iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Mesquite High School Yearbooks Pulled After 'Mentally Retarded' Used To Describe Some Students

The Huffington Post  |  By Posted: Updated: 05/21/2012 11:51 pm

Mesquite High School

Officials at Mesquite High School in Mesquite, Texas, have recalled their recently distributed school yearbooks after it was discovered the books described some students with special needs as "mentally retarded," KDFW-TV reports.

"Some of the disabilities the students in the Special Education Program have are being blind, deaf or non-verbal," school spokeswoman Laura Jobe told the station, describing the offending language.

According to KDFW, school officials confiscated the yearbooks after parents and students objected to the language and called it "appalling and disgraceful."

“There was an oversight in the editing approval process,” Jobe told the Dallas Morning News. “Those who work inside the special education department know these requirements.”

Jobe told KDFW the school "earnestly regrets" the error, and that students should be getting their yearbooks back next week, though without the pages including the language.

Mesquite High School's principal also plans to call the parents of the special needs students to apologize, and Jobe told the Dallas Morning News the district would never condone using the term "mentally retarded."

The “Spread the Word to End the Word” campaign, which is sponsored by the Special Olympics, has made it their mission to eliminate the use of the "r-word" in schools and everyday life.

On the group's website, Special Olympics athlete Karleigh Jones explains why the word is "old-fashioned" and offensive:

“The word retard is considered hate speech because it offends people with intellectual and developmental disabilities as well as the people that care for and support them. It alienates and excludes them. It also emphasizes the negative stereotypes surrounding people with intellectual and developmental disabilities; the common belief that people with intellectual and developmental disabilities should be segregated, hidden away from society, which, in my opinion, is really old fashioned.”

Other controversial school-related documents from around the country:

Loading Slideshow...
  • Slavery Examples Used On Math Worksheet

    In January 2012, parents of students at Beaver Ridge Elementary School in Norcross, Ga. expressed outrage over the school district's response to <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/08/examples-of-slavery-in-school-worksheet_n_1192512.html" target="_hplink">reports of using examples of slavery in math word problems.</a> The word problems in questions include references to slavery and "beatings."

  • More Slavery Math Problems

    In March 2012, students at another Georgia school were given a math problem that referenced slavery, upsetting students and parents. Nearly 140 fourth grade students at James A. Jackson Elementary School contained an extra-credit question that read, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/21/james-a-jackson-elementary-school-slavey-math-problems_n_1370125.html" target="_hplink">"A plantation owner had 100 slaves. If three-fifths of them are counted for representation, how many slaves will be counted?"</a>

  • Communism v. Capitalism Worksheet

    In February 2012, Roosevelt High School in Des Moines, Iowa received criticism for a class assignment on the Cold War. Based on a worksheet handed out in a social studies class, many questioned whether the lesson promoted communism over capitalism, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/05/roosevelt-high-school-und_n_1255842.html" target="_hplink">calling it "communist indoctrination."</a>

  • Morbid, Traumatizing Math Problems

    A Washington, D.C. teacher was fired from Center City Public School's Trinidad campus in March 2012 for <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/05/teacher-fired-for-giving-_n_1322173.html" target="_hplink">sending home violent, morbid and traumatizing math problems to third graders.</a> Questions included story lines about baking humans in ovens and a child waking up screaming after thousands of fire ants made a nest in a human brain.

  • Perceived Racist Vocab Quiz

    A teacher was suspended and handed disciplinary action in March 2012 for a question she wrote on a vocabulary quiz that some argued was racist. When district officials reviewed the test in context, however, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/20/lakeshore-schools-rescind_n_1367588.html" target="_hplink">the charges against her were rescinded.</a>

  • 'Degrading,' 'Offensive' Class Photo

    Sawgrass Elementary School in Sunrise, Fla. made the news in April 2012 when a second grade student was included in a class photo despite not having turned in a parental consent form. Instead of retaking the photo, the photographer resolved to <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/05/parents-upset-over-degrading-school-photo_n_1406159.html?ref=education" target="_hplink">paste a brown-colored smiley face over the boy's face.</a>

  • 'African American Attire' = 'Animal Print'?

    A letter sent home with students at Western Union Elementary School in North Carolina didn't sit well with parents in March 2012. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/21/western-union-elementary-african-american-attire_n_1370984.html" target="_hplink">The note asked students to wear "African American attire" or animal print for a Black History Month event,</a> calling into question educators' choice of words and cultural sensitivity.

  • Superintendent In KKK Robe

    In April 2012, flyers with an image of Atlanta Public Schools Superintendent Erroll Davis in a Ku Klux Klan robe sparked controversy in the community. The bill was in response to a contentious school redistricting plan that <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/07/atlanta-public-schools-re_n_1410029.html" target="_hplink">would have closed several schools</a> in a number of Atlanta's black neighborhoods.

FOLLOW EDUCATION

Officials at Mesquite High School in Mesquite, Texas, have recalled their recently distributed school yearbooks after it was discovered the books described some students with special needs as "mentall...
Officials at Mesquite High School in Mesquite, Texas, have recalled their recently distributed school yearbooks after it was discovered the books described some students with special needs as "mentall...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 4,520
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (84 total)
06:42 AM on 06/27/2012
There was an oversight in the editing approval process, "yea right that over sight proves what they think of people that are different"what sad is many schools as in teachers use this R WORD all the time and not just in texas either,kids report it parents ? it and school workers deny it said so child looks like a lier,for once this over sight proves it is being used,if one of them yr books got in my hands i wouldnt return it cuz in black and white shows how others think of people that are different then them
06:52 AM on 06/27/2012
i not mad at school for there so called oversight,infact im glad someone finally did that so called oversight too show when kids come home even the non-special needs kids report a teacher called them that is true.on a side note i however wonder how many kids went home told there parent they was called this word and parents brushed this off and all of sudden open yr book and read it.
our school system is not what it was original made for anymore.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Mojito
"Change is a constant fact of life"
12:44 PM on 05/24/2012
Texas the state with the worst education attainment in the country, just 80.7% of residents over 24 have high school diplomas. The state also has the ninth-highest poverty rate in the U.S. and the highest percentage of residents in the country without health insurance, at nearly one in four. Texas has an upward mobility score of just 31% compared to the national average of 34%.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/05/11/worst-states-to-get-a-raise_n_1509235.html#s=965763”
02:20 AM on 05/29/2012
I am a product of Texas public schools, and it is worse than the numbers you describe. Similar to the situation in China, where the society has made great leaps in economics and technology, while the schools follow a hundred year old routine. In Texas, the bulk of educators have degrees in education, are not particularly intelligent, cause damage to their student's intellects, and hold on to their jobs like grim death.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Mojito
"Change is a constant fact of life"
12:03 PM on 05/29/2012
And now they are locking up preschoolers in small wooden boxes...like the Japanese used in the move "The bridge over the river Kwai". Shameful....
05:32 PM on 05/23/2012
I wonder if everyone forgot that the term "retarded" is a medical term created by doctors and psychologists. It's just us as small minded Americans that seems to blow everything out of proportion that really doesn't even matter. So what they said it, it wasn't a word used as a prank, and I know they didn't use it to offend anyone. It's a word used in the medical world as a diagnosis. Get over it. It's not like they are being called out of their name. It is what it is. A MEDICAL WORD! If you want to blame someone, blame those who came up with it, not those who just chose to use it. If us as Americans could focus more on the REAL problems, like our economic crisis or the war on drugs, and not on silly bullcrap like a word that was said, maybe us as a country we could prosper again.
07:25 PM on 05/23/2012
A yearbook isn't a medical journal or book. A child's diagnosis has no place in a yearbook. Putting it in the yearbook is actually a violation of HIPPA Privacy laws. That is the real issue.

And the medical term is actually Mental Retardation, not "retarded."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LaurieAnn
Charity is NOT a substitute for justice.
11:20 PM on 05/23/2012
The medical,psychological and educational professions are all changing their terminology to 'intellectually disabled' precisely because the word 'retarded' has been so grossly misused as to now have overwhelmingly negative connotations. it's really time to have it dropped from the language, just like other very hurtful words used to described people.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:49 PM on 05/23/2012
Hi LaurieAnn: Agree with you about getting rid of hurtful words to describe people.

Still not convinced "intellectually disabled" is the right word, don't have a suggestion, but would like to see something affirmative or positive.

In his last year of high school, my son took an elective...working with "special needs students", with a range of developmental and physcial issues.

At the end of course, he told me, we could all learn a lot from people, who in his view had "Advanced Emotional IQ."

Love your posts.

Faved, a fan.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
justice1957
12:08 PM on 05/23/2012
This is just a sad commentary on our educational system. Students run the schools, teachers don't care about their jobs, therefore they don't do their jobs. In this case, it is just a sad "State" of affairs. Oh, by the way HuffPost thanks for not allowing my first comment to be posted.Sort of just makes me want to keep my thoughts to myself, as this site is for the far right or left who can post whatever they want, fully spelled curse words and all. Like most things, somewhat unfair.
07:14 AM on 06/27/2012
justice YOU SOUND LIKE MY SON when describing what school like too him in his eyes.WOW point blank u sound like my son students rule teachers dont care.these teachers are made too go too meetings and daughter tells me one of her teachers come back cryen everytime.my daughter ask her why she crys teacher says the new ways are wrong and teachers cant help kids like they use too.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
justice1957
11:44 AM on 06/27/2012
Hi Red Ats, Don't know if you are agreeing with me or not. I sometimes have strong views on a lot a issues. and it affects my emotions. Have a Special Needs Grandchild, a Autistic Nephew so this is an exceptionally important issue to me. If you're Daughter has a Teacher who comes back from meetings crying then she probably has a Teacher who is a very caring Teacher and Person as are the Teachers that my Granddaughter and Nephew have. It's the Cruel kids other Teachers and our failing Educational System that bothers me. Labeling kids from a School System like this one did is wrong and sets a bad example. There needed to be an Adult supervising these yearbooks before they were released. If there was, "They" should be held accountable, if not that school system failed. Take Care
11:15 AM on 05/23/2012
NYS and many other States still use this term and their programs are named after thie term MRDD etc. Why don't they change? http://www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/bmrdd/bmrdd.shtml
10:22 AM on 05/23/2012
The student editors and the staff should be very ashamed of themselves. Do they describe everyone in the school? Did they remark on all the girls with fat a@@es? Did they mention all the kids with serious acne? Did they mention the kids with sexually transmitted diseases? Sally Smith- 10th grade - Gonorrhea last year?

Yes all kids should be in the yearbook but to describe them by their intellectual ability or their disability is akin to stating medical conditions about kids or some sort of other physical condition.

These high school students need much more education prior to letting out in the world. I am frightened for our society if this is what is our next generation.
12:13 AM on 05/23/2012
Ok, here's the deal: It was a mistake. Now lets lay off of it.

They fixed the problem.

It was a nice page in the yearbook about a group of students in the school. There are stories in the yearbook about groups of students from all areas of the school whether that be extracurricular or just certain classes (like AP students, special needs, and photojournalism). These aren'y clubs but they are important parts of the school. The reason they were recalled was because of the lack of parental permission that was needed to print a page of those students.

It was a mistake that slipped past editors, administration, and the publishing company. The end.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SirReal1
12:29 AM on 05/23/2012
It sounds like you know an awful lot about this. Do you work for the School? Did you have something to do with this "page"?

Is there a reason you'd like everyone to "lay off of it"?
01:27 AM on 05/23/2012
I graduated from there last year. I just want my alma mater off the news. We get too much bad press as it is.

I also had been classmates with some of the staff of the yearbook and they are ready for this to be past them.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
justice1957
08:05 PM on 05/23/2012
Very well said. I believe most of the comments that this is no big deal are coming from Texans who are insensitive, ignorant, or just were not raised with a sense of common decency. And just maybe we have some that were responsible for this.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BUTCHER99
11:25 AM on 05/23/2012
they fixed the problem it appears by cutting out those pages, so these people are no longer in the yearbook. not much of a fix.
02:36 PM on 05/23/2012
You understand me mostly. I do don't condone calling out people for what their flaws might be. And the word choice of the article may have been offensive to people but it was an honest mistake. Made by a student. Who apologized. Are we going to reign this over their heads forever? They apologized and fixed the problem the best way they can.

Sorry I'm not sorry for being from my hometown and having pride in the school that taught me enough to survive me through college.
07:20 AM on 06/27/2012
butcher ure right not much of a fix,them yr books 1st are expensive 2nd are made for people too open and look back on,if they removed the pictures ure so right this is not a fix but a cover up.
photo
candlesmp
life is as good as you make it
11:23 PM on 05/22/2012
the editor of the year book needs to have their head examined. I can't believe that it got past them. What was the person thinking? Were they even thinking to allow that page to be printed????
Too often nowadays, the editorial process sucks goose eggs. Being able to edit - really is a lot of work and the person didn't do their job. Don't care how minimal the job is - do it right. This should have never happened. At least the mistake was acknowledged and remedied.
No one group should be singled out unless it's an extra-curricular activity group: like band, or volleyball etc. Most often special needs people want to be treated just like everybody else with the exception of their classes and how they are taught. Which means - do you really have to devote a special page to them? what are they going to do next? a page for the African Americans? The Asians?
06:22 PM on 05/22/2012
I just love how so many people are making such ignorant comments like "lolol what do you expect from Texas?" and whatnot. Grow the fuck up. Mistakes happen, they apologized, and everyone is getting their yearbooks back this week - revised. They fixed the issue. Yes, I agree that is shouldn't have happened in the first place, but it did. You have to remember, students are the ones who do just about the entire yearbook. There's always mistakes in the yearbook, some worse than others. That still doesn't make it right to bad mouth the yearbook staff, or anyone else for that matter.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SirReal1
12:40 AM on 05/23/2012
I wouldn't think of "blaming" the students who worked on the Yearbook, but whoever used that term needs to have it explained to them, so they don't make the same mistake again.

There must have been, however, a faculty member who was responsible for "proofreading" the Yearbook, to make sure that nothing like this ended up being in it. That person failed their responsibility. There should have been an opportunity for the staff to "see" the books before they were distributed to the Students. Those who were given that opportunity, failed their responsibility.

It's fine to say "they apologized, and everyone is getting their yearbooks back", but that completely MISSES THE POINT that these kids were mistreated, and apparently either many people thought that the use of this term was appropriate, or they failed to recognize the offensive term.

Mistakes DO happen, and if they are not properly corrected, they tend to keep happening.
09:28 PM on 05/23/2012
Did you not see what I said? They DID correct the issue. I'm pretty sure I know what I'm talking about, as I saw the page firsthand and have been keeping up with the whole situation since it happened. The pages were removed, the yearbooks were returned, and calls were made to parents of the special education students, who were very understanding. So no, it didn't miss the point. So once again, the mistake WAS corrected! I personally think that the whole page in general shouldn't have even been in there, seeing as it would be the equivalent of a page honoring say...foster children, but I do see the good intentions behind it. Unfortunately, what's done is done, and they are doing their best to fix the mess that they made.
02:36 PM on 05/23/2012
Thank you. I agree.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jill from NYC
Kiss my microbio.
05:18 PM on 05/22/2012
What a callous thing to do. Who on the staff was responsible for editing the yearbook?
04:20 PM on 05/22/2012
Rainbow: After reading your last post about spending years with the Special Olympics clears it all up for me. I hope you won many, many medals.
photo
Kailuabred
Life is Awesome!
02:53 PM on 05/22/2012
I'm not disputing the inappropriateness of the words, but this issue reminds me of a George Carlin bit where the terminology of a particular condition changes constantly over the years.

WWI = Shell shock
WWII = Battle fatigue
Korean War = Operational exhaustion
Vietnam and on = Post traumatic stress disorder

Some in the public can be excused, but I suppose a school should know better.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shannon Barber
Gay, atheist, liberal and proud of it.
01:20 PM on 05/22/2012
I sometimes have to wonder what era some of these so called educators come from. That is a word that carries a ridiculous stigma, and anyone in a position to edit any official document, especially in an educational environment, should know better. That word should not be in the vocabulary of anyone working with Special Education Programs, or with any students, period.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SirReal1
10:57 AM on 05/23/2012
Actually, the ONLY people who should be using that term are those who "work with" Special Education Programs".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_retardation

The term is applicable in Clinical diagnosis, and its use in documents relating to that would be perfectly acceptable.

Where it SHOULD NOT be used is in a general social context, like a School yearbook, because a specific diagnosis is not appropriate for a "public information" release, it is a breach of "privacy rules".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shannon Barber
Gay, atheist, liberal and proud of it.
04:25 PM on 05/23/2012
Yeah, in a clinical context, I understand. I'd just think that they, of all people, wouldn't print it in a yearbook.
03:34 PM on 05/24/2012
I'd be happy to show you my bird, soldier. Can you see it?
12:20 PM on 05/22/2012
My son was born with Down syndrome, so the struggles and concerns over not wanting him excluded or treated disrespectfully are part of my life now. I, like many who comment here, have had moments of impatience with "politically correct" language over time, though. I remember (before diagnosis) making jokes and put downs using the word "special".... comments about "the short bus"... calling myself a "retard" for doing something wrong or stupid. My attitude was changed on this term in a rather extreme way after my son's diagnosis. Yet I understand A LITTLE BIT when people get peevish or impatient over which word is right or wrong. What it comes down to is a struggle to encourage people to be kind and respectful.
11:51 AM on 05/22/2012
There is NO need to point out who is in special education!! That would be like having a "fat people" page or something. It is unforgivable and just plain ole stupid. I foresee several lawsuits. That information is confidential and any decent teacher goes out of their way to protect the students not put them on display. It's obvious by some of the comments on here that the public really needs educated on special needs. This is just sad that so many people feel this way.
02:09 AM on 05/29/2012
Yeah,, thanks for the post informing us that you're perfect. Change your name to Jesus the Second. . zzzzzzzzzz