iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Posted:  |  Updated: 08/22/12 EDT

Mind The Gap: Getting The Right Workers Into The Right Jobs

America remains in the midst of an unemployment crisis. Despite private-sector job gains in recent months, nearly 13 million people are still looking for work, and the national unemployment rate hovers stubbornly at 8.2 percent.

skills gap

And yet, in one of the more hopeful signs of recovery, the number of job openings has been growing steadily. American employers advertised an estimated 3.6 million job vacancies at the end of May, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Aside from March of this year, that's the most openings we've seen in roughly four years and by far the most since the recession officially ended in mid-2009, when there were only about 2.5 million openings.

The openings reveal a few rays of light in different sectors. Although construction still remains battered, manufacturing had a considerable 310,000 job vacancies, about triple the number from mid-2009, showing at least a temporary rebound for an industry long in decline. Education and health care job openings hit roughly 700,000 for the first time since mid-2008, having dropped to around 500,000 during the recession. Vacancies in the retail world are up by about a third of where they were just two years earlier.

"It tells us there's a need and willingness to add to payrolls," said Charlotte Oslund, a statistician at BLS. "The hypothesis is, when the economy is improving, then an employer is going to work current employees more, or they might hire temporary help. But the last thing they will do is post a job opening. That’s the final step in the recovery."

But there's a slightly puzzling trend in the numbers, Oslund said: The rate of new job openings has been outpacing the number of new hires.

There could be a number of reasons for this, including geography. Unemployed workers aren't necessarily where the new jobs are, or have a hard time moving because of their underwater homes. Wages could be another reason: Workers who had good jobs don't necessarily want to settle for less pay. And there's also the notion of "skills gaps" in certain industries -- the debatable idea that not enough workers have the proper training for certain jobs. Our education system, some argue, isn't addressing the mismatch between the skills acquired by American workers and the skills needed. As seen in the map below, some cities, like Missoula, Mont., have an overabundance of highly educated workers, while others, like El Paso, Texas, don't have enough.

BLS statistics don't pinpoint exactly where the new job openings are geographically -- only which sectors they fall in -- or how long particular job vacancies have gone unfilled. But the Brookings Institution has amassed data on what it calls "education gaps" -- the degree to which workers in certain areas have the education they need for jobs that are available locally. In addition to graphing which sectors hold the 3.6 million open jobs, HuffPost has mapped out the different education gaps of metro area across the country.

As for why openings are growing at a faster pace than new hires, Oslund said there are a handful of theories but no firm answers.

"For some reason, we're just not getting people into all those jobs," Oslund said. "If you figure it out, let us know."


Graphics by Timothy Wallace

FOLLOW EDUCATION

America remains in the midst of an unemployment crisis. Despite private-sector job gains in recent months, nearly 13 million people are still looking for work, and the national unemployment rate hover...
America remains in the midst of an unemployment crisis. Despite private-sector job gains in recent months, nearly 13 million people are still looking for work, and the national unemployment rate hover...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 66
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:37 AM on 08/01/2012
Excellent map.

I remember back in high school, instead of home Economics and other shame classes I took brick mason, cabinet making, drafting and auto mechanics. I am glad I did now.

lol, although, my current occupation is neither, I am a truck driver. However, I now enough about each one of those to have a basis of whether I would want to pursue and if so in what ways. Not to mention other work with hands is not off of the table.

I think youth should be required to take more of these shop classes. It believe it helped. However, none of it can replace the influence from home which can enable the person to look at work and providing for yourself in different ways.

Ultimately, it's not the school's responsibility to teach the youth about being able to provide for him/herself whether that is seeking employment or getting creating in finding work. It is the parent's responsibility.

So what we all should learn from the hard times and high employment is the type of lessons that we should be teaching our children.

It varies from entrepreneurship to learning a trade but most importantly, being creative and thinking outside of the box. Along with it, the rewards of being willing to work hard and the ability to learning how to work smart.

You see, work ethic is also a problem today. Many people are let go because they don't work in the first place. That's just real talk.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
No No No No No NO
03:54 AM on 07/29/2012
Nope, 1 track mind. All students must go to college and all students must get college degree's! There is no other option.

I wish someone would have steered me towards a trade when I was younger. Plumbing, iron, steel, construction, electrician.
09:41 AM on 07/27/2012
Enjoyed the article and yes I agree that the GAP in Skill, Demand and education STILL Exists here in the USA. With 3.6M jobs available that are NOT ABLE to be filled...I would say that's a bigger problem than what the political process want to address.
08:45 AM on 07/27/2012
M
More and more it seems that humanity is becoming subservient to the needs of big business. Today’s article, for example, suggests that jobs are available to unemployed workers who are willing to relocate. What is overlooked in such analyses is the human factor: it is often painful for people to leave their friends, family, church, schools and communities. This is especially true when there is no guarantee that the job to which a worker relocates will be permanent. Large corporations have no loyalty to place: Their only loyalty is to profits for shareholders. Thus, workers become pawns. To give up everything in order to take a job that pays $15 to $25 dollars an hour might be appealing if it came with an assurance that the new employer would not be sold, or relocate. It is easy to be totally “rational” about such decisions, unless you or your loved one is faced with this difficult prospect.
ore and more it seems that humanity is becoming conser
09:47 AM on 07/27/2012
living down and out would be more painful for you and that family if you've got one. so it would seem/appear you would want to take all measures to ensure take everyone down. and don't look for guarantees. as a sharholder and investor I like and need that loyalty. you see business doesn't exist to hire or employ people.
10:09 AM on 07/27/2012
I have a family, incluidng 3 college-educated adult children-each successful in the private sector and each relocated inorder to find jobs. I, too, relocated. My point is not that people should not seek employment. My point is that there are human factors that cannot be disregarded. The unbridled copetition among companies has a toll on our quality of life. Small business, with deep roots in a community, are taken over my larger corporations who seek to increase market share. They gain. We lose. If space permitted I could give you many examples starting with my father's drug store that was unable to compete with huge chains in the 1960's, to a local stationary and office supply company that was driven out of business by a large competitor that bought out the small operation's suppliers, then closed the local retail outlet. I have no idea what the solution might be. My point is that I value people over profits and I do not see people as feudal serfs whose quality of life is determined by the feudal lord.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
VictoryBlue
Motorcycle rider, Legalization supporter, Texan
03:54 PM on 07/27/2012
you see business doesn't exist to hire or employ people.

It doesn't? So that business doesn't make anything or sell anything, right? So, that would make it an investment bank? Last time I checked, you needed people to make things and sell things otherwise, you cannot make anything therefore you have nothing to sell.
03:05 AM on 07/27/2012
What’s more clear with Employment report is that when it comes to joblessness, having a college degree is more important than ever that is why we need the help of High Speed Universities now
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Mort
Once I thought I was wrong, but I was mistaken.
03:02 AM on 07/27/2012
I'd like a job where I can do anything I want without being responsible, make lots of money, be well taken care of for the rest of my life, take a third to half of every year off, never be expected to do what I was hired to do, accept all kinds of gifts & bribes, and can't get fired. But there are no openings in Congress at the moment.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
OntheBorder
Part of the 53% that carries the Liberal weight
04:00 AM on 07/27/2012
Europe is always an option.

But the down side is you'd be in Europe.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Mort
Once I thought I was wrong, but I was mistaken.
11:14 PM on 07/28/2012
lol. Good!
09:48 AM on 07/27/2012
every 2 years there are openings. get yourself together and make a run. otherwise whining is a no-go
05:00 PM on 07/28/2012
Actually, whining is how an election campaign starts!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Mort
Once I thought I was wrong, but I was mistaken.
11:13 PM on 07/28/2012
It'd never work. I'm not dishonest enough.
01:41 AM on 07/27/2012
Anyone can post a job. When you post a job people send you all their information...for free. I hope you can see my point already. In case you can't I will explain. Data is digital gold. And post jobs on the internet to get resumes is just free data.

Secondly, corporations that use work visas have to make up data to justify work visas. They have to prove to the government they couldn't find skilled Americans to get the jobs they posted. At Microsoft we got around this by offshoring resume screening to a company in India. The Indian company was a offshoring company that provided us with H-1B workers. So its not really a surprise that they never thought ANY Americans were qualified.
05:01 PM on 07/28/2012
Job hunting is like dating": recruiters (mostly female) want those already spoken for. If you're seen as actively searching, then you're "too needy".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
R307Johnson
Oh those silly Republicans
01:40 AM on 07/27/2012
The major problem is that there is no national employment system. Jobs are no longer published in the newspaper or job service. The majority of jobs today are only listed on that companies website. The hardest thing for job seekers is not getting the but finding if there are positions out there. This country needs a database that all jobs are listed and also that all seeking jobs are signed up. We need to stop this foolishness of trying to locate a couple of rowboats on a fog covered ocean.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JRambo
I'm coming to get you beer boy, WHEW!
02:42 AM on 07/27/2012
Well, LinkedIn is a pretty awesome place to find jobs. In fact in the past month I've been contacted with eight very high paying positions and I'm not even looking. There is no reason to set up another government entity for this. Besides, some of the best jobs are the ones not posted and come from who you know... A national database won't find those...
05:05 PM on 07/28/2012
Your first statement proves my point, and your last one proves Johnson's. If the government can win wars and get into space, then it can work with businesses to create jobs. But the public and private power elite don't care about most people, as long as they maintain power.
09:51 AM on 07/27/2012
oh another person that thinks that a national database run by the govt of course is good. every state has a database of jobs avail thru their employment services dept....thats all you need. once again someone thinks govt running things and their lives is best.
05:07 PM on 07/28/2012
Tell me how Halliburton sank the Japanese carriers at Midway, or built the internet, or funded the cure for polio, or the building of the Transcontinental Railroad.
photo
abbienormal
What hump?
01:21 AM on 07/27/2012
For the last two years I have been saying that structural unemployment was the real problem and it is.

Time and time again I hear about manufacturers that cannot find workers with enough math skills to work in the highly technologically advanced environment in which they now operate.
02:05 AM on 07/27/2012
The sad thing is they are talking about addition.
photo
abbienormal
What hump?
02:13 AM on 07/27/2012
Yes.  It is very sad that you are correct.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JRambo
I'm coming to get you beer boy, WHEW!
02:45 AM on 07/27/2012
LOL. Isn't that sad. I remember in college (I was a comp sci major) that I took a few business classes. The students were complaining how hard accounting was. Come on.. It is adding and subtracting and simple formulas. I said, really? This is hard? The entire country culture around math needs to change. While it isn't acceptable socially to not be able to read, people widely accept others that can't do math. Something as simple as calculating a tip... That is one of the reasons companies are looking to India and China for labor. It isn't just cost...
05:10 PM on 07/28/2012
Years ago, employers weren't too lazy to train up their workers. Read an online job description today, and it's like they're looking for an Atlas for every position.

The truth is that people from India or China who know math will work for less than native-born math-minded Americans; scabbing is nothing new here.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AGirlWithAPlan
It's all in a lifetime!
05:36 PM on 07/28/2012
Volkmoidruk: So what about cross training? Do they still do this? This is a sincere question. Btw, I was in the store yesterday and the young lady entered the wrong amount on the register. It was like 39.42. I gave her 40.00. She started to hand me back $1.58. I explained that she just needed to give me the change, not the dollar and the change.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Artamentous
Workplace Democracy!
01:13 AM on 07/27/2012
This country has millions unemployed, and millions of square feet of unused productive capacity

What kind go stupidity has millions who want work, and millions of tools, equipment, and space sitting idle, completely unused? Capitalism.
02:07 AM on 07/27/2012
Why do you think it matters that lots of people want jobs? That's irrelevant. There has to be a demand for their labor.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:35 AM on 07/27/2012
You missed his point!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Artamentous
Workplace Democracy!
09:01 PM on 07/27/2012
LOL WHAT? So you are telling me there is not glaring social needs for America? Our infrastructure is crumbling, we need a high speed rail system, we need to move to more sustainable energy. That means WE as AMericans create the demand through our government. This would in turn stimulate the economy. How do you think FDR handled the depression? Why is that option not even on the table? 
09:55 AM on 07/27/2012
what do you want to do with those things, tools? just start hammering ()hit together. pay people with govt dole money? give the ue something do to? borrow more money to pay the ue 25 an hour? you are just too good to be true. what a liberal
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Artamentous
Workplace Democracy!
09:13 PM on 07/27/2012
*Feeds troll* It worked just fine in the 1930's, in fact all the work they did ended up helping the economy in the proceeding decades thanks to all the infrastructure that was built.

BTW, if the government were to pay people 25 bucks an hour, that would spur massive demand. People want to make their money and spend it. It's not a difficult concept.
05:12 PM on 07/28/2012
What a Koch shill. How much do they pay you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
09:19 PM on 07/26/2012
Up here in Canada we have two post-secondary setups (Quebec's is slightly different with CEGEP): you go to college (diploma) or university (degree). People still poo poo the idea of their kid not going to university for four years, instead going to community college for three years. there is a shortage of tradespeople which provides a good living at good pay and good apprenticeship opportunities. I get tired of the elitist attitude that being a welder or mechanic or any hands-on work is too 'common'.
01:44 AM on 07/27/2012
On the contrary, I still wonder why business is a 4 year degree. Business is a trade and should be in trade schools, not the university. There isn't anything good or bad about either trade schools or university. I have been to both. They are just different.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JRambo
I'm coming to get you beer boy, WHEW!
02:48 AM on 07/27/2012
It depends... If you are talking about business management or finance, there are a number of theories to study. If you are talking about something like accounting, I agree. But most universities have a business administration degree and students specialize in say accounting. It probably depends on the aspirations of the student and whether he or she wants to go on to higher education or to go into management of people. But yea, neither one is better or worse. However, the four year students generally are paid more.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:10 PM on 07/26/2012
The Biggest problem we have in our school system is there is no more shop classes like woodshop metal shop or any other vocational training. The only thing taught in PUBLIC schools is how to share, be good to each other and never hurt anyone. And of course global warming and being a earth friendly citizen. Lastly we need to stop teachers from haveing sex with 15 yr olds
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:16 AM on 07/27/2012
There are vocational high schools students can choose to go to, and if that's what you think school is like then you are completely out of touch.
photo
abbienormal
What hump?
01:22 AM on 07/27/2012
Hear, hear!

F&F.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shaun Hensley
The American Experiment has failed
01:25 AM on 07/27/2012
The reality is that there are tradespeople with decades of experience out of work, vocational training isn't the solution, restoring and rebuilding our manufacturing base is.
02:08 AM on 07/27/2012
We manufacture more now than ever in history. These are the glory days.
02:41 AM on 07/27/2012
Too many times I have been on a job, (electrical construction) where I am given an apprentice to help me and he is pulled away because he/she is slowing me down.. I say that it is up to us to train these kids, and the foreman replies " We don't have time to teach them anything, we have to get the job done." It burns me up to hear these things.