Huffpost Politics
Jennifer Bendery Headshot

Gabby Giffords, Mark Kelly Confront Jared Loughner At Sentencing: We Are 'Done Thinking About You'

Posted: Updated:

WASHINGTON -- For the first time since she was shot in the head on Jan. 8, 2011, former Rep. Gabrielle Giffords (D-Ariz.) on Thursday laid eyes on her shooter, 24-year-old Jared Lee Loughner, as he was sentenced to life in prison amid powerful testimony from the survivors of his shooting rampage in Tucson that day.

Loughner's sentence -- seven life terms in prison, plus 140 years -- brings an end, at least in the legal sense, to a painful chapter in the lives of those impacted by the tragedy. Six people were killed and 13 others were injured in Loughner's attack. Each of the life terms represents one of the six people Loughner killed. The seventh is for the attempted assassination of a congresswoman.

"The sentence I've just imposed means Mr. Loughner will never step out of prison," U.S. District Judge Larry Burns said in his final remarks, per a family member of one of the victims who was in the room.

Loughner could have faced the death penalty, but nearly all of the victims and families of victims said they didn't want that.

There was no televised coverage of the hearing, but people inside were allowed to tweet, which kept many people glued to Twitter for updates through the proceedings.

Loughner said nothing the entire time, aside from "yes sir" to the judge to confirm that he was declining to make a statement. Several of Loughner's victims took the opportunity to speak to him. Some of them were forgiving, while others were quite the opposite, according to tweets from reporters in the room.

Pam Simon, who suffered two gunshot wounds, told Loughner that she knew he was mentally ill and that he "did not choose this illness that led to this tragedy." But Mavanell Stoddard, whose husband died during the shooting, told Loughner: "You forgot to shoot yourself."

Giffords, who either sat or stood silently alongside her husband, Mark Kelly, during the proceedings, looked directly at Loughner as Kelly read aloud a moving speech on behalf of both of them. In it, Kelly said that while everyone knows Loughner suffers from schizophrenia, he is still "responsible for the death and hurt you inflicted upon all of us on January 8th of last year."

Facing Loughner, Kelly wrapped up by saying, "After this moment. Here and now. Gabby and I are done thinking about you."

Surprisingly, Kelly also used his speech to criticize political leaders for not doing anything on gun control, an issue that he and Giffords have largely avoided since the shooting.

At the national level, "We have representatives who look at gun violence,
 not as a problem to solve, but as the white elephant in the room to ignore," Kelly said. Meanwhile, Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer has been "so feckless" in her leadership on the issue, Kelly said, that a week after the Tucson shootings, she argued the deaths didn't have "anything to do with" the size of Loughner's gun magazine or the caliber of his gun.

Even the judge touched on the issue, said the family member, getting "choked up" when he "spoke out against high-capacity magazines."

As for the effect the hearing had on Giffords, she "is looking and feeling strong," said the family member.

Here is Kelly's prepared speech, in its entirety:

Mr. Loughner, for the first and last time, you are going to hear directly from Gabby and me about what you took away on January 8th, 2011 and, just as important, what you did not. So pay attention.

That bright and chilly Saturday morning, you killed six innocent people. Daughters and sons. Mothers and fathers. Grandparents and friends. They were devoted to their families, their communities, their places of worship.

Gabby would trade her own life to bring back any one of those you savagely murdered on that day. Especially young Christina-Taylor Green, whose high-minded ideas about service and democracy deserved a full life committed to advancing them. Especially 30-year old Gabe Zimmerman, whom Gabby knew well and cherished, and whose love for his family and his fiancee and service to his country were as deep as his loss is tragic. Especially Judge John Roll, whom Gabby was honored to call a colleague and friend and from whose interminable dedication to our community and country she gained enormous inspiration. Gabby would give anything to take away the grief you visited upon the Morrises, the Schnecks, and the Stoddards – anything to heal the bodies and psyches of your other victims.

And then there is what you took from Gabby. Her life has been forever changed. Plans she had for our family and her career have been immeasurably altered. Every day is a continuous struggle to do those things she was once so very good at. Gabby is a people person: she exudes kindness, creativity, and compassion. If she were not born with the name – “Gabby” – someone would have given it to her. Now she struggles to deliver each and every sentence. Her gift for language can now only be seen in Internet videos from a more innocent time.

Gabby was an outdoor enthusiast. She was often seen rollerblading with her friend Raoul in Reed Park, hiking in Sabino Canyon, or careening down Rillito Wash Trail on her bike, as she was the night before you tried and failed to murder her. She hasn't been to any of those places since, and I don't know when she’ll return.

There’s more. Gabby struggles to walk. Her right arm is paralyzed. She is partially blind. Gabby works harder in one minute of an hour – fighting to make each individual moment count for something – than most of us work in an entire day.

Mr. Loughner, by making death and producing tragedy, you sought to extinguish the beauty of life. To diminish potential. To strain love. And to cancel ideas. You tried to create for all of us a world as dark
 and evil as your own.

 But know this, and remember it always: You failed.

Your decision to commit cold-blooded mass murder also begs of us to look in the mirror. This horrific act warns us to hold our leaders and ourselves responsible for coming up short when we do, for not having the courage to act when it’s hard, even for possessing the wrong values.

We are a people who can watch a young man like you spiral into murderous rampage without choosing to intervene before it is too late.

We have a political class that is afraid to do something as simple as have a meaningful debate about our gun laws and how they are being enforced. We have representatives who look at gun violence,
 not as a problem to solve, but as the white elephant in the room to ignore. As a nation we have repeatedly passed up the opportunity to address this issue. After Columbine; after Virginia Tech; after Tucson and after Aurora we have done nothing.

In this state we have elected officials so feckless in their leadership that they would say, as in the case of Governor Jan Brewer, “I don't think it has anything to do with the size of the magazine or the caliber of the gun.” She went on and said, “Even if the shooter's weapon had held fewer bullets, he'd have another gun, maybe. He could have three guns in his pocket” – she said this just one week after a high capacity magazine allowed you to kill six and wound 19 others, before being wrestled to the ground while attempting to reload. Or a state legislature that thought it appropriate to busy itself naming an official Arizona state gun just weeks after this tragedy occurred, instead of doing the work it was elected to do: encourage economic growth, help our returning veterans and fix our education system.

The challenges we face are so great, but the leadership in place is so often lacking. In so many moments, I find myself thinking, “We need Gabby.” In letter after letter, I’ve seen that others agree. As Americans mourned the six who died, they also mourned the loss of a representative who embodied the service they realized they should expect from those they elect, the type of person our county desperately needs to provide leadership and solve problems. Gabby was a courageous member of congress. Willing to stand up to the establishment when the establishment was wrong. She was thirsty for partnership across the aisle and was an unrelenting champion for her 600,000 constituents. One of which was you.

There’s something else Gabby and I have been spending a lot of time thinking about. The way we conduct politics must change. Sure it’s easier to win a debate if you can turn your opponent into a demon, but that’s not how we move forward. Not only does slash and burn politics make Americans cynical about their leaders, but it leads to bad ideas. It creates problems instead of solving the ones we have now.

Even amid all that was lost, Gabby and I give thanks for her life, her spirit, and her intellect, which are a continued force in this world despite what you’ve done. We exalt in sharing our lives with each other and with our family and friends.

As a city, Tucson has grown stronger. We love this community, and we love our neighbors. We are resilient, and the dynamism and compassion of our fellow Tucsonans will continue to push this city forward.

And there is what persists in Gabby: her love for this city, this state and this country. Her commitment to lifting us all up, and her ability to lead. Mr. Loughner, you may have put a bullet through her head, but you haven’t put a dent in her spirit and her commitment to make the world a better place.

Mr. Loughner, pay close attention to this: Though you are mentally ill, you are responsible for the death and hurt you inflicted upon all of us on January 8th of last year. You know this. Gabby and I know this.

 Everyone in this courtroom knows this.

You have decades upon decades to contemplate what you did. But after today. After this moment. Here and now. Gabby and I are done thinking about you.

Earlier on HuffPost:

Gabrielle Giffords' Road To Recovery
Share this
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

Jared Loughner sentencing: Gabrielle Giffords to be in courtroom for ...

Gabby Giffords Set to Appear at Jared Loughner's Sentencing

Metro - Gabrielle Giffords to face shooter Jared Loughner at ...

Jared Lee Loughner - The New York Times

Jared Loughner News, Photos and Videos - ABC News

Jared Loughner to be sentenced for 2011 shooting of Gabrielle ...

Jared Loughner Topics Page -

Jared Loughner Pleads Guilty: Gabby Giffords Weigh In | Video ...

Jared Loughner Sentenced: Arizona Shooter Gets Seven Life Sentences for ...

Prosecutor: Loughner thought he killed Giffords

Jared Loughner sentencing: Gabrielle Giffords to be in courtroom for Loughner ...

Gabrielle Giffords, Mark Kelly to Appear at Loughner Sentencing

Gabrielle Giffords to attend shooter's sentencing today

Gabby Giffords to face shooter in court

Mark Kelly's statement to Jared Loughner

Gabby Giffords to come face-to-face with Jared Loughner for first time as he ...