Women who might think twice about a summer trip to a national park can now officially rest assured: it turns out that menstrual odors do not attract bear attacks, according to a paper by the National Park Service.
The paper was written in response to the long-standing concern that the odors associated with menstruation could lure in hungry bears, putting women at a higher risk than men of being mauled. The concern proved to be little more than an urban legend, at least when it comes to grizzly and black bears.
According to researcher Kerry A. Gunther, who wrote the paper: "There is no evidence that grizzly and black bears are overly attracted to menstrual odors more than any other odor."
The paper also traced the origin of the myth to a single evening on Aug. 13, 1967, when two women were killed by grizzly bears in Glacier National Park. The events caused speculation at the time that the attacks may have been prompted by menstrual odors. Presumably, as years passed without any investigation, the speculation eventually morphed into belief — and, unfortunately, unjustified fears.
The NPS paper gleaned its conclusions from separate studies performed on grizzly bears, black bears and polar bears. For grizzly bears, hundreds of attacks on humans were analyzed, finding no link between menstruation and the attacks. Such a link was also debunked regarding black bears, after a 1991 study recorded the responses of 26 free-ranging black bears to used tampons collected from 26 different women. Not a single instance of a black bear being attracted to the tampons was observed.
Results were not so cut-and-dry when it came to polar bears, however. A 1983 study found that four captive polar bears elicited a strong response when presented with menstrual odors. That study also reported that wild polar bears were found to consume used tampons, while ignoring unused tampons. The bears also ignored non-menstrual human blood. So polar bears may provide the lone exception to the rule.
Even so, the unjustified spread of the menstruation/bear attack myth, in spite of the lack of corroborating evidence, raises concerns that old stereotypes regarding women, the outdoors, and the National Park Service have not gone away. As pointed out by one magazine, the persistence of the myth has reinforced the stereotype that women are not as suited for survival in the wilderness as men. It implies that the wilderness is a masculine domain, and that a woman's place is indoors — for her own safety, of course.
(Interestingly, 79 percent of all bear attacks in Yellowstone National Park from 1980-2011 were inflicted on men. In other words, it's possible that these stereotypes also mask the disproportionate dangers that men seem to face from bears.)
The National Park Service is no stranger to these biases either. According to an official NPS 1962 report, "women [(and people of color) were seen] as competent to be interpreters in historical parks, but not in the military or traditional 'national' parks where the prevailing ethic still saw a uniformed ranger as a white male." It was not until 1978 that women were allowed to don the same uniform as male rangers and assume equal responsibilities. Even today, only a third of park rangers are women.
In other words, it would appear that the real bias toward women has come from our culture and the National Park Service, not from the bears.
Perhaps now that the National Park Service has officially come clean about the bear attack myth, the bounty of open spaces in the U.S. national park system can finally begin to truly be open to all.
Kamchatka bear twins named Cuba and Toby, with their mother Kamcatka play in the outdoor enclosure at Brno Zoo for the first time on May 31, 2012. The Kamchatka bear is the largest subspecies of brown bear, weighing up to 1000 kg. RADEK MICA/AFP/GettyImages
Kamchatka bear Kamcatka, mother of twin bear cubs, plays in the outdoor enclosure at Brno Zoo for the first time on May 31, 2012. The Kamchatka bear is the largest subspecies of brown bear, weighing up to 1000 kg. RADEK MICA/AFP/GettyImages
Polar bear Anori lays in the sun on May 30, 2012 at the zoo in Wuppertal, western Germany. Anori was born January 4, 2012 at the zoo in Wuppertal and is a half-sister of world famous polar bear Knut, who died in 2011. FEDERICO GAMBARINI/AFP/GettyImages
A black bear is seen in the Shenandoah National Park in Virginia. KAREN BLEIER/AFP/GettyImages
Two Giant Pandas at an enclosure before they are taken back to the wild, at the Wolong National Nature Reserve in Wolong, southwest China's Sichaun province on May 3, 2012. The bears will be left to fend for themselves to learn crucial survival skills, and scientists plan to gradually reduce human interactions until they can live in the wild without any assistance, and while there have already been 10 attempts at setting pandas free over the past 30 years, and only two are thought to have been successful as the bears find it very hard to survive on their own. STR/AFP/GettyImages
A mother polar bear plays with one of her three cubs born in last November, at the Moscow Zoo, on March 22, 2012. ANDREY SMIRNOV/AFP/Getty Images
KINGUSSIE, SCOTLAND - APRIL 09: Walker (L) the polar bear meets with new male companion Arktos at the Highland Wildlife Park on April 9, 2012 in Kingussie, Scotland. Arktos arrived from Hannover Zoo in Germany on April 4 to be a companion to the Park's resident polar bear Walker. A year older than Walker and slightly larger, Arktos is four-years-old and it's hoped that the bears will establish a relationship of friendly competitiveness. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)
QUANZHOU, CHINA - FEBRUARY 24: (CHINA OUT) Bears stand by a wall at a bear farm of Guizhentang Pharmaceutical Co Ltd on February 24, 2012 in Quanzhou, Fujian Province of China. The Guizhentang Pharmaceutical Co Ltd, which makes medicine using bile extracted from live bears, opened one of its bear farms to the media on Wednesday, to quell growing criticism. (Photo by ChinaFotoPress/ChinaFotoPress via Getty Images)
A bear is seen at one of the traditional Chinese medicine company Guizhentang's controversial bear bile farms in Hui'an, southeast China's Fujian province on February 22, 2012. Bear bile has long been used in China to treat various health problems, despite skepticism over its effectiveness and outrage over the bile extraction process, which animal rights group say is excruciatingly painful for bears. STR/AFP/Getty Images
This photo taken on January 17, 2012 shows a zoo keeper attending to a new-born polar bear cub at the Ocean Aquarium of Penglai, in Yantai, in east China's Shandong province. This female cub was delivered by five-year-old polar bear 'Pengpeng' on January 1 weighing 640 grams, as the first polar bear born in the aquarium. STR/AFP/Getty Images
A spectacled bear (tremarctos ornatus), born in captivity four months ago, is seen at the zoo in Cali, Valle del Cauca department, Colombia, on January 11, 2012. LUIS ROBAYO/AFP/Getty Images
A pair of Brown bears play fight December 21, 2011 at the Bronx Zoo in New York. DON EMMERT/AFP/Getty Images
KINGUSSIE, SCOTLAND - DECEMBER 07: Walker the polar bear plays with a hard hat on his third birthday at the Highland Wildlife Park on December 7, 2011 in Kingussie, Scotland. Walker was born in Rhenen Zoo in Holland on 7th December 2008. He came to live at the Highland Wildlife Park after his aunt, Freedom, became pregnant and needed to retire to her cubbing den, his mother was also due to come on heat and be reintroduced back to the Zoo's adult male, Walker's dad. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)
EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - DECEMBER 16: Tian Tian the female panda bear looks out from her enclosure as members of the public view her for the first time at Edinburgh Zoo on December 16, 2011 in Edinburgh, Scotland. The eight-year-old pair of giant pandas arrived on a specially chartered flight from China over a week ago and are the first to live in the UK for 17 years. Edinburgh zoo are hopeful that the pandas will give birth to cubs during their 10 year stay in Scotland. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)
Polar bears play in the water of Blijdorp Zoo in Rotterdam, Netherlands on September 30, 2011. The weather forecast for the weekend to come promises plenty of sunshine and temperatures around 25 degrees. ROBERT VOS/AFP/Getty Images
KEENESBURG, CO - OCTOBER 20: A grizzly bear waits to be fed at The Wild Animal Sanctuary on October 20, 2011 in Keenesburg, Colorado. The non-profit sanctuary is a 720-acre refuge for large carnivores that have been confiscated from illegal or abusive situations and is currently home to over 290 lions, tigers, bears, wolves and other large carnivores. It is the oldest and largest carnivore sanctuary in the United States, having been in operation since 1980. On Tuesday the owner of a Zanesville, Ohio private animal reserve set loose 56 animals, of which 49 were hunted down and killed by law enforcement and six others were tranquilized and are being treated at the Columbus Zoo. (Photo by John Moore/Getty Images)
A bear is seen in the Kuwait Zoo in the heart of the capital on September 4, 2011. YASSER AL-ZAYYAT/AFP/Getty Images
Polar bear shakes off water in his enclosure at the zoo on July 26, 2011 in Prague. MICHAL CIZEK/AFP/Getty Images)
A brown bear rests at the Safari park in Fasano, in the Apulia region, on August 4, 2011. GIUSEPPE CACACE/AFP/Getty Images
A three month old bear cub who was born at the zoo in Stavropol takes a walk on May 5, 2011. DANIL SEMYONOV/AFP/Getty Images
Newborn Polar Bear Cubs
Newborn Polar Bear Cubs. A set of newborn polar bear twins make their public debut.
Anuri The Baby Polar Bear
Meet Germany's latest animal superstar - Anuri the polar bear.