Huffpost DC

Jose Andres Minibar Awarded Two Stars By Tom Sietsema Of 'The Washington Post'

Posted: Updated:
In this photo released by the United Nations Foundation, renowed chef Jose Andres and Executive Director of the Global Alliance for Clean Cookstoves Radha Muthiah participate in a discussion on clean cooking technologies at the Social Good Summit, Wednesday, Sept. 21, 2011 in New York. (AP Photo/United Nations Foundation, Gary He) | AP

WASHINGTON -- A prized possession for one of the biggest names in the D.C. restaurant scene just got a so-so review after years of being considered the best, experimental and innovative dining experience in the nation's capital.

The Washington Post's Tom Sietsema, in his upcoming Sunday review of José Andrés' Minibar, awarded the downtown spot, which reopened in a new, slightly larger location in November, just two stars.

Tom Sietsema
The return of minibar by is not what I had hoped. My Sunday review:

In Sietsema's book, two stars is still certainly "good," but as the critic sums up: "Dinner at the second Minibar is like watching a bunch of trailers when you’re hungry for a movie."


What happened? For starters, bigger is not always better. The Minibar experience lost some of its previous lustre in the move to upgrade its capacity from its former six-seat setup.

The result? Sietsema writes: "The scrunched intimacy of the original experience has been replaced by two broad oak counters that look onto a pristine kitchen and seat up to six participants each. Hovering over our heads are gold-colored domes that originated as boat shells. The performance space is clean and modern, if suggestive of an operating theater when you factor in the chefs in their whites bending over dishes manipulated by tweezers, tongs, liquid nitrogen and cloches galore."

The critic also noted "inattentiveness" with some dishes. Also, it was a bad sign that the first dish Sietsema "flipped" for -- beans with clams -- came as the 16th course.

Sietsema disclosed that his review was unusual because he only ate at the new version of Andres' "futuristic food lab" just once:

In this case, I made a rare exception and dined just once, partly because Minibar by Jose Andres is the world-famous chef’s second incarnation of his avant-garde concept, the first having opened in 2003 with just six seats at a small counter on the second floor of his late Cafe Atlantico. His team had the summer to rehearse its new show, prices for which have shot up $75, to $225 for the food alone.

Sietsema's bill for the evening for four people after tip? Nearly $1,800.

Andrés tweeted following Sietsema's review, which went online on Wednesday:

José Andrés
I'm disappointed too You came quick and only once.And thats unfair under any circumstance.Proud of my team.But we respect you..

Others thought the one-visit review was unfair, too.

Jeremy Horwitz
Very sad. Rating a place under 1 month old, after 1 visit, and dismissing the daring you once exulted? Minibar deserves better.

Andrés Think Food Group empire, rooted in the nation's capital, has expanded considerably since the first Minibar opened nearly a decade ago. With restaurants in Las Vegas and Los Angeles, expansion plans elsewhere including a soon-to-open restaurant in Puerto Rico, a PBS show and a teaching gig at George Washington University, Andrés is no doubt a busy man.

Andrés should take one thing to heart: At least this Sietsema review wasn't headlined "At Least The Water Is Cold."

Andrés tweeted on Thursday:

José Andrés
People of Tweeter! My team needs your love today! We got a hard review

Also on HuffPost:

Pepe Food Truck
Share this
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

Minibar by Jose Andres 2.0: Bigger, not better

Five outrageously-priced minibar items

Minibar - Penn Quarter - Washington, DC

100 Best Restaurants 2008: Minibar - Washingtonian

Minibar By Jose Andres - Penn Quarter - Washington | Urbanspoon

Minibar by José Andrés | Washington | Information, Menus and - Zagat

Minibar - Reviews and Ratings of Restaurants in Washington, D.C. ...

José Andrés Calls Out Tom Sietsema for Minibar Review