ENTERTAINMENT
08/01/2012 12:56 pm ET Updated Aug 06, 2012

How Soon Is Too Soon For A Hollywood Remake?

As the old adage goes, “There are no new stories; it all depends on how you handle them.” Or, how you make audiences want to buy another ticket. Remakes have been a part of Hollywood for decades — Alfred Hitchcock made The Man Who Knew Too Much twice — but the process has seemingly sped up in recent years: This summer, Sony is reviving Total Recall after just 22 years. Is that too soon? Audiences will decide, but here’s a look at Hollywood’s recent obsession with remake culture — and how the box office has responded.

Arthur (2011)

2012-08-06-MCDARTH_EC103_H.JPG
Years between: 30 years
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $46.6 million
If the underwhelming Arthur taught Hollywood anything, it’s that Russell Brand is no Dudley Moore.

King Kong (2005)
2012-08-06-MCDKIKO_EC082_H.JPG
Years between: 29 years
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $646.8 million
From Middle-earth to the middle of Manhattan. Peter Jackson used his technical prowess to bring the classic film King Kong back to the big screen after 29 years — and 72 years after the original.

Ocean’s ELEVEN (2001)
2012-08-06-oceanseleven2001posterartworkgeorgeclooneybradpittmattdamon.jpg
Years between: 41 years
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $584.3 million
The rare remake that actually improves on the original — both in gross and content. Steven Soderbergh turned Frank Sinatra’s Rat Pack classic into a playground for George Clooney, Brad Pitt, Matt Damon and Julia Roberts. It worked.

Get Carter (2000)
2012-08-06-AP08092704035.jpg
Years between: 29 years
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $25.8 million
The revenge thriller flopped at the box office, pushing star Sylvester Stallone back to what he does best: Playing Rocky and Rambo.

Fright Night (2011)
2012-08-06-AP110929161427.jpg
Years between: 26 years
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $41.8 million
Last summer, Colin Farrell had no box-office luck with Fright Night, a genre classic remake. Fingers crossed his remake of Total Recall, another genre classic, fares better here in 2012.

Casino Royale (2006)
2012-08-06-MCDCARO_EC122_H.JPG
Years between: 4
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $676.4 million
Just four years after Pierce Brosnan and Halle Berry made the derided Bond film Die Another Day, the franchise was rebooted back to square one with Daniel Craig. Casino Royale made 007 dark and brooding, but that didn’t stop audiences from showing up in droves.

War of the Worlds (2005)
2012-08-06-MCDWAOF_EC035_H.JPG
Years between: 52
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $695.3 million
Steven Spielberg dusted off H.G. Wells’ classic novel, and added some harrowing 9/11 imagery and Tom Cruise. The results are the most successful reboot ever — at least until The Amazing Spider-Man shuffles out of theaters.

The Amazing Spider-Man (2012)
2012-08-06-MCDSPID_EC022_H.JPG
Years between: 5
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $654 million (and counting)
Sony was chastised for rebooting the Spider-Man franchise just five years after Spider-Man 3, but the studio has had the last laugh. Amazing Spider-Man could top $800 million worldwide, making it he biggest reboot ever.

Alfie (2005)
2012-08-06-MSDALFI_EC064_H.JPG
Years between: 39 years
Reboot/remake worldwide gross: $41.3 million
What’s it all about, Alfie? Apparently, an unwanted remake. Like Get Carter, this was another failed attempt at remaking a once-successful Michael Caine film.

This story originally appeared in Huffington, in the iTunes App store.

CONVERSATIONS