The "Idol" results are in and Paul Jolley has been eliminated from the competition.

Lazaro Arbos and Paul were two of the only disappoints among the Top 9 in Wednesday night's performance show, which had the "Idol" hopefuls singing Beatles covers. But only Paul wound up in the bottom three along with Devin Velez and Amber Holcomb.

"I'm really shocked that Amber's in the bottom three -- I can't believe that," Randy Jackson said. Nick Minaj agreed, adding, "I definitely think Amber should not be in the bottom three ... That's common sense."

Paul sang Heart's "Alone" for the judges' one save of the season, but it was not enough and he was sent home.

On Wednesday night, Paul chose to sing "Eleanor Rigby" and though it was perhaps his best "Idol" performance, it wasn't enough to impress America (especially considering viewers' memory of David Cook's rendition of the song in Season 7). Nicki told Paul the performance was "very, very safe, very bland, and forgettable.” Randy told Paul he "disconnected from the song" and Mariah Carey added, "You have to be able to give as much emotion when you're singing softly as when you're singing at the top of your range."

Lazaro, Kree Harrison, Candice Glover, Angie Miller, Janelle Arthur, Burnell Taylor were safe and Devin and Amber later joined them to round out the Top 8.

Lazaro was the first to be inducted into the Top 8, which diminished the suspense for the evening. The judges were brutally honest with Lazaro after his rendition of "My Life" on Wednesday night, leaving the singer in tears. All four judges agreed that Lazaro should have chosen to sing in a higher key with Randy Jackson adding that it was his "worst performance.” Nicki Minaj felt like the singer was losing himself, saying, "You are not back to the Lazaro I know.”

Lazaro later tweeted about the performance and his breakdown thereafter:


"They were right for the most part," Arbos admitted of the judge's critiques in Thursday's elimination show. "I have to do songs that I love and that I want to sing and not change songs."

At the start of the show, the Top 9 performed “Got To Get Into My Life." Before the results were revealed, two "Idol" alumni also graced the stage: Season 10's Casey Abrams performed his single "Get Out" and last season's runner up Jessica Sanchez also returned in a whole lot of glitter to perform her new single “Tonight” with Ne-Yo.

Were you happy with tonight's "Idol" results? Who do you think will take it all? Sound off in the comments!

"American Idol" airs Wednesdays and Thursdays at 8 p.m. ET on Fox.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Jennifer Lopez and boyfriend Casper Smart had a casual dinner at Madeo in West Hollywood on April 17.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Aubrey Plaza, Jason Ritter, Dade Constantine, and Kayla Dobson attended the "About Alex" premiere afterparty during the Tribeca Film Festival at Kutsher's Tribeca in NYC, April 17.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Pregnant singer Christina Aguilera and her fiance Matthew Rutler were photographed out and about in New York City on April 17.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Katie Holmes spotted out and about in New York City on April 17.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    "Downton Abbey" actress Jessica Brown Findlay hopped on a train at Manchester Piccadilly Train Station after her interview on "BBC Breakfast" on April 17 in England.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Heather Graham visited NBC Studios for an appearance on "The Today Show" on April 17 in New York City.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Justin Bieber and his crew, including Lil Za, were spotted out for dinner at The Grove in Los Angeles, Calif., on April 16.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Georgia May Jagger, daughter of Mick Jagger, filmed a commercial for Rimmel London in London, England, on April 15.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Halle Berry filmed scenes for her TV series "Extant" in Century City, Calif. on April 15.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Lauren Conrad did some shopping in West Hollywood on April 15.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Andrew Garfield, Emma Stone, Jamie Foxx and Dane DeHaan posed during a photocall for their film "The Amazing Spider-Man 2" prior to the German premiere of the film in Berlin on April 15.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Kim Kardashian and her fiance Kanye West walked hand-in-hand as they went shopping in Givenchy, Balmain and Lanvin on April 14 in Paris, France.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Channing Tatum and Jenna Dewan-Tatum joked around backstage at the 2014 MTV Movie Awards at Nokia Theatre L.A. Live in Los Angeles, Calif., on April 13.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Lupita Nyong'o arrived at the 2014 MTV Movie Awards at Nokia Theatre L.A. Live in Los Angeles, Calif., on April 13.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Taylor Swift and a friend were spotted out and about in New York City on April 12.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Jessica Biel was all smiles as she headed out for an espresso in New York City on April 12.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Leonardo DiCaprio stopped by the McDonald’s® and Stingray Desert Coachella Pool Party at the Bootsy Bellows Estate on April 12 to celebrate the launch of McDonald’s® Bacon Clubhouse Burger™ and the 2014 Corvette Stingray.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Julianne Hough looked Coachella cool at The Old Navy Oasis in Indio, Calif.m on April 12.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Selena Gomez and Kendall and Kylie Jenner at the first weekend of The Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival on April 11.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield visited BBC Radio 1 in London on April 9 to promote their new film, "The Amazing Spider-Man 2."

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Pregnant Kristin Cavallari was spotted running in West Hollywood on April 9.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Danica McKellar left "Dancing with the Stars" practice in Hollywood on April 8.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Julianne Moore was pretty in white while out in NYC April 8.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Anne Hathaway wrapped herself up in a giant coat while out in NYC on April 8.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Lady Gaga struck her usual unique pose outside the Roseland Ballroom on April 7.

  • Celebrity News: April 2014

    British socialite <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/07/peaches-geldof-dead_n_5105968.html" target="_blank">Peaches Geldof died</a> of an "unexplained and sudden" cause on April 7. She was 25.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 7

    "Dancing with the Stars" star Derek Hough took a break from rehearsal on April 7 to snack on the new Ritz crackers.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Jamie Lynn Sigler was spotted purchasing a Rembrandt whitening kit at Target in New York on April 7.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Faith Hill and Tim McGraw at the 2014 Academy Of Country Music Awards at the MGM Grand Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas, Nevada on April 6.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Miranda Lambert and Blake Shelton at the 2014 Academy Of Country Music Awards at the MGM Grand Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas, Nevada on April 6.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Carrie Underwood at the 2014 Academy Of Country Music Awards at the MGM Grand Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas, Nevada on April 6.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Taylor Swift at the 2014 Academy Of Country Music Awards at the MGM Grand Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas, Nevada on April 6.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Cameron Diaz made an appearance on "Wetten, dass..???" TV show on April 5 in Offenburg, Germany.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Heidi Klum attended the "America's Got Talent" red carpet event at Madison Square Garden on April 4 in New York City.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Nicole Richie attended Lucky FABB: Fashion and Beauty Blog Conference at the SLS Hotel in Beverly Hills on April 4.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Shakira and Usher attended NBC's "The Voice" red carpet event at The Sayers Club in Hollywood on April 3.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Dianna Agron was spotted out and about West Hollywood on April 3.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Kiernan Shipka, Jessica Pare, Elisabeth Moss, Jon Hamm, January Jones and Christina Hendricks attended the "Mad Men" season 7 premiere at ArcLight Cinemas in Hollywood on April 2.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Kate Upton, Cameron Diaz and Leslie Mann attended the U.K. premiere of their movie "The Other Woman" on April 2 in London.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Lady Gaga arrived at the "Late Show with David Letterman" taping in NYC April 2.

  • Celebrity Photos: March 2014

    Heidi Klum joined Dr. Scholl’s to announce the DreamWalk line of insoles to help women everywhere bring their uncomfortable shoes out of the “shoe closet" in New York on April 2.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Jennifer Connelly and Russell Crowe posed together before the screening of their new film "Noah" in Paris on April 1.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Comedienne Amy Schumer promoted her "Finger Blaster" sketch from season 2 of the Comedy Central hit "Inside Amy Schumer" in NYC, April 1.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Naomi Watts left the gym with a friend after a morning workout on April 1 in Brentwood, Calif.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Hulk Hogan attended the WrestleMania 30 press conference at the Hard Rock Cafe New York on April 1.

  • Celebrity Photos: April 2014

    Sebastian Stan and Chris Evans posed with Captain America during The NYSE Opening Bell at New York Stock Exchange on April 1.

  • Celebrity Photos: March 2014

    Cobie Smulders attended The Cinema Society & Gucci Guilty screening of "Captain America: The Winter Soldier" at the TriBeCa Grand Hotel in NYC, March 31.

  • Celebrity Photos: March 2014

    Emma Watson wowed at the UK Premiere of "Noah" at Odeon Leicester Square on March 31 in London.

  • Celebrity Photos: March 2014

    Naomi Watts went for a morning jog with a friend in Brentwood, Calif., on March 31.

  • Celebrity Photos: March 2014

    Johnny Depp attended the "Transcendence" press conference at Grand Hyatt Hotel on March 31 in Beijing, China.

  • Celebrity Photos: March 2014

    Shailene Woodley, Theo James and Kate Winslet attended the European Premiere of "Divergent" at Odeon Leicester Square on March 30 in London.

Earlier on HuffPost: