The number of jobs created by startup companies in the U.S. is dropping at an alarming rate, according to a new study by the Hudson Institute.
The study, which draws on government data, finds that more than three years after the end of the recession in 2009, when job creation at new firms hit an all-time low, the number of startup jobs in America has continued to plummet.
“The state of entrepreneurship is, sadly, weaker than ever,” writes the paper’s author, Tim Kane, chief economist at the Hudson Institute, a conservative Washington, D.C. think-tank. “The rate of startup jobs during 2010 and 2011, years that were technically in full recovery, are the lowest on record.”
The findings contrast the torrent of startup success stories broadcast by the media in the aftermath of the recession. From Silicon Valley to Silicon Alley, and in entrepreneurial hubs across the nation, founders and venture capitalists have said they’ve observed rising levels of company creation as the fixed costs of launching a business fall to historic lows. But globalization and technology -- which have made starting a company easier and cheaper than ever -- appear to have also made it more difficult than ever for U.S. workers to land jobs at new firms, Kane’s study suggests.
The number of jobs created by establishments less than one-year-old decreased to an all-time low of 2.8 million in 2009 from 4.1 million in 1994, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data cited in the report. Then, in 2010, the number of startup jobs fell even further to 2.5 million. The plunge is unprecedented, Kane said in an interview with HuffPost.
“Yes this has been the most severe recession,” he noted. “You might say it’s been, say, twice as bad as some of the previous recessions. But what you’re seeing in startup jobs is much more than a twice-as-bad drop. It's like nothing in the data series we have seen.”
In many ways, Kane said, the figures are puzzling. The capital requirements to start a business are phenomenally low. “You don’t need to get a multi-million dollar loan to buy factory equipment, or open a new shop on Main Street. You can start an internet business for, what, ten dollars?” he added. “We should be seeing a trend going the other way.”
Part of the answer for why low startup costs have failed to spur startup jobs in the U.S. may be that the relentless drive for efficiency through outsourcing work overseas or technology has allowed new firms to get the same amount of work done, but with fewer workers.
Robert Litan, a former colleague of Kane’s at the Kauffman Foundation, an entrepreneurship advocacy group, identified this trend in a report released last year called, “Starting Smaller; Staying Smaller: America’s Slow Leak in Job Creation.”
He found that even before the Great Recession, new firms were starting smaller. “They were opening their doors with fewer workers than the historic norm and were relatively reluctant to expand their workforces even during good economic times,” Litan wrote. “Since at least the middle of the last decade and perhaps earlier,” new firms have contributed “fewer and fewer new jobs to the economy.”
Kane said that Litan’s findings mesh with his own, and that globalization is partly to blame. “The venture capital industry expects every startup now to have an international strategy. Not just for sales, but for putting their team together.”
“It’s just too easy for startup companies now to outsource some of their work as efficiently as they can, and if that means hiring people who aren’t Americans and whom they don’t have to pay taxes on and provide health benefits to, than we’re feeling the effects of that as a country.”
Kane suggests in his paper that the U.S. government could reduce globalization's negative effect on startup jobs by reducing the amount of taxes and benefits that new firms must pay for an American hire.
Felix Salmon at Reuters says he doesn’t buy it. And while Salmon finds the figures cited by Kane to be startling, he also notes that the percentage of Americans working at startups at its peak was only a little more than one percent of the population. Now, since the recession ended, that percentage has dropped to around .78 percent.
“Concentrating on startups is not going to move the broader employment needle very much,” he writes, adding, though, that “the dynamic here is surprising and troubling, all the same.”
Also on HuffPost:
Patrick Dowd, Millennial Trains Project
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/28/patrick-dowd-millennial-trains-project_n_1835967.html" target="_hplink">In the profile of the Millennial Trains Project</a>, founder Patrick Dowd described the powerful experience of connecting with 450 young Indians who all wanted to improve their country. Dowd was so moved by the community on board the Jagriti Yatra, he brought the idea back to America and is bringing together over 100 members of the Millennial generation to ride across America to listen, learn and create solutions together.
Fabio Rosati, Elance
After he grew disillusioned with the bureaucracy of a large company, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/04/elance-fabio-rosati_n_1855557.html" target="_hplink">Elance CEO and President Fabio Rosati</a> found a project where he could again feel connected to a distinct mission. Today, Elance's clients connect to a global marketplace of freelance work in a remarkable new way.
Brian Balasia, Digerati
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/06/brian-balasia-digerati-michigan-jobs_n_1860945.html" target="_hplink">Brian Balasia, CEO of Digerati,</a>commented on the power of seeing other entrepreneurs at work and how much easier it is to start your own company after seeing the success of others. Balasia's employees at Digerati confirmed this idea when they themselves followed his lead and went on to start businesses and continue the chain of entrepreneurship.
Allen Blue, LinkedIn
During one of <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/05/jobs-crisis-panel-global-economy_n_1858784.html" target="_hplink">HuffPost's job creation panels</a>, Allen Blue, co-founder of LinkedIn, said "Whenever I talk to young people, I always talk to them about finding something that they care enough about that they can build the energy behind it to acquire the skills they need. To follow that passion down the road toward something which is going to be great for them."
Samer Hamadeh, Zeel
When faced with a torn rotator cuff,<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/27/samer-hamadeh-zeel-alternative-medicine_n_1832948.html" target="_hplink">Samer Hamadeh founded Zeel</a>, an online platform helping people find accredited, convenient and affordable Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) practitioners. Hamadeh's anger over the lack of an easy way to find CAM specialists led him to create the solution. As Hamadeh explains, "When there's a product or service that you so desperately want but no one's offering, you become so compelled and so pissed off that you say, 'Let's go start it.'"
Craig Powell, ConnectEDU
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/30/connectedu-craig-powell-college-admissions_n_1839143.html" target="_hplink">Craig Powell founded ConnectEDU</a> after growing outraged over the inefficient college application process. "The system is just so damn broken," Powell said. "At every turn you see how broken it is. If you have an ounce of democratization, you realize that this is an issue that needs to be dealt with." Powell dealt with it, and now ConnectEDU helps both students and colleges view admissions in a new way.
Danny Kennedy, Sungevity
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/04/danny-kennedy-sungevity-solar_n_1853927.html" target="_hplink">Sungevity co-founder and President Danny Kennedy</a> learned how effective positivity is while running campaigns for Greenpeace: "I saw how people get inspired by positive vision and saying 'Yes' to things," Kennedy said. "You can get people supporting a cause if you're more about the for than the against."
Matt Singer, Videolicious
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/24/matt-singer-videolicious_n_1829351.html" target="_hplink">Matt Singer, the co-founder and CEO of Videolicious</a>, used his passion for video to create an easy-to-use platform so small business owners could market themselves in a more personal way. He believes in the power of video so much he found a way to share the power of video with everyone.
Walter Isaacson, The Aspen Institute
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/arianna-huffington/it-aint-just-about-you-an_b_1843351.html" target="_hplink">Walter Isaacson, CEO of the Aspen Institute</a> pointed out that passion isn't enough: "The second point is to not just follow your passion, but something larger than yourself." These entrepreneurs didn't just follow their passion, they found the point where their passion met a need and used their passion to create something bigger than themselves.
Bill Cunningham, OneMorePallet
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/03/bill-cunningham-onemorepallet_n_1851888.html" target="_hplink">OneMorePallet grew out of founder Bill Cunningham</a>'s observation of empty space. He used the power of technology to take advantage of a market opportunity, empowering small businesses by lowering shipping costs and benefitting shippers who were able to make something out of what was nothing.
Charlie Kroll, Andera
Though <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/07/andera-charlie-kroll-entrepreneuer_n_1864291.html" target="_hplink">Charlie Kroll's story</a> of surviving the dot com bust is a good example of perseverance, all of these stories include an underlying message of how important hard work is. These innovators found it to be essential to achieving the American dream.