Huffpost Politics

John Roberts Health Care Switch Detailed By Jeffrey Toobin In New Book

Posted: Updated:

Three months after the Supreme Court handed down its landmark ruling on President Obama's health care law, new details have emerged on Chief Justice John Roberts' controversial vote in favor of upholding the Affordable Care Act.

According to excerpts of a new book by New Yorker writer and CNN legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin published in Politico's Playbook on Saturday, Roberts had originally intended to side with his fellow conservatives on the court and overturn the law. However, Roberts' position turned "wobbly" as he considered the implications the ruling would have on his legacy.

Toobin reports:

Roberts was a conservative and lifelong partisan Republican. … Roberts had dual goals for his tenure as chief justice – to push his own ideological agenda but also to preserve the Court’s place as a respected final arbiter of the nation’s disputes. … A complete nullification of the health care law on the eve of a presidential election would put the Court at the center of the campaign … Democrats, and perhaps Obama himself, would crusade against the Court, eroding its moral if not its legal authority. … Gradually, then with more urgency, Roberts began looking for a way out.

Toobin writes that Roberts became increasingly uncomfortable with overturning the entire law, and instead sought out a "middle ground." He found that middle ground in arguing in his majority opinion that the individual mandate "need not be read to do more than impose a tax," thus falling within Congress' power to collect taxes.

The switch, according to Toobin, "enraged" Justice Antonin Scalia. In recent interviews, Scalia has insisted that there's no bad blood on the court. And, as Toobin points out, Roberts' ruling could come as a boon to conservatives.

[F]or Roberts personally and the conservative cause generally, his vote and opinion in the health care case were acts of strategic genius. … Roberts at a minimum laid down a marker on the scope of the commerce clause. … Roberts’s opinion is potentially a significant long-term gain for the conservative movement. … Roberts bought enormous political space for himself for future rulings. … Did Roberts, by his late switch in the health care case, poison his relations with his conservative allies on the Court? That is very unlikely.

Reports of Roberts' switch were first detailed by CBS News. According to CBS, the conservative wing of the court, including Justice Anthony Kennedy, tried for a month to bring Roberts back on its side.

"The discord is deep and it is personal," CBS' Jan Crawford said of the tension between the justices. "This could affect this court for a long time."

Toobin's book, "The Oath: The Obama White House and the Supreme Court," will be released on Tuesday.

Also on HuffPost:

Political Reaction To Health Care Ruling
Share this
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

Chief Justice John Roberts's health-care ruling gets plenty of second ...

John Roberts Health Care Decision: Supreme Court Chief Justice ...

John Roberts's Healthcare Ruling Is Based on Law, Not Politics ...

Sandra Day O'Connor defends John Roberts' healthcare ruling - Los ...

John Roberts' health care vote scrutinized - Political Hotsheet - CBS ...

Chief Justice John Roberts' Switch on 'Obamacare' Health Care ...

52 days to Nov. 6; 19 days to Debate 1 -- TOOBIN BOOK: Roberts switched ...

How Chief Justice John Roberts Will Handle Obamacare

Chief Justice Roberts Gained A Security Detail Due To Fears of Health Care ...

Health Care Reform and Obamacare Are Not Synonyms

NEWS FLASH: Chief Justice Roberts Expounds on the New Chief Justice Roberts

  Obama Romney
Obama Romney
332 206
Obama leading
Obama won
Romney leading
Romney won
Popular Vote
33 out of 100 seats are up for election. 51 are needed for a majority.
Democrat leading
Democrat won
Republican leading
Republican won
Democrats* Republicans
Current Senate 53 47
Seats gained or lost +2 -2
New Total 55 45
* Includes two independent senators expected to caucus with the Democrats: Angus King (Maine) and Sen. Bernie Sanders (Vt.).
All 435 seats are up for election. 218 are needed for a majority.
Democrat leading
Democrat won
Republican leading
Republican won
Democrats Republicans
Seats won 201 234
Click for Full Results
Register To Vote