Most women (and men) probably have trouble hearing criticism of their bodies, but elite female athletes -- those competing at Olympic-qualifying level -- are particularly exposed to public scrutiny and, as Houston's KHOU News noted in a report today, one in five of them suffer from eating disorders.
Even so, on July 24th the Melbourne, Australia-based Herald Sun published photos of Leisel Jones, the 26-year-old Aussie swimmer and eight-time Olympic medalist, taken recently and in 2008, claiming that she doesn’t look as good as she once did.
The media outlet even published a photo caption stating: “The Olympic veteran’s figure is in stark contrast to that of 2008.” They also ran a poll asking readers whether Jones was “fit” enough to swim in the 2012 Olympics, Yahoo! Sports reported. Unsurprisingly, many haven’t taken too kindly to the focus on Jones’ physique -- especially on the eve of the 2012 Summer Olympics Games in London. Public outcry prompted the Herald Sun to take down the poll soon after it was published.
Jones first competed in the 2000 Olympics in Sydney at the age of 15. She has earned Australia three gold, four silver and one bronze medal. Fellow Australian female Olympians were among the first to come to Jones’ defense:
Melanie Schlanger, Jones' teammate on the Australian Olympic swim team:
I'm embarrassed by the Aussie media having a go at Leisel, one of Australia's greatest Olympians. Support athletes don't drag them down— Melanie Schlanger (@Mel_Schlanger) July 24, 2012
Katherine Bates, former Olympic track and road cyclist:
My bad - I didn't realise Leisel Jones earned her spot in London at a pageant. Here was I thinking she was a great swimmer!— Katherine Bates (@KatherineLBates) July 25, 2012
Alice Tait, former Olympic swimmer:
The questioning over Leisel Jones fitness due to an unflattering photo is exactly what many girls have body image issues! Make me so angry!— Alice Tait (@Alice_Tait) July 24, 2012
Giaan Rooney, also a retired Olympic swimmer:
...an athlete is called 'overweight'. I didn't care about what my body looked like when I swam, I cared about what it could do. #perspective— Giaan Rooney (@GiaanRooney) July 25, 2012
The backlash Thursday led to a conversation about whether the media should comment on athletes’ physiques at all. Jezebel’s Doug Barry had some harsh words for the Herald Sun:
Jones has a whole pile of medals ... to prove that she doesn't need the Herald Sun's permission to wear a bathing suit, so maybe the sports editors over there should keep all their grubby little opinions about her weight to themselves.
Yet this sort of intense body scrutiny is a fact of life for many women in the public eye, especially models and actresses. While some would argue that celebrities sign up for this, or that it’s these women’s responsibility to ignore the criticism, actress Ashley Judd feels differently. She hit back at the media coverage of her supposedly “puffy face” back in April in an op-ed. “We are described and detailed, our faces and bodies analyzed and picked apart, our worth ascertained and ascribed based on the reduction of personhood to simple physical objectification,” Judd wrote in the Daily Beast.
Regardless of whether Jones’ body has changed since 2008 (as bodies often do between the ages of 22 and 26), she earned a spot on the 2012 Olympic team. Do you think that the media has a right to comment on her physique?
Margo Oberg is a three-time world surfing champion from the United States. She won her first world title in 1977, then won back-to-back titles in 1980 and 1981.
Serena Williams returns a ball against Danish Caroline Wozniacki during their match of the Madrid Masters on May 10, 2012 at the Magic Box (Caja Magica) sports complex in Madrid. Williams won 1-6, 6-3, 6-2.
U.S. swimmer Jenny Thompson from Dover, N.H. practices with paddles 24 July 1992. Thompson is favored to win several gold medals during the women's individual events.
USA woman's soccer player Mia Hamm prepares to center the ball during a practice session at Rice Eccles Olympic Stadium 13 June 2003 in Salt Lake City, Utah. The US will play Ireland in a friendly match 14 June, 2003, in Salt Lake City.
Gracia Leydon-Mahoney competes in the women's 10-meter platform final at the U.S. Olympic diving trials, Sunday, June 24, 2012, in Federal Way, Wash.
Brittney Griner and Chiney Ogwumike
Brittney Griner #42 of the Baylor Bears reaches for a rebound in the second half against Chiney Ogwumike #13 of the Stanford Cardinal during the National Semifinal game of the 2012 NCAA Division I Women's Basketball Championship at Pepsi Center on April 1, 2012 in Denver, Colorado.
Mary Lou Retton
Mary Lou Retton during the 1984 Olympics in Los Angeles where she took first overall.
Elena Hight practices for the ladies snowboard halfpipe finals during the U.S. Snowboarding and Freeskiing Grand Prix on March 3, 2012 in Mammoth, California. Hight went on to win the event.
At the World Championships in Athletics, under the auspices of the International Association of Athletics Federations, in Seville, Spain, 1999.
US athlete Julie Zetlin performs with the ribbon in the qualifying round during the 31st Rythmic Gymnastics World Championships on September 22, 2011 in Montpellier, southern France.
Michelle Kwan competes in the short program during the State Farm U.S. Figure Skating Championships January 8, 2004 at Philips Arena in Atlanta, Georgia.
April Ross dives for a ball during the AVP Hermosa Beach Open at the Hermosa Beach Pier on July 17, 2010 in Hermosa Beach, California.
Laila Ali and Shelley Burton
Laila Ali (R) of the US gets caught by a punch from Shelley Burton of the US during their WBC Super Middleweight Championship fight, 11 November 2006, at Madison Square Garden in New York.
Emily Jackson competes in the women's K1 of the 2012 U.S. Olympic Trials for Whitewater Slalom at the U.S. National Whitewater Center on April 14, 2012 in Charlotte, North Carolina.
Danielle Carruthers competes in the women's 100 meter hurdles semi-final during Day Two of the 2012 U.S. Olympic Track & Field Team Trials at Hayward Field on June 23, 2012 in Eugene, Oregon.
Neva Day of the USA in action during qualifying for the Women's Indiviual Pursuit at the UCI Track Cycling World Cup Classic at the Manchester Velodrome on February 24, 2007 in Manchester, England.
USA Team Synchro Swimmers
USA team synchro swimmers perform 24 March 2007 at the Susie O'Neill pool in Melbourne during the team free routine final of the 12th FINA World Swimming Championships. Russia won gold in the event with Spain taking silver and Japan the bronze. USA placed fifth.
Hyleas Fountain of United States competes in the shot put in the women's heptathlon during day three of the 13th IAAF World Athletics Championships at the Daegu Stadium on August 29, 2011 in Daegu, South Korea.
Michelle Wie hits a shot during the first round of the LPGA LOTTE Championship Presented by J Golf at the Ko Olina Golf Club on April 18, 2012 in Kapolei, Hawaii.
Lindsey Vonn of US competes during the women's first run of Alpine skiing World Cup slalom final in Schladming on March 17, 2012.
Florence Griffith-Joyner won three Olympic gold medals at the Seoul Games in 1988.