The most peculiar aspect is that quoted sources reveal a love relationship between Mr. Young and Mr. Edwards. Yet, Mr. Young is the prime witness for the prosecution. With love like that, one would not have time for enemies.

A week after the Closing Arguments, the jury is still examining the evidence. And so it should, because the defense proved that the million dollars was diverted to building a swimming pool at Young's home. This is so-ooo weird: The Finger Pointer who is accusing Edwards of using the campaign money to cover up Edward's adultry took the money to install a swimming pool. How can Mr. Edwards be using the money if the money is being spent by Mr. Young to improve his own estate?
03:02 PM on 05/21/2012
After reading a blog about no flowers or a headstone at Elizabeth Edwards grave. It makes me so sad how people can forget loved ones so fast. I go to my parents graves a lot and remember them with flowers on the altar for Easter and Christmas at my church. I can't fathom why he got involved with Hunter who will bring him down.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stephen Thorpe
Every breath you take - I'll take one too!
12:22 PM on 05/20/2012
Bunny Mellon in her own words said the money was a gift. She filed the gift tax form and paid gift tax. The IRS took the tax money and the form.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:22 AM on 05/20/2012
It is a good thing that I was not sitting on that jury in deliberation of this obnoxious jerk's fate. I would have found this dope guilty of ALL charges in a New York minute! This egomaniac is a disgrace to humanity!
tccat4
We all have a right to our opinion, like it or not
04:25 AM on 05/20/2012
She talks about Elizabeth like she knew her, easy to bash a dead woman, when she cant fight back. Lisa (her real name) knew he was married and stalked him. Edwards was foolish thinking this was going to stay hidden. Foolish man, the only difference between him and the lot in the Senate and Congress, is that he got caught.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pslcitizen
I intend to live forever. So far, so good.
03:22 AM on 05/20/2012
I will be glad when I don't have to hear this mans name anymore. lol
lcreated2
Jesus is God manifest in the Flesh! 1 tim 3:16
02:48 AM on 05/20/2012
There is always a bed next to Roddy Blago, and George Ryan...
11:44 PM on 05/19/2012
The tragedy in the mess Edwards created is what he did to his family. Elizabeth made a huge mistake in marrying Edwards and she paid too high a price. This weeks People has an article titled Who is John Edwards? In it, people stated that Edwards promised Elizabeth on her deathbed that he wouldn't let Hunter into the home she had made for her family. Not only have she and Quinn visited the home but they spent part of last Thanksgiving weekend in the house with Edwards. It's really sad when a man who caused so much harm refused to honor a deathbed promise.
I visited Oakwood Cemetery this week while on vacation and was deeply saddened that there were no flowers at Wade's grave, nor is there a headstone at Elizabeth's grave. She deserves to be remembered as a good mother, but for some reason, she wasn't given the respect she deserves. I hope and pray that her children grow into the happy, strong adults she so wanted them to be.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MiMi LLawsonn
Just my opinion****
10:16 PM on 05/19/2012
IF Edwards is found GUILTY.....THEN AMERICA HAD BETTER BUILD MORE PRISONS....as they will certainly need them and will probably FILL THEM UP FASTER THAN THEY CAN BUILD THEM.....EDWARDS is only the *TIP OF THE ICEBERG*.....let's start at the TOP with O and work our way down....OMG....there will be NO ONE TO RUN THE COUNTRY.....oh...that's OK....NO ONE IS RUNNING IT ANYWAY.....
10:21 PM on 05/19/2012
Faved
photo
Pferdefreund
May I always be the person my dogs think I am.
09:01 PM on 05/19/2012
John Edwards shoudl join the club for most horrible people in the world - gosh this guy makes me sick.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
offcenterlevi
07:17 PM on 05/19/2012
I really don't understand why people who have never violated posting guidelines are prohibited from posting unil moderators approve. This ruins the posting thread for no good reason. Some inappropriate comments still get through. Go figure, and what's the point.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DEBRET
07:39 PM on 05/19/2012
Is that your biggest problem in life?
10:24 PM on 05/19/2012
So YOUR OPINION is that they are inappropriate. Right?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canefighter
I post my thoughts on subjects, not opinions.
05:03 PM on 05/19/2012
I guess the Jurors need a couple days off listening to all the bull spewed from both sides. May they get some sleep and a few good meals in them.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DEBRET
07:40 PM on 05/19/2012
I bet they send a request to the Judge for a few shovels........
10:24 PM on 05/19/2012
Or maybe the tapes he made with his mistress.
lcreated2
Jesus is God manifest in the Flesh! 1 tim 3:16
02:50 AM on 05/20/2012
Drag in another set of waders, those got full!
04:43 PM on 05/19/2012
Hey Johnny... aren't you glad that marraige is between a man and a woman in NC. Bubba wasn't happy about that. He was looking forward to spending the next 30 years with you.
04:41 PM on 05/19/2012
Mr. Edwards is a perfect example of the SCUM we have running our country. They are not concerned about anything but advancing their own personal agenda. DON'T DO AS I DO.... DO AS I SAY!!!
If they are sincere about becoming PUBLIC SERVANTS... let ALL OF THEM serve thier first term... compensation and benefits FREE... kind of like a probabionary period. If re-elected, provide a reasonable compensation package that ends when the job does.
They are ALL... CAREER POLITICIANS... and could give a s*** about serving the public.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lglasst1964
10:30 PM on 05/19/2012
I couldn't agree with you more. All the politician's in Washington have no idea how a "real" person lives as they continue to collect their salary when they retire, don't have to pay into social security and have no idea how much medical insurance costs as they don't pay for theirs. And lets not forget they get secret service protention until they die, and that is quiet expensive, well that and paying for the prostitutes for the ss agents.
tccat4
We all have a right to our opinion, like it or not
04:31 AM on 05/20/2012
Also agree.. The elected ones that are too old are just propped up in their chair with their hands on the vote button...
photo
badboyzs
If you are a cheater.......then you are a liar.
04:17 PM on 05/19/2012
Oh Johnny Boy........You have a collect call from Rod Blago......he is making room for you
in his Fed Pen.....Hey Johhny....just want you to know the view is great....